The North American Union

You have yet to prove the NAU as you claim it to be even exists. There's lots of talk but little evidence. Present some to further your case.

As I said before, NAFTA is not the EU. They're not even in the same park. And it's worth recalling that much of the NAU fears are in the U.S., which is a curious thing since in any supposed North American union it's Canada and Mexico which will be losing their sovereignty and identities, not the U.S.

Perhaps you saw former Mexican president Vicente Fox on Larry King last night? He had some interesting points to make on this subject:

"KING: E-mail from Mrs. Gonzalez in Elizabeth, New Jersey. "Mr. Fox, I would like to know how you feel about the possibility of having a Latin America united with one currency?"

FOX: Long term, very long term. What we propose together, President Bush and myself, it's ALCA, which is a trade union for all of the Americas. And everything was running fluently until Hugo Chavez came. He decided to isolate himself. He decided to combat the idea and destroy the idea...

KING: It's going to be like the euro dollar, you mean?

FOX: Well, that would be long, long term. I think the processes to go, first step into is trading agreement. And then further on, a new vision, like we are trying to do with NAFTA.
http://transcripts.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/0710/08/lkl.01.html

He could hardly have made it plainer. NAFTA is one step on the way to a single currency trading bloc.

Whether we like it or not, the U.S. is the big boy on this continent and things ultimately get done his way.

Over time we will see that argument becoming less and less relevant.

I'll say it again, since I can only presume you are not familiar with the structure, organization, and workings of Canadian government and with the tone and reality of Canadian politics:

Any party which floats, in any way, any sort of direct political union with the U.S., is dead in a federal election. Dead and buried. It was a struggle enough back in 1988 for the government of the day to get re-elected when enacting the FTA was the central issue of the campaign. And such union cannot occur without the relevant legislation passing Parliament (there's a HUGE amount of changes which would need to occur for any sort of union to take place. The differences between the U.S. and Canada are not necessarily visible on the surface, but underneath there are marked differences on everything from the nature of government to laws to culture).

And what if the leadership of both main parties are already signed up to such an idea? Granted, it's box-office poison as far as the people are concerned, yet agreements have already been signed without the consultation of either Congress or the people. As I explained before, the political parties do not create the major policies.

With a dollar now surpassing the U.S., there's no way in hell we're about to give up our dollar for the U.S. greenback or some sort of new unified currency (for which there is no evidence whatsoever). It's not going to happen. Indeed, part of the reason for our currency's success is the fact we've followed our own monetary policy via the Bank of Canada - that's a measure of economic freedom we're not about to give up.

For that matter, I don't see Americans giving up their version of it and the independence it entails any time soon either.

Given the right crisis they will have little choice.

Heh, I can only conclude you've never seen Question Period then. That's the one hour a day where the Opposition gets to grill the government on its policies and legislation. There's no parallel to QP in the U.S. system; Senate debates probably come the closest, but are church meetings in comparison.

The Canadian equivalent of the BBC's 'Question Time'? Largely hot air and catharsis, with the occasional frisson of genuine political debate. I'm glad it exists, but have little faith in its ability to actually change anything.

So, where possible, co-ordination is the goal. That's hardly a radical proposal.

In the end, I keep coming back to this: how can any American think that there country is going to be the one losing its sovereignty and identity when it by far is the most dominant country on the continent in terms of economics and culture? Canada and Mexico are the ones which should be afraid.

All three will lose their sovereignty. From the policy creators' own mouths:

"In short, the 'house of world order' would have to be built from the bottom up rather than from the top down. It will look like a great 'booming, buzzing confusion,' to use William James' famous description of reality, but an end run around national sovereignty, eroding it piece by piece, will accomplish much more than the old-fashioned frontal assault."Richard Gardner, Council on Foreign Relations, 1974

"Some even believe we are part of a secret cabal working against the best interests of the United States, characterizing my family and me as ‘’internationalists’’ and of conspiring with others around the world to build a more integrated global political and economic structure—one world, if you will. If that’s the charge, I stand guilty, and I am proud of it." David Rockefeller, Memoirs 2001
 
Perhaps you saw former Mexican president Vicente Fox on Larry King last night?
No, but I did see him on The Daily Show.

He could hardly have made it plainer. NAFTA is one step on the way to a single currency trading bloc.
Trade deals are (relatively) easy. Political and economic unions are not. Besides, the currency of choice would be the U.S. dollar. And you still haven't explained how the U.S. comes out the loser since it dominates the continent economically.

Over time we will see that argument becoming less and less relevant.
Not in North America we won't. Or are you somehow proposing that Canada or Mexico will have economies which generate as much GDP as the U.S. economy generates?

And what if the leadership of both main parties are already signed up to such an idea?
Not going to happen. Politics is politics. And politicians go with the policies which get votes. There is a certain latent amount of anti-Americanism which has always been present in Canada. It's strength varies depending on the state of relations between the two nations, but it's always there.

Granted, it's box-office poison as far as the people are concerned, yet agreements have already been signed without the consultation of either Congress or the people.
And which agreements which have actual legislative impact are those? Agreements to conducts talks about perhaps harmonizing certain regulations and security procedures don't count, because they are just talk. Legislation to enact such changes have to be presented at some point, and the funding for them approved.

And, again, the Canadian political scene and system is entirely different from that of the United States.

Given the right crisis they will have little choice.
Why on Earth would the U.S. give up its one tool by which it controls its own monetary policy? I doubt the U.S. would care much if Canada or Mexico adopted the U.S. dollar as the national currency, since it wouldn't directly impact U.S. choices in regards to monetary policy. The same principle applies to Canada.

The Canadian equivalent of the BBC's 'Question Time'? Largely hot air and catharsis, with the occasional frisson of genuine political debate. I'm glad it exists, but have little faith in its ability to actually change anything.
The goverment and the opposition use it to score political points with the public. On occasion items raised in QP resonate with the public and become major issues.

Another feature of Canadian politics, at least until the current goverment, was the tradition of the media scrum. This is when members of Parliament, either of the government or the opposition, give impromptu interviews with the media before or after a session of Parliament. Points are often scored or lost here as well.

All three will lose their sovereignty.
Lose their sovereignty to whom? If the three nations merge, the U.S. dominates and the other two lose. It's as simple as that.


On a related note, there has been much talk of the alleged "NAFTA superhighway" which would bisect the United States. Maclean's magazine has a report on this in its latest issue. It turns out this supposed highway is mostly a myth mixed in with misunderstandings, misconceptions, and political theatre. You can read the online version of the article here.


I'd like to conclude with the observation that xenophobia and protectionism suck. Both of which are prime factors in the NAU hysteria, as far as I can discern.
 
You can read the online version of the article here.

Thanks for the link to your article which I read in full.


I'd like to conclude with the observation that xenophobia and protectionism suck.

On xenophobia, I completely agree. On protectionism, less so.

Both of which are prime factors in the NAU hysteria, as far as I can discern.

For some, you may well be correct. This is rather unlikely to be so in my case as I'm a UK citizen.

We appear to have very different political overviews which naturally colour our analysis of these events. But's that's okay. I'm not trying to browbeat anyone - just to present an alternative reading of why we are where we are.

Good talking to you.
 
Since it's my own mouth, I think I'm entitled to put words into it.

Your statement in red is meaningless hyperbole. Any shopkeeper who sells tobacco to 16/17 year olds once the ban is in place becomes a criminal at the time he or she does so, rather than becoming a criminal overnight without committing a crime, as your statement seems to imply. And don't try quibbling that it doesn't openly state that; I'm sure you're clever enough to play games with semantics.

I would comment again, you are making an argument against ever changing any law, ever, for any reason. To take a deliberately emotive example, suppose there is a law passed against assuming the identity of a minor on the Internet for the purpose of "grooming" minors for paedophile abuse. On some specific day this act becomes illegal, therefore by your analysis those doing it prior to that time become "criminals overnight". Is this, in any way whatsoever, a comment on the advisability of having such a law?

The law is clear, and everyone has the option of not breaking it.

I see your point and agree I could have worded it better. My point though, remains the same.
The U.K Government implimenting EU directives, it is not a EU suggestion; it is EU Legislation and is unconstitutional.
[FONT=&quot]If we were given the opportunity of a referendum to decide if we in the U.K wished to be ruled by the EU, and the outcome was a resounding ‘yes’ you would not see me complaining, it’s called Democracy, something that seems very scarce in the U.K at the moment.

[/FONT]
Nice and patronizing, I voted in both treaties against the referendum.

It was not my intention to be patronizing, if you feel I was, I apologies.
I’m very glad to hear you voted no… Even if you had to vote ‘no’ a second time because the EU were not happy with the original democratically achieved outcome of ‘NO’ at the first time of asking.
[FONT=&quot]Would you have voted ‘no’ a third time had the second vote been a resounding ‘no’ also?

[/FONT]
The smoking ban was not part of the Nice referendum. Sorry you are just wrong.
[FONT=&quot]I never said it was, I said that after the EU set the groundwork in place by making the people of Eira vote again to accept EU rule, ‘then’ the EU smoking ban was introduced.

[/FONT]
You're taking two separate events and claiming they are interconnected because one happened after the other. There's no link whatsoever. The smoking ban was a popular piece of local legislation.

[FONT=&quot]Show me then that the Irish smoking ban was ‘Irish Legislation’ implemented by the Irish Government prior to the first and second vote on whether or not to accept the Nice Treaty and not ‘EU Legislation’ implemented after the second ‘YES’ vote was gained.

[/FONT]
And what in the wild world of sport do this links prove?

[FONT=&quot]You haven’t seriously viewed the four links I attempted to provide then! You might not be asking that question if you had.

[/FONT]
Well, rather than having to rely on beliefs, suppositions, and conjecture, how about posting some evidence? You know, things which have some legitimacy and weight and which can be examined and discussed.

[FONT=&quot]I did! In my first post. I told you how my right to demonstrate had been removed undemocratically. This ‘Right’ goes back to Magna Carta and was removed over night with the stroke of a pen.

[/FONT]
Nebulous and unfocused fears about maybe this will happen and maybe that will happen do not count as evidence.

[FONT=&quot]Am I not allowed to share my views based on two years of political activity some time ago, and over twenty years of political observation, and not the reliance of a search engine at my finger tips. Or am I only allowed an opinion if it concurs with yours?

[/FONT]
As far as smoking bans, big deal. Lots of states and provinces have enacted various types of smoking bans. How is this EU smoking ban the harbinger of a NAU?

[FONT=&quot]It is not and I never said it was. [/FONT]
 
On xenophobia, I completely agree. On protectionism, less so.
Fair enough. What constitutes "protectionism" would need to be defined in order to discuss it properly.

For some, you may well be correct. This is rather unlikely to be so in my case as I'm a UK citizen.
On the other hand, you are more removed from the day-to-day occurrences and political goings-on here, just as I am more removed from the day-to-day occurrences and political goings-on in the U.K. and Europe. Such removal is worth taking into consideration.

We appear to have very different political overviews which naturally colour our analysis of these events. But's that's okay. I'm not trying to browbeat anyone - just to present an alternative reading of why we are where we are.
Well, it seemed to me more a reading of where things might go, which is a bit different I would say. Projection of where things might go is not necessarily a problem in itself, but I would suggest such projection be more based in hard evidence.

I did! In my first post. I told you how my right to demonstrate had been removed undemocratically. This ‘Right’ goes back to Magna Carta and was removed over night with the stroke of a pen.
And at the end you leaped to the conclusion that the same would happen as a result of NAFTA. Which is what prompted my replies to you. Here's what your post concluded with: "So, like I said, please educate yourselves as to what the NAFTA really entails."

Canada and the U.S. entered into the first free trade agreement in 1989, the FTA. In 1994 this was superceded by NAFTA, mostly at U.S. insistence since it wanted Mexico included in a free trade agreement. So, free trade between the U.S. and Canada has been going on for almost 19 years now, and both countries still exist as separate entities (in spite of Canadian opponents to the FTA who said it would mean the end of our sovereignty and independence). NAFTA has been in place for almost 13 years now, and all three countries still exist as separate entities.

Am I not allowed to share my views based on two years of political activity some time ago, and over twenty years of political observation, and not the reliance of a search engine at my finger tips. Or am I only allowed an opinion if it concurs with yours?
When you leap to conclusions on what is supposedly going to happen in North America, I expect such conclusions to be based on what's actually happening here. Europe is not North America and North America is not Europe. Different backgrounds, different situations, different histories, different systems. Base conclusions on what's actually going on here.

The article I linked to about the mythical NAFTA superhighway shows quite well just how unfounded many of the things are which have cropped up about NAFTA and the supposed NAU.

It is not and I never said it was.
Sorry, but you mentioned that particular item so often in connection with a loss of rights it seemed to be some sort of implication of what's going to happen here.
 
Well, it seemed to me more a reading of where things might go, which is a bit different I would say. Projection of where things might go is not necessarily a problem in itself, but I would suggest such projection be more based in hard evidence.

Fair comment in the confines of a forum such as this. My 'projection' is based on the long view of history, specifically in the 200 years since Hegel. It's essentially a study of gradualism - how extremely long-term plans are set in motion on the world stage. Given their scope, a forum such as this is one of the least favorable venues to present the 'hard evidence'.

However, if you wish to get an idea of what I really mean I wholeheartedly recommend the following as a sampler:
http://www.archive.org/details/NormanDoddInterview

A variety of formats are available: transcript/video.

Eye-opening stuff, indeed.
 
It was not my intention to be patronizing, if you feel I was, I apologies.

Suggesting I'm too young to remember a piece of legislation is patronizing.

I’m very glad to hear you voted no… Even if you had to vote ‘no’ a second time because the EU were not happy with the original democratically achieved outcome of ‘NO’ at the first time of asking.
[FONT=&quot]Would you have voted ‘no’ a third time had the second vote been a resounding ‘no’ also?


Yes as is my democratic right. You'll notice the Nice treaty has died a death haven't you?

[FONT=&quot]I never said it was, I said that after the EU set the groundwork in place by making the people of Eira vote again to accept EU rule, ‘then’ the EU smoking ban was introduced.


I'ts Eire. And you're implying we were brainwashed to accept a piece of legislation.
[/FONT]


[FONT=&quot]Show me then that the Irish smoking ban was ‘Irish Legislation’ implemented by the Irish Government prior to the first and second vote on whether or not to accept the Nice Treaty and not ‘EU Legislation’ implemented after the second ‘YES’ vote was gained.

[/FONT]

Sorry no. Please show me where the EU legislation for the smoking ban existed. Plenty of EU countries don't have a smoking ban.

The timing of the smoking ban in Ireland and the Nice treaty are irrelevant.

[FONT=&quot]You haven’t seriously viewed the four links I attempted to provide then! You might not be asking that question if you had.

[/FONT]

I'm not about to waste my time blindly following four links that you won't bother explaining their significance. Cooperation is a two way street.

[FONT=&quot]I did! In my first post. I told you how my right to demonstrate had been removed undemocratically. This ‘Right’ goes back to Magna Carta and was removed over night with the stroke of a pen.

[/FONT]

By your government not by the EU.

If you have an issue with the right to protest at the Square bring it to the EU court of human rights.

[FONT=&quot]Am I not allowed to share my views based on two years of political activity some time ago, and over twenty years of political observation, and not the reliance of a search engine at my finger tips. Or am I only allowed an opinion if it concurs with yours?


If you're incapable of proving that the Smoking ban was a piece of EU legislation then you can spout all you want, it'll just be ignored as mindless ranting.
 
8den.
If you don’t mind I’ll address your last two points first, as these were from the conversation with Corsair.

By your government not by the EU.

You are absolutely correct. The Exclusion Zone around Parliament was indeed implemented by ‘my’ Government.
I stated so myself in an earlier post in answer to a question from another user asking me to name a ‘Right’ that I claimed I had lost. The ‘Right’ in this case was the ‘Right’ to protest at the home of British Parliament.
I did not say this particular peace of Legislation was a directive from the EU.

If you have an issue with the right to protest at the Square bring it to the EU court of human rights.

At this moment in time I believe that is the case.

If you're incapable of proving that the Smoking ban was a piece of EU legislation then you can spout all you want, it'll just be ignored as mindless ranting.

In the first link below look for 31996Y1211(04) “Council Resolution of 26 November 1996 on the reduction of smoking in the
European Community”… It is about ¼ of the way down the page and it is taken from this europa.eu web site.

eur-lex.europa.eu/en/repert/1530.htm

europa.eu/scadplus/leg/en/cha/c11505a.htm

bmj.com/cgi/content/full/322/7297/1266/b

bmj.com/cgi/reprint/320/7251/1691.pdf

newscientist.com/article.ns?id=dn11063


(Towards the bottom of page one of the link below.) “European Union Toughens Anti-Smoking” Legislation.

ije.oxfordjournals.org/cgi/reprint/30/4/917.pdf

If you understand how EU Legislation operates it should be clear to you now that it is EU legislation that dictates to Eire and any other country that hands it’s authority over to Brussels by voting ‘YES’ in their referendum’s.

Had the original ‘NO’ vote been upheld, the EU smoking ban would not have introduced.

The EU ‘makes the rules’ and if you sign up to it, then you are bound by those rules it’s as simple as that. There are many reasons why I am against the U.K signing the ‘Reform Treaty.’ One of them is that Habeas Corpus will be struck from U.K Law, unfortunately a great deal of people in the U.K do not realize this, perhaps, and without wishing to be patronizing, you were unaware that one consequence of the ‘yes’ vote was that Eire had no alternative but to adopt the smoking ban.
Unless you can show me that the Irish smoking ban was wholly the concept of the Irish Government of course.

Suggesting I'm too young to remember a piece of legislation is patronizing.

I do not know your age and for the second time if you are offended I offer my humble apologies.

[FONT=&quot] Yes as is my democratic right.[/FONT]

Of course it is.

Now that you have edited the bit about how you remember very well voting on the same issue twice I am even more puzzled as to what exactly is your definition of Democracy.

[FONT=&quot]You'll notice the Nice treaty has died a death haven't you?[/FONT]

Of course it has ‘died a death’… It was a ‘Reform Treaty!!’ It has served its purpose and is now ‘surplus to requirements.’ It amended The Amsterdam Treaty and was followed by the Treaty of Accession in 2003, which did not include Eire.
All this is included in one of the links you chose not to read.

[FONT=&quot] I'ts Eire. [/FONT]

EIRE. Quite correct! I apologies.

[FONT=&quot]And you're implying we were brainwashed to accept a piece of legislation.[/FONT]

I was not implying anything of the sort. I was raising the issue of why a second vote was taken when the people of Ireland said ‘NO’ the first time. If you do not find that inherently wrong, then I am at a loss to understand what your definition of ‘Democracy’ is exactly.

Sorry no. Please show me where the EU legislation for the smoking ban existed. Plenty of EU countries don't have a smoking ban.

I have shown you,and one reason some countries do not have a ban is due to the fact that they are not bound by a treaty yet.

The timing of the smoking ban in Ireland and the Nice treaty are irrelevant.

No it is not, the Nice Treaty had to be ratified by the people of Ireland before the EU ban could be implemented, again, unless you can back your statement up that it was the concept of the Irish Government.

I'm not about to waste my time blindly following four links that you won't bother explaining their significance.

Should you change your mind the links will still be there for you then.

Cooperation is a two way street.

Indeed!


Corsair.

And at the end you leaped to the conclusion that the same would happen as a result of NAFTA. Which is what prompted my replies to you. Here's what your post concluded with:

I never jumped to any conclusion, I’ve had those views for quite some time and I expressed my feelings as to what direction your trade agreement will take based on personal observations over many years of the EEC evolution over time, ‘bit-by-bit’ into its present incarnation, the EU and all that it entails and I still hold those fears for the people of North America.
If time shows me to be wrong, then I’ll have ‘egg on my face.’
On the other hand, if you’re wrong, egg on your face will be the least of your worries.

"So, like I said, please educate yourselves as to what the NAFTA really entails."

This does sound a bit condescending, I apologies.
 
I never jumped to any conclusion...
Well, starting with a discussion of the EU and smoking bans and ending with the conclusion it means a political union of North America would seem to me to be a pretty big leap.

This does sound a bit condescending, I apologies.
I didn't take it as condescending, but I did take it as a rather large leap to an unfounded conclusion.
 
Like I said, these are my personal feelings, 'my-link-is-better-than-youre-link.com' holds no weight here.

Little bit's of Legislation creeping in without anyone noticing is how the U.K is (in my opinion) being destoyed from within.

Well, starting with a discussion of the EU and smoking bans and ending with the conclusion it means a political union of North America would seem to me to be a pretty big leap.

Could you clarify this please.
 
My original post mentioned only my fears, fears that I still hold.

I only mentioned the “EU smoking ban” and “The Exclusion Zone” in response to questions that were raised by other users and were first mentioned AFTER your initial response.

[FONT=&quot]For this reason I fail to see how you come to this conclusion.

[/FONT]
Well, starting with a discussion of the EU and smoking bans and ending with the conclusion it means a political union of North America would seem to me to be a pretty big leap.

The EU smoking ban was not at all mentioned in conection with the NAFTA.
I mentioned it only in a EU, British and Irish context.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom