NWO Sentryman
Proud NWO Gatekeeper
- Joined
- Jun 16, 2009
- Messages
- 6,994
Germany successfully tested their bomb in the Fall of 1944 and March 1945.

Evidence for that?
Otherwise, this is stundied.
Germany successfully tested their bomb in the Fall of 1944 and March 1945.

Germany successfully tested their bomb in the Fall of 1944 and March 1945.
For me personally it would depend entirely on the circumstances. I think the Germans winning the war they began on September 1 1939 is a plausible scenario, however it requires certain things to have happened/not happened throughout the progress of the war - mainly on the part of the allies. These are things that were likewise plausible.
If you mean the later stages of the war then no, Nazi victory is implausible.
The more obvious condition is the USA not joining the war against Germany, even after Pearl Harbor. I think this could have easily happened, and without the enormous weight of US industry behind them, the allies would have been hard pressed to defeat Germany in Europe.
I tried to come up with something witty to say here, but failed. So I'd like you to all pretend that I said something really, really funny, and nominate me.
Germany had similar long range strategic bomber research going on: the flying wing. Couple this with their bomb and things could have been different.
Germany successfully tested their bomb in the Fall of 1944 and March 1945.
Germany had similar long range strategic bomber research going on: the flying wing. Couple this with their bomb and things could have been different.
Russia won the war against Germany, Britain was an afterthought, and the US' biggest role was to ship arms to the Russians.
9 out of 10 dead German soldiers died in the Russian Campaign. Everything else? 1 out of 10. D-Day? THe battles to shatter what was left of Hitler's armies? The bombings and air strikes and African warfare? 1 out of 10.
All bets were off after Churchill and friends were elected to power in the UK
Minor nitpick, but Churchill wasn't elected; he was appointed Prime Minister by the King.
Minor nitpick, but Churchill wasn't elected; he was appointed Prime Minister by the King.
The 'Battle of the Atlantic' one of the most embarrassing 'battles' ever fought in the history of warfare? By 1943, the Germans had sank nearly a million tons of allied cargo for the price of a few handfuls of U-boats.
I'd like to point out though that, while the US aid certainly helped a lot, it helps if it's put in perspective.
The Russians produced some 84,000+ T-34's alone. Add in the heavy tank category approximately 5,219 KV-1, 255 KV-2, 3,854 IS-2, 2,311 IS-3, 250 IS-4. Then there was the buttload of older tanks which are much maligned, but were fairly on par with what Germany had in the early days. And then there are the tank destroyers and SP Artillery pieces (the ISU-152 sounds like a mobile howitzer, but the massive shell could mess up even a Tiger) and whatnot.
The 7000 tanks received from the allies were hardly the backbone of Russia's tank armies.
And for example they actually had to convert a lot of the 2000 or so underpowered 75mm Shermans (which couldn't penetrate the sloped armour on a Panther at any distance) to their own 76mm guns, as well as replace the tracks on most Shermans with something that actually worked in heavy snow. The gasoline engine also made it very much unloved by the crews.
Don't get me wrong, I'm not trying to say it didn't help, or anything. Just that one shouldn't underestimate the massive resources the Soviets themselves threw at it.
The 'Battle of the Atlantic' one of the most embarrassing 'battles' ever fought in the history of warfare? By 1943, the Germans had sank nearly a million tons of allied cargo for the price of a few handfuls of U-boats.
In fact, given the questionable 'quality' of the British naval ships in anti-submarine work, and the fact that merchant ships themselves were armed in the early stages, simply banding the ships into convoys and providing some weaponry would have most likely been as effective or more, at less expense, and offering more flexibility to the British Navy.
No, the 'Battle of the Atlantic' was important, but only in determining the rate at which the allies lost ships to U-Boats.
And there's no real evidence that the pre-1942/43 convoy efforts were truly much good at all, in terms of protection offered by naval ships.
The more important part was arming the merchant ships so that they could scare off a U-Boat in the event that one surfaced (as Torpedo quantities were limited) and the realization that a small number of highly concentrated targets is far more difficult for the Germans to target. It's that final realization that accounted for most of the success of convoys.
In terms of importance, it's true Allied shipping was paramount, but in terms of operations, the Battle of the Atlantic wasn't a clear-cut victory, or even particularly decisive in any way.`
From 1939 to 1942 the Germans increasingly sank more and more allied shipping, and while Allied production increased, it was a doomed equation, with Germany clearly having victory.
Their only possibility for changing the tide of the European theater would have been to develop the atomic bomb first...
...and employ it (especially threatening if added as a warhead to their V2 rockets).
Had they had the resources and could maintain manufacturing maybe air superiority using jet airplanes and rockets would have had an impact.
If you asked me if I'd rather roll around northern France in a Sherman or a Tiger, I'd take the German tank unhesitatingly, but I understand your point.
That's fine. You take your sexy Panther, I'll take the Shermans that were far easier on logistics, ran better and more reliably and that in their better/later incarnations were a match for the Panther anyways. I'll also take the late war Allied tanks that would have stomped any German tank and in far larger numbers. I'll also take the far superior planes and artillery that you couldn't swing a dead cat without hitting one or two nearby by the end of the war. I'll also take the massive amounts of trucks and mechanized transport, and the superior comms systems.![]()