Mojo
Mostly harmless
I stumbled across this abstract the other day: The Structure Of Liquid Water;Novel Insights From Materials Research;Potential Relevance To Homeopathy.
I think these guys may have had some sort of agenda:
Then again, I suppose, if they look at homoeopathy from the point of view of materials science rather than medicine they may also manage to negate the objection that all those pesky patients in the control group seem to do just as well as the ones that have been given the actual remedy...
The journal it is published in says that
What are "super peer review procedures"?
I think these guys may have had some sort of agenda:
The "single argument used against homeopathy"? It's not even the main one, which is of course that whenever homoeopathy is tested under properly controlled and blinded conditions, it doesn't appear to work. The fact that there is often none of the remedy substance left in the preparation is merely what makes the desperate attempts of homoeopaths to come up with a mechanism so hilarious.The most telling argument is the core paradigm of materials science, that properties of a phase are determined by structure, not composition. Hence the single argument used against homeopathy, that because there are no molecules of the remedy left in the final product it cannot be different, is completely negated.
Then again, I suppose, if they look at homoeopathy from the point of view of materials science rather than medicine they may also manage to negate the objection that all those pesky patients in the control group seem to do just as well as the ones that have been given the actual remedy...
The journal it is published in says that
Hmm: "tradition-bound journals". Is that near enough to "hidebound reactionary" to get 20 points from John Baez, d'you think?This journal - because of its super peer review procedures-is especially suited for the publication of results which are so new, so unexpected, that they are likely to be rejected by tradition-bound journals.
What are "super peer review procedures"?