The plausibility of a Nazi Victory

Are we assuming that Britain is still in the war?

If not, how do we get the bomb to Berlin?


The U.S. was already beginning work on long range and very long range strategic bombers. The capability specifications which ultimately led to the post-war B-36 Peacemaker were first introduced in April of 1941: a bomber capable of operating at altitudes up to 45,000 feet, a cruising speed of 275 MPH, and an range of 12,000 miles. This is eight months before the U.S. enters the war, and two months before Germany invaded the Soviet Union.

Now, while those requirements were soon toned down due to the technology of the day not being up to the task, the point is that the U.S. had already recognized the need for very long range strategic bombers. And it continued work on such weapons throughout the war, improving the technology.

As it was, the B-36 first flew in August of 1946, just a year after the war's end. It might have flown sooner had Convair not been told to put priority on other aircraft projects.
 
Last edited:
Are we assuming that Britain is still in the war?

If not, how do we get the bomb to Berlin? The same transport issues that make it hard for Germany to invade the States make it hard for the States to invade or attack Europe.

B-36 Peacemaker, the first operational bomber with an intercontinental range. First flight 1946, entered service 1949. I bet if they had to they could have made it operational sooner.
 
Are we assuming that Britain is still in the war?

If not, how do we get the bomb to Berlin? The same transport issues that make it hard for Germany to invade the States make it hard for the States to invade or attack Europe.

We'd use aircraft carriers if we couldn't use British bases, probably lose a few to U-boats early on but with our production and manpower advantages we'd be able to withstand it.
 
We'd use aircraft carriers if we couldn't use British bases, probably lose a few to U-boats early on but with our production and manpower advantages we'd be able to withstand it.

I don't think the US could have challenged the Nazi's in France with carrier based aircraft alone. You need a preinvasion bombing campaign which you can't get with carriers and frankly, without bases closer than the US, supplying the fleet and the troops would not be practical, certainly not in 1944 or 1945.

If the Nazi's win Europe through force of arms or diplomacy (Russia falls apart, Spain joins the Axis) its a race to the atomic bomb, which the US still wins. That's the path to victory, if the US has the stomach to nuke Europe.
 
If the US had not gotten into the war -- say, America's isolationists had exerted more influence and America did not join the UK and Dutch in the oil embargo of Japan in the late 1930's. So Japan doesn't attack Pearl harbor and America never gets involved in World War II at all, and never embarks on a nuclear program.

I don't know that Germany still would have won in the European theater, but is it possible that the end of the war may have ended in something less than German capitulation? Is it plausible that Germany could have fought to some sort of stalemate in Eastern Europe and then consolidated its hold over Western Europe, eventually defeating the UK?
 
And even when they had, I don't see it. The Nazis were hailed in by many Ukrainians as liberators, not surprising considering the treatment they had gotten from Uncle Joe. However, it took mere weeks for them to discover they had traded in Baal for Beelzebub. With the Nazis' racial ideas about Slavs, they would have had an endless struggle with the local population even if Barbarossa had gone better for them.

I don't see how they could have kept that up against an economically superior, and geographically virtually invulnerable enemy as the US.

The Ukrainian Slavs joined the Waffen SS to fight the Soviets.
 
The geographic location of the US is what makes me think that Germany would have lost the war even if Barbarossa had succeeded. We're isolated, except to the north and south, where we have, if not allies, then at least not-enemies. And it would be difficult for the Germans to have gotten enough manpower across the ocean to get a foothold.

There would never have been an invasion of North America if Germany won in Europe.

This is just fantasy.
 
Frankly, I don't think the Soviets would have surrendered - even when Moscow had fallen. That would have left the Nazis with a severely weakened enemy, but still fighting on a very long, stretched front, and a gigantic area where partisans would pop up all over the place.

Stalin would have surrendered once he knew it was all lost. Hitler would have allowed Stalin to run what was left of Russia.

Remember the Bulgarians were used to negotiate the Soviet surrender.
 
In addition to all the other factors mentioned above, the US would still have gotten the Bomb by 1945. I can't see how Germany could have continued the war against an atomic-armed foe.

Germany successfully tested their bomb in the Fall of 1944 and March 1945.
 
In summary, I see three things that would have to happen if the Nazis could possible win (winning being in this case a defeat of the Soviet Union)

1. Remove Britain from the war.
2. Ensure America doesn't oppose them.
3. Concentrate fully on the Soviets.

Does this chain of events seem far fetched? Or are their other obstacles, such as German low production that would stop them, even just fighting the Soviets?

No, it's not far-fetched. I mentioned before that what we call the Western Allies were perfectly fine with allowing a fascist victory in Spain. This changed only with the rise of Churchill and friends in the UK. Not much else had changed from 1936 to 1940.

Most of the people who argue the inevitability of Germany's defeat are not Europeans but Americans. It was only after the Second World War that Americans came to the conclusion that European conflicts are even important to them.
 
The U.S. was already beginning work on long range and very long range strategic bombers. The capability specifications which ultimately led to the post-war B-36 Peacemaker were first introduced in April of 1941: a bomber capable of operating at altitudes up to 45,000 feet, a cruising speed of 275 MPH, and an range of 12,000 miles. This is eight months before the U.S. enters the war, and two months before Germany invaded the Soviet Union.

Now, while those requirements were soon toned down due to the technology of the day not being up to the task, the point is that the U.S. had already recognized the need for very long range strategic bombers. And it continued work on such weapons throughout the war, improving the technology.

As it was, the B-36 first flew in August of 1946, just a year after the war's end. It might have flown sooner had Convair not been told to put priority on other aircraft projects.

Germany had similar long range strategic bomber research going on: the flying wing. Couple this with their bomb and things could have been different.
 
I've been having quite a bit of discussion on Alternatehistory.com about why a Nazi Victory is implausible. I even wrote an essay about it. But why do people assume that a Nazi victory was extremely likely (:rolleyes:) and that any cold war with America would have been a rollover for the Nazis?

I mean, look at Man in the High Castle and you'll understand what i mean.



For me personally it would depend entirely on the circumstances. I think the Germans winning the war they began on September 1 1939 is a plausible scenario, however it requires certain things to have happened/not happened throughout the progress of the war - mainly on the part of the allies. These are things that were likewise plausible.

If you mean the later stages of the war then no, Nazi victory is implausible.

The more obvious condition is the USA not joining the war against Germany, even after Pearl Harbor. I think this could have easily happened, and without the enormous weight of US industry behind them, the allies would have been hard pressed to defeat Germany in Europe.
 
If the US had not gotten into the war -- say, America's isolationists had exerted more influence and America did not join the UK and Dutch in the oil embargo of Japan in the late 1930's. So Japan doesn't attack Pearl harbor and America never gets involved in World War II at all, and never embarks on a nuclear program.

I don't know that Germany still would have won in the European theater, but is it possible that the end of the war may have ended in something less than German capitulation? Is it plausible that Germany could have fought to some sort of stalemate in Eastern Europe and then consolidated its hold over Western Europe, eventually defeating the UK?

Consolidated its hold?

Seen a map recently?

From 1940 onwards Germany had total control of Western Europe. It was Eastern Europe that was a problem, and had the UK been deprived of US industry Germany could have simply bottled them up with a few meager forces and focused much more attention on Russia.

There is no way in a million years that Britain and its Commonwealth could have even dreamed of successfully invading Nazi Europe without US support.

I would argue that the Battle of the Atlantic was the most important campaign of WW2, as it revolved around the lifeblood of supply from primarily the USA to the UK and Russia. Whoever won the Battle of the Atlantic would win the war, essentially.

Even as late as 1943, two years after serious US military contribution to the campaign, allied shipping was still at breaking point, before finally establishing supremacy.

Importantly, the Battle of the Atlantic was a tonnage-war, based on the principle that you could defeat the enemy by sinking supply ships faster than they could replace them.

By 1943 the US were launching three Liberty Ships a day, forcing up the rate at which the Germans had to sink them. This combined with the added protection afforded by US military power, made the tonnage war impossible for Germany to win.

But, had the USA not joined the war, production never would have reached these levels and the Germans would not have needed to sink so many ships to establish victory.

The true heroes of WW2 were the workers in the eighteen shipyards that built the Liberty Ships.
 
I've been having quite a bit of discussion on Alternatehistory.com about why a Nazi Victory is implausible. I even wrote an essay about it. But why do people assume that a Nazi victory was extremely likely (:rolleyes:) and that any cold war with America would have been a rollover for the Nazis?

I mean, look at Man in the High Castle and you'll understand what i mean.

That's not actually what The Man in the High Castle is about, but I'm not sure you want to get into that digression. Suffice to say Phillip K. Dick books are never as simple as that.
 
Consolidated its hold?

Seen a map recently?

From 1940 onwards Germany had total control of Western Europe. It was Eastern Europe that was a problem, and had the UK been deprived of US industry Germany could have simply bottled them up with a few meager forces and focused much more attention on Russia.

There is no way in a million years that Britain and its Commonwealth could have even dreamed of successfully invading Nazi Europe without US support.

I would argue that the Battle of the Atlantic was the most important campaign of WW2, as it revolved around the lifeblood of supply from primarily the USA to the UK and Russia. Whoever won the Battle of the Atlantic would win the war, essentially.

Even as late as 1943, two years after serious US military contribution to the campaign, allied shipping was still at breaking point, before finally establishing supremacy.

Importantly, the Battle of the Atlantic was a tonnage-war, based on the principle that you could defeat the enemy by sinking supply ships faster than they could replace them.

By 1943 the US were launching three Liberty Ships a day, forcing up the rate at which the Germans had to sink them. This combined with the added protection afforded by US military power, made the tonnage war impossible for Germany to win.

But, had the USA not joined the war, production never would have reached these levels and the Germans would not have needed to sink so many ships to establish victory.

The true heroes of WW2 were the workers in the eighteen shipyards that built the Liberty Ships.

Hahahahaha

Last time I had this stupid debate was at stupid ChristianForums, and it was as inane there as it was here.

Russia won the war against Germany, Britain was an afterthought, and the US' biggest role was to ship arms to the Russians.

9 out of 10 dead German soldiers died in the Russian Campaign. Everything else? 1 out of 10. D-Day? THe battles to shatter what was left of Hitler's armies? The bombings and air strikes and African warfare? 1 out of 10.

Russia had ALREADY broken Germany's back. It wasn't a fight to keep Hitler from winning, it was a fight to keep Stalin from swallowing Europe.

And he would have. Russia was larger, Russia was backed by US weaponry, and Russia would most likely have won. Hell, who the hell looks at Stalingrad and doesn't think that Russia would have thrown every last man, woman, and child at the Germans to kill them? Hell, after Stalingrad, they'd have done it themselves - and did.

As for the most important battle of the war, there is no question. The Battle of Stalingrad. Control of the river that allowed Russian industry to function. A handful of miles from Moscow. Route to the oil and refineries that would allow the German war machine to continue running.

And at the end? Two million dead.
 
Last edited:
Hahahahaha

Last time I had this stupid debate was at stupid ChristianForums, and it was as inane there as it was here.

Russia won the war against Germany, Britain was an afterthought, and the US' biggest role was to ship arms to the Russians.

9 out of 10 dead German soldiers died in the Russian Campaign. Everything else? 1 out of 10. D-Day? THe battles to shatter what was left of Hitler's armies? The bombings and air strikes and African warfare? 1 out of 10.


Actually it's more like 7 out of 10, not 9 out of 10.


Russia had ALREADY broken Germany's back. It wasn't a fight to keep Hitler from winning, it was a fight to keep Stalin from swallowing Europe.

I'm not sure what you're referring to, but the generally agreed turning point of the Eastern Front is Stalingrad, followed by the Battle of Kursk. Both of these occurred at about the time I have been referring to as the tipping point; 1943, at which point Germany had finally lost the Battle of the Atlantic as a result of the USA winning the war.

With regards to the Kursk offensive in particular, the only reason the offensive went ahead is because the Germans were very concerned about allied operations in the west, and they were desperate for a rapid victory so they could prepare for the inevitable allied invasion of Western Europe. To illustrate the importance of this, when Hitler learned of the allied invasion of Sicily he immediately halved the forces involved in Operation Citadel, despite the fact that a Russian counter-attack was pushing the German 9th Army backwards.


And he would have. Russia was larger,

In what terms?



Russia was backed by US weaponry

Which could only reach Russia because of the efforts of those that fought in the Battle of the Atlantic.


Hell, who the hell looks at Stalingrad and doesn't think that Russia would have thrown every last man, woman, and child at the Germans to kill them? Hell, after Stalingrad, they'd have done it themselves - and did.

No doubt, but that tactic doesn't necessarily bring victory.


As for the most important battle of the war, there is no question. The Battle of Stalingrad. Control of the river that allowed Russian industry to function. A handful of miles from Moscow. Route to the oil and refineries that would allow the German war machine to continue running.

I disagree. It was certainly a crucial battle, but neither Russia nor Germany could have been assured victory from that one battle. Had Germany not attacked the Kursk salient, and not had to move forces into the west, they could have held the Russians off.

Had the Americans not poured millions of tonnes of supplies into Russia, and had their supplies in men and equipment to the western theatres not split the German war effort, the Germans could have starved them out and whittled them away over a decade or two.

Without any question, the single most important engagement of WW2 was Pearl Harbour, because it brought the largest factory in human history onto the allied side.

Of particular note is the raw material production. Looking at the three most important raw materials - coal, crude oil, and iron ore - Russia lags behind the USA considerably in all three categories, with the USA producing 4 (coal), 5 (iron), and 8 (oil) times as much as Russia.

Finally, as the most compelling evidence of my argument, I point to the Murmansk Run - the 1,600 mile trip from Scotland to the Russian ports of Archangel and Murmansk.

This route was a sticking point of the allied war effort as the Russians and Americans insisted that the British kept sending the convoys despite horrendous losses. Protecting the convoys tied up virtually the entire British Home Fleet.

Through this lifeline - which began in 1941 - Russia was supplied with a staggering amount of equipment, including:

Aircraft: 14,800
Tanks: 7,000
Jeeps: 51,500
Trucks: 375,800
Motorcycles: 35,000
Tractors: 8,000
Guns: 8,000 (that's field guns)
Machine guns: 130,000 (that's heavy machine guns)
Explosives: 345,000 tons
Building equipment valued: $10,000,000 (in 1940s dollars)
Railroad freight cars: 11,000
Locomotives: 1,900
Cargo ships: 90
Submarine hunters: 100
Torpedo boats: 200
Ship engines: 7,700
Food supplies: 4,400,000 tons
Machines and equipment: $1,000,000,000 (in 1940s dollars)
Non-ferrous metals: 800,000 tons
Petroleum products: 2,600,000 tons
Chemicals: 840,000 tons
Cotton: 106,800,000 tons
Leather: 49,800 tons
Tyres: 3,700,000
Army boots: 15,400,000 pairs
Field Telephone cable: 1,000,000 miles

It wasn't exactly a small contribution to the Russian war effort.
 
The 'Battle of the Atlantic' one of the most embarrassing 'battles' ever fought in the history of warfare? By 1943, the Germans had sank nearly a million tons of allied cargo for the price of a few handfuls of U-boats.

In fact, given the questionable 'quality' of the British naval ships in anti-submarine work, and the fact that merchant ships themselves were armed in the early stages, simply banding the ships into convoys and providing some weaponry would have most likely been as effective or more, at less expense, and offering more flexibility to the British Navy.

No, the 'Battle of the Atlantic' was important, but only in determining the rate at which the allies lost ships to U-Boats. And there's no real evidence that the pre-1942/43 convoy efforts were truly much good at all, in terms of protection offered by naval ships. The more important part was arming the merchant ships so that they could scare off a U-Boat in the event that one surfaced (as Torpedo quantities were limited) and the realization that a small number of highly concentrated targets is far more difficult for the Germans to target. It's that final realization that accounted for most of the success of convoys.

In terms of importance, it's true Allied shipping was paramount, but in terms of operations, the Battle of the Atlantic wasn't a clear-cut victory, or even particularly decisive in any way.`
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom