The memory of water rides again?

Mojo

Mostly harmless
Joined
Jul 22, 2004
Messages
47,082
Location
Nor Flanden
I stumbled across this abstract the other day: The Structure Of Liquid Water;Novel Insights From Materials Research;Potential Relevance To Homeopathy.

I think these guys may have had some sort of agenda:
The most telling argument is the core paradigm of materials science, that properties of a phase are determined by structure, not composition. Hence the single argument used against homeopathy, that because there are no molecules of the remedy left in the final product it cannot be different, is completely negated.
The "single argument used against homeopathy"? It's not even the main one, which is of course that whenever homoeopathy is tested under properly controlled and blinded conditions, it doesn't appear to work. The fact that there is often none of the remedy substance left in the preparation is merely what makes the desperate attempts of homoeopaths to come up with a mechanism so hilarious.

Then again, I suppose, if they look at homoeopathy from the point of view of materials science rather than medicine they may also manage to negate the objection that all those pesky patients in the control group seem to do just as well as the ones that have been given the actual remedy...

The journal it is published in says that
This journal - because of its super peer review procedures-is especially suited for the publication of results which are so new, so unexpected, that they are likely to be rejected by tradition-bound journals.
Hmm: "tradition-bound journals". Is that near enough to "hidebound reactionary" to get 20 points from John Baez, d'you think?

What are "super peer review procedures"?
 
Could the first author of the paper, Rustum Roy, be any relation to the Editor-in-chief of Materials Research Innovations, one Rustum Roy?

That sure is super peer review!
 
I have memories of water. I remember when I caught that big largemouth bass, it was living in water. I remember when the idiot in the huge motorboat tried to swamp my canoe while we were fishing, that was on water. I remember crossing the St. of Juan de Fuca in a high wind, that was water giving me indigestion...

I have lots of water memories. You?
 
Rustom Roy has been going on about peer review for like decades. He doesn't like it.

I don't know what super peer review is, but over ten years ago, I recall he had a proposal for a mentoring peer review, wherein young faculty would only need to get endorsement from a senior, established colleague and could forego peer review. He wanted to start a journal that used this approach. I don't know if any of these have anything to do with that.
 
FYI Some information on the authors of this paper:

Rustum Roy:
The Fourth World Qigong Congress - Visionary of the Year for 2001

William Tiller:
Guest Speaker at 15th Annual International UFO Congress Convention, Laughlin Nevada.
Special Appearance in the film What the $#*! Do We Know?

Bell IR:
Publication: Evidence-based homeopathy: Empirical questions and methodological considerations for homeopathic clinical research.

Hoover, M.R:
Publication : Spectroscopic Analyses of Healing Water Samples: Instructive Anomolies
 
I don't know what super peer review is, but over ten years ago, I recall he had a proposal for a mentoring peer review, wherein young faculty would only need to get endorsement from a senior, established colleague and could forego peer review. He wanted to start a journal that used this approach.
Well, I guess that that could be what is meant as "super peer" review, so maybe this is the journal in question.
 
I have lots of water memories. You?

I have memories of water rides. Again. One time, we went to Magic Mountain and the guy loading people into the boats asked us if we wanted to try a new car, designed to get the riders extra wet. Me and my brother both said yes and overrode our dad, who did not want to get "extra wet". Bwahahaha. So we were led off to a different area and went into boat that was pointier on the front end. We got really soaked. Then at the end, some guy with a clipboard asked me and my brother some questions. Great fun.
 
In which case, could somebody please hold a chunk of Kryptonite up to this journal? It looks like it could use a little color in its skin.
 
After reading the abstract these material "scientists" need to actually go to a chemistry course. Every assertion in the abstract is wrong, wrong, wrong. The structure or water in the courses I took discussed the intermolecular hydrogen bonding which influenced the structure of the molecules within the liquid. The surface interaction is not part of the structure of liquid water. The several dozen structures that are known is not exactly true. H2O is a simplified formula, again due to hydrogen bonding, within real water you can also see H4O2, H6O3, H8O4 etc. This is well known and constantly changing on the order of nano seconds IIRC (there has been a measurement on this but I haven't had a chance to research the paper). There is NO SIMILARITY between silicon dioxide and water, none, no way, no how, no chance NONE NONE NONE. Silicon is tetravalent and can have both positive and negative ions, oxygen is divalent and can only be negatively charged and hydrogen is monovalent. The bond angle would be slightly different, the bond lengths completely different. In water hydrogen bonding (again) is dominant in silicon dioxide there is no hydrogen hence no hydrogen bonding. The nearest substance to water is H2S and even this has different properties. The highly anomalous property temperature relations in water do not baffle chemists once hydrogen bonding was understood it explained away these anomalies very nicely thank you.

In summary these guys are morons and probably have never taken a single course in water chemistry, don't understand water chemistry and like homeopaths are very happy using there ignorance to prove something that is not even debated really in chemistry. Researched yes, there are still things to look at, but the debate is pretty much over just some details to clean up (sound familiar).
 
While I am not a fan of this work, I can guarantee that Rustom Roy knows a heck of a lot more chemistry than you learned in "the classes you took."

Your views on the structure of water and SiO2 are extremely simplisitic, and sound like they come from someone who maybe took a couple of chemistry courses in college. It's far more complicated than you suggest here.

No, I may not agree with the claims in this paper, BUT at the same time, I know that your claims about the structure of liquid water are still too simplistic. For starters, your assertion about the "surface interaction" not being a part of liquid water is blatently idiotic. Liquid water has a surface. There are interactions at the surface. In fact, there is a whole field that investigates the properties at the interface of water and other media (including air), and it is still very poorly understood what it going on there.

The highly anomalous property temperature relations in water do not baffle chemists once hydrogen bonding was understood it explained away these anomalies very nicely thank you.

This would be news to all the water chemists I know (and I know a lot of them, BTW)
 
While I am not a fan of this work, I can guarantee that Rustom Roy knows a heck of a lot more chemistry than you learned in "the classes you took."
BSc Geochemistry focus on groundwater interactions. I tried to keep my response to a relatively simplistic level and only answer his claims.


Your views on the structure of water and SiO2 are extremely simplisitic, and sound like they come from someone who maybe took a couple of chemistry courses in college. It's far more complicated than you suggest here.
I know that he simplified it even further than I have. He seems to look at the water molecule as a rigid structure which it definetly is not. To fully explain water chemistry and it's interactions is several courses which cannot be fully explained on a forum such as this. The only similarities in SiO2 and water is the tetrahedral bond angles. The expected electron distributions and hence the bond strengths, and type of extramolecular bonding will be different especially the bonding between two molecules of the same type (SiO2 and water have extremely different bonding structures) In it's liquid form (ie. magma) SiO2 behaves different than liquid water. When both solidify water has a single crystaline structure whereas SiO2 has many possible structures.

No, I may not agree with the claims in this paper, BUT at the same time, I know that your claims about the structure of liquid water are still too simplistic. For starters, your assertion about the "surface interaction" not being a part of liquid water is blatently idiotic. Liquid water has a surface. There are interactions at the surface. In fact, there is a whole field that investigates the properties at the interface of water and other media (including air), and it is still very poorly understood what it going on there.
I know there is a surface interaction but this is not the structure of water, this is involved more with the evaporation and interaction of water with it's surroundings. The surface interactions of water is very important to water but not as much as the disolved components in it.

This would be news to all the water chemists I know (and I know a lot of them, BTW)
If you would like to get one of them to read that abstract and come up with a criticism you are more than welcome, this is the criticism that I have. If you can prove any of my assertions false feel free to post them.
 
To fully explain water chemistry and it's interactions is several courses which cannot be fully explained on a forum such as this. The only similarities in SiO2 and water is the tetrahedral bond angles. The expected electron distributions and hence the bond strengths, and type of extramolecular bonding will be different especially the bonding between two molecules of the same type...
The problem with the homoeopathic arguments as to mode of action, whether they involve quantum mechanics, memory of water or whatever is the tendency that it has of getting learned people, such as participate on this forum bogged down in debates such as this as though the subject was worthy of debate. Frankly whether Dick Hoover or Rustom Roy are PhD's or have based their argument on the Ladybird book of Pondlife is immaterial. All they have to do is to show that they are able to tell the difference between a homoeopathic remedy and plain water using their latest theory or any other means for that matter. If the theory is so brilliant this should be easy, but somehow there's always an objection.

Yuri
 
The journal it is published in says that Hmm: "tradition-bound journals". Is that near enough to "hidebound reactionary" to get 20 points from John Baez, d'you think?

What are "super peer review procedures"?
I'd also give them;
"40 points for claiming that when your theory is finally appreciated, present-day science will be seen for the sham it truly is. (30 more points for fantasizing about show trials in which scientists who mocked your theories will be forced to recant.)

# 50 points for claiming you have a revolutionary theory but giving no concrete testable predictions. "
 
H2O is a simplified formula, again due to hydrogen bonding, within real water you can also see H4O2, H6O3, H8O4 etc. This is well known and constantly changing on the order of nano seconds IIRC (there has been a measurement on this but I haven't had a chance to research the paper).

That is exactly correct. The changing is due to Brownian Motion, which is something that I have to educate the fellow called Kayvee at the Hpathy web site and the lot of them. This is a well covered topic in fluid mechanics and I know for sure that Pharmacology does cover the dynamics of fluids and how it interacts with the target molecule (protein). I am not a pharmacologist but I have seen a book on the subject which introduces 'Pharmaco-kinetics' (systems dynamics of molecules) in early chapters of the book.
 
That is exactly correct. The changing is due to Brownian Motion, which is something that I have to educate the fellow called Kayvee at the Hpathy web site and the lot of them. This is a well covered topic in fluid mechanics and I know for sure that Pharmacology does cover the dynamics of fluids and how it interacts with the target molecule (protein). I am not a pharmacologist but I have seen a book on the subject which introduces 'Pharmaco-kinetics' (systems dynamics of molecules) in early chapters of the book.


And, of course, the fact that water molecules break up and reform (what do you think pH 7 means, anyhow?) all the time, that they form small groups and reform, and that they do this on a very very fast basis (well, I forget, was it something like an hour for the half-life of a given H2O to disassociate and reform, of course with one different proton, most likely), goes to show just how far beyond lamely imaginary the idea of "water memory" has to be.

Of course if any DBT showed it worked, we'd have to reexamine that idea, but water still boils, you know ...

As to SiO2 being the same as water, well, err, um, one is quadravalent and divalent, one is divalent and monovalent. One is a solid, usually existing in crystaline form, the other is a liquid at room temperature/pressure. One is about as inert and nonsolvent (again at room temperature/pressure) as things get, the other one is one of the best solvents going...

Well I mean other than that ...

Let's see (no CRC here)
What's the heat of formation of H2O from H2 and O2? (properly stoichometric, of course, 2 moles to one)
What's the heat of formation of SiO2? Ditto.

What's the fraction of disassociated SiO2 at room temperature? Do you get wandering O's? :) :)

What's the fraction of disassociated H2O at room temperature? Yeah, we already discussed that above.
 
Kayvee = Kumar

I'd give up now, sionep. He's a nutcase of the first water!




Sorry. :) I just realised what I wrote and the thread I'm in...
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom