The Revolution Begins

Really?

So you think we should band together and over throw the government by use of force?

peaceful protest is what everyone wants. but in order to change the status quo, violent revolution is inevitable. americans had to have a violent revolution in order to be free and prosperous. tyrannical states have to be handled via physical revolution.
 
peaceful protest is what everyone wants. but in order to change the status quo, violent revolution is inevitable. americans had to have a violent revolution in order to be free and prosperous. tyrannical states have to be handled via physical revolution.

So, you'd support the arming and funding of revolutionaries in Iran, Syria and North Korea?
 
I have to admit that at first I had originally held out a lot of hope that Ron Paul would be the candidate I could vote for: "Progressives" on social values (i.e. secular governance, pro-abortion, pro-free speech, sex-positive, anti-war, etc.) and largely "capitalist" on economic issues. In other words, someone far more consistant on issues of indvidual rights and personal choice than either the theocratic conservatives or the maternalistic liberals tend to offer. Then I found out that Paul was more than willing to suck up the JEEZ-us freak Right and embraced the failed concept of the gold standard. After that, I decided that, once again, I was going to write "Mark A. Siefert" on my ballot and vote for the only candidate who could represent my views.

I used to consider myself a "libertarian," but given the number of CT-kooks, survivalists, and embittered scofflaws I've come across in that area, I think I better look for a new label.
 
Last edited:
The american revolutionary war led to a lot of tyranny huh dopey?

maybe that's the kind of propaganda that the redcoats told their fellow redcoats. "hey we have to kill them. They will bring fascism."

Thomas jefferson once said. "every generation needs a revolution". I agree.

Thomas Jefferson was a smart guy, but he was not perfect. Additionally, he died in 1826. There is new data available to us that Jefferson was not able to take into consideration.

I did say that revolutions can work, and when things are very bad they are probably justified. But history has a rather mixed record regarding revolutions. Look at Russia, or Iran, or how many colonies became dictatorships. Hitler and Mussolini came to power not because of the government growing more and more egregiously corrupt but of some new guys showing up with "hip new ideas" to change things.

Furthermore, the argument has been made that for all the carnage, the American Revolution was not quite as revolutionary as it could be. The colonists had had de facto self-rule for quite a while. The revolutionary step was merely in how forcefully they defended the preservation of these de facto freedoms. Now granted, Ron Paul is also arguing for the return to the old ways, but the difference is that these are very old ways. Ron Paul's nemesis the Federal Reserve has been around for almost a century, for instance. Even if I concede that the Federal Reserve should be destroyed, radically changing institutions that have been around for a century is something that is riskier than merely getting the King out of our hair after a long absence.

Freedom is a relatively new concept. Freedom has not been around that long in comparison to other entities like tyranny. And I will defend a guy who defends freedom and supports the belief of these men who knew in their hearts what freedom was and how to enable freedom in a society.

Although I subscribe to a somewhat different concept of freedom from libertarians, I will agree with you that freedom is good. But because freedom is right, it is logical. Its goodness is not some magical axiom passed down from the divine prophet John Locke, but rather its goodness can be justified through logical arguments. Gradual reform gives logic time to make its case. You argue to others why freedom is good, and they are persuaded, and the changes are made. (This does not always work of course, since the benefits of freedom to those who are doing the oppressing is more limited, but there are ways to persuade even them.) Revolution is far too hasty a proccess for reason to have much say. An well-reasoned argument only goes so far when there are bullets flying around. In revolutions, ideas which would not last very long under the calm eye of cold deliberative reasoning can suddenly surge in popularity, and from this comes problems.
 
Last edited:
peaceful protest is what everyone wants. but in order to change the status quo, violent revolution is inevitable. americans had to have a violent revolution in order to be free and prosperous. tyrannical states have to be handled via physical revolution.

There's your problem right there. Since most American libertarians are largemouthed couch potatos, their revolution is doomed to sleep in with a six-pack from the start.

I have pet rocks for sale, cheap, for you and Dr. Fascism. And a good bridge, hardly used.
 
peaceful protest is what everyone wants. but in order to change the status quo, violent revolution is inevitable. americans had to have a violent revolution in order to be free and prosperous. tyrannical states have to be handled via physical revolution.
And so you consider our existing government of Laws passed by our Elected Representatives (like Ron Paul) to be equal to a TYRANNICAL STATE?
 
the USA..is a tyrannical state?

i suggest a short vacation to China, Cuba, North Korea, or Iran. See what true tyranny is like.

what is it with Americans being so clueless as to thinking we actually live in tyranny? is it a deeper emotional need to feel like we are victims, and our pathetic lives are not the fault of our own, but of the evil governmant?

ah, I get it now. if our governmant and society is not a tyranny, and we actually have many choices in our lives and economic status, then we suck. =)
 
Last edited:
Thomas Jefferson was a smart guy, but he was not perfect. Additionally, he died in 1826. There is new data available to us that Jefferson was not able to take into consideration.

I did say that revolutions can work, and when things are very bad they are probably justified. But history has a rather mixed record regarding revolutions. Look at Russia, or Iran, or how many colonies became dictatorships. Hitler and Mussolini came to power not because of the government growing more and more egregiously corrupt but of some new guys showing up with "hip new ideas" to change things.

Furthermore, the argument has been made that for all the carnage, the American Revolution was not quite as revolutionary as it could be. The colonists had had de facto self-rule for quite a while. The revolutionary step was merely in how forcefully they defended the preservation of these de facto freedoms. Now granted, Ron Paul is also arguing for the return to the old ways, but the difference is that these are very old ways. Ron Paul's nemesis the Federal Reserve has been around for almost a century, for instance. Even if I concede that the Federal Reserve should be destroyed, radically changing institutions that have been around for a century is something that is riskier than merely getting the King out of our hair after a long absence.



Although I subscribe to a somewhat different concept of freedom from libertarians, I will agree with you that freedom is good. But because freedom is right, it is logical. Its goodness is not some magical axiom passed down from the divine prophet John Locke, but rather its goodness can be justified through logical arguments. Gradual reform gives logic time to make its case. You argue to others why freedom is good, and they are persuaded, and the changes are made. (This does not always work of course, since the benefits of freedom to those who are doing the oppressing is more limited, but there are ways to persuade even them.) Revolution is far too hasty a proccess for reason to have much say. An well-reasoned argument only goes so far when there are bullets flying around. In revolutions, ideas which would not last very long under the calm eye of cold deliberative reasoning can suddenly surge in popularity, and from this comes problems.

Dr. paul is a doctor and he sees the problem and he found the remedy for the sickness that is the american government. His platform is a cure for what he sees today. The fed outta control etc. the fed is the problem and although I don't know as much about free markets and the economy as ron paul, I trust that he knows the cure that will get the country back to where it was supposed to be.

it's risky, but that is what patriots do.
 
The fed outta control etc. the fed is the problem and although I don't know as much about free markets and the economy as ron paul, I trust that he knows the cure that will get the country back to where it was supposed to be.

it's risky, but that is what patriots do.

You trust Ron Paul from a position of faith?

How can you admit that and then criticize posters for being fooled by the current government?
 
Dr. paul is a doctor ...... I don't know as much about free markets and the economy as ron paul, I trust that he knows the cure that will get the country back to where it was supposed to be.

it's risky, but that is what patriots do.

It's called Das Führer Prinzip, the Führer Principle. Have fun with it, it always turns out very badly in the end. Lucky for the rest of us that Ron Paul is nothing more than a pathetic joke.

And: Physician, heal thyself.
 
It's called Das Führer Prinzip, the Führer Principle. Have fun with it, it always turns out very badly in the end. Lucky for the rest of us that Ron Paul is nothing more than a pathetic joke.

And: Physician, heal thyself.

he sees the gold standard as a solution to the current situation. THat's what doctors do, they see the symptoms and find a cure.
 
Dr. Fascism said:
(this is a highly left-wing forum, after all).
gtc said:
Actually, I am not left-wing and would not vote for Obama (if I could actually vote in the US election). I think Ron Paul's policies are silly and his supporters, on average, even sillier.
So?

And I think you're silly. What point are you trying to make?

I believe gtc was trying to show how quickly an uninformed blanket statement can be shown to be false.
 
he sees the gold standard as a solution to the current situation. THat's what doctors do, they see the symptoms and find a cure.

Dr. Mengele, Dr Harold Shipman and Dr John Bodkin Adams are obviously your medical role models of choice.
 
ron paul is not W. we'll leave it that.

So you mean you do trust Ron Paul from a position of faith because he isn't George W Bush.

You've just both proved the cult like nature of Ron Paul supporters and given a really irrational reason for being part of it.
 
Last edited:
So you mean you do trust Ron Paul from a position of faith because he isn't George W Bush.

You've just both proved the cult like nature of Ron Paul supporters and given a really irrational reason for being part of it.

Well, I've never said that, so you're putting words in my mouth.

Ron Paul has a little thing called integrity. Maybe you've heard of it?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom