The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Nope they did empirical science! :D

and it's been VERY fruitful!

No they didn't. Scott is a clueless clown, who has fusion going on in the chromosphere! Lol. Think we might have noticed that. For the hard of thinking (i.e. Scott & Sol), that would bathe the planet in lethal gamma radiation! Only an idiot would propose such a thing, and only an idiot would believe it.
 
So, it may happen? There could be coupling to other, larger, current systems as well?

Could any of this electric curcuit containing empirically testable both on earth and in space plasma, have plasma structures we are not 100% sure of?

This is a pubic forum, we can do a dash of speculation. :thumbsup:

Seems like just such a teaser. :eye-poppi

Who cares? It has nothing to do with the total failure of the electric comet woo.
 
What it actual said was the SAFIRE team, doing repeatable empirical roll ya sleeves up hands on science has been EXTREMELY fruitful for SAFIRE and VERY fruitful for the EU-ES-EC

Nope, they have been pissing about sticking a squillion volts through a metallic sphere. Who gives a damn? It has nothing to do with the Sun or any other sort of astrophysics, and will never be published in any sort of decent journal. They are wasting time and money.
 
So, it may happen? There could be coupling to other, larger, current systems as well?

Why don't you come up with a description of whatever nonsense it is that you are proposing, and then it can be laughed at assessed?
What is the observed effect when comets, as they often must do, cross the heliospheric current sheet? Sod all, I would say. A change in the orientation of the magnetic field? Whooppee! Anything else?
 
A lying " it may happen?" question to derail from his electric comet insanity

So, it may happen?...
A lying " it may happen?" question to derail from his electric comet insanity.

tusenfem's post is clear. Circuit theory is not real electric currents or circuits. It is a model of plasma systems that needs knowledge about plasma physics that Sol88 and his cult are ignorant about. When Alfvén used circuit theory to model solar flares this was not real wires, resistors, inductors or double layers on the ~5700 K surface of the Sun :eye-poppi!
 
SAFIRE insanity in addition to his electric comet insanity

What it actual said was the SAFIRE team, doing repeatable empirical roll ya sleeves up hands on science has been EXTREMELY fruitful for SAFIRE and VERY fruitful for the EU-ES-EC
SAFIRE insanity in addition to his electric comet insanity.

The SAFIRE team have been EXTREMELY successful in exposing the electric Sun insanity to the world and making "EU-ES-EC" even more obviously deluded. We have a web site that includes the insanity that the Sun is externally powered. We have an deluded to the point of insanity "model" of the Sun.
Sol88 cannot understand the SAFIRE insanity.
  • Astronomy 101: Hydrostatic equilibrium means an externally powered Sun collapses to a white dwarf as the Sun will do when it runs out of fuel for fusion.
  • The insanity of denying the evidence that the Sun is powered by fusion.
    Hydrostatic equilibrium + nuclear physics tells us that fusion would be happening in the core of the Sun. We detect the neutrinos from that fusion.
  • A lying and deluded "Genesis" page.
    The mainstream model has been "proven" because it works!
    A lie that the electric sun has been "250 years in the making". The electric sun is a decades old delusion.
  • A lying list of "electric sun pioneers" (Benjamin Franklin, Michael Faraday, James Clerk Maxwell, Sir William Crookes, Kristian Birkeland, Nikola Tesla, Irving Langmuir and Hannes Alfvén).
    They list the documented liar and deluded Wal Thornhill and the deluded Don Scott.
  • The idiocy of up to 6 years of work only being presented at crank conferences and in PDFs on their site.
    I suspect that a team of actual experimental plasma physicists would have completed the project in a couple of years and published several papers along the way.
  • The utter stupidity of "I see bunnies in the clouds" logic.
    The fact is that some features of plasma in a magnetic field in a plasma experiment will look similar to features of plasma in a magnetic field on the Sun.
 
Last edited:
No, it is how all the scientists studying it think it works. You haven't got a clue.

Gas sublimating off the nucleus holds back the solar wind, as you have said many time jd116.

and that was the thinking at the time for the mainstream, now it's the ELECTRIC FIELD doing the "work" not "gas".

This is from the charge separation of the quasi-neutral solar wind plasma around a charged rocky object. :D

You know, the..

Electric Comet
 
Usual lies to derail from his electric comet insanity

Gas sublimating off the nucleus holds back the solar wind, as you have said many time jd116.

and that was the thinking at the time for the mainstream, now it's the ELECTRIC FIELD doing the "work" not "gas".
Usual lies to derail from his electric comet insanity.

jonesdave116 has been agreeing with the mainstream science where gas sublimating off the nucleus holds back the solar wind. This is basic physics. That is what is observed. A cloud of gas called a comet coma shields the nucleus from a flow of gas called the solar wind.

That is not the cause of a diamagnetic cavity which is all of the interactions of the plasma of the solar wind with plasma of the coma, including "ion-neutral friction".
The formation of magnetic cavities in comets (1992)
In this paper a unidimensional model for the formation of magnetic cavities in comets is presented. This model includes ion-neutral friction, dissociative recombination, photoionization, and thermal and energetic ion
pressure coupled with a nonconstant velocity profile which was chosen to simulate the flow pattern. The model explains the thermal ion population profile. Conditions under which a cavity may not form are discussed.
In the paper the roles of the various processes are studied, and it is shown that focusing on ion-neutral friction as the major process in the creation of the cavity is not in general correct. In the last part of the
paper, the limitations of the model are delineated.

ETA: Ice sublimating off the nucleus is not his electric comet insanity which includes the stupidity of EDM magically converting actual rock into gases.
 
Last edited:
No they didn't. Scott is a clueless clown, who has fusion going on in the chromosphere! Lol. Think we might have noticed that. For the hard of thinking (i.e. Scott & Sol), that would bathe the planet in lethal gamma radiation! Only an idiot would propose such a thing, and only an idiot would believe it.

Did you happen to watch the video?


28:20 Is the money shot! ;)
 
Usual lies to derail from his electric comet insanity.

jonesdave116 has been agreeing with the mainstream science where gas sublimating off the nucleus holds back the solar wind. This is basic physics. That is what is observed. A cloud of gas called a comet coma shields the nucleus from a flow of gas called the solar wind.

That is not the cause of a diamagnetic cavity which is all of the interactions of the plasma of the solar wind with plasma of the coma, including "ion-neutral friction".
The formation of magnetic cavities in comets (1992)

The ELECTRIC FIELD much more efficient!

in case you did'nt catch jd116 link to the paper Surface localization of gas sources on comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko based on DFMS/COPS data

The "outgassing" is not uniform over the surface as EXPECTED from an MOSTLY ICY nucleus.

This "outgassing" can not "hold back" the solar "wind". Good explanation for the kiddies dinosaurs though.
 
Usual lies to derail from his electric comet insanity.

jonesdave116 has been agreeing with the mainstream science where gas sublimating off the nucleus holds back the solar wind. This is basic physics. That is what is observed. A cloud of gas called a comet coma shields the nucleus from a flow of gas called the solar wind.

That is not the cause of a diamagnetic cavity which is all of the interactions of the plasma of the solar wind with plasma of the coma, including "ion-neutral friction".
The formation of magnetic cavities in comets (1992)


ETA: Ice sublimating off the nucleus is not his electric comet insanity which includes the stupidity of EDM magically converting actual rock into gases.

All these years and still completely clueless clutching at straws!


The strong localized surface electric fields lectricaly stress the ROCK until it suffers coulomb explosions on a atomic level that dissociates SANDSTONE, LIMESTONE and PHYLLOSILICATES into DUST (refractory dust) and ionised H20, CO2 and CO, H-, O2 along with your ZOO of organics!

No majick involved except for the ignorant!


or
 
Thanks.

So let me see if I understand correctly.

By “Electric Comet Model” you mean that “comets are rocks discharging in the solar plasma”.

And, to be quite clear, you do NOT mean the Thornhill & Talbott idea of comets being blasted off the Earth in historical times, displaying tails etc due to the Sun’s radial electric fields, jets due to EDM, etc.

If so, then you yourself have posted lots of material that is inconsistent with your own idea (I cannot, in good conscience, call it a “model”).

For example, estimates of the bulk density of at least some comets is consistent with them being “mostly space” (i.e. comets are very porous), and certainly not the ROCK of your idea.

Second, your attempts to provide any details about “discharging in the solar plasma” have shown that you have an exceedingly poor grasp of the relevant physics; in fact, what you have posted on this is, without a doubt, no more than cherry picking words that you think bolster your case.

If you are not just trolling, why is it that you never (as far as I can tell) even try to dig into the details? Why, for example, have you never (apparently) taken tusenfem’s advice and at least tried to understand some very basic plasma physics?

So what shall we do sweetie?

Not much I can do until it's excepted that electricity "does stuff" in space.

I'd put my money on LINDKVIST'S new paper.

have you read it?

on another note, do you agree or disagree with M.A'Hearn statement that cometary nuclei are MOSTLY ROCK?

If disagree, why?
 
Last edited:
I don’t know whether to thank you or curse you, RC! :p

That CQ thread is ... really depressing, or hilariously funny, or ... but at least it confirms that Sol88 (a.k.a. Starboy)’s primary (or sole?) rationale for his “Electric Comet Theory” is false dichotomy (“mainstream is WRONG, THEREFORE the EC MUST be right!”)!

Thank you jt!

Question for you what is the mainstream cometary model? Do you know or just here for the occasional drive by trolling?


Because A'Hearn knew what the mainstream model was. One would assume you are quite happy, safe and satisfied this is correct except for a few minor details.

Like asking very basic questions like
At the simplest level, a very basic question is whether comets are mostly ice or mostly rock/dirt/refractory material
:D
 
Last edited:
Like how much ice it contains, for instance or how the jets work.

:D

This thread is about the long debunked electric comet woo. How about telling us the EU take on how much ice there is, or what the jets are? And, in doing so, point to the evidence that proves it?
 
The strong localized surface electric fields lectricaly stress the ROCK until it suffers coulomb explosions on a atomic level that dissociates SANDSTONE, LIMESTONE and PHYLLOSILICATES into DUST (refractory dust) and ionised H20, CO2 and CO, H-, O2 along with your ZOO of organics!

No majick involved except for the ignorant!

Hahahahahaha! Fairy story, with zero science to back it up, and not a jot of evidence. Stop making crap up.
 
Gas sublimating off the nucleus holds back the solar wind, as you have said many time jd116.

and that was the thinking at the time for the mainstream, now it's the ELECTRIC FIELD doing the "work" not "gas".

This is from the charge separation of the quasi-neutral solar wind plasma around a charged rocky object. :D

You know, the..

Electric Comet

Nope. That is another lie. Just point to the literature where this is claimed as the cause of the DC.
 
Did you happen to watch the video?


28:20 Is the money shot! ;)

Nope, I'm not watching a video from a bunch of clueless clowns. I need only look at Scott's ignorant website to see that he is one of those clueless clowns.
 
on another note, do you agree or disagree with M.A'Hearn statement that cometary nuclei are MOSTLY ROCK?

If disagree, why?

Nope, no rock ever detected at a comet. If you believe otherwise, then point to the detection in the scientific literature. Otherwise, QUIT LYING.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom