damien pastaume
Thinker
- Joined
- Sep 23, 2007
- Messages
- 145
You have yet to prove the NAU as you claim it to be even exists. There's lots of talk but little evidence. Present some to further your case.
As I said before, NAFTA is not the EU. They're not even in the same park. And it's worth recalling that much of the NAU fears are in the U.S., which is a curious thing since in any supposed North American union it's Canada and Mexico which will be losing their sovereignty and identities, not the U.S.
Perhaps you saw former Mexican president Vicente Fox on Larry King last night? He had some interesting points to make on this subject:
"KING: E-mail from Mrs. Gonzalez in Elizabeth, New Jersey. "Mr. Fox, I would like to know how you feel about the possibility of having a Latin America united with one currency?"
FOX: Long term, very long term. What we propose together, President Bush and myself, it's ALCA, which is a trade union for all of the Americas. And everything was running fluently until Hugo Chavez came. He decided to isolate himself. He decided to combat the idea and destroy the idea...
KING: It's going to be like the euro dollar, you mean?
FOX: Well, that would be long, long term. I think the processes to go, first step into is trading agreement. And then further on, a new vision, like we are trying to do with NAFTA.
http://transcripts.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/0710/08/lkl.01.html
He could hardly have made it plainer. NAFTA is one step on the way to a single currency trading bloc.
Whether we like it or not, the U.S. is the big boy on this continent and things ultimately get done his way.
Over time we will see that argument becoming less and less relevant.
I'll say it again, since I can only presume you are not familiar with the structure, organization, and workings of Canadian government and with the tone and reality of Canadian politics:
Any party which floats, in any way, any sort of direct political union with the U.S., is dead in a federal election. Dead and buried. It was a struggle enough back in 1988 for the government of the day to get re-elected when enacting the FTA was the central issue of the campaign. And such union cannot occur without the relevant legislation passing Parliament (there's a HUGE amount of changes which would need to occur for any sort of union to take place. The differences between the U.S. and Canada are not necessarily visible on the surface, but underneath there are marked differences on everything from the nature of government to laws to culture).
And what if the leadership of both main parties are already signed up to such an idea? Granted, it's box-office poison as far as the people are concerned, yet agreements have already been signed without the consultation of either Congress or the people. As I explained before, the political parties do not create the major policies.
With a dollar now surpassing the U.S., there's no way in hell we're about to give up our dollar for the U.S. greenback or some sort of new unified currency (for which there is no evidence whatsoever). It's not going to happen. Indeed, part of the reason for our currency's success is the fact we've followed our own monetary policy via the Bank of Canada - that's a measure of economic freedom we're not about to give up.
For that matter, I don't see Americans giving up their version of it and the independence it entails any time soon either.
Given the right crisis they will have little choice.
Heh, I can only conclude you've never seen Question Period then. That's the one hour a day where the Opposition gets to grill the government on its policies and legislation. There's no parallel to QP in the U.S. system; Senate debates probably come the closest, but are church meetings in comparison.
The Canadian equivalent of the BBC's 'Question Time'? Largely hot air and catharsis, with the occasional frisson of genuine political debate. I'm glad it exists, but have little faith in its ability to actually change anything.
So, where possible, co-ordination is the goal. That's hardly a radical proposal.
In the end, I keep coming back to this: how can any American think that there country is going to be the one losing its sovereignty and identity when it by far is the most dominant country on the continent in terms of economics and culture? Canada and Mexico are the ones which should be afraid.
All three will lose their sovereignty. From the policy creators' own mouths:
"In short, the 'house of world order' would have to be built from the bottom up rather than from the top down. It will look like a great 'booming, buzzing confusion,' to use William James' famous description of reality, but an end run around national sovereignty, eroding it piece by piece, will accomplish much more than the old-fashioned frontal assault."Richard Gardner, Council on Foreign Relations, 1974
"Some even believe we are part of a secret cabal working against the best interests of the United States, characterizing my family and me as ‘’internationalists’’ and of conspiring with others around the world to build a more integrated global political and economic structure—one world, if you will. If that’s the charge, I stand guilty, and I am proud of it." David Rockefeller, Memoirs 2001