The North American Union

Arkan Wolfshade.

Thank you for the helpful information in post # 106 regarding URL’s, or more importantly, the lack of them.

Sorry for the delay in replying, but other things have taken my time of late.

A.K, to the best of my knowledge, previously, in order to hold a demonstration for whatever reason in what has now become the exclusion zone, ‘notification’ to the authorities has always been a prerequisite by them, information such as your organization/name? Who you represent perhaps and maybe most importantly, what you are demonstrating about.
I have no problem with this. There is nothing wrong with a bit of openness and honesty concerning an individuals/groups/organizations/parties views on any given subject. Especially! If, that subject ignites a flame inside their stomachs that drives them to the streets.

After handing in your ‘notification’ you could go home safe in the knowledge that your demonstration would go ahead as planned, we could meet up on the big day and demonstrate to our hearts content, whatever it is we are demonstrating about.

Democracy…In action!!

The two-year-old link you provided states quite clearly that should I wish to demonstrate about anything, anywhere in what is now the exclusion zone, I need ‘Permission’!!
I did not point out the age of the link to ridicule it, but to point out the possible lack of public interest or even ‘knowledge’ of an exclusion zone.
I doubt if you had ever heard of it until you searched for it.

If it’s not on the people’s minds, why report it?!!

As it stands…I now need ‘permission’ to demonstrate as opposed to, I have the ‘freedom/Right’ to demonstrate…It is crystal clear to me!

I saw on the news today that it is now illegal for anyone under the age of eighteen to buy tobacco here in the U.K, yesterday anyone wishing to buy tobacco had to be over sixteen.
Irrespective of the ‘rights and wrongs’ of smoking, overnight an entire age group, and any shop keeper trading tobacco with them are now criminals…Overnight!!

The U.K smoking ban is E.U, and not British Parliamentary Legislation.
Considering that the U.K is not fully entwined into the E.U, do you not find it at least strange, that an out side force can inflict onto the U.K whatever dictate it so chooses.

Gordon Brown is now the Prime Minister of the U.K. As I’m sure you will recall he has held the purse strings of the U.K under Tony Blair during Blair’s time in offace as PM.

Gordon Brown was not elected PM by the people of the U.K

Gordon Brown was not even elected leader of New Labour, not even by New Labour members themselves.

It seems no election was necessary within New Labour as nobody challenged his candidacy for P.M. No challenger, no internal party election.
Does this situation sound like a democracy or a dictatorship to you!

At this moment in time I find myself living in a ‘democracy’ with an un-elected leader, who, in my opinion, has no plans for the ‘snap election’ I keep hearing about on the news! Telling me he has no intention of giving me a vote by way of a referendum regarding full membership of the E.U. According to Mr Brown and the other main parties, Europe is the way forward. With, or without my consent.

After writing to our M.P’s, signing petitions all to no avail, what other means of having my voice heard is there! Other than taking to the streets in protest over the actions Mr Brown is taking, actions I feel will have a detrimental effect on my life.
New Labour introduced this exclusion zone and it is New Labour taking me, against my will into this new empire called the E.U

Should enough people in the U.K have the same thoughts regarding Europe, at the same time and decide to act upon those thoughts by descending on Parliament to legally and peacefully show their opposition at being forced to accept new masters.

Do you believe a protest demonstration in the numbers equal to the U.K anti Iraq war march, the numbers reached were one million plus, would be granted ‘permission’ to protest against the very government that are leading them into Europe un-democratically.
Do you believe the government who introduced the exclusion zone would allow access to this zone where the worlds media ‘should’ all be gathered to witness the mass voices of the people telling their ‘un-elected’ leader, the party he represents and all main parties in general that their views on what is best for the U.K may not be the view held by the majority of the population they claim to represent. If, that is, the people of this country were given enough of the realities of what is going on un-reported by the main-stream media. Sadly they remain fairly quiet on matters such as the removal of habeas corpus from the British Legal System.
I’m sure people would sit up and take notice if they were informed fully about the removal of habeas corpus if it were reported with as much zeal as the war on terror is reported. Informing them what will happen and what exactly, the consequences would be to each and every individual living in the U.K.
Alas it is the media bosses that determine what I am to be told by way of news reporting of world events.

The right of habeas corpus goes back to Magna Carta.

Two people holding up a banner outside Parliament never changes anything, if you want change you need to let the people in charge know you want change. How better than taking to the streets in numbers to show your feelings.

I tend to drift off to images of Nicolae Ceausescu and the Romanian uprising when thinking of the power of the people.

A very good reason to introduce into a ‘democracy’ a ‘protest exclusion zone’

Good luck!!
 
No reply A W?… Odd, you seemed eager to jump in before!
Oh well, not to worry.

Anyway, Gordon Brown, our Prime Minister, who by the way has no mandate to be so!! Has finally confirmed my belief, as stated in the above post, that he had no intention of giving the good people of the U.K the opportunity to decide whether or not we actually want him as our Prime Minister. 2009 is the earliest we can expect the chance to exercise a little bit of democracy over here.

The problem with this for me is that prior to 2009 he will have committed an act of Sedition if he is successful in his attempt to hand the U.K over to a foreign power, the E.U
Again, without allowing us to have any say in an event that will have an effect on all of us in the U.K.

A politician who does not like the ballot box!! Now there’s a novel idea!!

Getting back to the ‘Exclusion Zone’ and my ‘lost rights’

Not much from the ‘mainstream media’ about this… Keeps the numbers down I suppose!!

But, there is going to be an unauthorised anti war demonstration today right in the Exclusion Zone itself, obviously it is against the illegal ongoing war and the soon to be, if the rhetoric flying around at the moment is anything to go by, war with Iran.

"The authority for this march derives from our ancient right to free speech and assembly enshrined in our history. It is only fair to tell you that the march will go ahead, in any case, and I will be among those marching."
Tony Benn, in letter to the Home Secretary.

If FOX/CNN fail to inform you about the outcome, I’d be more than happy to let you know how things go in the real world.

The reason ‘some’ of the majority of people in the U.K are opposed to the illegal bogus war against ‘imaginary threats’ is because the real enemy is from within, those that are quite happy to send our sons and daughters off to their deaths are the very same people that are stabbing us in the back and selling us down the river, so to speak.

The same thing is happening with the NAFTA.
 
Question Mark, the Smoking in enclosed public spaces ban was first proposed in 1997, by Tony Blairs Labour party following scientific studies that showed passive smoking can and does kill.
It has nothing to do with the EU, (I loathe and detest the EU and vote UKIP in EU elections btw).
........................................
As for illegal bogus war against imaginary threats ?

What imaginary threats do you mean ?

Do you mean the war in Iraq (which in my view was not legal, and contravened the obligations of treaties the UK is signed up to), or do you mean the wider 'war on terror' which despite being more disorganised than Leeds United's performance in last years 2006 - 2007 season, is aimed at stopping a real and credible threat to western society, and the threat from Islamist terrorists should not be ignored...
............................
As for the exclusion zone around parliament which restricted protests, its been scrapped.
http://commentisfree.guardian.co.uk/mark_thomas/2007/06/demonstrations_of_victory.html
 
Last edited:
I saw on the news today that it is now illegal for anyone under the age of eighteen to buy tobacco here in the U.K, yesterday anyone wishing to buy tobacco had to be over sixteen.
Irrespective of the ‘rights and wrongs’ of smoking, overnight an entire age group, and any shop keeper trading tobacco with them are now criminals…Overnight!!

As did people who didn't wear their seat belt, overnight when the law changed making it manditory. Your point?

The U.K smoking ban is E.U, and not British Parliamentary Legislation.
Considering that the U.K is not fully entwined into the E.U, do you not find it at least strange, that an out side force can inflict onto the U.K whatever dictate it so chooses.

There are many things wrong with that sentence. If there's a EU dictated smoking ban, why wasn't it dictated across the UK? It is UK law not EU.

Gordon Brown is now the Prime Minister of the U.K. As I’m sure you will recall he has held the purse strings of the U.K under Tony Blair during Blair’s time in offace as PM.

Gordon Brown was not elected PM by the people of the U.K

Gordon Brown was not even elected leader of New Labour, not even by New Labour members themselves.

It seems no election was necessary within New Labour as nobody challenged his candidacy for P.M. No challenger, no internal party election.
Does this situation sound like a democracy or a dictatorship to you!

No, no candidate challenged Brown, they could have, they choose not to. Don't like that? Well then join the labour party and get involved. The people of Britain elected a majority of MPs to represent them, these MPs choose to elect Brown to led them, so what's your point.
 
I saw on the news today that it is now illegal for anyone under the age of eighteen to buy tobacco here in the U.K, yesterday anyone wishing to buy tobacco had to be over sixteen.
Irrespective of the ‘rights and wrongs’ of smoking, overnight an entire age group, and any shop keeper trading tobacco with them are now criminals…Overnight!!

This is rather a ridiculous statement. Nobody has been transformed from a law abiding citizen to a criminal overnight. A tobacconist who sold tobacco to under 16's the day before the law changed and ceased to do so the day after, has not broken any laws. Nor is "an entire age group" now criminals; in my experience there are at least some 16-17 year olds who don't smoke, and those who bought tobacco the day before the ban are no more criminals than they ever were. Your fallacious argument is an argument against changing any law, ever, for any reason.

Dave
 
No reply A W?… Odd, you seemed eager to jump in before!
Oh well, not to worry.

Anyway, Gordon Brown, our Prime Minister, who by the way has no mandate to be so!! Has finally confirmed my belief, as stated in the above post, that he had no intention of giving the good people of the U.K the opportunity to decide whether or not we actually want him as our Prime Minister. 2009 is the earliest we can expect the chance to exercise a little bit of democracy over here.

The problem with this for me is that prior to 2009 he will have committed an act of Sedition if he is successful in his attempt to hand the U.K over to a foreign power, the E.U
Again, without allowing us to have any say in an event that will have an effect on all of us in the U.K.

A politician who does not like the ballot box!! Now there’s a novel idea!!

Getting back to the ‘Exclusion Zone’ and my ‘lost rights’

Not much from the ‘mainstream media’ about this… Keeps the numbers down I suppose!!

But, there is going to be an unauthorised anti war demonstration today right in the Exclusion Zone itself, obviously it is against the illegal ongoing war and the soon to be, if the rhetoric flying around at the moment is anything to go by, war with Iran.

"The authority for this march derives from our ancient right to free speech and assembly enshrined in our history. It is only fair to tell you that the march will go ahead, in any case, and I will be among those marching."
Tony Benn, in letter to the Home Secretary.

If FOX/CNN fail to inform you about the outcome, I’d be more than happy to let you know how things go in the real world.

The reason ‘some’ of the majority of people in the U.K are opposed to the illegal bogus war against ‘imaginary threats’ is because the real enemy is from within, those that are quite happy to send our sons and daughters off to their deaths are the very same people that are stabbing us in the back and selling us down the river, so to speak.

The same thing is happening with the NAFTA.

QM you are of course aware as well that a smoking ban was imposed in all the areas of devolved government within the UK before a similar law came to pass in England? Or are you one of these very educated people from south of the border here who equate England with the UK?
 
No, no candidate challenged Brown, they could have, they choose not to. Don't like that? Well then join the labour party and get involved. The people of Britain elected a majority of MPs to represent them, these MPs choose to elect Brown to led them, so what's your point.


Oh, come on! You don't really believe that regular people, getting involved in issues they care about, can actually have an effect on the course of government, do you?



Oh, wait!


As for the exclusion zone around parliament which restricted protests, its been scrapped.
http://commentisfree.guardian.co.uk/mark_thomas/2007/06/demonstrations_of_victory.html


Some opposed the law by refusing to cooperate with it, like Maya, and held demonstrations without permission, like the Sack Parliament demo, calling for MPs to resign. Other less brave souls, like myself, decided to take on the law by organising mass lone demonstrations, where individuals applied for lone protests but en mass, swamping the police with paperwork. Each month people would arrive demanding everything from "an end to aggression in Palestine" to "free chocolate for the unemployed". In the process I became the Guinness World Record holder for "most political demonstrations in 24 hours" - I have a framed certificate - and in April this year we applied for 2,500 individual demonstrations around the Socpa zone in the space of a week, giving the police about three years' worth of work in seven days.



Never mind......



As I've said before, the greatest danger of the CT mindset is, it encourages people to give up even trying to make changes in their world. And once you do that, you really have lost out to those who would be only too happy to tell you what to do.

Thank the FSM that CTists are so few in the world, or we'd really be in trouble.
 
The same thing is happening with the NAFTA.
NAFTA is a trade agreement, nothing more. It's about lowering tariffs and other trade barriers between the three signatory nations. You can read the entire text of the agreement for yourself here.

As to the alleged NAU which purports to be eliminating the distinction between the U.S., Canada, and Mexico, it would seem to have run into a couple of roadblocks.

First, there were the recent Congressional theatrics revolving around the GAO's "investigation" of lax border security on the U.S.-Canadian border (the report shockingly found that crossing the border where there were no border stations or customs agents was easy!). The senators who received the report made a big show over insisting more security was vitally necessary. This is the opposite of open borders, wouldn't you say?

Second, the Canadian dollar is at parity with the U.S. dollar, something which hasn't happened in thirty years. In fact, it closed slightly above the U.S. dollar on Friday, and some analysts predict the Canadian dollar will be worth as much as $1.10 U.S. within a year. Given this upsurge in the exchange rate, Canadians will be even less interested than they were already in adopting some sort of continental currency.
 
Hello Peteweaver.

I agree, lots of studies into the dangers of smoking have been carried out and as a smoker I am not disputing the findings. Personally I would love to stop smoking, but in this one respect I admit I am weak.
The EU commissioned many of these studies too don’t forget.
I do however believe you are mistaken. Tony Blair became PM in 1997 and announced New Labour would abolish tobacco sponsorship in sports in line with earlier EU findings and directives. It is my belief that the present smoking ban is a direct result of the EU dictating to the UK.
That is where I have a problem.

Pope Urban 7th introduced the first know smoking ban in 1500’s so maybe that’s where Blair got the idea.

When John Reed was Health Secretary in 2004, he said in June 2004 “ poorer people regard smoking as one of the few pleasures they have access to.”

This came a couple of days after Tony Blair said ministers were considering banning smoking in public places.


www bbc co uk/1/hi/uk_politics/3789591 . stm


In July 2004 Reed told Britain’s publicans and restaurants to draw up plans to phase in smoking restriction across all their premises as the first steps towards a blanket national ban.

www guardian . co . uk/publichealth/story/0,,1269300,00.html

New Labour first proposed a smoking ban as part of their 2005 election manifesto.

www society. Guardian.co.uk/health/story/0,,170581,00.html

………………………………………………………………………...
(I loathe and detest the EU and vote UKIP in EU elections btw)

I’m glade to hear that, I’m not to sure about UKIP though, do you mind if I message you with some information regarding the EU?
………………………………………………………………………….
As for illegal bogus war against imaginary threats ?

What imaginary threats do you mean ?

I mean Afghanistan, Iraq and ‘the war on terror’

Afghanistan. The reason we went there supposedly was to capture the C.I.A’s buddy Bin Ladden, who, by the way is not the FBI’s ‘most wanted’!! The man ‘responsible’ for 9/11 is not the most wanted man in the world…. Why? Of all the things he is wanted for, 9/11 is not one of them!! Maybe there is not enough evidence.
Call me cynical if you like but in 2001 the Taliban had reduced the production of Opium to next to nothing, we go there and before you know it, now, in 2007 Opium production is the largest harvest ever. What’s going on out there? Is it that this bunch of mountain goat herders to much of a match for the best equipped army in the world that they can still tend the crops to fund their ‘terrorist’ activities?
Where do you think this year’s bumper crop is going to end up?

Iraq. When the West sold Saddam all those WMD, what exactly did we think he was going to do with them? LOOK at them!! If Saddam was guilty of using WMD against the Northern Kurds, shouldn’t whoever sold those WMD in the first place be hung as well? I think so.
When we all felt so sorry for those poor Kurds who, if we are honest with ourselves, we knew nothing about until we were ‘told’ about them and then ‘demanded’ we avenged their deaths, or at the very least, wanted our leaders to protect us form any attempt by Saddam to launch those WMD in our direction… ‘45 minutes’ I believe was the claim. Will we still feel sorry for them now that they are ‘evolving’ into the PKK?

‘War On Terror’ I think you do not have to be all that clever to work out my views on this war on terror, everything is going to plan, it appears most of the people on here are ‘terrified’. That’s why they attack anyone who holds an opposing view on sight.
As for the Islamic Terrorist’s, I’m surprised at you Pete, a Yorkshire man who advocates rolling up in a little ball and accepting whatever comes. If Fred could see this! Yes there is good and bad in all races. If you were being attacked by let say the Red Rose today!! Would you not wish to fight back?
Well, I must be a U.K Terrorist too, as the threat to the U.K is real, it is very serious and people are going to die but my… no, our enemy is not Islam, our enemy sits in Parliament and in every council office in the U.K. This Nation is being destroyed systematically you can see it every time you walk out the front door if you know what to look for.
…………………………………………………………………………………………

The link you posted, could you copy and paste where it states that the ban has been lifted. All I can see is Brown promising to make a symbolic gesture.
I think you will agree that Tony Benn has more knowledge on the matter than the pair of us put together, therefore I fail to see why he would write a letter to Jacqui Smith informing her of his intentions to march if he already had ‘symbolic permission’ to do so in the first place.
It was only thirty minutes before the march was due to commence before the police backed down and gave ‘permission’ for the march to take place, they had the power to stop it just as they still do have the power to refuse any further planned marches.
The march did take place and the ban is still in place. Fact.
…………………………………………………………………………………………

Hello 8den.

“As did people who didn't wear their seat belt, overnight when the law changed making it manditory. Your point?”

My point is how fragile your existence is, my point is how with the stroke of a pen your life can change overnight, my point is how with nothing more than a flick of a switch you could find yourself without electricity, without a phone, without heat. Do you get my point?

