The next pandemic?

Reuters has this ambiguous headline:

Unlikely monkeypox outbreak will lead to pandemic, WHO says

How would you parse that?

Anyway, the story is:

LONDON, May 30 (Reuters) - The World Health Organization does not believe the monkeypox outbreak outside Africa will lead to a pandemic, an official said on Monday, adding it remains unclear if infected people who are not displaying symptoms can transmit the disease.

More than 300 suspected and confirmed cases of monkeypox - a usually mild illness that spreads through close contact and can cause flu-like symptoms and pus-filled skin lesions - have been reported in May, mostly in Europe.
The strain of virus implicated in the outbreak is understood to kill a small fraction of those infected, but no deaths have been reported so far.

Am I right in assuming that because this is a "pox" disease, that vaccines are pretty effective at preventing it?
 
Michael Worobey is something of an expert in viruses, and he is reporting on work done by Aine O'Toole and Andrew Rambaut:

Key take home: current MPXV outbreak is very likely "just" a global expansion of a localized human outbreak that has been going on continuously since *at least 2017*

Link
 
A brief update. Monkeypox doubling time in UK about 15 days. The at risk population remains GBMSM with 75% of cases in London. Mortality about 1/2,000 cases.
https://www.gov.uk/government/publi...ypox-outbreak-in-england-technical-briefing-3

In Europe as a whole;
A total of 8238 cases of monkeypox have been identified through IHR mechanisms and official public resources up to 12 July 2022, 14:00, from 35 countries and areas throughout the European region. Case-based data were reported for 6900 cases from 29 countries and areas to ECDC and the WHO Regional Office for Europe through The European Surveillance System (TESSy), up to 12 July 2022, 10:00.

Of the 6900 cases reported in TESSy, 6899 were laboratory confirmed. Furthermore, where sequencing was available, 130 were confirmed to be of the West African clade. The earliest date of symptom onset was reported as 03 April 2022. The majority of cases were between 31 and 40 years-old (2890/6892 - 42%) and male (6782/6818 - 99.5%). Among cases with known HIV status, 43% (561/1313) were HIV-positive. The majority of cases presented with a rash (3505/3683 - 95.2%) and systemic symptoms such as fever, fatigue, muscle pain, vomiting, diarrhea, chills, sore throat or headache (2346/3683 - 64%). 183 cases were hospitalised (10.2%), of which 98 cases required clinical care. Three cases were admitted to ICU. No cases were reported to have died. Some (23) cases were reported to be health workers, however further investigation is ongoing to determine whether infection was due to occupational exposure.
https://monkeypoxreport.ecdc.europa.eu

US reports 1400 cases and running short of vaccine.

https://www.aha.org/news/headline/2...r-1400-monkeypox-cases-growing-vaccine-supply
https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/world-us-canada-62188005

ETA given 45% are in HIV positive persons this implies prep isn't effective for monkeypox. It also flags the issue that although prep allows unprotected intercourse with a low risk of transmission of HIV, it leaves people vulnerable to other, including novel, STD. One might argue the switch to prep from safe sex is a probable contributor to the outbreak.
 
Last edited:
WHO declares Monkeypox a public health emergency of international concern. I think the trigger is the spread from the GBMSM population, with some children being infected (and some health care workers*).

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-62279436

International update here.
https://www.who.int/news/item/23-07...rding-the-multi-country-outbreak-of-monkeypox

*You will be reassured to know that your very own Planigale has been genetically modified to fight not only SARS-CoV-2 but Monkeypox and Smallpox and FWIW Chickenpox.
 
WHO declares Monkeypox a public health emergency of international concern. I think the trigger is the spread from the GBMSM population, with some children being infected (and some health care workers*).

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-62279436

International update here.
https://www.who.int/news/item/23-07...rding-the-multi-country-outbreak-of-monkeypox

*You will be reassured to know that your very own Planigale has been genetically modified to fight not only SARS-CoV-2 but Monkeypox and Smallpox and FWIW Chickenpox.
Yes reassured.
You are an indispensable forum pet who will provide vital insight into this new pandemic.
Thank you in advance.
 
WHO declares Monkeypox a public health emergency of international concern.

I don’t know. Who declares Monkeypox a public health emergency of international concern?


I think the trigger is the spread from the GBMSM population, with some children being infected (and some health care workers*).

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-62279436

International update here.
https://www.who.int/news/item/23-07...rding-the-multi-country-outbreak-of-monkeypox

*You will be reassured to know that your very own Planigale has been genetically modified to fight not only SARS-CoV-2 but Monkeypox and Smallpox and FWIW Chickenpox.

Is the last one with the varicella vaccine or does the monkeypox vaccine take care of it?

In Japan, chickenpox is a routine vaccine, but apparently not in the UK. This is strange to me but looking it up it seems it is only recommended to vaccinate in countries where a very high proportion of the population can get vaccinated. Surprised if this cannot be done in the UK.
 
I don’t know. Who declares Monkeypox a public health emergency of international concern?




Is the last one with the varicella vaccine or does the monkeypox vaccine take care of it?

In Japan, chickenpox is a routine vaccine, but apparently not in the UK. This is strange to me but looking it up it seems it is only recommended to vaccinate in countries where a very high proportion of the population can get vaccinated. Surprised if this cannot be done in the UK.

Anyone who cares for pregnant women or children in the NHS and who hasn't had natural infection is vaccinated against chickenpox. So most healthcare workers who do not have antibodies are vaccinated.

The reason for not routinely vaccinating children in the UK is because of the concern that this would shift the infection into an older population who would get more severe disease, particularly women of childbearing age.
 
The reason for not routinely vaccinating children in the UK is because of the concern that this would shift the infection into an older population who would get more severe disease, particularly women of childbearing age.

I don't understand. Wouldn't they be vulnerable anyway if children aren't vaccinated?

Or is the idea that you want the virus to be more prevalent so that everyone gets it in childhood? Is this because of anti-vaxxers ultimately? I think if 100% of children were vaccinated, this "shifting" would not be a concern.



Anyway, I think this was already known, but now there's a study:
Monkeypox is being driven overwhelmingly by sex between men, major study finds

Overwhelmingly meaning 95% of cases are believed to be transmitted that way.

No one has died of monkeypox infection outside of Africa during this outbreak. And for many people, the disease is relatively mild and resolves on its own in a few weeks without any need for medical intervention. However, the new paper reports that monkeypox can cause pain so intense that a substantial proportion of people with the virus require hospitalization for pain management.

“We have seen patients with severe rectal pain that worsens every time they go to the bathroom, genital pain every time they urinate and throat pain every time they swallow,” said Dr. Jason Zucker, an infectious disease specialist at Columbia University Department of Medicine.
 
I don't understand. Wouldn't they be vulnerable anyway if children aren't vaccinated?

Or is the idea that you want the virus to be more prevalent so that everyone gets it in childhood? Is this because of anti-vaxxers ultimately? I think if 100% of children were vaccinated, this "shifting" would not be a concern.
....
It's actually an economic problem. If you vaccinate kids you might be delaying the infection rather than giving the vaccinee lifetime immunity. In countries that have decent vaccine coverage, should the need for boosters arise, boosters will likely be available.

It's my understanding the NHS decided to forego the expense of vaccinating the whole population when so few kids have serious disease.

https://www.nhs.uk/conditions/vaccinations/chickenpox-vaccine/

In the US given the disease can be severe even in children, we opted to vaccinate everyone and give them boosters later in life if they need it.

https://www.cdc.gov/vaccines/vpd/varicella/index.html
 
Last edited:
I was trying to find something on how different decisions came about and found this:

BBC News: Why don't we vaccinate against chickenpox?

... all debates about childhood vaccines still take place under the shadow of the upset over the measles, mumps and rubella jab (MMR), sparked by a now discredited research paper over a decade ago.

Despite international confirmation of its safety, a small number of parents still refuse to give their child the jab - and many in the medical community believe this explains the reluctance of the authorities to introduce a brand new injection into the childhood immunisation schedule.

"This is what it's really all about," says Professor Adam Finn, consultant in paediatric infectious diseases at Bristol Royal Hospital for Children.
That's not all it is about though in the UK it might be partially the reason.

If you look back ~25 years you'll find the debate really was about the cost benefit analysis. In the US we mandate 3rd party payers cover routine vaccines. But for pediatric vaccines, the government will pick up the vaccine cost as long as we providers then only charge a fixed amount for administering the shots.

One argument put forward in the US was the toll varicella takes in the workforce. Your kid gets sick then you have to stay home with them for a week. Very few daycares will take kids with chicken pox. In addition the cost burden of hospitalization was also factored in.

It would be interesting to see how each country fared now that the vaccine has been used routinely here for a couple decades while the UK doesn't use it in all kids.
 
I don't understand. Wouldn't they be vulnerable anyway if children aren't vaccinated?

Or is the idea that you want the virus to be more prevalent so that everyone gets it in childhood? Is this because of anti-vaxxers ultimately? I think if 100% of children were vaccinated, this "shifting" would not be a concern.



Anyway, I think this was already known, but now there's a study:
Monkeypox is being driven overwhelmingly by sex between men, major study finds

Overwhelmingly meaning 95% of cases are believed to be transmitted that way.

If vaccine uptake is incomplete you get an increased number of young adults who never had chickenpox as children, and are vulnerable because they were not vaccinated as children, risking an increase in severe chicken pox in adults. Naturally circulating chickenpox will boost immunity in adults providing protection against shingles. The vaccination has to clearly provide a nett health benefit if it is to be introduced. Economic arguments about reducing the need for parents to take time off work would not be considered (within the NHS system). There would have been a variety of models looked at for instance;

Two possible dangers of an extensive varicella vaccination program are more varicella (chickenpox) cases in adults, when the complication rates are higher, and an increase in cases of zoster (shingles). Here an age-structured epidemiologic–demographic model with vaccination is developed for varicella and zoster. Parameters are estimated from epidemiological data. This mathematical and computer simulation model is used to evaluate the effects of varicella vaccination programs. Although the age distribution of varicella cases does shift in the simulations, this does not seem to be a danger because many of the adult cases occur after vaccine-induced immunity wanes, so they are mild varicella cases with fewer complications. In the simulations, zoster incidence increases in the first three decades after initiation of a vaccination program, because people who had varicella in childhood age without boosting, but then it decreases. Thus the simulations validate the second danger of more zoster cases.

Modeling the Effects of Varicella Vaccination Programs on the Incidence of Chickenpox and Shingles. Matthew C.Schuette, Herbert W.Hethcote.
Bulletin of Mathematical Biology 61, (6) 1999, 1031-1064

Adoption of varicella vaccination in Europe is limited due to its unclear effects on herpes zoster.

•New perspectives of HZ control are offered by new subunit recombinant zoster vaccine.

•We used mathematical modeling to investigate a complete range of vaccination strategies.

•Given uncertainty on boosting, targeted vaccination of adolescents is a viable strategy.
Modeling the impact of combined vaccination programs against varicella and herpes zoster in Norway
SabinaMarchettia, GiorgioGuzzetta et al
Vaccine 36, (8), 2018, 1116-1125


So the argument is that though childhood vaccination will result in more shingles this negative impact can be ameliorated by also introducing a shingles vaccination for adults.
 
Last edited:
Worryingly a new outbreak of mpox has arisen, based in DRC. Unlike the previous outbreak that occurred a couple of years ago this is clade 1 which is much more virulent, with a 10% mortality similar to variola (smallpox) minor.

Unlike previous cases of clade 1 this now seems endemic and sexually transmissible. The animal origin is uncertain and the adaption to humans will no doubt lead to claims it is an escapee of a genetically modified virus.

https://www.cidrap.umn.edu/mpox/dr-congo-mpox-outbreak-expands-becomes-deadlier
https://www.eurosurveillance.org/content/10.2807/1560-7917.ES.2024.29.11.2400106
This is occurring at the same time as there are outbreaks of the milder clade 2 elsewhere.
Virginia
https://www.rttnews.com/3434979/mpox-outbreak-on-the-rise-in-virginia.aspx
Canada
https://toronto.ctvnews.ca/toronto-public-health-reporting-spike-in-mpox-infections-1.6815067
 
Worryingly a new outbreak of mpox has arisen, based in DRC. Unlike the previous outbreak that occurred a couple of years ago this is clade 1 which is much more virulent, with a 10% mortality similar to variola (smallpox) minor.

That's not good news, 10% is shockingly high.

Unlike previous cases of clade 1 this now seems endemic and sexually transmissible.

As long as it remains transmissable only when symptomatic, it shouldn't be too much of a problem.
 
That's not good news, 10% is shockingly high.



As long as it remains transmissable only when symptomatic, it shouldn't be too much of a problem.

I applaud your rational view about decision making around sexual congress. I fear the reality is that persons with symptoms will continue to have sexual desires.
 
I applaud your rational view about decision making around sexual congress. I fear the reality is that persons with symptoms will continue to have sexual desires.

I'm certain they will. I'm equally certain that if it's consensual sex they're old enough to weigh the risks and act accordingly.

If they don't, my level of caring is zero. To me, it's identical to clowns who choose not to wear a seatbelt or motorbike helmet, or who do use wingsuits - if you're doing something dangerous and accept your risk, I don't give a damn if they die from mpox or AIDS or end splattered against a rock wall.

When we have kids being blown apart, what people do knowing the risks are immaterial to me.
 
And here it is:

In the U.S., mpox still remains largely contained to the social networks of men who have sex with men, not yet becoming a pathogen of concern for the general public. But Varma warned that this could change, pointing to the mpox outbreak in the Democratic Republic of Congo, where heterosexual encounters between men and sex workers are a major vector of transmission.

Yet...

A study released by the CDC last year found that two-thirds of people eligible for mpox vaccination remained unimmunized.

Concern level 0 continues.
 
What is the fatality rate of Monkey pox?
However, the new clade 1 circulating in Africa (DRC) has a mortality of 10%. This was previously a sporadic zoonosis; it has moved to being sexually transmissible (and contagious - there are a number of child deaths thought to be familial non-sexual transmission), and now seems to be endemic in humans. The concern is that as we move into pride season this more virulent form of mpox may begin to circulate outside of Africa.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom