The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Sol88! As promised ... a soon to be very lengthy 'discussion' of the Lisse et al (2006) paper!

<sipped for brevity>

Another Spitzer paper that Sol continually ignores is the following;

Investigation of dust and water ice in comet 9P/Tempel 1 from Spitzer observations of the Deep Impact event
Gicquel, A. et al.
https://www.aanda.org/articles/aa/full_html/2012/06/aa18718-11/aa18718-11.html

The total mass of dust is (0.7−1.2) × 105 kg for grain sizes 0.1−1 μm and (0.5−2.1) × 106 kg for sizes 0.1−100 μm. A sustained production of water is observed, which can be explained by the sublimation of pure ice grains with sizes less than 1 μm and comprising a mass of ice of (0.8−1.8) × 107 kg.
 
So, mostly PURE ice for comet Tempel 1?

:rolleyes:

Yes. And, as we know from other comets, the D/H ratio is very different from the solar wind value. Which is another reason to dismiss T & T's impossible mechanism for water production.
 
You make it sound like it was some ground breaking discovery that comet Tempel 1 was mostly ice?

It was seen in the pictures that there was ice everywhere, so meh.


So fluffy ice all the way down?

Ummm...that’s a dirtysnowball. And you said there not dirty snowballs.

Contradicting yourself much, champ?
 
Last edited:
You make it sound like it was some ground breaking discovery that comet Tempel 1 was mostly ice?

It was seen in the pictures that there was ice everywhere, so meh.


So fluffy ice all the way down?

Ummm...that’s a dirtysnowball. And you said there not dirty snowballs.

Contradicting yourself much, champ?

I'm not contradicting anything. You just haven't got a clue about comets, that is your problem. You do not understand the paper, you do not understand much of anything.
There was melted silicate ejecta and water vapour. That was from the upper layer. It was ejected in a low angle plume. There was cooler dust and ice ejected from deeper in the comet, ejected at a higher angle.
It is not rocket science, as anybody who has read and understood the papers would know. Comprehension does not seem to be one of your strong points.
 
But why would you have to run a projectile to confirm what you already new when there is abundant ice on the surface.

That would suggest comets are mostly ice!

In which the latest papers would seem to contradict your understanding of cometary nuclei!

You change cometary composition like I change undies!

EC in the other hand understand cometary nuclei are mostly rock...
 
But why would you have to run a projectile to confirm what you already new when there is abundant ice on the surface.

That would suggest comets are mostly ice!

In which the latest papers would seem to contradict your understanding of cometary nuclei!

You change cometary composition like I change undies!

EC in the other hand understand cometary nuclei are mostly rock...

What the hell are you talking about now? There cannot be much ice on the surface. It tends to sublimate. Therefore it has to be below the surface. Along with the dust. Hit it with a projectile, and you see the ice and dust excavated. Which part of that are you having trouble with?
And EC is 100% debunked. No rock, no discharges, plenty of ice and plenty of water vapour, along with other gases. Just because Thornhill lied to you about all that is no excuse for your ignorance.
 
Last edited:
What the hell are you talking about now? There cannot be much ice on the surface. It tends to sublimate. Therefore it has to be below the surface. Along with the dust. Hit it with a projectile, and you see the ice and dust excavated. Which part of that are you having trouble with?
And EC is 100% debunked. No rock, no discharges, plenty of ice and plenty of water vapour, along with other gases. Just because Thornhill lied to you about all that is no excuse for your ignorance.

There cannot be much ice on the surface. It tends to sublimate.

Comparison of Deep Impact and Stardust photos of a smooth elevated feature on the surface of the nucleus showing recession of icy cliffs at the margins.


Which is it?
 
<snip>

EC in the other hand understand cometary nuclei are mostly rock...
Curious.

I could have sworn that, quite recently, you said that comets are ROCK.

Maybe the EC is, now what’s the word, evolving? :D
 
Curious.

I could have sworn that, quite recently, you said that comets are ROCK

Maybe the EC is, now what’s the word, evolving? :D

This is the mainstreams understanding that comets are MOSTLY ROCK, as stated by Michael F. A’Hearn []To quote,
At the simplest level, a very basic question is whether comets are mostly ice or mostly rock/dirt/refractory material. Whipple’s [2] model of the dirty snowball, the first quantitative model, envisioned cometary nuclei as mostly ice, although our understanding has been evolving more toward mostly rock, particularly for 67P/C-G

No it hadn’t evolved, as it has always been rock.

You may have noticed jd116 just completely contradict himself. :D

How high do you reckon the icy cliffs of Tempel 1 are? We know just some 10’s of meters down there is nothing but PURE WATER ICE. These ICY cliffs are sublimating away leaving a layer of mostly DUST on the surface. so the dust was in the ice leaving a smooth plain of DUST on the surface?

How to you think it’s working?
 
Last edited:
What the hell are you on about? And what the hell has it got to do with the 100% debunked EC woo?

Didn’t think you could or would answer. Typical :rolleyes:

Because your statement
Dust, if you are talking about mass. Vacuum if you are talking about volume.[Jonesdave116 7/12/18]
my needed addressing again..,
 
Last edited:
This is the mainstreams understanding that comets are MOSTLY ROCK, as stated by Michael F. A’Hearn []To quote,

No it hadn’t evolved, as it has always been rock.

You may have noticed jd116 just completely contradict himself. :D

How high do you reckon the icy cliffs of Tempel 1 are? We know just some 10’s of meters down there is nothing but PURE WATER ICE. These ICY cliffs are sublimating away leaving a layer of mostly DUST on the surface. so the dust was in the ice leaving a smooth plain of DUST on the surface?

How to you think it’s working?

I have not contradicted anything, you clown. We saw cliffs collapsing (i.e. retreating) at 67P.
 
Didn’t think you could or would answer. Typical :rolleyes:

Because your statement my needed addressing again..,

No it does not need addressing. Dust, ice, with microporosity of ~ 75%. Nothing has contradicted that. It is only your piss poor understanding of the relevant science that puts you at a disadvantage. Which is not surprising in someone who thinks comets are rocks blasted off of planets by lightning bolts.
 
How high do you reckon the icy cliffs of Tempel 1 are? We know just some 10’s of meters down there is nothing but PURE WATER ICE.

LIAR.

I said;

Therefore it has to be below the surface. Along with the dust. Hit it with a projectile, and you see the ice and dust excavated. Which part of that are you having trouble with?

So quit lying about what I said when it is plain for all to see. I'm getting sick to death of the constant lying and obfuscation.
Here is a little summary for the hard of understanding;

On the surface there is mostly dust and organics. Ice is close to the surface along with dust. The surface layer is ~ 50% porous. Below that it is ~ 75% porous. As the near-surface ice sublimates, it travels every which way, not just 'upwards'. When the temperature drops below the sublimation temperature, that gas refreezes in the pores between the dust, cementing it into a harder layer than that below. As the ice that sublimates 'upwards' escapes, it takes dust with it. Therefore the surface is eroded, and ice that was beyond the depth at which the heat could penetrate to sublimate it is now within that range. And so it goes on.
As for cliffs, they are very weak, as described in the literature. They are also composed of dust and ice. They can collapse due to stresses from outgassing, and torque from the spin of the comet. When they collapse they leave a fresh, icy face. Not just ice, of course - plenty of dust as well, but the icier layer is exposed, as detected. They also dump icy boulders at their feet. These icy boulders are, by definition, in areas where they spend a lot of time in shadow, due to the cliff. They can therefore survive for quite some time. As observed.

All of the above is in the literature. Why haven't you read it? Because it falsifies your religion? Or just didn't understand it?
 
Last edited:
Oh, we playing that game...ok then

LIAR LIAR LIAR pants on fire. :p

What you actually said, just a few posts back was...
Originally Posted by jonesdave116
What the hell are you talking about now? There cannot be much ice on the surface. It tends to sublimate. Therefore it has to be below the surface. Along with the dust. Hit it with a projectile, and you see the ice and dust excavated. Which part of that are you having trouble with?

To which you replied to my question on the structure of a mainstream Dirtysnowball comet with...
I have not contradicted anything, you clown. We saw cliffs collapsing (i.e. retreating) at 67P.
icy cliffs still there after 6 years...

So again, drop kick, mostly ice or mostly dust? I.e what are the “icy” cliffs resting on? Mostly dust or mostly ice....or mostly vacuum or rock but not real rock, but ice and dust?

Absolutely hilarious, you’ve painted yourself into a corner.
 
Last edited:
It’s a moot point anyway, as the dust is charged the ions have already decoupled from the neutral gas and the whole shebang is being accelerated of the nucleus and down the tail by the AMBIPOLAR ELECTRIC FIELD! :D

Could be made out of cream cheese as long as it has an electric field.
 
<snip>

No it hadn’t evolved, as it has always been rock.

<snip>
ROCK ... mostly rock ... rock ... I can’t keep up with all the twists and turns of the EC ...

Maybe I should look at something simpler, like a radial electric field centered on the Sun ... that will make all ROCK/mostly rock/rock/whatever bodies which orbit the Sun in elliptical orbits comets, complete with comas, tails, etc, right?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom