The Revolution Begins

Until you guys read naomi wolfs book "end of america", you should just keep quiet! Read the book and then you can comment on it.

You mean the one we had a seven page thread on a while ago? http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=95779

Yeah, us dumb old "book" people. Amazing how little we know about your paper tigers and cultural icons, isn't it.

Are you ever gonna get over yourself?

(And note that the thread was introduced with substance and comments, not by just shouting out the name of the book and saying, "You righties have to read this!")
 
You mean the one we had a seven page thread on a while ago? http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?t=95779

Yeah, us dumb old "book" people. Amazing how little we know about your paper tigers and cultural icons, isn't it.

Are you ever gonna get over yourself?

(And note that the thread was introduced with substance and comments, not by just shouting out the name of the book and saying, "You righties have to read this!")

Ok, well , what was your impression of the book?
 
My impression, like a lot of us on the left, is that she actually made some good points, but took those points to extreme conclusions.

I'm not concerned about the Executive usurping the powers of the states - if the Executive is/was doing so for the benefit of the Federal Government and equal treatment under the law. What I'm concerned about is the Executive usurping the powers of the Legislative, which is where Bush has inched towards a more totalitarian form a government.

Yet, it's a far cry from the death of the United States as a democracy (her view) and paranoid visions of Bush/Cheney staging a NWO coup (your view). The Executive has been fighting with Congress for the past hundred years over just this trend. There have been many acts passed by Congress, under Presidents of all stripes, taking more and more power into the Executive.

Same situation in the Judiciary. It was FDR who invented the "stacking of the Supreme Court", after all. (Maybe not so much by intention, but by the duration of his tenure in office. But he did put out a court that oversaw decisions well into the 60s.) The coincidence (and some mathematical advantage) that since 1960, Supreme Court vacancies have occurred more during the 7 Republican presidential terms than in the 5 Democratic terms has allowed the conservatives to do unto the liberals what they done unto them... stack the court with more conservative jurists for a generation.

States Rightists (pun intended) tend to think the separation of powers has four parties, Executive, Legislative, Judicial, States. The States were never meant to be equal partners. If you look at the overall framework of the Constitution, the States were almost an after thought. If you actually understand the mentality of the BF(Blessed Founders), you realize that there was still quite a bit of noblesse oblige in their attitudes. "Look, we're the Blessed Founders, and we're so frakkin' smart that we've thought of everything... everything, I tells ya! And whatever we didn't outline here as our job? Well, the states can take care of that."

And then, when they found out they left out certain things ("Err, Pssst, Blessed Founders what about, uh, like personal rights of citizens?"), they amended their document to make it more clear that the Fed was writing the rules for EVERYTHING. "Oh, and anything left over after we finish all this amending? Well, that the states can have."

That, like it or not, is what your Blessed Founders were all about. Upper Middle Class and Upper Class White Guys. I think all you guys are confusing Sam Adams and Patrick Henry with Hamilton and Madison.
 
My impression, like a lot of us on the left, is that she actually made some good points, but took those points to extreme conclusions.

I'm not concerned about the Executive usurping the powers of the states - if the Executive is/was doing so for the benefit of the Federal Government and equal treatment under the law. What I'm concerned about is the Executive usurping the powers of the Legislative, which is where Bush has inched towards a more totalitarian form a government.

Yet, it's a far cry from the death of the United States as a democracy (her view) and paranoid visions of Bush/Cheney staging a NWO coup (your view). The Executive has been fighting with Congress for the past hundred years over just this trend. There have been many acts passed by Congress, under Presidents of all stripes, taking more and more power into the Executive.

Same situation in the Judiciary. It was FDR who invented the "stacking of the Supreme Court", after all. (Maybe not so much by intention, but by the duration of his tenure in office. But he did put out a court that oversaw decisions well into the 60s.) The coincidence (and some mathematical advantage) that since 1960, Supreme Court vacancies have occurred more during the 7 Republican presidential terms than in the 5 Democratic terms has allowed the conservatives to do unto the liberals what they done unto them... stack the court with more conservative jurists for a generation.

States Rightists (pun intended) tend to think the separation of powers has four parties, Executive, Legislative, Judicial, States. The States were never meant to be equal partners. If you look at the overall framework of the Constitution, the States were almost an after thought. If you actually understand the mentality of the BF(Blessed Founders), you realize that there was still quite a bit of noblesse oblige in their attitudes. "Look, we're the Blessed Founders, and we're so frakkin' smart that we've thought of everything... everything, I tells ya! And whatever we didn't outline here as our job? Well, the states can take care of that."

And then, when they found out they left out certain things ("Err, Pssst, Blessed Founders what about, uh, like personal rights of citizens?"), they amended their document to make it more clear that the Fed was writing the rules for EVERYTHING. "Oh, and anything left over after we finish all this amending? Well, that the states can have."

That, like it or not, is what your Blessed Founders were all about. Upper Middle Class and Upper Class White Guys. I think all you guys are confusing Sam Adams and Patrick Henry with Hamilton and Madison.
Great post, even if you are a leftie... ;)
 
Great post, even if you are a leftie... ;)

Hey, thanks, Randfan! I do training here and like to put things in over-simplified terms, sometimes, as the students are about forty-five years my junior and are challenged by English, anyway. Of course there's exaggeration and hyperbole in there, but, hey... we're on the Interwebs.
 
My impression, like a lot of us on the left, is that she actually made some good points, but took those points to extreme conclusions.

I'm not concerned about the Executive usurping the powers of the states - if the Executive is/was doing so for the benefit of the Federal Government and equal treatment under the law. What I'm concerned about is the Executive usurping the powers of the Legislative, which is where Bush has inched towards a more totalitarian form a government.

Yet, it's a far cry from the death of the United States as a democracy (her view) and paranoid visions of Bush/Cheney staging a NWO coup (your view). The Executive has been fighting with Congress for the past hundred years over just this trend. There have been many acts passed by Congress, under Presidents of all stripes, taking more and more power into the Executive.

Same situation in the Judiciary. It was FDR who invented the "stacking of the Supreme Court", after all. (Maybe not so much by intention, but by the duration of his tenure in office. But he did put out a court that oversaw decisions well into the 60s.) The coincidence (and some mathematical advantage) that since 1960, Supreme Court vacancies have occurred more during the 7 Republican presidential terms than in the 5 Democratic terms has allowed the conservatives to do unto the liberals what they done unto them... stack the court with more conservative jurists for a generation.

States Rightists (pun intended) tend to think the separation of powers has four parties, Executive, Legislative, Judicial, States. The States were never meant to be equal partners. If you look at the overall framework of the Constitution, the States were almost an after thought. If you actually understand the mentality of the BF(Blessed Founders), you realize that there was still quite a bit of noblesse oblige in their attitudes. "Look, we're the Blessed Founders, and we're so frakkin' smart that we've thought of everything... everything, I tells ya! And whatever we didn't outline here as our job? Well, the states can take care of that."

And then, when they found out they left out certain things ("Err, Pssst, Blessed Founders what about, uh, like personal rights of citizens?"), they amended their document to make it more clear that the Fed was writing the rules for EVERYTHING. "Oh, and anything left over after we finish all this amending? Well, that the states can have."

That, like it or not, is what your Blessed Founders were all about. Upper Middle Class and Upper Class White Guys. I think all you guys are confusing Sam Adams and Patrick Henry with Hamilton and Madison.

And having a presidential candidate who would get rid of mischievous organizations like the CIA and the IRS is Bad? You don't hear any other candidate talking about getting rid of the CIA. (cuz they don't have a death wish)

Corrupt government. Thomas jefferson once said "every generation needs a revolution" Do you think he's right on that or wrong?
 
Why would you want to get rid of the CIA? How would you replace it?
 
And having a presidential candidate who would get rid of mischievous organizations like the CIA and the IRS is Bad? You don't hear any other candidate talking about getting rid of the CIA. (cuz they don't have a death wish)

Corrupt government. Thomas jefferson once said "every generation needs a revolution" Do you think he's right on that or wrong?

I give up. No, really... I just plain give up. I've tried to be patient with you, but here comes my next yellow flag or trip to AAH.

You just continue ignoring well-wrought and serious answers from those of us who are still naive enough to think we might actually deliver some sort of comprehensible interpretaiton to you. You, in turn, respond with derails and non-sequiturs.

I responded to your request for an analysis of the book you claimed to be reading. You responded, in turn, with some bilge water and ambergris. You obviously haven't the slightest knowledge of the questions that were being raised. You just want headlines and talking points.

You wannabe frakking revolutionaries are a thing to behold. It's really comfy down there in mom's basement looking at your monitor, I guess. When it comes time to put your a** on the line for your beliefs, where will you be? Like the other twoofers, waiting for a sunny day?
 
Last edited:
I was just going by my spell check. I was making fun of him on how he couldn't spell. Skepticism is the only way I know how to spell it.
Because I could't spell? It was a typo. You've made typos. I don't mind people poking fun of a typo but please don't tell me that I can't spell when you also make mistakes.

Sheesh.
 
I give up. No, really... I just plain give up. I've tried to be patient with you, but here comes my next yellow flag or trip to AAH.

You just continue ignoring well-wrought and serious answers from those of us who are still naive enough to think we might actually deliver some sort of comprehensible interpretaiton to you. You, in turn, respond with derails and non-sequiturs.

I responded to your request for an analysis of the book you claimed to be reading. You responded, in turn, with some bilge water and ambergris. You obviously haven't the slightest knowledge of the questions that were being raised. You just want headlines and talking points.

You wannabe frakking revolutionaries are a thing to behold. It's really comfy down there in mom's basement looking at your monitor, I guess. When it comes time to put your a** on the line for your beliefs, where will you be? Like the other twoofers, waiting for a sunny day?

What? I have to show you my gratitude? OH THANK YOU SO MUCH! YOU ARE SO WISE BUDDY! Anyway, I want to know if you agree with Jefferson's quote of "every generation needs a revolution". Do you agree or disagree?

Your analysis was good. I liked it. Don't be so hard on yourself. When the revolution comes, will you be there?
 
Last edited:
What? I have to show you my gratitude?
He's not asking you for your gratitude. He's asking you to acknowledge the arguments made and either modify your views or rebut the arguments.

Anyway, I want to know if you agree with Jefferson's quote of "every generation needs a revolution". Do you agree or disagree?
I don't know enough about the specific quote to comment one way or the other. I think a revolution like the American revolution every generation would be very impractical and quite unnecessary. The founding fathers were wise and it's quite appropriate to give them deference but we have an advantage of hindsight. Hopefully we aren't too stupid to think for ourselves and not simply act on every word or idea of the founding fathers.

Your analysis was good. I liked it. Don't be so hard on yourself. When the revolution comes, will you be there?
In other words you a.) didn't read his posts b.) don't understand what he is saying c.) are simply ignoring him.
 
Last edited:
It was FDR who invented the "stacking of the Supreme Court", after all. (Maybe not so much by intention, but by the duration of his tenure in office. But he did put out a court that oversaw decisions well into the 60s.) The coincidence (and some mathematical advantage) that since 1960, Supreme Court vacancies have occurred more during the 7 Republican presidential terms than in the 5 Democratic terms has allowed the conservatives to do unto the liberals what they done unto them... stack the court with more conservative jurists for a generation.

Oh yeah fool? This country was hijacked in 1913 and things have never been the same since.

The president, with help from the CIA appoints an attorney general who is just as corrupt as he.

Attorney general john mitchell, went to prison for his corrupt activities. Attorney general edwin meese who was a former california attorney and alameda county district attorney, was prominently associated with an escalation of the sleazy and corrupt activities in government. He was implicated in the 1980 October Surprise scheme that helped bring the reagan-bush team to power. As a reward, or to protect the reagan-bush team from prosecution in that scandal, the reagan-bush administration appointed meese U.S attorney general. Meese was then used to protect reagan and bush from the october surprise scandal and others that followed.

Corrupt government. Vote Ron Paul, the one man brave enough to take down the CIA.
 
Corrupt government. Vote Ron Paul, the one man brave enough to take down the CIA.
Power corrupts. The founding fathers knew this which is why Jefferson suggested a revolution every generation.

I don't know if Ron Paul really is immune to the corrupting influence of power or if he could do all that he claims he can. I doubt it and I don't think it's even necassary. The system could be better and hopefully it will be. Ron Paul isn't the only means for change.

I'm sorry to tell you but Ron Paul is at best going to get a fraction of the vote.
 
It was FDR who invented the "stacking of the Supreme Court", after all. (Maybe not so much by intention, but by the duration of his tenure in office. But he did put out a court that oversaw decisions well into the 60s.) The coincidence (and some mathematical advantage) that since 1960, Supreme Court vacancies have occurred more during the 7 Republican presidential terms than in the 5 Democratic terms has allowed the conservatives to do unto the liberals what they done unto them... stack the court with more conservative jurists for a generation.

Oh yeah fool? This country was hijacked in 1913 and things have never been the same since.

Interesting. Hijacked?

The president, with help from the CIA appoints an attorney general who is just as corrupt as he.

Attorney general john mitchell, went to prison for his corrupt activities. Attorney general edwin meese who was a former california attorney and alameda county district attorney, was prominently associated with an escalation of the sleazy and corrupt activities in government. He was implicated in the 1980 October Surprise scheme that helped bring the reagan-bush team to power. As a reward, or to protect the reagan-bush team from prosecution in that scandal, the reagan-bush administration appointed meese U.S attorney general. Meese was then used to protect reagan and bush from the october surprise scandal and others that followed.

I'm reasonably sure you'll have sources for this?

Corrupt government. Vote Ron Paul, the one man brave enough to take down the CIA.
[/quote]

Taking down the CIA doesn't really mean much without a plan.
 
Ichabod,
Can you source that quote? I'd love to use it in my tertiary career as Leader of the Grammar Resistance. (But the people I'm fighting are such pedants that if it's not a for-real Andrew Jackson quote, I'm dead meat.)

Can't find it on the internets; my American Lit. teacher used it the other day, and I made sure to write it down. I'll shoot her an e-mail...
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom