The General Theory of Stellar Metamorphosis

Yes, arguing and pointing out flaws is how science works. But then, you are not doing science.
You are preaching, and noone is good like preachers at ignoring actual well written opposition. Hence your liberal use of the ignore feature. Pretty soon everyone you see in this thread will agree with you, and they will all be called Jeffryw.

Ignore feature is useful, esp. when people are not actually reading what I have written given they can't even spell my name. It is Jeffreyw.

Oh yea, I do not want to waste a post so here's the preliminary book, of course it needs editing, but that will happen soon enough. I will continue to work on the theory and pointing out all the flaws establishment dogma chooses to ignore, given they are truly the ignorant ones. Planets are ancient stars. They are the same fn things.

http://vixra.org/abs/1711.0206
 
Last edited:
Ah, extolling the virtues of one's own deliberate ignorance while attempting to chastise others for what's perceived as theirs. Hypocrisy much? Who would have thunk?
 
jeffreyw: 284 items of ignorance and delusion since 15th January 2015

... the preliminary book...
A book collecting your ignorance and delusions into 1 place would be useful - if this thread did not exist.
jeffreyw: 220 items of ignorance and delusion since 15th January 2015 :eye-poppi!
Add a lot more items since last September:
  1. 11 September 2017 jeffreyw: Martian water evaporation irrelevancy.
  2. 11 September 2017 jeffreyw: A delusion that Mercury is "in excess of 65 billion years old" because it has no atmosphere and has craters.
  3. 11 September 2017 jeffreyw: A delusion that impact craters are "healed" by "interior fluid motion".
  4. 11 September 2017 jeffreyw: A "paradigm of stellar metamorphosis is much more advances" lie - ignorant delusions are not more advanced that working science.
  5. 11 September 2017 jeffreyw: A "old, painfully outdated models that were taught in the 1950’s" lie because they are not the 2017 models.
  6. 21 September 2017 jeffreyw: Lies about and insults other posters in this thread.
  7. 21 September 2017 jeffreyw: An idiotic natural gas and oil PDF ignoring basic facts.
  8. 22 September 2017 jeffreyw: His hydrocarbons PDF is deluded from the first 2 words in the abstract: "Establishment dogma"
  9. 22 September 2017 jeffreyw: The abstract ends with a lie of "Explanation is provided" since no explanation is provided.
  10. 22 September 2017 jeffreyw: A lie of "The dogma fully accepts the false notion of life somehow being independent of the natural world".
  11. 22 September 2017 jeffreyw: Abysmal ignorance about hydrocarbons leads to the delusion that petroleum and life have the same hydrocarbons so petroleum must have existed before life!
  12. 22 September 2017 jeffreyw: An ignorant statement that natural gas is just methane.
  13. 22 September 2017 jeffreyw: A lie that natural gas is found on Jupiter, Saturn, Neptune and Uranus.
  14. 22 September 2017 jeffreyw: A delusion that "seemingly abiogenic atmospheres such as Jupiter" contain methane from life.
  15. 22 September 2017 jeffreyw: A lie of "is found deep in the interior crust".
  16. 22 September 2017 jeffreyw: The dumb suggestion that anyone can confuse coal for petroleum.
  17. 22 September 2017 jeffreyw: The stupidity of life evolving in the atmospheres of stars where the temperature destroys complex molecules.
  18. 22 September 2017 jeffreyw: A delusion of "bacterial blooms that appear on evolved stars".
  19. 2 October 2017 jeffreyw: 13 ignorant fantasies about stars, e.g. CME's, flaring, photoevaporation, etc. do not get rid of 99.99% of a star or just iron!
  20. 2 October 2017 jeffreyw: 6 delusions about the crust, atmosphere magnetic field, age, etc. of Mars.
  21. 5 October 2017 jeffreyw: 10 delusions and lies about the Solar System, etc.
  22. 5 October 2017 jeffreyw: Idiocy that the Goldich dissolution series has something to do with his deluded stellar evolution + 3 more items
  23. 6 October 2017 jeffreyw: A delusion that different isotope abundances between the Sun and Earth means that did not they form from the same cloud.
  24. 6 October 2017 jeffreyw: A lie that his delusions predict anything, including isotope abundances.
  25. 6 October 2017 jeffreyw: A inane and abysmally ignorant delusion that weathering on the Earth's surface applies to the interiors of stars + 8 more items.
  26. 6 October 2017 jeffreyw: Repeats ignorant delusions about stars including being ignorant about his delusions! + 6 more items.
 
Last edited:
jeffreyw: Repeats the ignorant delusion of science being "establishment dogma"

... pointing out all the flaws establishment dogma chooses to ignore, given they are truly the ignorant ones.
13 November 2017 jeffreyw: Repeats the ignorant delusion of science being "establishment dogma".
13 November 2017 jeffreyw: A lie about pointing out flaws in mainstream science - his ignorance prevents that.
13 November 2017 jeffreyw: A lie about scientists ignoring flaws in mainstream science.
13 November 2017 jeffreyw: Insults scientists using centuries of collected knowledge about the universe.
 
151 pages of ignorance, delusions and lies - Part 1

So what is in this PDF by the ignorant Jeffrey Joseph Wolynski and his sidekick Barrington James Taylor?

151 pages of ignorance, delusions and lies.
Page 1: A lie of "Career scientists are trained these days to keep their head down and do as they are told" and similar ignorant ranting.

Page 3: Admits his ignorance of astronomy and an delusional rant about science education and universities brainwashing for a few pages.

Page 8: Finally gets to his "discovery" - he reads a Wikipedia page which inspires his ignorant fantasy about planets which his has held onto for years :eek:!
Stupidly links to a Wikipedia image (https://commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/File:Evolved_star_fusion_shells.svg) that has nothing to do with planets, especially Earth.

Page 11: The reasonable act of asking a astronomy professor about his idea who told him that it was wrong. Followed by the insane act of asking a delude Internet crank (Bill Gaede).

Page 15: "The Super-Genius Illusion Versus Discovery" ignorant ranting. A few discoveries are made by geniuses such as Newton and Einstein. Most discoveries are any years of work by many scientists.

Page 20: Introduction about his many delusions. Obvious stupidity of stars and "nuclear processes as observed in active galaxies and radio jets".

Page 21: A lying list of people "endorsing" his delusions.
We have seen his lie about the biologist Alexander Ivanovich Oparin in this thread. The rest are ignorant or deluded cranks judging by the references.

Page 22: Lies about Alexander Ivanovich Oparin, etc.

Pages 22 onward = take his delusion and run with it. Adds more lies, e.g. from his blog.

Page 42: A lie that Sillimanite, Kyanite, Andalusite formed on the surface of the Earth and are evidence of a delusion about "very thick highly pressurized gas" (2000-9,800 atmospheres).

Page 43: A "A main astronomical assumption is that all stars have visible spectrums" lie.

Page 44: A "It is assumed that all stars are massive like the Sun" lie followed by conservation of mass and energy stupidity Mass and energy leaving stars is conservation of their mass and energy :eek:!

Page 46: "disk nebula" fantasy- they do not exist! There were spiral nebulae that were shown to be galaxies by Edwin Hubble.

Page 46: A "As of 2017 they still have no evidence to back their claim that planets form out of disks" lie.

Page 47: A "It is assumed that nothing can enter the solar system from another star system entirely" lie.
It was calculated that this is a rare event and we have a good candidate for the first such visitor (an asteroid).

Page 48: Stars are "assumed to fusion powered" lie and physics stupidity. Then stars are powered by chemistry idiocy.

Page 48: A lie that dark matter is a "theoretical entity" that has never been observed.

Page 49: Inane stuff about "gravitational instability" - almost sounds like the idiocy that gravity does not attract!

Page 50: A delusion about charge separation needed to "birth a star".

Page 51: The usual inanity of "dogma of establishment" + a "nuclear decay being importing in stats" delusion + repeated denial of the theory and observation of nuclear fusion in stars + the stupidity of a " birthing galaxy" image. This is the real Hercules A.


Page 145: The stupid grouping together of Young Earth Creationism and the Big Bang and "time has never been show experimentally to possess orthogonality" gibberish.
 
Last edited:
151 pages of ignorance, delusions and lies - Part 2

Page 51: The delusion that imaginary "birthing galaxies" are the only places with nuclear element synthesis.

Page 52: Ignorant musings about gravitational collapse and its energy release. This was debunked as a source of stellar energy release well over century ago when Kelvin and von Helmholtz calculated that it would only last for 20 million years.

Page 54: "Thermodynamics of Evolving Stars" based on the delusions that stars are powered chemically and form planets + idiocy of " stars obey the mass-energy equivalence", etc.

Page 55: More about the chemically powered and gravitational collapse delusions.

Page 58: "Chemistry of Evolving Star" delusions, e.g. " thermochemical, electrochemical and photochemical reactions take place in stars".

Page 60: Ignorant delusion of rocks contain water so "The Earth was covered in deep oceans of water at one point, many millions of years in the past."

Page 63: An ignorant fantasy about imaginary stars with "gaseous hydrogen" that reacts with iron/nickel meteors clouding with the outer atmosphere.

Page 66: "Stellar Engineering" delusions with the stupidity of the metallurgy of meteorites determining the "actual physical characteristics of stellar interiors".

Page 68: Idiotically quotes the 18th century chemist, Antoine Lavoisier about meteorites.

Page 68: A lie of "examining the equations for stellar structure" when what he writes an insane demand that they include "co-efficients of thermal contraction" which are for solids!

Page 70: Delusions about plasmas, gases and stars.

Page 71: "Stellar meteorology" delusions. Mostly gibberish about "weather" on stars.

Page 72: "Magnetosphere Evolution" delusions. Primarily the abysmally ignorant idea that stellar magnetic field reduce to planetary fields when they actually get bigger as stars get older.

Page 73: "Encompassed Theories" is an admission that he will include parts of other ignorant delusions from other cranks.

Page 74: Tectonic plate ignorance and delusions.

Page 75: Ignorant fantasies about "Abiogenic oil and natural gas".

Page 77: Cites the ignorant crank Robitaille who thinks the Sun is made of liquid metallic hydrogen and had the delusion that the CMB was light reflected from the earth's oceans.

Page 78: "Contracted/Expanding/Contraction Earth" cranks.

Page 80: Rejects stellar mass black holes because he can write ignorant gibberish and lies (black holes are not "zero dimensional").

Page 80: Ignorant paragraph about the "Disk gravitational instability model"

Page 81: Lies about the core accretion model.

Page 83: Lies about gravity, "pebble accretion" and "rock self-assembly".

Page 84: A delusion of "Evolutionary Earth" is compared to his fantasy of what uniformitarianism means.

Page 84: A "rock cycle" lie.

Page 84: Many "Iron catastrophe" lies and gibberish, e.g. hot rocks from "pre-existing heat from gravitational pressure". The real iron catastrophe

Page 87: Delusions about the Goldilocks zone .
 
Oh yea, I do not want to waste a post so here's the preliminary book, of course it needs editing, but that will happen soon enough. I will continue to work on the theory and pointing out all the flaws establishment dogma chooses to ignore, given they are truly the ignorant ones. Planets are ancient stars. They are the same fn things.

http://vixra.org/abs/1711.0206


I slogged through the first 12 pages of jeffreyw's manifesto. He began by attempting to explain how a lack of knowledge of astrophysics is a big advantage if one aspires to make groundbreaking discoveries. He then evidently felt it necessary to visit some of the antiscience stations of the cross; astrophysicists are a) incompetent, b) conspiring to suppress original thinking and, sadly, c) committing fraud.

He then described how his idea, which he terms a discovery, came to him. It’s as he descibed it in his early videos. He noted a similarity between the concentric shells of elements in a star before supernova and the concentric layers of the Earth. That’s the long and short of it. Just another case of “looks like a bunny” science.

He concluded his intro with a flight of fancy that his idea will some day take the world by storm.

I’m of two minds in cases like these. Sadness for the enthusiasm and passion that might have led to real discoveries had it been married with proper training, and on the other hand anger at scurrilous accusations and the attempt to spread abject nonsense.
 
jeffreyw: Thinks a deluded PDF from a crank is support for his ignorant delusion

Another paper from an outside source that uses stellar metamorphosis to explain the dust belts around Proxima Centauri.
15 November 2017 jeffreyw: Thinks a deluded PDF from another ignorant crank else is support for his ignorant delusions.
This is an ignorant Daniel Archer mindlessly parroting a stars = planets = "astron" delusion. A PDF of 2 pages, mostly images, a few paragraphs of ignorant fantasies and the idiocy of the references being 3 links to PDFs.
Similar ignorance, delusions and lies we have seen from jeffreyw
  • The Sun and Proxima Centauri are actually similar in age - 4.6 billion years and 4.85 billion years respectively.
  • jeffreyw's ignorant delusion of planets are old stars is extended to the trillions of objects in a dust belt are also old stars :eek:!
  • jeffreyw's insanity that the Solar System does not exist is indirectly referred to (stellar systems are sets of captured objects).
  • A stupid fantasy of "smaller astrons would get closest to their host".
  • A delusion of planets being "eroded away" by their star.
  • Gibberish of "resonant/harmonic distances".
  • A lie of "faulty nebular theory"
  • The idiocy of comparing Saturn to Proxima Centauri.
  • A lie that Saturn's moons get smaller as they get closer - Moons of Saturn.
    There are lots of tiny moons far away mixed with a few moons that are 2-5 times their size. Then there is Phoebe, Iapetus (larger than Phoebe), Titan (larger than Iapetus), Rhea (bigger than Phoebe and Iapetus but not Titan), etc.

    The lie is probably based on the stupidity of looking at the Wikipedia image he copies with no citation and not understanding that it only has the major, inner moons. If we ignore 57 moons (:eek:) then Rhea to Mimas do get smaller.

The real world science is:
ALMA Discovery of Dust Belts Around Proxima Centauri
Proxima Centauri, the star closest to our Sun, is known to host at least one terrestrial planet candidate in a temperate orbit. Here we report the ALMA detection of the star at 1.3 mm wavelength and the discovery of a belt of dust orbiting around it at distances ranging between 1 and 4 au, approximately. Given the low luminosity of the Proxima Centauri star, we estimate a characteristic temperature of about 40 K for this dust, which might constitute the dust component of a small-scale analog to our solar system Kuiper belt. The estimated total mass, including dust and bodies up to 50 km in size, is of the order of 0.01 Earth masses, which is similar to that of the solar Kuiper belt. Our data also show a hint of warmer dust closer to the star. We also find signs of two additional features that might be associated with the Proxima Centauri system, which, however, still require further observations to be confirmed: an outer extremely cold (about 10 K) belt around the star at about 30 au, whose orbital plane is tilted about 45 degrees with respect to the plane of the sky; and additionally, we marginally detect a compact 1.3 mm emission source at a projected distance of about 1.2 arcsec from the star, whose nature is still unknown
 
Last edited:
151 pages of ignorance, delusions and lies - Part 3

Page 89: Ignorant delusions about the spectrums of "older stars" (planets do shine by their own light because they are hot!).

Page 89: Ionization energy idiocy.

Page 89: Marklund convection lie of sorting atoms.

Page 91: "Five Delusions of Host Jupiters"

Page 92: Ignorant delusions on determining the ages of stars. Starts with the stupidity of "Big Bang theory" being about the age of stars. In the real world there are multiple techniques (Stellar age estimation), e.g. mass + luminosity gives age.

Page 96: One of the many lies about ages of planets - the Earth is 4.54±0.04 billion years old, not 10 billion.

Page 99: A delusion that O-16, O-17 and O-18 can be used to determine the age of a star.

Page 99: The obvious stars lose mass as they age and so their gravity diminishes. The idiocy is that they lose 99.999% of their mass to become planets.

Page 101: The stupidly of rocky planets being the still hypothetical Chthonian planets.

Page 102: A lie that white dwarfs are "stars in early stages of evolution" when they are the end stage of stellar evolution.

Page 103: A "Mass loss" delusion is stated. As stars "evolve, cool and die", they stop losing mass.

Page 103: A lie of "stars are not the location for any significant fusion processes"

Page 104: "Ockham's razor" lie when it is not applied and cannot be applied.

Page 104: Delusions about gyrochronology

Page 105: A delusion of "heat evolution" starting with stupidity of "the interior regions are cooler".

Page 107: More deluded "principles" based on the idiocy of just stating his fantasy makes it true.

Page 109: "Orbit principles" insanity and lies, e.g. that stellar systems would "match the inclination of the Sun’s equator". Astronomers have never thought that :eye-poppi.
A lie that established science predicts that all of the planets in the Solar System will form with exactly the same inclination and never interact to change their inclinations.
 
151 pages of ignorance, delusions and lies - Part 4

Page 111: The "dogma" label insanity.

Page 111: The stupid delusion that Earth was "many magnitudes more massive in its past" because he wants Earth to have multiple moons.

Page 111: The massively more massive Earth delusion leads to a "The more massive the star, the more objects will orbit it." delusion. And the idiocy that hundreds of moons magically vanished from the early Earth.

Page 112: Idiocy about Kepler and the transit method of detecting exoplanets.

Page 113: A "Multiple nebulas" delusion.

Page 113: A deluded "principle" that the Solar System has multiple stars when it only has the Sun.

Page 113: "Accretion" starts with "inside the stat" idiocy when URL="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Accretion_(astrophysics)"]accretion[/URL] is a body gaining mass from outside of the body. But then contradicts itself!
Inane fantasies about accretion, etc. follow.

Page 117: The insanity of a "crystal growth" in "late stage orange dwarf, early stage red dwarf evolution". Stars are made of plasma, not solids.

Page 119: Lies abut Earth being younger than Venus and Mars. His delusion of 10 billon years make Earth a few time older than them!

Page 119: Lies about Venus not having active volcanoes.

Page 120: The irrelevance of Goldschmidt classification

Page 121: Idiotic "principle of spherical celestial object".

Page 121: Idiotic "principle of stellar adoption" and the stellar adoption insanity.

Page 122: Exoplanets are old stars delusion lead to more ignorant fantasies and a lie of giving examples .

Page 123: Ignorant fantasy of "principles of volume and surface area".

Page 123: Ignorant fantasy of "principle of stellar co-evolution".

Page 123: Abysmally ignorant about biology delusion of "principle of biostellar evolution".
 
Hi,

I wanted to post reply but it is not possible to post anything 'normallly' on this forum.

This will be my first and last post on this forum.

You can see my reply on the graham hancock forum in the GTSM thread.

Regards,
Daniel
 
Hi,

I wanted to post reply but it is not possible to post anything 'normallly' on this forum.

This will be my first and last post on this forum.

You can see my reply on the graham hancock forum in the GTSM thread.

Regards,
Daniel

Everybody else seems to manage it! Look, I just did it!

This is the reply to RC that DA is talking about:
http://grahamhancock.com/phorum/read.php?3,722712,1123783#msg-1123783

Daniel is quite active on there, promoting EU woo, as well as on Dunderdolts. Science doesn't appear to be his strong point.
 
Last edited:
You can see my reply on the graham hancock forum in the GTSM thread.
When we see someone touting the forum of the ancient civilizations crank Graham Hancock in a thread about astronomy then we have to suspect little knowledge of science!

His thread there is a regurgitation of the insanity that planets are stars as in 15 November 2017 jeffreyw: Thinks a deluded PDF from another ignorant crank (Daniel Archer) is support for his ignorant delusions.
That post has:
  • Mindlessly parrots a lie that I recall from jeffreyw that Three Theories of Planet Formation Busted, Expert Says is that nebular theory "struck out".
    Geoffrey Marcy opinion on February 22, 2011 was that the theory of gravitational drag from leftover gas and dust eroding planetary orbits has struck out and we need to look more at gravitational interactions.
  • Does not know the ages of the Sun and Proxima Centauri are recorded with sources in Wikipedia :eek:!
  • Cannot understand the stupidity of stellar systems collecting random objects to form the fairly structured systems we observe, e.g. the Solar System.
  • Cannot understand how stupid the fantasy that smaller objects magically get captured closer to the star is.
    The orbit a captured object takes does not depend just on its mass - there is also velocity and direction.
  • Repeats a ignorant delusion of planets being "eroded away" by their star.
    A probable delusion of airless planets being eroded by the solar wind. The Moon has dust that is levitated by the solar wind and falls back to the surface. What makes this idiotic is not knowing that the Moon also gains mass through impacts.
  • Compounds the idiocy of comparing Saturn to Proxima Centauri by pointing out that Proxima Centauri is a flare star (no flares on Saturn :eek:!).
  • Repeats his lie that Saturn's moons get smaller as they get closer. Anyone read what the sizes of the moons are and that he has written a lie.
    Makes it clear that his lie is based on the idiocy of looking at an image of some of Saturn's moons.
 
Last edited:
Hi,

I wanted to post reply but it is not possible to post anything 'normallly' on this forum.

This will be my first and last post on this forum.
[...]

Regards,
Daniel

OK. Talk to you later! Don't use ISF to promote your own crackpot/kook site.
 
Hi,

I wanted to post reply but it is not possible to post anything 'normallly' on this forum.

This will be my first and last post on this forum.

You can see my reply on the graham hancock forum in the GTSM thread.

Regards,
Daniel

Its all good dude. Oh BTW I wrote up a new paper on some differences between EU, GTSM and the dogma. I made the layout a bit different, but it definitely needs to be developed more. http://vixra.org/pdf/1711.0347v1.pdf
 
Everybody else seems to manage it! Look, I just did it!

This is the reply to RC that DA is talking about:
http://grahamhancock.com/phorum/read.php?3,722712,1123783#msg-1123783

Daniel is quite active on there, promoting EU woo, as well as on Dunderdolts. Science doesn't appear to be his strong point.

Archer understands GTSM, which is the replacement of establishment's nonsense. That by itself makes up for any woo he may apparently promote. Besides, your boy Newton tried to decipher the fn Bible.

Doing great science doesn't mean you never have really bad ideas. In fact, in order to do great science really bad ideas are a necessity at times, because they give something to compare progress with. I can compare GTSM to the dead on arrival nebular hypothesis and explain the exoplanets with it, which the nebular hypothesis couldn't explain.

I'm sort of glad the dogma is engaged in pseudoscience, it gives me more room to breathe and develop theory.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom