The Mentality of Skeptics

What I do not quite understand is why this Bigfoot is important. This has little to do with scepticism its some kind of mania. Exist, does not exist, what does it matter to anything? What grants it all the attention? I dont get it.

It's like making models of car accidents out of toothpicks. Just something to do.

But the drama seems real. Fair call.

Because (post 1015):
Because the OP's complaints arise solely from that subject, need to be considered in that context, and will always default to that subject.
 
What I do not quite understand is why this Bigfoot is important. This has little to do with scepticism its some kind of mania. Exist, does not exist, what does it matter to anything? What grants it all the attention? I dont get it.

What's happening:

*guy sees evidence of Bigfoot*

*isn't able to handle the cognitive dissonance*

*joins the JREF forum*

*tries hard to convince himself that there's no such thing*

*reads a thread like this which addresses the real issue*

*uses the debate on Bigfoot as a red herring*
 
What's happening:

*guy sees evidence of Bigfoot*

*isn't able to handle the cognitive dissonance*

*joins the JREF forum*

*tries hard to convince himself that there's no such thing*

*reads a thread like this which addresses the real issue*

*uses the debate on Bigfoot as a red herring*

You have yet to provide a single shred of credible evidence for this strawman skeptic.
 
Last edited:
I'm confused. I PMed him and asked him if he thought I was derailing his thread and his response was as follows:

12th December 2015, 02:07 PM
OntarioSquatch
Graduate Poster

Re: possible derailing of thread
Your posts were all on topic. It was the discussion on the existence of Sasquatch that derailed it.

3th December 2015, 08:33 PM
OntarioSquatch
Graduate Poster


Then I asked him if he would mind me using the above PM and put it in one of my replies. He said as follows:

Re: Using your response to my first PM to you.
Yeah no problem.

Could you please tell me the thread number where he recanted or whatever it was you think he did. If the thread got turned from its original intent and is now about Bigfoots, then I'm out. No interest in that. Thanks.


You were told that this thread, like all other OS threads, was about Bigfoot a fortnight ago. Have you been extremely inebriated since then, or do you just feign ignorance on a regular basis?

LOL @ "original intent." The thread is obviously about Bigfoot, it always has been, there was no original intent to delve into the supposed mentality of sceptics, this is about as clear as clear can be, or it at least should be, if you're sober. I'm astounded that anyone actually presumed OS was at all interested in scepticism or any aspect of its workings.

His avatar is a bloke in a bad Chewie suit with a diaper on. I'll let that sink in for a moment.
 
Last edited:
I'm confused. I PMed him and asked him if he thought I was derailing his thread and his response was as follows:

12th December 2015, 02:07 PM
OntarioSquatch
Graduate Poster

Re: possible derailing of thread
Your posts were all on topic. It was the discussion on the existence of Sasquatch that derailed it.

3th December 2015, 08:33 PM
OntarioSquatch
Graduate Poster


Then I asked him if he would mind me using the above PM and put it in one of my replies. He said as follows:

Re: Using your response to my first PM to you.
Yeah no problem.

Could you please tell me the thread number where he recanted or whatever it was you think he did. If the thread got turned from its original intent and is now about Bigfoots, then I'm out. No interest in that. Thanks.

Post #25, OntarioSquatch brings up Bigfoot. In subsequent discussions he brings up Bigfoot and is disinclined to point out that bringing up Bigfoot is derailing the thread. Since the disbelief in Bigfoot is an area of great importance to him, it seems reasonable that discussions of that concrete example of the general issue would be on topic.
 
Post #25, OntarioSquatch brings up Bigfoot. In subsequent discussions he brings up Bigfoot and is disinclined to point out that bringing up Bigfoot is derailing the thread. Since the disbelief in Bigfoot is an area of great importance to him, it seems reasonable that discussions of that concrete example of the general issue would be on topic.

It's virtually the only subject of importance to him on this site. Look at the silly strawman skeptic he proposes in post#1044. This is the "skeptic mentality" he's on about, without a shred of evidence that such a person exists here. Or anywhere.
 
OntarioSquatch said:
Originally Posted by OntarioSquatch View Post
What's happening:

*guy sees evidence of Bigfoot*

*isn't able to handle the cognitive dissonance*

*joins the JREF forum*

*tries hard to convince himself that there's no such thing*

*reads a thread like this which addresses the real issue*

*uses the debate on Bigfoot as a red herring*
You have yet to provide a single shred of credible evidence for this strawman skeptic.

Seconded. This description does not fit me in any way.
For at least the second time of asking by me alone: do please name one member of this forum that this description applies to.
 

Priceless! Thanks for that, Slowvehicle.
So it turns out they didn't install the infra-red cameras on trails at all. They set them up on their cabin. They then relate the seriously evidence-heavy and terrifying story verified scientific observation that they heard " extremely loud crashing multiple impact sounds. The men were a bit unnerved because the sound was very loud and sounded as though “something had thrown a Volkswagen.” The men clearly heard the extremely loud impact sounds while inside the cabin. The men could not agree on where the sounds originated." They must have spent a lot of money on that Volkswagenometer. That's science right there, folks.
Later on: "21:45 – With Hayes sitting in a chair near the bunk beds, and Colyer sitting in a chair near the west bedroom, both men heard loud, bipedal, jogging footsteps to the east of the cabin. The men believed the thudding footfalls came from the area between the shed just east of the cabin to the outhouse east of the cabin. "
So, did these fearless and intrepid (Operation Persistence Alpha Team, no less) investigators go out to see what was happening, and record it for posterity?
Did they thingummy.
"They were hopeful the Reconyx camera on the tree just outside the east window captured images of what surely ran right in front of it ......The next day, the men checked the cameras around the cabin".
Needless to say, nothing showed up on the camera.
Contrary to what OntarioSquatch seems to think, I had no real interest in this subject until a few months ago, when I looked into one of these threads out of idle curiosity.
The more I have seen of the quality of the research and the evidence, the more horrified I have become. Laughable nonsense. Unadulterated bilge. Truly a slow-motion train wreck. This, and only this, is what is keeping me in these threads. Pure entertainment.
Thanks OntarioSquatch!
 
Priceless! Thanks for that, Slowvehicle.
So it turns out they didn't install the infra-red cameras on trails at all. They set them up on their cabin.

They had dozens of trailcams out during the study they did between 2006-2011. The paper you looked at was on the their new study between 2011-present where they actually stopped using cameras and are instead using firearms to collect a specimen.

Here are some of their pictures from their older study https://www.flickr.com/photos/tbrc/albums/72157623451529670
 
.
Contrary to what OntarioSquatch seems to think, I had no real interest in this subject until a few months ago, when I looked into one of these threads out of idle curiosity.
The more I have seen of the quality of the research and the evidence, the more horrified I have become. Laughable nonsense. Unadulterated bilge. Truly a slow-motion train wreck. This, and only this, is what is keeping me in these threads. Pure entertainment.
Thanks OntarioSquatch!
Like you, I had no idea about the depth and breadth of the bigfoot nonsense until I began reading these threads back at the JREF. Like yourself, I was astounded that folks actually still defended the hypothesis. If you want more entertainment, head on over to the BFF. OS has even started a thread there titled Conceptual Bigfoot and in his last post there introduced the already debunked notion of the Lovelock Giants.
 
The possibility of an unlisted anthropoid species indigenous to the Ouachita Mountain
Ecoregion was investigated on a protracted basis by the North American Wood Ape
Conservancy (NAWAC). Surveys ranging from 60 to 120 uninterrupted days were​

A conservation group for an unlisted anthrapoid species investigates the possibility of the existence of same. Comedy gold right from the abstract.
 
This, and only this, is what is keeping me in these threads. Pure entertainment.
Thanks OntarioSquatch!

This subject can only be taken as a source of entertainment. It's not grounded in common-sense, and nor is it based in reality.

The only realities that exist in this subject, are the realities of deception, imagination and gullibility.

It's at a point where, if you know even half of the nonsense involved in Bigfootery, you can't possibly take any of it seriously. There was a time when people who hadn't bothered to look into it might have vaguely been open-minded about the possibility of something being out there, but those people didn't care much either way.

Now, in the year Nearly-2016, it's at a point where, if you follow anything related to the subject and are still open-minded, then you need a shrink.

To think that people like OS actually buy into this kind of stuff is hard to believe for any moderately sane individual, but that doesn't mean that he doesn't believe... But when he openly lies about certain things, that is when you have to call his sincerity into question.

I've never really bought the idea that OS is an actual believer in the way that he likes to portray, and this past year has cemented that for me.

This entire thread is based on his frustration with being ousted as a "gamer," hence why he is now underhandedly claiming blatant untruths about certain unknown sceptics being secret-believers or part-time worry-warts.

No rational adult would think like that. If we weren't in a relatively anonymous forum, but instead in a pub, or a living-room, chatting face-to-face, he'd be absolutely laughed at and the topic of Bigfoot would've ended after the first round of drinks, because certain questions and basic facts couldn't be avoided in person.

He's having a giraffe, no more, no less. If he genuinely believes even half of what he claims, then he's quite obviously not playing with a full-deck.
 
What's happening:

*guy sees evidence of Bigfoot*

*isn't able to handle the cognitive dissonance*

*joins the JREF forum*

*tries hard to convince himself that there's no such thing*

*reads a thread like this which addresses the real issue*

*uses the debate on Bigfoot as a red herring*

I think I understand the process. That much I was able to observe. I was curious why anyone pays attention to it. I got answer satisfying my curiosity.

I've never met anyone in my life speaking of Bigfoot. Except in comedy play where Yeti (in my language phonetically .. Já-ty .. in English You-me) is male and female in one creature, having dialogue when coming home late from a party.

What time was it when you came home yesterday?
I dunno there was still light
There is always light, its polar night!
I was celebrating your birthday.
Dont lie! You run around parties and my legs hurt!

Coincidently this Já-ty was discovered by another mythical person this play is about.
 
To my knowledge, it has never been debunked. If it has, please post a link to it.

https://skeptoid.com/episodes/4390
And it turned out to be the greatest yet. Nobody in the fields of anthropology or archaeology has ever received a greater bounty than Loud did on that day. To the amazement of the scientific community, he collected over 10,000 artifacts from the rubbish heap and various regions of the cave, mostly along the walls where the miners had not cut. Loud's workload was such that it took him 17 years before he was finally able to publish a comprehensive account of his findings.

In none of it did he report anything pertaining to giants.In 1924 Loud and M. R. Harringon, with a number of Paiute assistants, continued the exploration. Again, no giants were mentioned.

Further expeditions in 1936, by N. Nelson and Heizer and Krieger collected relics, but no giants. Krieger returned in 1949, 1950, and 1965. Still no giants . . .

No giants, just stories of giants.

What I found, in fact, is that every mention of the Si-Te-Cah appears only in paranormalist books and websites that promote the claim that a Paiute oral tradition says the red-haired giant cannibals were real. Every mention of the Saidaku appears in scholarly books and articles about the Lovelock Culture, with no mention whatsoever of red hair or gigantism. If you're looking for the legend, search for Si-Te-Cah; if you're looking for the true history, search for Saidaku.
Like most things fringe/paranormal, the enthusiasts talk to each other and the scientists do the science. Never the twain meet.
 
To my knowledge, it has never been debunked. If it has, please post a link to it.

https://skeptoid.com/episodes/4390
What I found, in fact, is that every mention of the Si-Te-Cah appears only in paranormalist books and websites that promote the claim that a Paiute oral tradition says the red-haired giant cannibals were real. Every mention of the Saidaku appears in scholarly books and articles about the Lovelock Culture, with no mention whatsoever of red hair or gigantism. If you're looking for the legend, search for Si-Te-Cah; if you're looking for the true history, search for Saidaku.

ETA: multiply (and capably) ninja-ed by Cervelo and Resume...
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom