Assuming for the moment that jeffreyw intends his theory to be taken seriously, I can only suggest that "he" reverse the situation hypothetically. If I had some truly unusual idea about military strategy, I would assume that jeffreyw would be willing to consider what I might have to say. Although jeffreyw appears to not believe this, scientists usually are very willing to hear how they may have gotten it wrong. I in fact have had some truly exciting moments when I myself realized, or someone else told me, that there was a novel way of re-interpreting most of my data in a new way that helped make sense of things that never did before. I truly treasure those moments and they are among the high points of my career as a scientist.
But the novel reinterpretation must help make better sense of the known facts so as to be accepted. So, if after capturing your attention by telling you that I had a novel military strategy, if I then went on to state a strategy that relied on an entire series of things you knew were untrue: a battalion representing 1000000 men, use of force shields, arrays of matter transporters, you would stop taking me seriously and justifiably ignore me. What if I also insulted your knowledge as a Marine of military tactics, and state that I was both braver and smarter than you were. Do you think that my ideas would be readily accepted by you?
So, although I do not think that I can change your views, I am suggesting a better way of convincing "the establishment" if you do indeed think that you are correct: learn a lot about the accepted theories and why people think that they are right, explain how your theory explains the known facts better than the accepted theory, make certain that your theory doesn't negate any of the known facts, and be polite in doing so.
But the novel reinterpretation must help make better sense of the known facts so as to be accepted. So, if after capturing your attention by telling you that I had a novel military strategy, if I then went on to state a strategy that relied on an entire series of things you knew were untrue: a battalion representing 1000000 men, use of force shields, arrays of matter transporters, you would stop taking me seriously and justifiably ignore me. What if I also insulted your knowledge as a Marine of military tactics, and state that I was both braver and smarter than you were. Do you think that my ideas would be readily accepted by you?
So, although I do not think that I can change your views, I am suggesting a better way of convincing "the establishment" if you do indeed think that you are correct: learn a lot about the accepted theories and why people think that they are right, explain how your theory explains the known facts better than the accepted theory, make certain that your theory doesn't negate any of the known facts, and be polite in doing so.
Last edited: