Indagator
Scholar
- Joined
- May 2, 2018
- Messages
- 112
Apologies for the delay! I was unable to escape a previous social commitment. And then there's work!
Sol88! As promised ... a soon to be very lengthy 'discussion' of the Lisse et al (2006) paper!
Referring to Lisse et al - 2006 - Spitzer Spectral Observations of the Deep Impact Ejecta
PART 1 of MANY ...!
I note that you only quote the Abstract of the referenced paper and offer no 'electric comet' thoughts of your own. Any reason you wish to avoid discussing the 'electric comet' implications of a mainstream paper, written by mainstream scientists, in support of mainstream science?
Sol88, you do know what is about to happen, don't you?
I wonder if you, the resident 'ec' expert, could tell me why you think the bolded text is not worthy of discussion? You see, Sol88, I intend to discuss every aspect of this paper, and there is precious little you can do to stop me! So, ...
The first sentence provides basic information on the telescope employed to gather the spectral emission data. I've recently provided a link to the Spitzer Heritage Archive! In general, can we trust the data acquired by Spitzer? Specifically, can we trust the Spitzer data acquired on the day of the Deep Impact experiment? Do you always blindly accept everything you read? Or are you simply guided by a religious agenda? Given the IRS instrument's range, what molecular species' emission signatures are we going to miss below 5.2 micrometers? And above 38.0 micrometers? Should we be concerned that we cannot access the 1.5, 2.0, and 3.0 micrometer features in the ejecta? And why are those three data points important? What are the 'big picture' implications for your 'electric comet' model when using Spitzer data? How does instrument selection modify our understanding of an event such as the Deep Impact experiment? Tough questions! As the IRS instrument will be part of our discussion, I suggest you read ...
Werner et al - 2004 - The Spitzer Space Telescope Mission and
Houck et al - 2004 - The Infrared Spectrograph (IRS) on the Spitzer Space Telescope
FYI - It turns out, that at the time of writing, three of 17 authors were affiliated with the Spitzer Space Science Center at the California Institute of Technology. Does that fact make the results more, or less reliable according to 'eu/es/ec' doctrine? In other words, which mainstream scientists are trustworthy and which should be ignored? Your answer to that question will ultimately destroy your religion!
What does all this bolded text mean? Why do you think it is not important to you and your 'electric comet' model? You'll recall from my previous post that statistics is one of the tools used by scientists. Why is this important to our discussion of a mainstream paper? Scientists assume that the basic laws that govern physics and chemistry are everywhere, consistent. Of course, we are also aware that some of these laws will 'bend' as we approach relativistic regimes! Fortunately, we are not concerned with relativistic effects in this paper! So, what's my point? Assuming consistency, here, there, and everywhere, scientists seek statistical correlation! For example, ...
The ejecta spectra from the Deep Impact experiment is consistent with material observed being emitted by comet C/1995 O1 (Hale-Bopp)!
The ejecta spectra from the Deep Impact experiment is consistent with that observed in circumstellar material around the young stellar object HD100546!
Furthermore, the atomic abundance of observed ejecta material from the Deep Impact experiment is consistent with solar and C1 chondritic abundances!
And why is a dust-to-gas ratio ... greater than or equal to 1.3 important? This last question is worthy of a 20-page research paper all by itself! Are you at all interested in mainstream modelling and simulation experiments? No? We'll get back to this ratio in another post!
Now, Sol88, why would you want to ignore the fact that this mainstream paper presents 'evidence' (i.e., correlation, albeit weak given a small sample size of only three data points) that comets 9P/Tempel 1 and C/1995 O1 (Hale-Bopp) accreted in a protosolar nebula, much like the observed young stellar object HD100546?
Sounds to me like A'Hearn and Lisse are on the same page regarding the formation history of comets, even though these papers are separated by eleven years! Now, what is the probability, Sol88, that YOU are wrong about Dr. A'Hearn's understanding of what comets are really made of?
And we've just barely scratched the surface of the Abstract! Can you imagine sitting through one of my lectures? EXCITING!
What I would really like to do, Sol88, is discuss this paper in a civil manner! I have asked you a number of important questions that require your 'electric comet' expertise! If you're serious about this, and you take the red pill, ... I'll "show you how deep the rabbit hole goes. Remember ... all I'm offering is the truth. Nothing more."
Because we are discussing Lisse et al (2006), it seems appropriate that we also include a little A'Hearn (2017) in the mix! Are you OK with that?
FYI - I will post ASSIGNMENT #002 and ASSIGNMENT #003 in short order. I will also provide some feedback on your answers to ASSIGNMENT #001 -- I wish I had more time to spend on the ISF, but unlike some here, I still need to earn a living!
Let’s go in chronological order.
Spitzer
Spitzer Space Telescope imaging spectrometer observations of comet 9P/Tempel 1 during the Deep Impact encounter returned detailed, highly structured, 5- to 35-micrometer spectra of the ejecta. Emission signatures due to amorphous and crystalline silicates, amorphous carbon, carbonates, phyllosilicates, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, water gas and ice, and sulfides were found. Good agreement is seen between the ejecta spectra and the material emitted from comet C/1995 O1 (Hale-Bopp) and the circumstellar material around the young stellar object HD100546. The atomic abundance of the observed material is consistent with solar and C1 chondritic abundances, and the dust-to-gas ratio was determined to be greater than or equal to 1.3. The presence of the observed mix of materials requires efficient methods of annealing amorphous silicates and mixing of high- and low-temperature phases over large distances in the early protosolar nebula.
How do the assembled “experts” here on the thread, reconcile the bolded texts?
Sol88! As promised ... a soon to be very lengthy 'discussion' of the Lisse et al (2006) paper!
Referring to Lisse et al - 2006 - Spitzer Spectral Observations of the Deep Impact Ejecta
PART 1 of MANY ...!
I note that you only quote the Abstract of the referenced paper and offer no 'electric comet' thoughts of your own. Any reason you wish to avoid discussing the 'electric comet' implications of a mainstream paper, written by mainstream scientists, in support of mainstream science?
Sol88, you do know what is about to happen, don't you?
Lisse et al (2006) said:Spitzer Space Telescope imaging spectrometer observations of comet 9P/Tempel 1 during the Deep Impact encounter returned detailed, highly structured, 5- to 35-micrometer spectra of the ejecta. Emission signatures due to amorphous and crystalline silicates, amorphous carbon, carbonates, phyllosilicates, polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons, water gas and ice, and sulfides were found. Good agreement is seen between the ejecta spectra and the material emitted from comet C/1995 O1 (Hale-Bopp) and the circumstellar material around the young stellar object HD100546. The atomic abundance of the observed material is consistent with solar and C1 chondritic abundances, and the dust-to-gas ratio was determined to be greater than or equal to 1.3. The presence of the observed mix of materials requires efficient methods of annealing amorphous silicates and mixing of high- and low-temperature phases over large distances in the early protosolar nebula.
I wonder if you, the resident 'ec' expert, could tell me why you think the bolded text is not worthy of discussion? You see, Sol88, I intend to discuss every aspect of this paper, and there is precious little you can do to stop me! So, ...
The first sentence provides basic information on the telescope employed to gather the spectral emission data. I've recently provided a link to the Spitzer Heritage Archive! In general, can we trust the data acquired by Spitzer? Specifically, can we trust the Spitzer data acquired on the day of the Deep Impact experiment? Do you always blindly accept everything you read? Or are you simply guided by a religious agenda? Given the IRS instrument's range, what molecular species' emission signatures are we going to miss below 5.2 micrometers? And above 38.0 micrometers? Should we be concerned that we cannot access the 1.5, 2.0, and 3.0 micrometer features in the ejecta? And why are those three data points important? What are the 'big picture' implications for your 'electric comet' model when using Spitzer data? How does instrument selection modify our understanding of an event such as the Deep Impact experiment? Tough questions! As the IRS instrument will be part of our discussion, I suggest you read ...
Werner et al - 2004 - The Spitzer Space Telescope Mission and
Houck et al - 2004 - The Infrared Spectrograph (IRS) on the Spitzer Space Telescope
FYI - It turns out, that at the time of writing, three of 17 authors were affiliated with the Spitzer Space Science Center at the California Institute of Technology. Does that fact make the results more, or less reliable according to 'eu/es/ec' doctrine? In other words, which mainstream scientists are trustworthy and which should be ignored? Your answer to that question will ultimately destroy your religion!
Lisse et al (2006) said:Good agreement is seen between the ejecta spectra and the material emitted from comet C/1995 O1 (Hale-Bopp) and the circumstellar material around the young stellar object HD100546. The atomic abundance of the observed material is consistent with solar and C1 chondritic abundances, and the dust-to-gas ratio was determined to be greater than or equal to 1.3.
What does all this bolded text mean? Why do you think it is not important to you and your 'electric comet' model? You'll recall from my previous post that statistics is one of the tools used by scientists. Why is this important to our discussion of a mainstream paper? Scientists assume that the basic laws that govern physics and chemistry are everywhere, consistent. Of course, we are also aware that some of these laws will 'bend' as we approach relativistic regimes! Fortunately, we are not concerned with relativistic effects in this paper! So, what's my point? Assuming consistency, here, there, and everywhere, scientists seek statistical correlation! For example, ...
The ejecta spectra from the Deep Impact experiment is consistent with material observed being emitted by comet C/1995 O1 (Hale-Bopp)!
The ejecta spectra from the Deep Impact experiment is consistent with that observed in circumstellar material around the young stellar object HD100546!
Furthermore, the atomic abundance of observed ejecta material from the Deep Impact experiment is consistent with solar and C1 chondritic abundances!
And why is a dust-to-gas ratio ... greater than or equal to 1.3 important? This last question is worthy of a 20-page research paper all by itself! Are you at all interested in mainstream modelling and simulation experiments? No? We'll get back to this ratio in another post!
Now, Sol88, why would you want to ignore the fact that this mainstream paper presents 'evidence' (i.e., correlation, albeit weak given a small sample size of only three data points) that comets 9P/Tempel 1 and C/1995 O1 (Hale-Bopp) accreted in a protosolar nebula, much like the observed young stellar object HD100546?
Lisse et al (2006) said:The presence of the observed mix of materials requires efficient methods of annealing amorphous silicates and mixing of high- and low-temperature phases over large distances in the early protosolar nebula.
A'Hearn (2017) - Comets: Looking Ahead said:(a) Where did comets form?
Comets certainly formed in the protosolar nebula, or more specifically in the protoplanetary disc around the Sun or proto-Sun and they almost certainly formed primarily by accretion of solids rather than gases or liquids. But did they form close to the Sun or far from the Sun? Did they form primarily in the thin mid-plane of the disc or over a range of heights above and below the mid-plane? Did they incorporate pre-solar solids that survived from the interstellar medium?
Sounds to me like A'Hearn and Lisse are on the same page regarding the formation history of comets, even though these papers are separated by eleven years! Now, what is the probability, Sol88, that YOU are wrong about Dr. A'Hearn's understanding of what comets are really made of?
And we've just barely scratched the surface of the Abstract! Can you imagine sitting through one of my lectures? EXCITING!
What I would really like to do, Sol88, is discuss this paper in a civil manner! I have asked you a number of important questions that require your 'electric comet' expertise! If you're serious about this, and you take the red pill, ... I'll "show you how deep the rabbit hole goes. Remember ... all I'm offering is the truth. Nothing more."
Because we are discussing Lisse et al (2006), it seems appropriate that we also include a little A'Hearn (2017) in the mix! Are you OK with that?
FYI - I will post ASSIGNMENT #002 and ASSIGNMENT #003 in short order. I will also provide some feedback on your answers to ASSIGNMENT #001 -- I wish I had more time to spend on the ISF, but unlike some here, I still need to earn a living!
Last edited: