The Power of Prayer.

Navigator

Philosopher
Joined
Apr 18, 2004
Messages
7,324
The Power of Prayer.

In a recent thread I made this comment in a post:

That is good. I was ‘praying’ for something like that to happen.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=9349790&postcount=161

Now I was being tongue in cheek as well as realizing that some find the word ‘Prayer’ to be ‘wooish’ and are easily offended by such expressions, so it felt appropriate to use it.

But what I was really saying was that I was hoping that a particular outcome would evolve and when it did, I was grateful for it.

So I was wondering about my use of the word in relation to hoping for a certain outcome and this got me thinking more about the ‘Power of Prayer’ in relation to individual Consciousness – that mindful thing – and the mindless environment which individual Consciousness exists within.

Prayer in relation to the individual is itself a ‘personal request’ which involves the manipulation of events outside of ones own ability to effect in a way which ‘makes it happen’.

I have personally used it throughout the greater proportion of my life and have come to recognise the different ways it can be expressed – verbally, in the thoughts, through the emotions, and I have never been disappointed at the results although I can also say that the prayer may not have been answered in any specific way that I may have personally visualised, it does nonetheless show itself to be connected to my request and always shows itself to be a better – more well adjusted and useful – unfolding than any I may have imagined.

In relation to wooism and the Sceptical Atheist Meme which would like to see all forms of wooism dumped from every Human Meme, even for the sake of Humanity, I find it difficult to understand how SAM is going to achieve this dream and make it real, given the Power of Prayer, which to me is perhaps the most significant obstacle to remove from the various Memes which use Prayer...and swear by its authenticity.

This observation is based on the fact that, regardless of what branch of the Religious Meme, from Catholic, to Spiritualist, From Islam to the Gypsy Fortune Teller, all operate with some form of Prayer – making requests and seeing them unfold in reality as if the mindless physical universe has a mind, can hear, understands, is intelligent and able to interact with the individual mind in relation to the outside influences of nature and circumstance to which the mind has no direct control over.

This is Mighty Big Power, and as such might need to be addressed more fully that a viable understandable explanation regarding the Science of Prayer might evolve and prosper.
Now personally I haven’t really analysed it too scientifically. But as I understand it for what it does, and that it works – even be that it is a subjective realisation – it nonetheless is a shared subjective realisation which amounts to millions and maybe billions of individuals using it with varying degrees of perpetual success and in this such Power is more convincing than Scientists, Skeptics, or even Magicians.

What is Prayer, how come it works and is it even necessarily 'wooish'?
 
Those that have analysed it scientifically found that it doesn't appear to work, I'm afraid.
 
Those that have analysed it scientifically found that it doesn't appear to work.

Do you think a one line statement is adequate an argument to encourage those who know that Prayer works to ignore their experience?
 
The Power of Prayer.
Prayer in relation to the individual is itself a ‘personal request’ which involves the manipulation of events outside of ones own ability to effect in a way which ‘makes it happen’.

I have personally used it throughout the greater proportion of my life and have come to recognise the different ways it can be expressed – verbally, in the thoughts, through the emotions, and I have never been disappointed at the results although I can also say that the prayer may not have been answered in any specific way that I may have personally visualised, it does nonetheless show itself to be connected to my request and always shows itself to be a better – more well adjusted and useful – unfolding than any I may have imagined.

[...]

This observation is based on the fact that, regardless of what branch of the Religious Meme, from Catholic, to Spiritualist, From Islam to the Gypsy Fortune Teller, all operate with some form of Prayer – making requests and seeing them unfold in reality as if the mindless physical universe has a mind, can hear, understands, is intelligent and able to interact with the individual mind in relation to the outside influences of nature and circumstance to which the mind has no direct control over.

[...]

What is Prayer, how come it works and is it even necessarily 'wooish'?
Prayer is a way of talking to yourself.

When people pray for things which their actions and attitudes can help bring about, it can be an effective way of psyching themselves up, of motivating themselves to take those actions or adopt those attitudes which they reasonably expect will bring about the results they seek.

When people pray for things which their actions can't possibly alter, the events they pray for may happen some proportion of the time. Confirmation bias, post hoc rationalization, and selective forgetting will often provide the illusion that their prayers have been more effective than not praying.

It's absolutely irrational. If you did test it scientifically, you'd see that it's only effective in reinforcing behaviors which the individual wants to cultivate, i.e., "Help me to eat more healthy meals, and to find time to exercise" or "Help me to be more patient with the idiots who afflict me daily."

Praying for rain -- no effect whatsoever. But if you pray for rain, and it does rain, you may attribute it to prayer. If it doesn't rain, you may rationalize it (i.e., "well, this was a more well adjusted and useful unfolding than any I may have imagined. It didn't rain until three months after all the crops had died, which enables us to make a fresh start with all new crops. My prayers were answered!") or you may tend to forget about all the failures and emphasize the "successes".

The power of prayer is the power of people to deceive themselves.
 
Do you think a one line statement is adequate an argument to encourage those who know that Prayer works to ignore their experience?

No, but I don't think that an entire book would, either.

The Templeton Foundation funded a large study in 2006 called The STEP Project.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Studies_on_intercessory_prayer#The_STEP_project

That's probably the largest available and it found that those being prayed for weren't affected, unless they actually knew about it, in which case they were worse than either those not being prayed for or those being prayed for that were unaware of it.

You know that it works. Studies have shown that it doesn't appear to.
I'm sure that this information isn't going to impact upon your opinion in any meaningful manner.
 
Do you think a one line statement is adequate an argument to encourage those who know that Prayer works to ignore their experience?

There has to be some agency at work to actually make prayer have any effect on anything. There has been no evidence of such agency in the history of humankind despite millenia of claims. Therefore the power of prayer does not exist.
 
Last edited:
No, but I don't think that an entire book would, either.

So then, a major reason why wooism will never be purged from the Human Consciousness is, as I suggested, that it is a mighty big power.

So any hope one might have and support one might personally give to any Meme whose ambition it is to eradicate wooism from the face of the Planet, is wasted hope and effort?

One liners will suffice? Books are pointless? The wooist will never be talked out of it.

It seems Prayer, for those who use it, is neither a wasted hope nor effort.

That is what makes it a mighty big power. In some ways, a Super Power.

I say this in regard to the millions if not billions of individuals who use it and because it works, give their allegiance to that which promotes its use ... various ways in which it is used.
 
Last edited:
So then, a major reason why wooism will never be purged from the Human Consciousness is, as I suggested, that it is a mighty big power.

How did you get that from what I'd written?

No attempt to address the scientific study of prayer?
 
I'm sure most of the passengers on the planes on 9/11 were praying to see their families again.
 
There has to be some agency at work to actually make prayer have any effect on anything. There has been no evidence of such agency in the history of humankind despite millenia of claims. Therefore the power of prayer does not exist.

But the power of Prayer does exist in the experiences of those (perhaps billions) who use it.

The 'agency' credited depends on the particular Meme which the individual is aligned with and supports.

The individual does the crediting, or acknowledges and supports the leaders of whatever particular Meme the individual belongs to and supports - in agreeing with those leaders as to the agency.
 
I'm sure most of the passengers on the planes on 9/11 were praying to see their families again.

There are 2 arguments (at least) against this:
1) The terrorists and their backers were praying that they'd succeed, too.
2) They will see their families in the afterlife.

Add the other old ones about god moving in mysterious ways, you don't always get what you pray for, etc. and any other excuses that anyone can think of for prayer.
 
But the power of Prayer does exist in the experiences of those (perhaps billions) who use it.

The 'agency' credited depends on the particular Meme which the individual is aligned with and supports.

The individual does the crediting, or acknowledges and supports the leaders of whatever particular Meme the individual belongs to and supports - in agreeing with those leaders as to the agency.

So, circular reasoning? Groovy.
 
Placebo effect if anything.

If this were real, pharmaceutical companies would not exist.
People would just engage their placebo and effect the necessary changes.
Or maybe it is real, and people are not encouraged to think it is so that pharmaceutical companies continue existing.
Either way, saying it is placebo effect seems to be like saying it is prayer – just another word for it.
Or:
The mind is far more capable of effecting things than we realise, and that there is no outside mindless assistance (agency) involved.
 
How did you get that from what I'd written?

From this at the end of my OP:
What is Prayer, how come it works and is it even necessarily 'wooish'?

...and aligned with the known fact that there is a growing effort to eradicate wooism from the Human Consciousness.

If it is not completely understood, how can there be a successful way to explain what is happening that those suffering wooism might understand.
How can one thing encourage the other to stop teaching its children things which encourage woosim?

Especially when it come to this big power called prayer?
 
If this were real, pharmaceutical companies would not exist.
People would just engage their placebo and effect the necessary changes.
Or maybe it is real, and people are not encouraged to think it is so that pharmaceutical companies continue existing.
Either way, saying it is placebo effect seems to be like saying it is prayer – just another word for it.
Or:
The mind is far more capable of effecting things than we realise, and that there is no outside mindless assistance (agency) involved.

No it isn't.
 

Back
Top Bottom