“There are many things wrong with that sentence. If there's a EU dictated smoking ban, why wasn't it dictated across the UK? It is UK law not EU”

For the same reason Eire, Germany, Spain and any other European country you care to mention have been forced to introduced EU anti-smoking legislation at different times. Take a look at the new EU map of the U.K, you will see the county’s have disappeared and are to be replaced with ‘regions’ each region responsible for the administration of itself accountable to the EU and not Parliament as is the case with individual county’s are now.

As I said earlier The U.K is being dismantled bit by bit, you have to have a memory longer than a week to notice these things and google wont help you find the answers.

“No, no candidate challenged Brown, they could have, they choose not to. Don't like that? Well then join the labour party and get involved. The people of Britain elected a majority of MPs to represent them, these MPs choose to elect Brown to led them, so what's your point.”

At least you agree that Gordon Brown does not hold a mandate to lead the labour party then !! If no one opposed him and there was no internal balloting, who as you state, chose to‘elected’ him?? Exactly, no one did!!
I was in the past a paid up member of a political party, that is where I get my knowledge of the political system in the U.K. That is how I know it’s nothing but a sham.
Who is Gordon Brown accountable to? The people of the UK? How? The people of the U.K didn’t elect him.
Is he accountable to his party? How can he be, they never elected him did they!
That! Is my point.
……………………………………………………………………………………….

Hello Dave Rogers.

Dave, you are putting words into your own mouth here!! Re-read what I wrote and you will see I said.

“And any shop keeper ‘TRADING’ tobacco with them are now criminals overnight”

I do however concede my statement regarding “an entire age group” I should have said smokers within that age group who continue to smoke.
………………………………………………………………………………………..
Hello Parsman.

“QM you are of course aware as well that a smoking ban was imposed in all the areas of devolved government within the UK before a similar law came to pass in England? Or are you one of these very educated people from south of the border here who equate England with the UK?”

Yes, I am aware Scotland and N. Ireland, not to sure about Whales, introduced smoking bans prior to it being introduced in England.
South of the border and proud of it!!
To be educated all you have to do is copy what is in a book and repeat it over and over again, so no, I am not ‘educated.’ Intelligent however, very!! You?
Although I confess, I have no bothered to learn how to use the quote button thingy yet.
………………………………………………………………………………………

Hello Horatius.
“Oh, come on! You don't really believe that regular people, getting involved in issues they care about, can actually have an effect on the course of government, do you?”

That really depends on how you approach the problem doesn’t it !!

“As ‘I’ said before in post # 281”

“I tend to drift off to images of Nicolae Ceausescu and the Romanian uprising when thinking of the power of the people.”


Do you have any recollection of the events above mentioned?

I believe I’ve addressed peterweaver’s original link you copied and I can overlook his misunderstanding of the reality that it is incorrect.

You on the other hand have just proved to all on our side your complete and utter ignorance.

“As I've said before, the greatest danger of the CT mindset is, it encourages people to give up even trying to make changes in their world. And once you do that, you really have lost out to those who would be only too happy to tell you what to do.”

And your mindset is to state things that are incorrect and ridicule others, well, you look pretty stupid to me, and once/if you can be bothered to check the facts I bet you’ll agree, well, you ‘should’ agree when you realize your error!! Will you? I doubt it very much. How many of your 4000 plus post are riddled with stupid statement like the one above.
Do you think I was born with this ‘mindset’ I have? No, I used to be the same as you, never questioning anything, accepting ‘as is’ what ever I was told.

Unlike you I’ve seen and experienced things that have forced me to question things and ‘change’ my views on the world, hence the name.

“Thank the FSM that CTists are so few in the world, or we'd really be in trouble.”

It’s because of you and people like you that we really are in trouble, you included.

Hello Corsair.

Like the E.E.C was do you mean? Well, time will tell won’t it and I will be watching!!

Sorry in advanced for the links not working, but I’m sure the more ‘educated’ amongst you will know what to do.
Horatius, just ask someone!!

[FONT=&quot]Goodnight all.[/FONT]
 
Like the E.E.C was do you mean? Well, time will tell won’t it and I will be watching!!
Three things:

First, please learn to use the quotation feature. It makes reading your replies much easier.

Second, unless legislation is passed in the respective legislatures, NAFTA is only what it is, a trade agreement. And not even a well-followed one, since the U.S. has at times felt entirely free to ignore NAFTA's rules when political pressure from lobbyists have pushed for certain rules or decisions to be ignored (see: softwood lumber).

Third, the EEC is not North America nor NAFTA. One is not the other. You never actually addressed the points I raised previously.
 
Hello Horatius.
“Oh, come on! You don't really believe that regular people, getting involved in issues they care about, can actually have an effect on the course of government, do you?”

That really depends on how you approach the problem doesn’t it !!

“As ‘I’ said before in post # 281”

“I tend to drift off to images of Nicolae Ceausescu and the Romanian uprising when thinking of the power of the people.”

You on the other hand have just proved to all on our side your complete and utter ignorance.

“As I've said before, the greatest danger of the CT mindset is, it encourages people to give up even trying to make changes in their world. And once you do that, you really have lost out to those who would be only too happy to tell you what to do.”

And your mindset is to state things that are incorrect and ridicule others, well, you look pretty stupid to me, and once/if you can be bothered to check the facts I bet you’ll agree, well, you ‘should’ agree when you realize your error!! Will you? I doubt it very much. How many of your 4000 plus post are riddled with stupid statement like the one above.

“Thank the FSM that CTists are so few in the world, or we'd really be in trouble.”

It’s because of you and people like you that we really are in trouble, you included.



Your post #281?



...
After writing to our M.P’s, signing petitions all to no avail, what other means of having my voice heard is there! Other than taking to the streets in protest over the actions Mr Brown is taking, actions I feel will have a detrimental effect on my life.


...

Two people holding up a banner outside Parliament never changes anything, if you want change you need to let the people in charge know you want change. How better than taking to the streets in numbers to show your feelings.

I tend to drift off to images of Nicolae Ceausescu and the Romanian uprising when thinking of the power of the people.




That post 281?

The one where you pretty much admit you haven't done anything to advance the changes you claim to desire?

Oh, I'm sorry, getting off your butt and actually trying would have "a detrimental effect on [your] life". That's okay then, wouldn't want you to be put out or anything. It's not like you believe democracy has been subverted in your country or anything, is it?


Oh, wait.....
 
Firstly learn to use the quote function

My point is how fragile your existence is, my point is how with the stroke of a pen your life can change overnight, my point is how with nothing more than a flick of a switch you could find yourself without electricity, without a phone, without heat. Do you get my point?

What first they came for the smokers???

Whats is your point can you give me an example of someone deprived of a phone/heat/electricity by EU legislation.

For the same reason Eire, Germany, Spain and any other European country you care to mention have been forced to introduced EU anti-smoking legislation at different times.

Thats just wrong. The smoking ban was brought into Ireland first at our volition, after studying the success of the ban in New York. It's one of the few pieces of legislation that I think have been a great local success, the UK and Scotland followed suit after they saw the benefits of this.

Take a look at the new EU map of the U.K, you will see the county’s have disappeared and are to be replaced with ‘regions’ each region responsible for the administration of itself accountable to the EU and not Parliament as is the case with individual county’s are now.

That is just incorrect.
As I said earlier The U.K is being dismantled bit by bit, you have to have a memory longer than a week to notice these things and google wont help you find the answers.

But UKIP a party that makes the BNP look like a bastion of sanity and effeciency, has the answers.

Have they even found Brussels yet?

At least you agree that Gordon Brown does not hold a mandate to lead the labour party then !! If no one opposed him and there was no internal balloting, who as you state, chose to‘elected’ him?? Exactly, no one did!!

Again just wrong. He stood as a candidate. No one wanted to oppose him, therefore he takes it that the Labour party want him to run the party.

He didn't get boo'd and jeered at the conference the other week, so I take it all those labour party members, angry just buggered off.

I was in the past a paid up member of a political party, that is where I get my knowledge of the political system in the U.K. That is how I know it’s nothing but a sham.
Who is Gordon Brown accountable to? The people of the UK? How? The people of the U.K didn’t elect him.
Is he accountable to his party? How can he be, they never elected him did they!
That! Is my point.

You're quite wrong on many levels. Technically Gordon Brown is accountable to the Queen, as she has to invite him to form her government.

She also disbands parliament. The MPs stand in their costituencies to ask to represent the people in Parliament.

The people of this country do not directly elect the Prime Minister, it is not the same as a US presidental race. The MPs with the largest majority are invited to form a government, they elect their leader who the Queen makes her Prime Minister.

This called a Parlimentary Democracy. You don't seem to understand that. You are not voting for Cameron or Brown(unless you're in their constituency), you're voting either conservative or labour.


You seem ignorant of the fundamental manner your country is governed. This is ironic because you want to "defend" the values of this country. It's really ironic that the person educating you on this matter is an immirgrant to this country and has only lived here for two years.

Honestly, UKiP is the only party to look less credible after they dumped Kilroy.
 
Last edited:
As it stands…I now need ‘permission’ to demonstrate as opposed to, I have the ‘freedom/Right’ to demonstrate…It is crystal clear to me!

This is indeed the crux of it - and something depressingly few seem to grasp. The government has no right to force the people to ask permission to excercise their rights.

This serves to point out the crucial difference between the British constitution and that of the EU - and why the two are completely incompatible.

At the most fundamental level there are only two types of constitution -
a) where the government is in the service of its people
and
b) where the people exist to serve the state

Transitioning from a) to b) is problematic as it involves the violation of oaths and the possibility that sufficient people may just smell a rat. This is why Ted Heath had to lie about the impact of the original EEC referendum on the sovereignty of the UK.

There can be no referendum because Gordon Brown knows full well that it would be an abject and debilitating failure.

I've found one good source for information on this subject from this insider, MEP Ashley Mote: http://www.ashleymote.co.uk/

Good post - thanks.
 
Perhaps you'd better define what you mean by country, since I think most folks would think that without national sovereignty a country is no longer a country.

It's instructive to look at current developments in the EU as this entity is further down the same road that the NAU is embarking upon. Here's an MEP explaining in stark terms the impact of the EU 'treaty' (read: constitution) on the ability for Britain to remain self-governing:

"4. Membership of the euro is mandatory, despite Blair’s commitment of long ago to run a referendum on that as well.

5. Under the new treaty we shall lose (but not immediately) our right to decide:
i) our own defence policy
ii) our foreign affairs policy (so what about the British Commonwealth?)
iii) who can come to live in the UK

6. EU foreign policy will be run by a man masquerading under the wonderfully Gilbert & Sullivan title of High Representative. His policies and decisions will be EU wide. Elsewhere, the treaty demands from all member states support for EU foreign policy which is ‘active and unreserved’.

7. No member states will be able to sign international agreements.

8. Commissioners will be selected by the president of the Commission. (This ensures that only pliant supporters nominated for a post will be chosen.)"http://www.ashleymote.co.uk/topics.php?filter=&sec=article&art_id=462

Worth a ponder, I hope you'll agree.

Who exactly are the people above politics? How did they achieve their positions of power? Why do politicians listen to them? After all, it's politicians who have the power to make something illegal. If the government wanted to nationalize an industry, only government has the power to make that happen.

Actually, these days government is only about halfway up the food chain, power-wise. All the important policies are decided by unelected bodies (CFR, Trilateral commission, RIIA etc)outside of government. It's government's job to implement these policies, not to create them. For example, the SPP/NAU policy documents were drafted by the CFR. All the three countries' leaders really did was sign the documents. They had little or nothing to do with their creation.www.cfr.org/content/publications/attachments/NorthAmerica_TF_final.pdf
 
It's instructive to look at current developments in the EU as this entity is further down the same road that the NAU is embarking upon.
You have yet to prove the NAU as you claim it to be even exists. There's lots of talk but little evidence. Present some to further your case.

As I said before, NAFTA is not the EU. They're not even in the same park. And it's worth recalling that much of the NAU fears are in the U.S., which is a curious thing since in any supposed North American union it's Canada and Mexico which will be losing their sovereignty and identities, not the U.S.

Whether we like it or not, the U.S. is the big boy on this continent and things ultimately get done his way.

Actually, these days government is only about halfway up the food chain, power-wise. All the important policies are decided by unelected bodies (CFR, Trilateral commission, RIIA etc)outside of government.
I'll say it again, since I can only presume you are not familiar with the structure, organization, and workings of Canadian government and with the tone and reality of Canadian politics:

Any party which floats, in any way, any sort of direct political union with the U.S., is dead in a federal election. Dead and buried. It was a struggle enough back in 1988 for the government of the day to get re-elected when enacting the FTA was the central issue of the campaign. And such union cannot occur without the relevant legislation passing Parliament (there's a HUGE amount of changes which would need to occur for any sort of union to take place. The differences between the U.S. and Canada are not necessarily visible on the surface, but underneath there are marked differences on everything from the nature of government to laws to culture).

With a dollar now surpassing the U.S., there's no way in hell we're about to give up our dollar for the U.S. greenback or some sort of new unified currency (for which there is no evidence whatsoever). It's not going to happen. Indeed, part of the reason for our currency's success is the fact we've followed our own monetary policy via the Bank of Canada - that's a measure of economic freedom we're not about to give up.

For that matter, I don't see Americans giving up their version of it and the independence it entails any time soon either.

It's government's job to implement these policies, not to create them.
Heh, I can only conclude you've never seen Question Period then. That's the one hour a day where the Opposition gets to grill the government on its policies and legislation. There's no parallel to QP in the U.S. system; Senate debates probably come the closest, but are church meetings in comparison.

For example, the SPP/NAU policy documents were drafted by the CFR. All the three countries' leaders really did was sign the documents. They had little or nothing to do with their creation.
Then perhaps you'll point out the exact paragraphs which call for a direct, EU-style political union with some sort of Canamerico as the only country on the continent. You can point out the paragraphs which outline the plans for a unifed continental currency, right? You can point out the parts which specify the how and when of the borders being totally open? (Is open skies a part of that?)

The SPP is simple: harmonizing laws and procedures where possible to smooth trade and put forth a common front towards keeping out terrorists. If you took a look at the dollar value of trade between the three nations, you'd see pretty quickly that unnecessary delays at the border due to differing security measures and varying standards are hampering the smooth flow of goods. This hurts the economies of all three nations.

So, where possible, co-ordination is the goal. That's hardly a radical proposal.

In the end, I keep coming back to this: how can any American think that there country is going to be the one losing its sovereignty and identity when it by far is the most dominant country on the continent in terms of economics and culture? Canada and Mexico are the ones which should be afraid.
 
If none of you view the EU in the same light as many in the U.K do, if you have no recollection of the lies and broken promises of our ‘elected’ leaders, then you will never understand the depth of feeling and anger many in the U.K hold.

Carry on believing that NAFTA and NAU are nothing to worry about if you want to, it’s your choice.

A_W.
Thanks for the help.

Corsair.
Sorry if I failed to explain myself clearly enough for you.

Horatius………….. The less said about you the better I think!

8den.
In time you will see how incorrect you really are, I’d just like to say that I feel you must be to young to remember the first vote the people of Ireland had when they rejected the Nice Treaty in 2001, only to be forced by the EU to retake the ballot the following year.

Only after this did the EU Smoking Ban take affect, just as it has around Europe!!


W’s not included.

news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/europe/1376379.stm
news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/europe/2345193.stm

Only then! Was the smoking ban introduced!!




commonpurpose.org.uk/home.aspx

thewestminsternews.co.uk

eutruth.org.uk/ukc.html

[FONT=&quot]video.google.co.uk/videoplay?docid=3664960863576873594&hl=en-GB[/FONT]
 
Last edited:
Hello Dave Rogers.

Dave, you are putting words into your own mouth here!! Re-read what I wrote and you will see I said.

“And any shop keeper ‘TRADING’ tobacco with them are now criminals overnight”

I do however concede my statement regarding “an entire age group” I should have said smokers within that age group who continue to smoke.

Since it's my own mouth, I think I'm entitled to put words into it.

Your statement in red is meaningless hyperbole. Any shopkeeper who sells tobacco to 16/17 year olds once the ban is in place becomes a criminal at the time he or she does so, rather than becoming a criminal overnight without committing a crime, as your statement seems to imply. And don't try quibbling that it doesn't openly state that; I'm sure you're clever enough to play games with semantics.

I would comment again, you are making an argument against ever changing any law, ever, for any reason. To take a deliberately emotive example, suppose there is a law passed against assuming the identity of a minor on the Internet for the purpose of "grooming" minors for paedophile abuse. On some specific day this act becomes illegal, therefore by your analysis those doing it prior to that time become "criminals overnight". Is this, in any way whatsoever, a comment on the advisability of having such a law?

The law is clear, and everyone has the option of not breaking it.

Dave
 
Last edited:
In time you will see how incorrect you really are, I’d just like to say that I feel you must be to young to remember the first vote the people of Ireland had when they rejected the Nice Treaty in 2001, only to be forced by the EU to retake the ballot the following year.

Nice and patronizing, I voted in both treaties against the referendum.

Only after this did the EU Smoking Ban take affect, just as it has around Europe!!

The smoking ban was not part of the Nice referendum. Sorry you are just wrong.

W’s not included.

news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/europe/1376379.stm
news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/europe/2345193.stm

Only then! Was the smoking ban introduced!!

You're taking two separate events and claiming they are interconnected because one happened after the other. There's no link whatsoever. The smoking ban was a popular piece of local legislation.


commonpurpose.org.uk/home.aspx

thewestminsternews.co.uk

eutruth.org.uk/ukc.html

[FONT=&quot]video.google.co.uk/videoplay?docid=3664960863576873594&hl=en-GB[/FONT]

And what in the wild world of sport do this links prove?
 
Carry on believing that NAFTA and NAU are nothing to worry about if you want to, it’s your choice.
Well, rather than having to rely on beliefs, suppositions, and conjecture, how about posting some evidence? You know, things which have some legitimacy and weight and which can be examined and discussed.

Nebulous and unfocused fears about maybe this will happen and maybe that will happen do not count as evidence.

As far as smoking bans, big deal. Lots of states and provinces have enacted various types of smoking bans. How is this EU smoking ban the harbinger of a NAU?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom