The explosive racial question Osaka asked Japan

I was simply stating that on balance white Western countries are the most accommodating and least racist / xenophobic in the world.

"On balance" needs a metric to avoid being anything other than an opinion you pulled out of your butt.
 
"On balance" needs a metric to avoid being anything other than an opinion you pulled out of your butt.

Human rights. The first thing I said. Would you like me to Google it for you or would you prefer to pull something out of your own butt?
 
Being considered an "outsider" isn't always simple racism. Isn't it difficult for even "white" immigrants and visitors to become assimilated into certain "white" Western cultures such as in Norway? I've also heard similar things about Switzerland. Hey, it took me 25 years to be fully adopted by the locals as a "true" citizen of my small USA college town.

Yep. Just try being a Tennessean moving to Maine or vice versa.

I moved from another region of the state to Nashville over 30 years ago and am still not considered a true resident of the city by some of my acquaintances. My accent is wrong.
 
I've heard that only white people can be racist but I have never heard someone say that this trait is linked to the 'white gene'

White jeans were popular in the 90s where I lived. I heard they're making a comeback, could that be what MAGA means? Restoration of pre-grunge 90s fashions? They still make K-Swiss shoes! We can do this!
 
Only the far left believe that whites and whites alone are racist. White people are, IMO, the least racist group on the planet, by a considerable margin.

...so which race do you think is the most racist?
 
Any documentation for those ideas?

That White people are the least racist people on the planet? It's pretty obvious if you look around. f White people were racist, why do so many non-Whites want to live among us? Hordes of Africans are desperate to get into Europe while Central Americans and Mexicans riot at the border trying to get into the United States. If they experienced endless microaggressions and were marginalized by a society steeped in institutionalized and systemic racism, wouldn't they go home? Or at least warn their families not to join them?

Either White people aren't racist or the opportunity to serve the White man by doing the jobs we won't do and paying the pensions for our aging population is enough of an incentive for PoC to overlook any bigotry and prejudice and discrimination they might suffer.
 
That White people are the least racist people on the planet? It's pretty obvious if you look around. f White people were racist, why do so many non-Whites want to live among us? Hordes of Africans are desperate to get into Europe while Central Americans and Mexicans riot at the border trying to get into the United States. If they experienced endless microaggressions and were marginalized by a society steeped in institutionalized and systemic racism, wouldn't they go home? Or at least warn their families not to join them?

Either White people aren't racist or the opportunity to serve the White man by doing the jobs we won't do and paying the pensions for our aging population is enough of an incentive for PoC to overlook any bigotry and prejudice and discrimination they might suffer.


Because American culture is NOT the same thing as 'white culture'. Whites are one part of American culture, which other peoples have just as much claim to.

Racism and racial divisions are, unsurprisingly, astonishingly moronic ways to divide cultures.
 
Only the far left believe that whites and whites alone are racist. White people are, IMO, the least racist group on the planet, by a considerable margin.

Do I really. You know what I'm going to ask now. Just one post, in your own time.

Here. You used them to mean the same thing. The group is a racial group.

So what race do you think is the most racist if whites are the least?
 
Here. You used them to mean the same thing. The group is a racial group.

A group is a group, not a race. If I had meant race I would have written 'race'. I made a clear distinction and went on to explain how I had not defined the groups 'white' and 'non-white', those groups had been specified for me.

So what race do you think is the most racist if whites are the least?

Do you mean what group?
 
A group is a group, not a race. If I had meant race I would have written 'race'. I made a clear distinction and went on to explain how I had not defined the groups 'white' and 'non-white', those groups had been specified for me.



Do you mean what group?


Yeah, I know what you said, and I'm pointing out how silly it is. You explaining how it was even more silly than that doesn't actually detract from my point.

You decide to divide into the groups 'white' and 'non-white', which makes your original assertion even more pointless.

So what racial group is most racist to you? You've said it can't be 'whites', so I'm left assuming you mean 'non-whites are the most racist group on the planet'.

You really do mean to say that non-whites are the most racist group on the planet, correct? I mean, you say you've thought this through, and that's what your words mean by necessity, so you do intend to communicate that?
 
Yeah, I know what you said, and I'm pointing out how silly it is. You explaining how it was even more silly than that doesn't actually detract from my point.

You decide to divide into the groups 'white' and 'non-white', which makes your original assertion even more pointless.

I've explained three times now that I made no such division. The far left makes that distinction. not me, and routinely talks in terms of whites and non-whites. We are told about the racism of whites and the victim status of non-whites. I am using their terminology.

So what racial group is most racist to you? You've said it can't be 'whites', so I'm left assuming you mean 'non-whites are the most racist group on the planet'.

You really do mean to say that non-whites are the most racist group on the planet, correct? I mean, you say you've thought this through, and that's what your words mean by necessity, so you do intend to communicate that?

Let's talk this through. We have two groups, white and non-white. I maintain that whites are the least racist group, and you are asking me what is the most racist group? Are you kidding me?
 
What's even being argued here?

Which of following two statements is incorrect?

1. On an individual level prejudice by one person against another person for any manner of reasons, including racial, can absolutely be a thing and to suggest otherwise is insane. To claim individual members of a particular group are incapable of prejudice or racism is laughable.

2. When a dominant group (even if the grouping is arbitrary or pointless) in a society has a tipping point, which isn't an exact science by any means, of members who discriminate against another group that form of racism can be particularly dangerous and hard to combat because of the size and influence of the groups in questions.

Both of those are true and neither of them contradict each other. What's the mystery?

Other than the annoying habit of "Woke" people to use "Racism" when they mean "Institutional Racism" (or similar) which... yeah I wish they wouldn't do that but whatever... what's up for debate?
 
What's even being argued here?

Which of following two statements is incorrect?

1. On an individual level prejudice by one person against another person for any manner of reasons, including racial, can absolutely be a thing and to suggest otherwise is insane. To claim individual members of a particular group are incapable of prejudice or racism is laughable.

2. When a dominant group (even if the grouping is arbitrary or pointless) in a society has a tipping point, which isn't an exact science by any means, of members who discriminate against another group that form of racism can be particularly dangerous and hard to combat because of the size and influence of the groups in questions.

Both of those are true and neither of them contradict each other. What's the mystery?

Other than the annoying habit of "Woke" people to use "Racism" when they mean "Institutional Racism" (or similar) which... yeah I wish they wouldn't do that but whatever... what's up for debate?

The argument between baron and I revolves mostly along the lines of him using the existence and discussion of 2 to pretend that means excluding 1.

I too am against the 'power plus' definitions, but I don't pretend that talking about racism in the context of the US or western history where the racism of white people has and continues to have by far the largest impact is the same as the 'power plus' thing, and certainly isn't pretending that it's all about 'whites are the only racists'.

I also can't help but laugh at the 'the left is wrong for using these invalid divisions but also non-whites are worse' reasoning. Even if I agree that the 'power plus' definitions are unhelpful (to use understatement as I think they are actively harmful), and that some on the far left do pretend racism is only a 'white problem', that doesn't mean I'm going to agree with such laughable reasoning as 'non-whites are the real racists'.

As long as everyone else sees the problem with baron's reasoning, as no matter how he protests that is indeed inescapable in the reasoning he laid out, I'm fine leaving it be.
 
Seriously is "Japan is an extremely homogeneous society" and "The Japanese can be xenophobic dicks sometimes" really blowing anyone's mind? Is this really new information?

From 1931 to 1945 the Japanese were worse then Xenophobic Dicks;They went into full blown "Master Race" mode and tried to conquer and rule the inferior races, and eventually formed a partnership with Nazi Germany which was in the same mode. Of course, if the Axis had won the war, conflict between the Germans and their "Honorary Aryan" buddies would have been inevitable.
 
The argument between baron and I revolves mostly along the lines of him using the existence and discussion of 2 to pretend that means excluding 1.

I didn't know we'd had an argument, I've only restated what I originally posted. If you dispute the original groupings that's fine, I see them as moot at best, but my assertion is based on the premise that they exist. That being so, the 'white' group is on average less racist than the 'non-white' group, despite what we are told by the left, and that is supported by significant bodies of evidence.
 
From 1931 to 1945 the Japanese were worse then Xenophobic Dicks;They went into full blown "Master Race" mode and tried to conquer and rule the inferior races, and eventually formed a partnership with Nazi Germany which was in the same mode. Of course, if the Axis had won the war, conflict between the Germans and their "Honorary Aryan" buddies would have been inevitable.

"Japanese form alliance with Genocidal White Supremacists Death Empire in completely well thought out scheme that has zero chance to backfire" - The Onion: Our Crazy Century headline from WW2.

Alright in all fairness I have in the past raised an eyebrow over how, let's be 100% honest here, white guilt has caused us to give Imperial Japan more of a "We just won't bring it up if you won't" pass over say Nazi Germany or Stalinist Russia when.. not exactly any better guys. Unit 731 did stuff that would have made Menegele "Oy mate tone it down a notch will ya?" and yeah Imperial Japan had some pretty... icky ideas about racial purity.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom