they've done exactly that. they identified nux vomica from Na Cl from a control
...oh wait, the alcohol was contaminated. good catch there rolfey!
Sigh. No, they really didn't.
Now I know you're just trolling, but I'm a bit bored too right now so let's run with it for a little.
1. The Rao
et al. (2007) paper, which is what you appear to be referring to, has absolutely bugger-all to do with the "memory of water". For the extremely simple reason that the authors didn't do any experiments on water. They did some experiments on 95% ethanol. Why do you suppose that was?
Amazing property, this "memory". People theorise for pages and pages about the precise structure of the water molecule, and how it might give rise to this esoteric property, but then when they actually start to do the experiments they don't even use water at all, suddenly they're using 95% ethanol, which has a very different structure. Nobody has theorised at all about how this memory might be present in that liquid. But nevertheless, significant results are claimed to have been found.
Why might that be, do you suppose?
2. While the M&M section of the paper did refer to "unique identification numbers" being attached to the preparations supplied by Hahnemann Laboratories, there was no description of any blinding of the experiments. At no point was any evidence presented to suggest that anyone could tell which bottle a given sample had come from just by inspecting the UV trace.
3. Even unblinded, no statistical data were presented to demonstrate that there was any actual difference between the three types of preparation Meow referred to. What was in the paper was a couple of wiggly lines representing each preparation. While the text stated that each sample had been run ten times, we only got to see two selected runs for each preparation. Then we only had the authors' word that these were "different". Just eyeballing the wiggly lines, and being aware that these only represent a selected 20% of the wiggly lines actually obtained, it's not actually possible to say whether or not what the authors claim is true.
Meow seemed awfully impressed with "p<0.001" reported by another paper. Why do you suppose there isn't a single p value given anywhere in the Rao
et al. paper?
4. In fact all the wiggly lines presented for the 9 succussed preparations (Nat Mur, Nux Vom and no mother tincture, each at 3 different potencies) were all quite similar. Without seeing all the data (as opposed to a cherry-picked 20% of it) it's only a guess as to whether there is actually more than one population there. What is quite striking is the single wiggly line presented for the unsuccussed ethanol. Even subjectively (and that is the only way Rao allows us to consider her data) it does seem to represent a very different population (a population with a lot more absorbance between 250 and 350nm, and a marked absorbance maximum at 330nm the succussed preparations lack).
To the naive observer, this might tend to suggest that it is the shaking process that is causing these changes, not the nature of any solute the ethanol might or might not have been exposed to at an earlier stage in the preparation. How might that work, do you think?
Consider, the "plain ethanol", the unsuccussed stuff, the stuff with the marked absorbance maximum at 330nm, is the closest thing to an actual control in this presentation. It's just ethanol, as she comes, no succussion, no dilution, no exposure to any mother tincture. Now, the UV absorbance properties of plain (definitely not vanilla!) 95% ethanol around 330nm are well characterised and well understood, for the very simple reason that 95% ethanol is used as a spectroscopic solvent for solute-based work at that sort of wavelength. And in all the literature that is available on the subject, absorbance between 250 and 350nm is low, and there is no record or sign or even hint of an absorbance maximum at 330nm.
Why do you suppose that is?
...oh wait, the alcohol was contaminated.
Uh-huh. Or would you care to suggest an alternative explanation for the findings?
Rolfe.