The Mentality of Skeptics


I've seen that before and it doesn't debunk anything. It goes over the backstory and says that the evidence disappeared, which it did.

What you won't read is any record of these allegedly giant bones having ever been preserved for study. Some say that they're being covered up or deliberately hidden away in locked cabinets in secure sections of museum collections, but most sources that discuss the stories speculate that the bones were simply lost over time. It's a fact that earliest excavations of Lovelock Cave were exceedingly destructive, and unscientific in the extreme. So let's take a look at the known history of Lovelock Cave to see when and where these red-haired giants may have lived and died.


Here's a picture of one of the skulls before it disappeared http://i.imgur.com/AcaBvsM.png
 
Last edited:
What's happening:

*guy sees evidence of Bigfoot*

*isn't able to handle the cognitive dissonance*

*joins the JREF forum*

*tries hard to convince himself that there's no such thing*

*reads a thread like this which addresses the real issue*

*uses the debate on Bigfoot as a red herring*

Sounds about as real as Bigfoot.

Dave
 
I've seen that before and it doesn't debunk anything. It goes over the backstory and says that the evidence disappeared, which it did.

How convenient. We wouldn't want the discovery of red-haired giants ruining our understanding of the world, would we?

Better sweep it under the rug, lads.

Of course, the irony of sweeping evidence of a giant under the rug is rather hilarious, and obviously lost on you.
 
What's happening:

*guy sees evidence of Bigfoot*

*isn't able to handle the cognitive dissonance*

*joins the JREF forum*

*tries hard to convince himself that there's no such thing*

*reads a thread like this which addresses the real issue*

*uses the debate on Bigfoot as a red herring*

*Voldemort kills harry Potter's parents

*Gandalf gives Harry the One Ring to Rule Them All

*Katniss Everdeen helps Harry to get the ORTRTA to Elysium

*Harry uses the ORTRTA to solve all of the medical issues in the world

And they lived happily ever after, except for Voldemort who lived in the woods and sulked a lot
 
I've seen that before and it doesn't debunk anything. It goes over the backstory and says that the evidence disappeared, which it did.
Reading is a skill.
And it turned out to be the greatest yet. Nobody in the fields of anthropology or archaeology has ever received a greater bounty than Loud did on that day. To the amazement of the scientific community, he collected over 10,000 artifacts from the rubbish heap and various regions of the cave, mostly along the walls where the miners had not cut. Loud's workload was such that it took him 17 years before he was finally able to publish a comprehensive account of his findings.

In none of it did he report anything pertaining to giants.


Here's a picture of the skull from before it disappeared http://i.imgur.com/AcaBvsM.png
Evidence? Provenance? Anything? Bueller?
 
Last edited:
I've seen that before and it doesn't debunk anything. It goes over the backstory and says that the evidence disappeared, which it did.

Here's a picture of one of the skulls before it disappeared http://i.imgur.com/AcaBvsM.png

Interesting that the skull in the picture is presented at an angle intended to maximize the appearance of the brow ridge.

Interesting that the "pronounced nuchal crest" is actually disarticlulated from the occipitus proper, falsely exaggerating its size and prominence.

Interesting that the supposed "high nasal bridge" is the result of missing bone.

Interesting that not one thing about the picture suggests that the skull is of unusual size...

ANd so on.
 
It doesn't say anything about the evidence from Lovelock cave..
Posts 1060 and 1067. As I said above, reading is a skill.

All it does is debunk the idea that the Smithsonian is covering up evidence of giants.
Which is a bigfootery claim as well.
If the evidence is being covered up, it obviously wouldn't be the Smithsonian that's doing
Not what your co-fringe believers claim.

What's yours, then?
 
A comparison

Yqwpc5U.png
 
More Colavito on the Lovelock claim:
http://www.jasoncolavito.com/blog/greg-little-is-still-mad-about-my-2013-post-on-giant-bones
There are obvious problems with that sentence. The “old newspaper reports” are notoriously unreliable—and not just on nutty fringe issues—and these so-called “giant” skeletons largely don’t exist at all. Any report of a “giant” can’t also report that it was a mammoth since anyone who mistook a mammoth for a giant wouldn’t recognize the error. That said, when the “giants” can be tracked down, they just aren’t what the papers claim. The most famous are those of Lovelock Cave, supposedly full of “giant” bones. But Ancient Aliens—an impeccable source!—gained access to these skeletons in 2010, and David Childress showed the skulls on TV. They were utterly and completely normal in size—if anything, somewhat smaller than David Childress’s swollen head. The claim that mammoths were mistaken for giants in this case does not originate with me; if originates with Georges Cuvier in 1806. Adrienne Mayor wrote about the Lovelock case in Fossil Legends of the First Americans and explained that the Paiute may have mistaken nearby mammoth bones (from a known bed of them) for those of giants, creating the legend of Lovelock Cave. Later, after archaeology found only normal sized skeletons in the cave, (white) hucksters created roadside displays to fool tourists into thinking they saw Bible giants. Their fake skeletons, first set out in 1911, were still on display as late as the 1960s.
 
The Patterson film subject wouldn't be considered a giant. She'd fit normal human height just like the original Lovelock skeletons. The fake giants that people are creating aren't relevant.

I thought Patty was over 6 foot in height? Didn't you champion Bill Munns' assessment of Patty being over 6.5 feet?

Normal human height is not what Munns suggested.
 
I've seen that before and it doesn't debunk anything. It goes over the backstory and says that the evidence disappeared, which it did.




Here's a picture of one of the skulls before it disappeared http://i.imgur.com/AcaBvsM.png

Why so much denial of the facts...it's nothing but a legend...game, set, match as clearly stated in the above mentioned article. You sure you read it?

Please provide proof that any of what you claim is true...as in you can back it up, with something other than....you read it somewhere.
 
The Patterson film subject wouldn't be considered a giant. She'd fit normal human height just like the original Lovelock skeletons. The fake giants that people are creating aren't relevant.
By what metric do you make this assertion?

And what does this have to do with the Lovelock myth?
 
More on the Lovelock myth.
http://www.andywhiteanthropology.co...a-jawbone-that-slips-over-that-of-a-large-man
As you might guess if you've been paying attention, there is no empirical support for the idea that the human remains and the archaeological deposits from Lovelock Cave are related to anything other than Native American inhabitants of the region. And as you also might guess, that doesn't stop fringe theorists from making the same inaccurate statements about Lovelock Cave over and over again . . . Apparently the "Paiute legend" of cannibalistic, red-haired giants originated with a story by a Paiute woman named Sarah Winnemucca Hopkins in her 1883 book Life Among the Piutes: Their Wrongs and Claims (see this 2013 post by Brian Dunning). The part relevant to Lovelock is the last paragraph of Chapter IV. If you read it you'll notice there's no mention of giants: the often-repeated statement that Paiute legends include giants in Lovelock cave seems to be a later addition. I guess it makes it easier to find giants if you just make them up. . .
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom