The Revolution Begins

If asked a direct question concerning the truthers, any politician should denounce them and instead acting like a typical politician and tap dancing around the question.
And who says Obama didn't make a mistake? He should have denounced him a long time ago.

why should he have denounced him? I like reverend wright. Besides HILARY SOUGHT HIM FOR SUPPORT TAMBIEN!!
 
By looking at the evidence. He's written a lot of books on economics. He's studied austrian economics among others. If you watch the interview he had with john stossel you can get an impression with what kind of economic plan he has and how much he knows on economics.
I've seen some of his economic plans, and I think they would end up hurting the American economy. Why do you hate America?
 
yeah well, you're a spaghetti monster. See, easy huh?
Like the Flying Spagetti Monster? I didn't know I've been deified.

Yes, my "why do you hate america?" was in jest, but it was more a joke about the simplicity of your arguments. Essentially your claim is that Ron Paul's economic plans are best is because Ron Paul knows more about economics than you do and is thus correct. Many other people know more about economics than you do and they disagree with Paul, so what makes him right and they wrong?
 
That's funny, I don't think he has.

He's arguing a neutral foreign policy (except, like a cultist, he's using the same repetitive language that True Believers tend to use, "entangling alliances") with a military concerned with defense within its borders, similar to Switzerland's. The country itself does not get involved in the problems of other countries, the country freely trades, and people are free to go to other countries to help in conflicts, etc. No, I don't think that's a bad idea at all.

Except Switzerland quite liberally helped the Nazi's in the war until the Alllies said "If you don't stop, you'll be blacklisted after the war." And then went "EEP." at losing that money.

You can point to the WWII as a counter to this, but WWII was very much caused by, or at least a very large cause, WWI, thanks to the Versailles treaty and the conditions that allowed a dictator to arise in Germany at that time. A country is concerned with its own survival; in fact, that's what a country is, an administrative body held together to run the show and protect itself from outside forces. Americans didn't support entering the war back then until it was clear that the country was at risk, too, and then people were gladly joining. A country is not a body that plays (or should be playing, in my view) hero around the world; groups of people are free to do that, though.
Americans were quite stupid about that, honestly. Let me put it this way: The Versailles treaty didn't' succeed in anything but leaving Germany stronger than many of the Allied Powers. However, the stab-in-the-back legend overtook reason.. well, in any case, I recommend A World At Arms about WWII..


Now on to the main show.

Well I just got done reading it and he wasn'T agreeing with me, he was mocking my sayings. Well, I'll tell you this. America was not designed to be super power empire like the brits. IT was designed to be a free,sovereign, prosperous nation, that trades with all people and helps everyone out. Who said we NEED to be a superpower? If we're technically a superpower right now, then I would rather NOT be a superpower, because we're hurtin' being a superpower.
Incorrect. Seriously, incorrect. The original design was to be the first three (and maybe the last two, because only Washington advocated THAT policy, the next two Presidents, Adams and Jefferson simply did not.)

And, look, I'll admit something here. Globalism != bad, automatically. In a global era, you need to have global abillities.. we just took it too far. Being a superpower isn't what hurt us, it was a series of mess ups by the US Government over the last 20 years, honestly.
 
Last edited:
Many other people know more about economics than you do and they disagree with Paul, so what makes him right and they wrong?
This is the problem with appealing to authority which I'm guilty of myself from time to time. Even authorities in their fields of expertise can be wrong.

I'm glad folks have slapped me upside the head when I have relied too heavily on authority. Not that I like it at the time.
 
That's somewhat true, but it also is true that his district also pays taxes. The money is going to be spent, so give some back to his district. It's a way of trying to change the game but also playing it while it's still there so you don't get screwed.

And if you say it is not integrity, then you also must say that it is not integrity for Obama, etc, whom do do that, which I doubt you will do.

The difference is that the pork that Obama supports (unless there are some whoppers I'm not aware of) consists of programs that Obama supports in principle. Ron Paul, on the other hand, is opposed to the very idea of the government funding programs, but does it anyway, and that makes a difference.

That said, I will agree that there is some sound pragmatic reasoning in using pork to "send money back to the district," but the main problem is that Ron Paul is so often extremely idealistic. He often votes against fairly benign things due to his beliefs, and in an otherwise generally pro-Paul article, Club for Growth cites some examples of where his idealism clashes with his and their goals, such as his opposition to free trade agreements and vouchers. The fact that he makes an exception in his idealism for pork can easily be interpreted to imply that he's making exceptions here for his own benefit rather than for the benefit of his district or the country at large. Although perhaps you're right.
 
Last edited:
vote ron paul in 2008. He's americas only hope.

Also, these are my favorite smilies :tank::bigtank::diamond::grouphug3:hug3:hug7:bigclap:bunpan:grouphug6

Ron Paul will not be on the ballot come November. How the hell do you expect people to vote for him, or are you totally ignorant of the way American Elections work?
And no one here gives a damn about what smilies you like.
I am now convinced you cannot be older then 16 at the most.
 
Last edited:
If asked a direct question concerning the truthers, any politician should denounce them and instead acting like a typical politician and tap dancing around the question.
And who says Obama didn't make a mistake? He should have denounced him a long time ago.

No, no politician should denounce their supports if their supporters simply believe in something crazy. What next, should politicians denounce all their supporters that believe in UFOs too? Or that Kennedy was killed by a CIA conspiracy? Or those that might believe in Sylvia Browne's nonsense...?

They're not advocating someone get hurt, and it doesn't matter: RP himself said that the idea of a government 9/11 conspiracy was silly. He doesn't need to bash on a group of technically harmless but kooky group of people.

Obama doesn't need to denounce Rev. Wright. He does, however, need to provide a credible reason why he tolerated that nonsense and was so close to man that was. In this aspect, Paul is also similar, but not why you say--Paul has some real explaining to do over those newsletters, but of course he's not going to (might require him to "out" one of his buddies or something).
 
Ron Paul will not be on the ballot come November. How the hell do you expect people to vote for him, or are you totally ignorant of the way American Elections work?
And no one here gives a damn about what smilies you like.
I am now convinced you cannot be older then 16 at the most.

Come on. There's so many ways to handle this guy, and you are leaving yourself wide open.

Someone not being on the ballot doesn't mean you cannot vote for them (in most states). Ever hear about write-ins? Do YOU know how American elections work...?

This isn't about whether you're wasting your vote or not--as far as I can see, voting is like a tear in the ocean--your individual opinion is utterly meaningless.
 
A write in candidate has about 0.00000000000000000001% chance of being elected President.
Nice to see have such total faith in democracy with the final sentence of your post.
 
The difference is that the pork that Obama supports (unless there are some whoppers I'm not aware of) consists of programs that Obama supports in principle. Ron Paul, on the other hand, is opposed to the very idea of the government funding programs, but does it anyway, and that makes a difference.

That said, I will agree that there is some sound pragmatic reasoning in using pork to "send money back to the district," but the main problem is that Ron Paul is so often extremely idealistic. He often votes against fairly benign things due to his beliefs, and in an otherwise generally pro-Paul article, Club for Growth cites some examples of where his idealism clashes with his and their goals, such as his opposition to free trade agreements and vouchers. The fact that he makes an exception in his idealism for pork can easily be interpreted to imply that he's making exceptions here for his own benefit rather than for the benefit of his district or the country at large. Although perhaps you're right.

That's true, but again:

His district still pays taxes, and he can't change that fact. He can try to change things, but when your districts money is being taken you also have to do the dance so his taxpayers aren't getting completely screwed--basically, he still has to support his district back home.

Additionally, I believe the money is already allocated to the budget: it's going to get spent, whether he wants it to or not, so if someone is taking ingredients from you to help make a pie you might as well take a slice.

Paul isn't so much idealistic (no, he's not idealistic at all; he's actually quite realistic) as he is rigid. He generally sticks on principle with some exceptions. (No, ronpaulisright, he has voted against the constitution, most notably on an issue related to abortion/beginning of life)
 
A write in candidate has about 0.00000000000000000001% chance of being elected President.
Nice to see have such total faith in democracy with the final sentence of your post.

I know a write-in candidate has almost no chance. That's irrelevant; you're the one who didn't realize that you could still write-in.

As for democracy, no, I have no "faith" at all.
 
like I said, I don't know much about economics but I know Dr. Paul does. The economy is his special interest. he got INTO the presidential race for the foreign policy issue.

I know all about Ron Paul, probably more than you do. The fact that he's into economics doesn't change anything; people have written the exact opposite on Paul, many PhDs. and others. What does that say, then?

Besides, I think economics is too often a diversion, that it's implied the most important thing is economy and not individual freedom. Libertarians actually support this also they often like to borrow the utilitarian angle which I think is a bad idea.

Here's an example:

Do you think unions help or hurt the economy? Most libertarians would say "hurt".

Do you think the government should break up unions? No libertarian would say "yes".

In that case, it's an economic inefficiency in the name of individual freedom, and there's nothing wrong with that.
 
This is because nobody really wants Switzerland so it isn't a priority. The topography stinks, and it isn't exactly rich with raw materials essential to an ongoing war of conquest unless an army needs better watches, good chocolate, and a place to ski. As it poses no threat it would be insane to occupy it while more important targets await. Germany would have passed over Greece and Yugoslavia as well pending the Russian invasion if Mussolini didn't launch his idiotic invasion of Greece, requiring Hitler to bail him out, which allowed Tito's gang to tie up significant Nazi military resources, etc.

That, and being a neutral during WWII in Europe is simply nothing anyone should point to as a positive. Especially considering it involved financial concessions, thus assisting the Nazis from a financial perspective. Even then, if the Nazis brought the rest of Europe to heel, they would have taken over Switzerland as well, even though they probably would have left most of it alone after killing everyone they didn't care for.

The real force behind the famed Swiss neutrality were the people that derailed Hitler before it got to the point where occupying Switzerland was worth the trouble.

Your examples of the Nazis eventually invading Switzerland (and you are almost certainly right, given enough time) show that neutrality of neutrality's sake is not a good idea; there's nothing wrong when attacking when there's a very real threat against you, however. And self-defense when threatened, that only makes perfect sense.

Additionally, Hitler's doctrine of lebensraum made it very likely they'd get invaded if not simply for their land itself.

Perhaps Switzerland was a bad idea, but being neutral is not a death sentence if you defend yourself when threatened. There's nothing wrong with having a strong military, it's how you use it, and I think it should be for defending the country and strictly for that purpose.

But, regarding entry to the war on our half: It's easy to look back when we know everything that took place and make a decision on what we would have done today, but it's not so easy when you're back then, you have to deal with the concerns of the day, and not having the benefit of seeing how the history played out.
 
Last edited:
This is because nobody really wants Switzerland so it isn't a priority. The topography stinks, and it isn't exactly rich with raw materials essential to an ongoing war of conquest unless an army needs better watches, good chocolate, and a place to ski.

I can't resist bringing up Orson Welles famous line about Switzerland from "The Third Man".....
 
No, no politician should denounce their supports if their supporters simply believe in something crazy. What next, should politicians denounce all their supporters that believe in UFOs too? Or that Kennedy was killed by a CIA conspiracy? Or those that might believe in Sylvia Browne's nonsense...?

They're not advocating someone get hurt, and it doesn't matter: RP himself said that the idea of a government 9/11 conspiracy was silly. He doesn't need to bash on a group of technically harmless but kooky group of people.

Obama doesn't need to denounce Rev. Wright. He does, however, need to provide a credible reason why he tolerated that nonsense and was so close to man that was. In this aspect, Paul is also similar, but not why you say--Paul has some real explaining to do over those newsletters, but of course he's not going to (might require him to "out" one of his buddies or something).

If you have supporters that believe in UFO's and 911 conspiracy theories, you need to denounce them. They are loons, and they don't need that kind of support. Is that the kind of supporters you would want? And yes, Obama has denounced Wright to a certain degree, and it was necessary.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom