The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Nope, no rock ever detected at a comet. If you believe otherwise, then point to the detection in the scientific literature. Otherwise, QUIT LYING.

Then why would M.A'Hearn say our understanding is evolving toward MOSTLY ROCK with some ice?

Why would he not say CONFIRMED comets are MOSTLY ICE and some dust?

and why would Marco Fulle say there is only a minor mass component from ice?

He's left you in a very difficult spot!
 
Last edited:
The ELECTRIC FIELD much more efficient!

in case you did'nt catch jd116 link to the paper Surface localization of gas sources on comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko based on DFMS/COPS data

The "outgassing" is not uniform over the surface as EXPECTED from an MOSTLY ICY nucleus.

This "outgassing" can not "hold back" the solar "wind". Good explanation for the kiddies dinosaurs though.

And another LIE.. You can't help yourself, can you? I guess that when your idiotic beliefs have been totally debunked, LYING is all you've got left. Sad. And pathetic.



 
Then why would M.A'Hearn say our understanding is evolving toward MOSTLY ROCK with some ice?

I have no idea. He was obviously referring to dust. There is no rock at comets. Not a single detection ever. If there was, you could point to that detection. You can't, because it doesn't exist. Your continued failure to point to any detection proves that you are just playing around with words from a scientist who has since died, and is in no position to defend what he said, or meant. Which is cowardly, but typical.

And who gives a toss what the mass fraction of ice is? Your idiotic high priests said it wasn't there! So, you were wrong, weren't you? You said there would be rock. You were wrong, weren't you? You said there would be electric discharges (lol). You were wrong, weren't you?
So, what are you still doing here? Because you were wrong. Weren't you?
 
Why the hell would I? This is a bunch of clowns modelling something that is scientifically impossible, and will never see the light of day in the scientific literature. Complete waste of time. Hint; we already know what powers the Sun.

Ok then.
 
Either A’Hearn was evolving or he was deluded, which one?

How many bloody times do I need to say this; there is no rock at a comet. Point to the detection if you disagree.
Quit with the LYING and OBFUSCATION. Go through the literature, and find this non-existent rock, or shut the hell up about it.
 
Sorry if A’Hearn’s statement about science advancing evolving upsets you so much.

I’m not lying, this is what he said.
 
Last edited:
Comets are rocky objects and mainstream sciences understanding is slowly for some at least, evolving toward comets being mostly rock.

Marco Fulle is also of this opinion.
 
Last edited:
Comets are rocky objects and mainstream sciences understanding is slowly for some at least, evolving toward comets being mostly rock.

Nope, no rock has ever been detected at a comet. Prove me wrong. Show the detection, or STFU.
 
Sorry if A’Hearn’s statement about science advancing evolving upsets you so much.

I’m not lying, this is what he said.

Yes, you are LYING. He referenced his claim by linking to two papers. Go read them, and find the rock. He was talking about dust. He was talking to an audience of intelligent people who know that comets are not rock, as opposed to a bunch of semi-evolved Velikovskian fruitloops that think comets are literally rock. I've shown you a paper that post-dates that one, on which he was a co-author, and it is bloody obvious that they are not describing rock. There is no rock at comets. Full stop.
 
Deep Impact Was a Dust-up, Not a Gusher

Results are still coming in, but so far the scientists report seeing only weak emission from water vapor and a host of other gases that were expected to erupt from the impact site.

It's pretty clear that this event did not produce a gusher," said SWAS principal investigator Gary Melnick

"The more optimistic predictions for water output from the impact haven't materialized, at least not yet."

Both the head and tail consist of gases and dust ejected from the comet's nucleus - a frozen chunk of rock and ice about half the size of Manhattan Island.

Five decades ago, Harvard astronomer Fred Whipple developed a model of comet nuclei as "dirty snowballs." He hypothesized that comets consist of mostly ice with some dirt and rock mixed in.
MOSTLY ROCK or MOSTLY ICE jd116?

SMA astronomers saw little increase in production of gases following the impact. Gas production rates remained so low that they could set only an upper limit on the total.

All we needed was a factor of three boost from the impact to get a definite detection," said Qi. "We didn't see that."

Theories about the volatile layers below the surface of short-period comets are going to have to be revised," Qi said.

Revised to what exactly?


So you think Astronomers are confused on what dust, ice, gas and rock are?
 
Last edited:
Revised to what exactly?


So you think Astronomers are confused?

Back to OBFUSCATING again, yes?

Those Tempel 1 quotes are from press releases immediately after the impact. I have already linked to papers showing how much ice and vapour was released in that impact, so you can quit with this crap.
 
Last edited:
Most striking is that the comet is not made up of very much at all. "It's mostly empty," said Prof A'Hearn. The fine particles of dust and ice are held together extremely loosely, with pores thought to run throughout. "We have deduced that around 75% to 80% of the nucleus is empty and that tells me there is probably no solid nucleus. That is a significant advance in our understanding," said Prof A'Hearn.

The finding overturns the view held by some scientists that comets were hard balls of solid dust and ice. "The outer several tens of metres of the cometary material is extremely fragile," said Prof A'Hearn whose study is published online by Science Express today.
Deep Impact space collision reveals comets to be fluffy balls of powder

Nope looks like A'Hearn‘s understanding was evolving.
 
Nope looks like A'Hearn‘s understanding was evolving.

Nope, see the paper I linked that you refuse to deal with. The strength of that material is extremely low. As A'Hearn, being a co-author, knew.
 
A large dust/ice ratio in the nucleus of comet 9P/Tempel 1.

The corresponding dust/ice mass ratio is probably larger than one, suggesting that comets are 'icy dirtballs' rather than 'dirty snowballs' as commonly believed. High dust velocities (between 110 m s(-1) and 300 m s(-1)) imply acceleration in the comet's coma, probably by water molecules sublimated by solar radiation. We did not find evidence of enhanced activity of 9P/Tempel 1 in the days after the impact, suggesting that in general impacts of meteoroids are not the cause of cometary outbursts.

Yup evolving...

Oh and that snookers one of the mechanism that you invoke for active main belt comets (asteroids - ROCK)

Leaves you with just spin up!

Should we keep going?

They found squat in the way of ice.

You make it sound like it was triumphant moment when it was a huge disappointment as it was not as expected from the mainstream model of cometary nuclei.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom