Jack by the hedge
Safely Ignored
How you ask a question should never change the answer in pure math.
Exactly. How you ask the question does not change the answer unless that change means you literally ask a different question.
How you ask a question should never change the answer in pure math.
I don't understand what you mean about there being something vague about the probability itself.
I see the probability as being a property of the system itself rather than some property of the human observer. You can perfectly easily write a computer program which uses random numbers to choose what to do next and over thousands of iterations the probabilities of each outcome shine through without any human intervention.

How you ask a question should never change the answer in pure math.
Exactly. How you ask the question does not change the answer unless that change means you literally ask a different question.
It has been done for this problem. The versions I've seen favor answer 4 (1/11). However, one suspects the programmers wrote the procedure in the way they also conceived of the puzzle (with their assumptions injected thereby) and so created a kind of self-fulfilling simulation.![]()
Indeed, and this is a key point: in questions of probability, how you ask the question influences the answer you get. It's not merely deductive, the procedure makes a difference.
That property is troubling all by itself. And not just troubling because of vagueness in the statement of the puzzle (or language), but something vague attached to probability itself.
That's the property that makes it troubling. (Which is to say, "interesting.")
In other words they made a mistake in their code. That answer is most definitely wrong.
It is true the problem just says, "Sally rolls two dice..." and doesn't specify whether they are rolled together or separately. It is also true that the problem does not outline Sally's internal "procedure" for her subsequent actions.
If probability is about making statements about the dice (as randomizing objects) how is it that any of that matters?
That's the property that makes it troubling. (Which is to say, "interesting.")
You've disagreed by assuming an answer, not by obviating my insistence on clarification. If it were stated as you do here, then I agree with your further analysis. My point is that it was not stated so clearly.Not really. In this case it is pretty simple.
Known :
* 2 dice are thrown
* 1 dice is a 6
* dice are fair so assumed independent
unknown :
* value of other dice
In the one interpretation, but given its wording in the OP, that interpretation is not the only legitimate one.Aepervius said:There is no monty halling or anything at work. It is a straightforward.
See above.Aepervius said:Whether you count all pair with 6 as above or you count all a pair where one fixed die is a six you always come to the same conclusion : 1/6 because this is by definition the value probability of any fair dice.
This doesn't come naturally to me, and I'm distracted with other work, so I will admit I don't fully follow this.Aepervius said:You could get something more complicated if :
Sally knows one die is a six.
What is the probability if you look at one of the die at random , that it is a six ?
Well you have 1/2 chance at looking at one die so 1/2 is a six
then the other die 1/6, sot the probability to SEE one six when you look at ONE die is : 1/6+1/2 = 7/12 far more interesting IMO.
But as stated , what is the probability of the other die being a six, it is straightforward.
I suppose I tend to find it more "annoying".Sometimes answers become obvious if people just spend a bit more effort on deciding what their actual question is.
Maybe not the code but the recipe the code simulates. Do you code? Apparently it can be done in Excel.
Does the answer change in your framing if one die is red and the other green or wouldn't that matter? (Just curious about how you are thinking about the puzzle.)
Does the answer change in your framing if one die is red and the other green or wouldn't that matter? (Just curious about how you are thinking about the puzzle.)
Well I was thinking of red and blue in case anyone was a red-green colourblind thinker.
In rejecting their claim for answer (4) it matters that they differentiate between 1,6 and 6,1 regarding those as two separate outcomes but they do not differentiate between 6,6 and 6,6. So there really are twelve possible outcomes, not eleven, and two of them have a six on the unseen die.
As Aepervius said, it's not true that the answer depends on how you ask the question; the answer depends on what the initial circumstances are. As long as the question reflects that correctly, then you'll get the correct answer. For example, taking your question: "Sally rolls two dice (6-sided, assumed fair). She shows one is a six. What is the probability that the other one is a six?" There are some things unstated here that in effect render the question unanswerable unless they are assumed. If in reality Sally picks one die at random and shows it, and if the number six is written on only one side of the other die, then the probability is 1/6, however you may want to slice and dice your other assumptions. If, however, you know when asking the question that Sally deliberately chose to reveal the die with the higher number, that may in some situations (though not this one, I think) change the answer, and if you happen to know that both dice have 6 written on all six sides then that most definitely changes it. And if you choose to conceal such information when asking the question, then the XKCD -gry rule applies.
Not really, no. The property is simply that, unless the initial conditions are correctly stated, then the calculated resulting probability will not be correct. That's pretty much the case for any predictive statement.
Dave
Well I was thinking of red and blue in case anyone was a red-green colourblind thinker.
In rejecting their claim for answer (4) it matters that they differentiate between 1,6 and 6,1 regarding those as two separate outcomes but they do not differentiate between 6,6 and 6,6. So there really are twelve possible outcomes, not eleven, and two of them have a six on the unseen die.
But my point is that in fact you're not making a statement about the dice. You are making a statement about a set of dice rolling events, some of which have already occurred. The likelihood of an outcome from the set depends equally on all the rolls.It is true the problem just says, "Sally rolls two dice..." and doesn't specify whether they are rolled together or separately. It is also true that the problem does not outline Sally's internal "procedure" for her subsequent actions.
If probability is about making statements about the dice (as randomizing objects) how is it that any of that matters? Surely it wouldn't matter if I were talking about the probability of other types of random events, would it?
(e.g. the chances of the San Andreas fault slipping tomorrow.)
But my point is that in fact you're not making a statement about the dice. You are making a statement about a set of dice rolling events, some of which have already occurred. The likelihood of an outcome from the set depends equally on all the rolls.
I agree to an extent, but the step you took isn't the whole trip.
If I state the problem with enough specificity, I get answer 1. Why? Because enough specificity gives me all the relevant details (Sally's hand position, the forces on the dice, the constitution of the surface they land on, etc. ad nauseum) and any notions of less than certainty (probability one or zero) evaporates thereby.
What you seem to be asking for is only enough specificity to differentiate between certain answers and then stop.
It is interesting that you differentiate a red six and a blue six from a blue six and a red six (answer 5, which no one likes yet, depends on this too). Where did the ordering element come in? Is it because Sally shows one dice and has a choice?
Suppose Sally merely stated, "At least one of the dice is a six" (but didn't show any). Would this change alter your analysis? (Keeping the colors in play.)