The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Gas light era physics again champ.

Where are the electric field measurements?

What plasma/electric field instruments do Hayabusa and OSIRIS-REx carry?

Of which instrument do they carry can we measure the properties of the plasma surrounding the asteroids they are probing.

Again, I rest my case.

Asteroids and comets are a continuum they are ALL ROCK.

Asteroids are KNOWN to be MOSTLY ROCK but comets were thought to be MOSLTY ICE.

Our understanding has been evolving away from MOSTLY ROCK.

I didn't say it, someone far more knowledgeable than me on comets did... ;)

Wrong. Trivially. No rock ever detected at a comet. I'm still waiting for the paper announcing the discovery. Where is it? What type of rock was it? Lying is all you have left, as science appears to be well beyond you.
 
Comet nuclei and D-type asteroids have several similarities at optical and near-IR wavelengths, including near-featureless red reflectance spectra, and low albedos

Reflectance spectroscopy of comet nuclei has revealed spectral similarities akin to certain asteroid taxonomic classes (Tholen 1984, Bus andBinzel 2002, DeMeo et al. 2009). Classification in these taxonomy schemes is typically based on principal component analysis of color photometry or spec-tra, including tests for the presence or absence of certain spectral features and consideration of overall spectral slope. There are approximately two dozen classes and sub-classes of asteroids. The spectra of some cometary nuclei resemble those asteroid classes with red-sloped reflectance spectra lacking strong spectral features

Mid-infrared spectra of comet nuclei

Very similar rock, asteroids and comets.

(c) What are comets made of? At the simplest level, a very basic question is whether comets are mostly ice or mostly rock/dirt/refractory material. Whipple’s [2] model of the dirty snowball, the first quantitative model, envisioned cometary nuclei as mostly ice, although our understanding has been evolving more toward mostly rock, particularly for 67P/C-G for which refractory/volatile ratios as high as 6 have been cited [3,4].

:D

plenty of paper stating similar. In the Mid-infrared spectra asteroid and comets are the same! The only thing you have against comets being rocks is the RSI data.

Anywhoo believe whatever you like I'm not going to change your mind. I have more than enough patience to wait.
 
Last edited:
So stupid. I guess it takes a massive ignorance of science to believe the garbage that you do. In fact, it would seem to be a prerequisite.

sorry much more believable;
Volcanic eruptions on these asteroids released tremendous amounts of heat into the space around them. Any smaller objects passing by during an eruption would experience a short, intense blast of heat.

how much heat into space? just enough it seems! :rolleyes:

As long as you believe that, i have not hope.

:rolleyes:
 
Mid-infrared spectra of comet nuclei

Very similar rock, asteroids and comets.



:D

plenty of paper stating similar. In the Mid-infrared spectra asteroid and comets are the same! The only thing you have against comets being rocks is the RSI data.

Anywhoo believe whatever you like I'm not going to change your mind. I have more than enough patience to wait.

There is no rock. Never detected at a comet. If it were, you would be able to tell us what paper it is in, and what type of rock it was. The RSI data are just one undeniable piece of data that shows it not to be rock. There is the thermal inertia of the material. Not rock-like. There is the strength of the material from MUPUS' hammering. Not rock-like. There is a dirty great hole in Tempel 1 from an impact. Not rock-like. There are boulders on the surface that have fallen from cliffs. They have ice in them. Not rock-like. There is the strength of the material calculated from overhangs. Not rock-like.
That is plenty of evidence for it not being rock. And there is not a single piece of evidence saying that it is rock. Therefore, you failed.
 
Last edited:
:thumbsup:


Summary from jonesdave116.

Cheers champ. :rolleyes:


Ice boulder from ice cliffs...classic :D

Along with your MUPUS assertion, I’d say you’d better off handing your shovel over, cob.
 
Last edited:
There is no rock. Never detected at a comet. If it were, you would be able to tell us what paper it is in, and what type of rock it was. The RSI data are just one undeniable piece of data that shows it not to be rock. There is the thermal inertia of the material. Not rock-like. There is the strength of the material from MUPUS' hammering. Not rock-like. There is a dirty great hole in Tempel 1 from an impact. Not rock-like. There are boulders on the surface that have fallen from cliffs. They have ice in them. Not rock-like. There is the strength of the material calculated from overhangs. Not rock-like.
That is plenty of evidence for it not being rock. And there is not a single piece of evidence saying that it is rock. Therefore, you failed.

The tell-tale clue to how meteorites were made, at the birth of the solar system

As the chondrules melt into little spheres, they will release gas to the matrix, which traps those elements as the meteorite hardens. If chondrules and chondrites form together in this manner, we expect the matrix to be enhanced in exactly the same elements that the chondrules are depleted.

The matrix?

Formed inside an electric arc is far more plausible than passing close to a volcano for just the right amount of time.

Who boy, jonesdave116. Next you’ll be telling me the Easter bunny’s real!

And

Have the MATH to prove it!

:rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
:thumbsup:


Summary from jonesdave116.

Cheers champ. :rolleyes:


Ice boulder from ice cliffs...classic :D

Along with your MUPUS assertion, I’d say you’d better off handing your shovel over, cob.

I am making no assertions. I am telling you what is scientifically proven within the scientific literature. You have zero science. Only a religion.
 
Not just any astronomer, the preeminent COMETARY astronomer. :D


Reckon he’d be all over it, after all our understanding has been evolving.

Well, he is dead now, so who is now the preeminent COMETARY astronomer? Maybe you could get him to confirm it?



Do you know what evolving means?

Yes, it means that A'Hearn is not the only one thinking this. So where are the others?
 
The usual lies, delusions, insults, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years

The usual insane lies, delusions, insults, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years.

Sol88's usual insanity that a ices and dust comets paper is about asteroid or Sol88's electric comet insanity.

Sol88's usual insanity of lies about what he cites. The paper does not say that comets are asteroids because astronomers are not insanely ignorant or deluded. The paper is on similarities between the spectra from minstrels on comets and asteroids as expected from a common origin in the early solar system :jaw-dropp
 
The usual lies, delusions, insults, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years

[The only thing you have against comets being rocks is the RSI data.

The usual insane lies, delusions, insults, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years.

Sol88's usual insane lies. The RSI data measured the mass of 1 comet (67P). We have many other comet density measurements. We measured the mass of 67P before the Rosetta mission :eye-poppi! Its strange shape made the volume we assigned and so the density of 67P invalid. So we applied a between value fro the volume. The RSI data gave us a double-check on the mass and density.

Sol88's usual insane lies. Comet 67P is not the only comet that exists :jaw-dropp! We have measured the density of many comets using several methods as Sol88 ha s been told again and again and again over the last 10 years.
 
Last edited:
The usual lies, delusions, insults, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years

The usual insane lies, delusions, insults, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years.

Sol88's usual insane lies. That is a quote from a physics article about mainstream science with the simple physical fact that hot bodies in space will have volcanic eruptions.

Sol88 is touting insane delusions that no one with a sane, knowledgeable mind believes in and writes that basic physics is unbelievable :jaw-dropp!
 
How would that even work?
This is just Sol88's usual stupidity of making up ignorant delusions to mimic his cult's deluded prophets. Sol88 has no idea how any physics works.

From memory, he may have accidently brought up an alternative mainstream mechanism for making chondrules. The early solar system would have lots of turbulent dust. There is a possibility of friction between dust grains charging then up. There could be lightning with its brief high temperatures and that could create chondrules.
The tell-tale clue to how meteorites were made, at the birth of the solar system is a theory that volcanic eruptions (not Sol88's lie of volcanoes) would release heat in bursts that will melt grains and so make chondrules.
Our idea is quite simple. Radioactive dating of hundreds of chondrules shows that they formed between 1.8 and 4 million years after the beginning of the solar system—some 4.6 billion years ago. During this time, fully molten asteroids, the parent bodies of the iron meteorites, were abundant. Volcanic eruptions on these asteroids released tremendous amounts of heat into the space around them. Any smaller objects passing by during an eruption would experience a short, intense blast of heat.

Sol88's lies include that this is just math (which his electric comet insanity has not been able to do for over 45 years!) - they did experiments to see if the theory was feasible ("Out came a nice-looking synthetic chondrule. Case closed? Not so fast."). Their extended model makes predictions that match the existing data. It predicts that meteorites will be full of chondrules and gets that right. It predicts that chondrules will be less abundant in asteroids. So they have a testable, falsifiable prediction for the sample return missions that we expect back in a few years.

But in Sol88's demented world, that never happened because his cult's insane obsession has stellar systems made via plasma pinches - where it is impossible to have his new delusion of "electric arcs" (plasma conducts!).
 
Last edited:
This is just Sol88's usual stupidity of making up ignorant delusions to mimic his cult's deluded prophets. Sol88 has no idea how any physics works.

From memory, he may have accidently brought up an alternative mainstream mechanism for making chondrules. The early solar system would have lots of turbulent dust. There is a possibility of friction between dust grains charging then up. There could be lightning with its brief high temperatures and that could create chondrules.

But in Sol88's demented world, that never happened because his cult's insane obsession has stellar systems made via plasma pinches - where it is impossible to have his new delusion of "electric arcs" (plasma conducts!).

Lightning is plasma in arc mode.

Thanks you rc
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom