Indagator
Scholar
- Joined
- May 2, 2018
- Messages
- 112
Sol88!
My plan was to provide an ASSIGNMENT update in two PARTS before moving on to ASSIGNMENT #005 : Forces Acting on Rosetta during the RSI Experiment - Calculations Based on Real Cited DATA! And then you spew this, ...
Everything about this post is downright LAUGHABLE, Sol88!!! Unless, of course, this is further evidence of a traumatic brain injury! If that's the case, I extend my deepest and most sincere apologies and condolences for your loss!
Let's take a minute to dissect this putrid cadaver, shall we? I would like you and all the lurkers to note that you have never answered any of my simple plasma physics questions from ASSIGNMENT #004! Two of those questions are dead easy! The answers to one of those questions is required if WE are going to discuss DOUBLE LAYERS! Don't you want to discuss DOUBLE LAYERS in Deca et al (2017)?
Are you a plasma numpty, Sol88?
Are you a plasma ignoramus?
Do you know the difference between "electric field strength" and a "potential difference?"
Can you tell me what the solar wind Debye length is from the Deca et al (2017) simulation, Sol88?
Why are you afraid to explore the plasma physics of your 'electric comet' model?
Why are you afraid to look through the telescope, Sol88?
How can you spot a plasma numpty, Sol88?
Are you a plasma numpty?
Let's look at each line ...
That statement is completely WRONG! Of course, there's charge separation! The question has never been, "Is there charge separation, Sol88?" The question has ALWAYS been, "What causes charge separation?" You see, science is about precision! Science is about observation! A plasma, being an ionized GAS, already has separated charges! The problem, for you Sol88, is what mechanisms can cause charges to separate enough to violate quasi-neutrality? And then, how are these separated charges important to your religion? Read on ....
What do you know of electric currents, Sol88? EVERYONE knows you play clueless about plasmas! What about electric currents in plasmas? What about electric currents in space? What about electric currents, in general?
What is SWEAP, Sol88?
Where is SWEAP being used?
Why is SWEAP mainstream science?
How will the 'electric star' make use of SWEAP data when it is released to the scientific community?
Describe in detail, what YOU see in this SOLAR DYNAMICS OBSERVATORY (SDO) "telescope" image, Sol88! What are those crazy lines, Sol88? Can you use them to map electric currents on the sun? Describe the electric currents responsible for this ever changing image (check back every hour, or so, to see how the magnetic field evolves and changes)!
What's fascinating about this image, Sol88, is that it cannot be explained or modeled by 'electric star' proponents! Furthermore, SDO and SWEAP observations will never, ever be duplicated by SAFIRE, as SAFIRE is the farthest thing from empirical science! Just sayin! In my opinion, SAFIRE is nothing more than a bunch of grown men, wasting valuable resources, playing with a child's toy! Hee! Hee! Any thoughts?
I'll ask again, in case you've forgotten (short-term memory is adversely affected by brain trauma, which might explain the last thirteen years) ...
Are you a plasma numpty, Sol88?
Are you a plasma ignoramus?
Do you know the difference between "electric field strength" and a "potential difference," Sol88?
Can you tell me what the solar wind Debye length is from the Deca et al (2017) "mathematical" simulation?
Why are you afraid to explore the plasma physics of your 'electric comet?'
Why are you afraid to look through the telescope?
How can I spot a plasma numpty, Sol88?
Are you a plasma numpty?
You know, Sol88, as relates to this thread, I ultimately don't care what jonesdave116, Reality Check, or anyone else on the ISF has to say! I don't care what Alfven may, or may NOT have said (e.g., Alfven said the Sun would operate on alternating current! TRUE STORY! AND crazy WRONG)! As a scientist, all I really care about is what the physics has to say!
Again, the question is not, "Are there any electric fields in space, Sol88?" The real question is, "Are the electric fields in space capable of doing the MAGIC that the 'electric comet' model demands?"
The answer to that is a deafening, NO! Read on ...
Again, is this evidence of a traumatic brain injury? My condolences. First, the man's name is Deca, just one c! Second, the entire simulation run by Deca et al was built around the Whipple model! Are you now claiming that you accept the Whipple model? Have you ever read Whipple (1950)? Would you like to answer a few questions about Whipple (1950), Sol88?
According to Deca et al (2017), what conditions were required to produce the published results you seem to think support your religion? A "frozen-in" magnetic field? Check! Water production consistent with that measured by the MIRO instrument? Check! Anything else, Sol88? ASSIGNMENT #003, perhaps?
And to reiterate (I'm so sorry for your loss), there are NO mainstream papers that support your religion, Sol88! NONE! Would you like to discuss Lisse et al (2006)? Would you like to discuss Lisse et al (2007)? Would you like to discuss Deca et al (2017)? Are there any other papers you'd like me to dissect on behalf of your 'electric comet' religion? PICK ONE!
[size=+1]WRONG! WRONG! WRONG! AND PATHETIC![/size]
My heart goes out to you, Sol88! I cannot imagine the struggles! First, the quoted value from Laakso (1991) is 135 kV! Your error is quite significant! Second, a potential "difference" is measured between two points! Anyone with knowledge of plasma physics knows that! The problem is, the number you cited is meaningless if you don't take into account the distance between the two points! In the case of comet Halley, that potential difference is spread out over 7000 km! It's right there in the text! That means that the "electric field strength" is ...
135000 V / 7000000 m = 0.019 V/m! That's some electric field you've got there, Sol88! Just to put things in perspective, "Coulomb explosions" (another FAILURE of comprehension on your part) require "electric field strengths" on the order of 1010 V/m!!! Does that even register with you, Sol88? Twelve orders of magnitude?
Restated! Comet Halley --- EHalley = 0.019 V/m vs. Coulomb explosion --- ECEx = 10000000000 V/m! We're talking thermonuclear here! REALLY! Thermonuclear weapons involve Coulomb explosions! And lots of shrapnel! Do we find temperatures at comets consistent with thermonuclear explosions, Sol88? NO! What was the maximum temperature recorded at 67P? Would you like me to go into more detail on Coulomb explosions? 'Tis a fascinating subject! Would you like to discuss the other electric fields measured at Halley? They're even smaller!
That's for sure! The 'electric comet' is hilarious! The 'electric star' is a laugh riot! And the 'electric universe' is stupidly funny! And I do emphasis STUPID! NO science! NO math! NO model! NO evidence! Just BAD fiction!
Are the "electric fields" in your 'ec' model strong enough to move mountains, Sol88? What mechanisms are involved in "separating charges" at a comet (HINT: one of them involves the ionization of sublimated volatile ices)? Are any of these mechanisms available at asteroids? What are the differences between active comets, inactive comets, dormant comets, extinct comets, and asteroids? Describe in detail the "electric currents" found operating at comets! Be specific when discussing current densities! Define "a nucleus composed of consolidated dust?" What physical and chemical processes are involved in making DUST "consolidated?" Could ices be involved? Holy Doodle! This is painful!!!
And ...? Are you going to finish that sentence? "All we need for an 'electric comet' is ...." WHAT? So far, NO science! NO math! NO model! NO evidence! What kind of "electric field strengths" are at play in your 'electric comet' religion? I need NUMBERS here!
Oh, the hypocrisy, Sol88! This is all so obvious and horribly sad! Your 'electric comet' is physically IMPOSSIBLE!
Remember, Sol88 (apologies again for the brain thing), Deca et al (2017) used "icy dirt balls," not the "Dirtysnowball" you keep mentioning! Why is that fact so difficult for you to grasp? SORRY! SORRY! My bad!
Post Script! According to Deca et al (2017), Whipple is still an important part of the mainstream comet model, and apparently yours as well! According to Deca et al (2017), "frozen-in" magnetic fields are REQUIRED for charge separation! According to Deca et al (2017), significant amounts of sublimated water are REQUIRED for charge separation! Would you like to talk? Or are you going to ignore all the obvious holes I've punched in your religion? I'll wager you'll "IGNORE!" RELIGION is hard to give up, Sol88! Uncomplicated comfort! NO thought required!
My plan was to provide an ASSIGNMENT update in two PARTS before moving on to ASSIGNMENT #005 : Forces Acting on Rosetta during the RSI Experiment - Calculations Based on Real Cited DATA! And then you spew this, ...
Not really, remember charge seperation can not happen.
Like your myopic view of electric currents.
Plasma numpties have trouble with the basics.
are there any electric fields in space, jonesdave116?
Decca’s paper was a boon for the Electric comet, along with all the following papers confirming electric fields and currents at comets.
145kv potential drop at P1 Halley should have been a warning, but alas mainstream still trying to smash a round peg into square hole.
Hilarious.
Anywhoo, happy to have electric fields, charge separation, electric currents, charged dust (complex plasma) and a nucleus composed of consolidated dust.
All we need for an ELECTRIC COMET.
I’d say that’s looking pretty good, not so for a sublimating Dirtysnowball!
Everything about this post is downright LAUGHABLE, Sol88!!! Unless, of course, this is further evidence of a traumatic brain injury! If that's the case, I extend my deepest and most sincere apologies and condolences for your loss!
Let's take a minute to dissect this putrid cadaver, shall we? I would like you and all the lurkers to note that you have never answered any of my simple plasma physics questions from ASSIGNMENT #004! Two of those questions are dead easy! The answers to one of those questions is required if WE are going to discuss DOUBLE LAYERS! Don't you want to discuss DOUBLE LAYERS in Deca et al (2017)?
Plasma numpties have trouble with the basics.
Are you a plasma numpty, Sol88?
Are you a plasma ignoramus?
Do you know the difference between "electric field strength" and a "potential difference?"
Can you tell me what the solar wind Debye length is from the Deca et al (2017) simulation, Sol88?
Why are you afraid to explore the plasma physics of your 'electric comet' model?
Why are you afraid to look through the telescope, Sol88?
How can you spot a plasma numpty, Sol88?
Are you a plasma numpty?
Let's look at each line ...
Not really, remember charge seperation can not happen.
That statement is completely WRONG! Of course, there's charge separation! The question has never been, "Is there charge separation, Sol88?" The question has ALWAYS been, "What causes charge separation?" You see, science is about precision! Science is about observation! A plasma, being an ionized GAS, already has separated charges! The problem, for you Sol88, is what mechanisms can cause charges to separate enough to violate quasi-neutrality? And then, how are these separated charges important to your religion? Read on ....
Like your myopic view of electric currents.
What do you know of electric currents, Sol88? EVERYONE knows you play clueless about plasmas! What about electric currents in plasmas? What about electric currents in space? What about electric currents, in general?
What is SWEAP, Sol88?
Where is SWEAP being used?
Why is SWEAP mainstream science?
How will the 'electric star' make use of SWEAP data when it is released to the scientific community?
Describe in detail, what YOU see in this SOLAR DYNAMICS OBSERVATORY (SDO) "telescope" image, Sol88! What are those crazy lines, Sol88? Can you use them to map electric currents on the sun? Describe the electric currents responsible for this ever changing image (check back every hour, or so, to see how the magnetic field evolves and changes)!
What's fascinating about this image, Sol88, is that it cannot be explained or modeled by 'electric star' proponents! Furthermore, SDO and SWEAP observations will never, ever be duplicated by SAFIRE, as SAFIRE is the farthest thing from empirical science! Just sayin! In my opinion, SAFIRE is nothing more than a bunch of grown men, wasting valuable resources, playing with a child's toy! Hee! Hee! Any thoughts?
Plasma numpties have trouble with the basics.
I'll ask again, in case you've forgotten (short-term memory is adversely affected by brain trauma, which might explain the last thirteen years) ...
Are you a plasma numpty, Sol88?
Are you a plasma ignoramus?
Do you know the difference between "electric field strength" and a "potential difference," Sol88?
Can you tell me what the solar wind Debye length is from the Deca et al (2017) "mathematical" simulation?
Why are you afraid to explore the plasma physics of your 'electric comet?'
Why are you afraid to look through the telescope?
How can I spot a plasma numpty, Sol88?
Are you a plasma numpty?
are there any electric fields in space, jonesdave116?
You know, Sol88, as relates to this thread, I ultimately don't care what jonesdave116, Reality Check, or anyone else on the ISF has to say! I don't care what Alfven may, or may NOT have said (e.g., Alfven said the Sun would operate on alternating current! TRUE STORY! AND crazy WRONG)! As a scientist, all I really care about is what the physics has to say!
Again, the question is not, "Are there any electric fields in space, Sol88?" The real question is, "Are the electric fields in space capable of doing the MAGIC that the 'electric comet' model demands?"
The answer to that is a deafening, NO! Read on ...
Decca’s paper was a boon for the Electric comet, along with all the following papers confirming electric fields and currents at comets.
Again, is this evidence of a traumatic brain injury? My condolences. First, the man's name is Deca, just one c! Second, the entire simulation run by Deca et al was built around the Whipple model! Are you now claiming that you accept the Whipple model? Have you ever read Whipple (1950)? Would you like to answer a few questions about Whipple (1950), Sol88?
Deca et al (2017) said:Cometary nuclei are small, irregularly shaped "icy dirt balls" left over from the dawn of our Solar System 4.6 billion years ago and are composed of a mixture of ices, refractory materials, and large organic molecules. When a comet is sufficiently close to the Sun, the sublimation of ice leads to an outgassing atmosphere and the formation of a coma, and a dust and plasma tail.
According to Deca et al (2017), what conditions were required to produce the published results you seem to think support your religion? A "frozen-in" magnetic field? Check! Water production consistent with that measured by the MIRO instrument? Check! Anything else, Sol88? ASSIGNMENT #003, perhaps?
And to reiterate (I'm so sorry for your loss), there are NO mainstream papers that support your religion, Sol88! NONE! Would you like to discuss Lisse et al (2006)? Would you like to discuss Lisse et al (2007)? Would you like to discuss Deca et al (2017)? Are there any other papers you'd like me to dissect on behalf of your 'electric comet' religion? PICK ONE!
145kv potential drop at P1 Halley should have been a warning, but alas mainstream still trying to smash a round peg into square hole.
[size=+1]WRONG! WRONG! WRONG! AND PATHETIC![/size]
My heart goes out to you, Sol88! I cannot imagine the struggles! First, the quoted value from Laakso (1991) is 135 kV! Your error is quite significant! Second, a potential "difference" is measured between two points! Anyone with knowledge of plasma physics knows that! The problem is, the number you cited is meaningless if you don't take into account the distance between the two points! In the case of comet Halley, that potential difference is spread out over 7000 km! It's right there in the text! That means that the "electric field strength" is ...
135000 V / 7000000 m = 0.019 V/m! That's some electric field you've got there, Sol88! Just to put things in perspective, "Coulomb explosions" (another FAILURE of comprehension on your part) require "electric field strengths" on the order of 1010 V/m!!! Does that even register with you, Sol88? Twelve orders of magnitude?
Restated! Comet Halley --- EHalley = 0.019 V/m vs. Coulomb explosion --- ECEx = 10000000000 V/m! We're talking thermonuclear here! REALLY! Thermonuclear weapons involve Coulomb explosions! And lots of shrapnel! Do we find temperatures at comets consistent with thermonuclear explosions, Sol88? NO! What was the maximum temperature recorded at 67P? Would you like me to go into more detail on Coulomb explosions? 'Tis a fascinating subject! Would you like to discuss the other electric fields measured at Halley? They're even smaller!
Hilarious.
That's for sure! The 'electric comet' is hilarious! The 'electric star' is a laugh riot! And the 'electric universe' is stupidly funny! And I do emphasis STUPID! NO science! NO math! NO model! NO evidence! Just BAD fiction!
Anywhoo, happy to have electric fields, charge separation, electric currents, charged dust (complex plasma) and a nucleus composed of consolidated dust.
Are the "electric fields" in your 'ec' model strong enough to move mountains, Sol88? What mechanisms are involved in "separating charges" at a comet (HINT: one of them involves the ionization of sublimated volatile ices)? Are any of these mechanisms available at asteroids? What are the differences between active comets, inactive comets, dormant comets, extinct comets, and asteroids? Describe in detail the "electric currents" found operating at comets! Be specific when discussing current densities! Define "a nucleus composed of consolidated dust?" What physical and chemical processes are involved in making DUST "consolidated?" Could ices be involved? Holy Doodle! This is painful!!!
All we need for an ELECTRIC COMET.
And ...? Are you going to finish that sentence? "All we need for an 'electric comet' is ...." WHAT? So far, NO science! NO math! NO model! NO evidence! What kind of "electric field strengths" are at play in your 'electric comet' religion? I need NUMBERS here!
I’d say that’s looking pretty good, not so for a sublimating Dirtysnowball!
Oh, the hypocrisy, Sol88! This is all so obvious and horribly sad! Your 'electric comet' is physically IMPOSSIBLE!
Remember, Sol88 (apologies again for the brain thing), Deca et al (2017) used "icy dirt balls," not the "Dirtysnowball" you keep mentioning! Why is that fact so difficult for you to grasp? SORRY! SORRY! My bad!
Post Script! According to Deca et al (2017), Whipple is still an important part of the mainstream comet model, and apparently yours as well! According to Deca et al (2017), "frozen-in" magnetic fields are REQUIRED for charge separation! According to Deca et al (2017), significant amounts of sublimated water are REQUIRED for charge separation! Would you like to talk? Or are you going to ignore all the obvious holes I've punched in your religion? I'll wager you'll "IGNORE!" RELIGION is hard to give up, Sol88! Uncomplicated comfort! NO thought required!
Last edited:
).
!