The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Everything ok Indy?

Please discuss with me just one paper.

This one. Electron and Ion Dynamics of the Solar Wind Interaction with a Weakly Outgassing Comet DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.118.205101

You up to narrow the scope to just this one paper?

What we are going to talk about is charge seperation and quasi neutrality.

Why would he need to discuss a subject with a complete layman with no understanding of the subject? Do yourself a favour - grow a pair, and email the lead author of the paper with your idiotic assertions.
 
Why would he need to discuss a subject with a complete layman with no understanding of the subject? Do yourself a favour - grow a pair, and email the lead author of the paper with your idiotic assertions.


Because your clueless

Specifically
Quote:
Haha. How is this 'plasma potential' arising in the quasi-neutral solar wind?
from jonesdave116.


You asked!

Charge separation.
 
No, I was not shown to be wrong. You were. You know nothing about the subject. As a real plasma physicist kept telling you. Learn the subject before prattling on endlessly about it.


But you just posted Specifically

Haha. How is this 'plasma potential' arising in the quasi-neutral solar wind?.


Cometary electrons eventually end up neutralizing the solar wind protons, and solar wind electrons eventually neutralize the cometary ions.
jan Decca.

Keep going champ.
 
Because your clueless




You asked!

Charge separation.

What has charge separation got to do with your failed woo? You need EDM (lol), not charge separation. You need electric discharges (lol), not charge separation. You need rock, not charge separation. It is a complete irrelevance to the observed failure of your pathetic, unscientific woo.
 
Last edited:
You need charge seperation for your plasma potential difference.

Which creates an ambipolar field to maintain quasi-neutrality. So what? This is what the idiot Thornhill said;

The long-period comets spend a longer time in a region of lower plasma potential than the short-period comets. Consequently, their voltage difference on their approach to the Sun will be higher, leading to a brighter and more energetic discharge.

He is not talking about anything going on in the coma. He is assuming a non-existent radial electric field from the Sun, and a highly charged comet. Which leads to non-existent discharges. So, as I've said, this is a total irrelevance to the observed failure of your ridiculous woo. No discharges. And any minor charge separation is coming from interactions between the solar wind, and cometary ions and electrons. And where do those cometary ions and electrons come from? Cometary neutrals. And where do they come from? Ice. You have no mechanism to explain the cometary neutrals that lead to any charge separation.

Your woo is dead.
 
Last edited:
Which creates an ambipolar field to maintain quasi-neutrality. So what? This is what the idiot Thornhill said;



He is not talking about anything going on in the coma. He is assuming a non-existent radial electric field from the Sun, and a highly charged comet. Which leads to non-existent discharges. So, as I've said, this is a total irrelevance to the observed failure of your ridiculous woo. No discharges. And any minor charge separation is coming from interactions between the solar wind, and cometary ions and electrons. And where do those cometary ions and electrons come from? Cometary neutrals. And where do they come from? Ice. You have no mechanism to explain the cometary neutrals that lead to any charge separation.

Your woo is dead.


You do know about spacecraft charging in different plasma environments?

Same thing.

Comets are charged bodies...:D

Charge seperation causing electric fields and currents to form. Pretty basic stuff ‘ol mate.

You banging on about no mechanism, why?

There it is slapping you in the face.

Ice:rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
Yay, jd116 agrees there is charge separation at 67P.


Win :)

Now back to that special comet rock...
 
You do know about spacecraft charging in different plasma environments?

Same thing.

Comets are charged bodies...:D

Charge seperation causing electric fields and currents to form. Pretty basic stuff ‘ol mate.

You banging on about no mechanism, why?

There it is slapping you in the face.

Ice:rolleyes:

Complete crap. Comets are no more charged than asteroids. Why are asteroids not turning into comets? Dumb argument for which there is no mechanism and no evidence. As usual.
 
Yay, jd116 agrees there is charge separation at 67P.


Win :)

Now back to that special comet rock...

Nope, I said it has no relevance to your failed woo. And you have not shown why it is relevant. No EDM (lol), no discharges, no rock. No science, no mechanisms, no evidence. Your woo is dead. Where is the charge separation coming from? Explain.
 
You do know about spacecraft charging in different plasma environments?

Same thing.

Comets are charged bodies...:D

Charge seperation causing electric fields and currents to form. Pretty basic stuff ‘ol mate.

You banging on about no mechanism, why?

There it is slapping you in the face.

Ice:rolleyes:

What mechanism? Explain it in detail, and explain why the EDM (lol) is not seen. And the discharges are not seen. And the rock is not seen. And why ice is seen. And why gas is seen.
You are still batting zero after a decade and a half. Pretty pathetic, wouldn't you say? That is more time than it takes to get through high school, get a BSc degree, and then a masters or PhD! And here you are, still believing in impossible woo! Lol.
 
For the hard of thinking

There is no radial electric field from the Sun. There are no such regions of higher and lower 'plasma potential'. If the comet is not outgassing neutrals, as observed, there are no cometary ions and electrons. Therefore there is nothing to charge separate other than the solar wind. Given that we do see cometary neutrals, where does Sol think they are coming from? Mars?
If the comet is not outgassing, it is essentially an asteroid. Why are asteroids, particularly those on highly eccentric orbits, not glowing like a very glowy thing?
These are all questions Sol has ignored before, and will continue to ignore, as he has no explanation. And no science. And no mechanisms. And no evidence.
 
[size=+3]WOW![/size]

Sol88! This goes way beyond the absurd! I have NEVER seen such PATHETIC BEHAVIOUR in another human being!

My heart goes out to you, though! You seem to have suffered a traumatic brain injury which has stolen your ability to learn, comprehend, think, reason, communicate, or remember! My condolences for your loss!

Everything ok Indy?


PATHETIC!

First! The name is Indagator! You will address me as Indagator! You will not shorten my name! You will not corrupt my name! You have been told this! Why is this such a hard concept for you to grasp? You seem incapable of reading! You seem incapable of learning! And THANKS for asking! Everything is awesome in my world, except for this one ignorant, zealous troll that I'm trying to educate. Unfortunately, I may not be able to break through his RELIGIOUS myopia, regardless of my patience or optimism! This individual seems as dense as depleted Uranium! He can't seem to grasp the simplest of concepts like "frozen-in" magnetic fields (i.e., fundamental plasma physics) and that the sublimation of volatile ices is required for charge separation at comets! And you, Sol88? How's your world? Everything OK? Sincere questions!



WAY BEYOND PATHETIC!

Now you want to discuss Deca et al (2017)? A mainstream paper, written by mainstream scientists, in support of the mainstream comet model? The model first proposed by Whipple in 1950? The model that has been subsequently and continuously updated as our technical skills grow and our "vision" improves?

IF YOU REALLY WANT TO DISCUSS Deca et al (2017), START HERE --> ASSIGNMENT #003!

Because you seem incapable of following links, following instructions, reading, comprehending, communicating, learning, reasoning, or staying focused, here are those ASSIGNMENT #003 questions again! I WANT EVERYONE TO SEE WHAT YOU, Sol88 ARE SCARED OF! I WANT EVERYONE TO SEE WHAT YOU ARE RUNNING AWAY FROM! Real science ...

Just a few more questions then, Sol88, ...
  1. List ten (10) additional statements or concepts that are consistent with the mainstream comet model!
  2. List just two (2/0) statements or concepts that are consistent with your "electric comet" model!
  3. List just three (3/6) CHEATS that Deca et al (2017) used to generate the results obtained! OUCH!
  4. Describe in your own words what the Vlasov equation is!
  5. Describe in your own words what the Vlasov-Maxwell equations are!
  6. Describe in your own words how an implicit particle-in-cell code works!
  7. In a paragraph, describe the known instabilities inherent in implicit PIC codes!
  8. In a paragraph, describe the connection between Deca et al (2017) and MAGNETIC RECONNECTION!
  9. How many computational nodes are employed in the simulation (to four sig. figs. please)?
  10. How many SW proton/electron pairs are used to populate the computational domain (to four sig. figs.)?
  11. How long does it take for an unperturbed SW particle to cover the length of the computational domain?
  12. What cometary gas species is used in the simulation, and WHY?
  13. What is the initial temperature of the cometary gas species, and WHY is that important to the results?
  14. How does Deca et al introduce the cometary gas species into the computational domain?
Referring to Figure 1. in Deca et al (2017)
  1. Identify the four (4) panels that contain the "frozen-in" interplanetary magnetic field!
  2. Identify the four (4) panels that illustrate magnetic field draping as proposed by Alfven (1957).
  3. In which panel(s) do we find evidence of an ambipolar electric field? Explain in detail!
  4. What is the areal extent of the ambipolar electric field in three-dimensions?
  5. What is the electric field strength in this ambipolar region?
  6. Does the ambipolar electric field strength vary with time?
  7. What might cause the ambipolar electric field strength to change?
  8. Under what circumstances do ambipolar electric fields form?
  9. Under what circumstances do ambipolar electric fields dissipate?
In the past, Sol88, you've made the unsubstantiated claim that double layers will be found at comets! PROVE IT!
  1. Where do you "see" double layers mentioned in the text of Deca et al (2017)?
  2. In which panel(s) of Figure 1. do you find evidence for double layers? Explain in detail!
  3. Are hallucinogenic drugs required to "see" your double layers?
  4. Where are these double layers going to be found? The nucleus? Coma? Tail? BE SPECIFIC!
  5. How far from the nucleus will these double layers be found? Distance measurements are required!
  6. What is the areal extent of these double layers? Surface area measurements are required!
  7. How thick are these double layers? You know the drill! Give me a number!
  8. How transient are these double layers? How do you know? BE SPECIFIC!
  9. Under what circumstances do double layers form at comets?
  10. Under what circumstances do double layers dissipate at comets?
  11. What is the potential difference across these double layers? How do you know? BE SPECIFIC!
I can't wait to see what answers you come up with for all these questions! And guess what? There are hundreds more waiting in the wings! Show us what you've got 'ec' expert!

So, Sol88! Would you really like to discuss Deca et al (2017)? Would you really like to discuss Lisse et al (2006)? Would you really like to discuss A'Hearn et al (date TBD by your fine self (ref. ASSIGNMENT #002))? Or are you going to continue cowering in some dark corner hoping the scary Indagator goes away? And just to let you know, I can bring this kind of scientific and academic rigour to you and your religious fantasies all day long! There are NO mainstream papers that support your "electric" religion! NONE! Now, if you'd like, we can turn the discussion of the Vlasov-Maxwell equations into a full-year course! That would be fun, wouldn't it? Do you think you could pass one of my exams, Sol88?

I wonder, Sol88? Do you really want to discuss your 'electric comet' model? Are you open to the possibility that your 'electric comet' is physically IMPOSSIBLE? Or are you just trolling? Based on your posting history, I don't think you want to engage in any kind of real intellectual conversation. Am I wrong about you, Sol88? Perhaps you're nothing more than a missionary hoping to recruit for ThunderButts! How's that going?


When you've answered ALL my questions from ASSIGNMENT #003, you can then address these ...

A few simple questions, Sol88!
  1. According to Deca et al (2017), how much water was required to produce the simulated charge separation?
  2. According to Deca et al (2017), how much dust was required to produce the simulated charge separation?
  3. According to Deca et al (2017), what was the water temperature required to produce the simulated charge separation?
  4. According to Deca et al (2017), is the "frozen-in" magnetic field orthogonal to, or parallel to the solar wind flow?
  5. According to Deca et al (2017), why is the orientation of the "frozen-in" magnetic field important?
  6. According to Deca et al (2017), why is it important to know the ion and electron Larmor radii?
  7. According to Biver et al (2015), how much water did MIRO "observe" being emitted by 67P at 3.4 AU?
  8. According to Biver et al (2015), what was the "observed" physical distribution of the water being emitted?
  9. Is the amount of water used by Deca et al (2017) consistent with that "measured" by MIRO (ref. Biver et al (2015))?
  10. Regarding Q, please provide a detailed description of the Haser model and why it is still applicable when used correctly!


You do know, Sol88, that Deca et al built their ENTIRE simulation on the fact that comets are "icy dirt balls," accreted from volatile ices and dust in the protosolar nebula 4.6 billion years ago! These volatile ices sublimate when insolated producing the observed coma and tails! ARE YOU NOW CLAIMING YOUR 'electric comet' embraces the Whipple (1950) model? I call that progress!

Hey ISF community, by applying Deca et al (2017) to his 'electric comet,' Sol88, embraces and endorses the "icy dirt ball" model of comets! True FACT! Furthermore, Sol88's 'electric comet' now includes a "frozen-in" magnetic field!

Are you starting to understand how little you know about REAL plasma physics, Sol88?


You up to narrow the scope to just this one paper?


JUST ... PATHETIC!

NOPE! And neither are you! Just like a toddler, or a troll, you are unable to stay focused! But we can start there if you wish! I've literally thousands of ways to dismantle your model, and you've got NOTHING to counter with! ABSOLUTELY NOTHING! How are you doing on ASSIGNMENT #004, "plasma" expert? What a joke! Sol88, you are no "plasma" expert!!! You can't answer a single question from that ASSIGNMENT! Apparently, you can't answer any kind of scientific inquiry!

NO science! NO math! NO model! NO evidence! At least thirteen years you've wasted on this dead-end with NOTHING to show for it! ABSOLUTELY NOTHING!

What physical processes might be required to produce charge separation, Sol88? A "frozen-in" magnetic field? Significant quantities of water sublimated from volatile ices? Ionizing processes? Any clues, Sol88? What can you tell me about the Vlasov-Maxwell equations? What do they really tell us about charge separation? Still no clues?

What we are going to talk about is charge seperation and quasi neutrality.


PATHETIC! AND [size=+2]WRONG![/size]

NO! Sol88! We are going to discuss Deca et al (2017)! We are going to discuss Whipple (1950)! We are going to discuss "frozen-in" magnetic fields! We are going to discuss MAGNETIC RECONNECTION! We are going to discuss how your 'ec' MUST account for the observed outgassing (i.e., with respect to 67P, your model must contain (20 ± 8) per cent ICES by volume ... and NO ROCK, just DUST)!

Sol88! WAKE UP! This is your 'electric comet' thread! You are the only soul on this planet that wants to talk about your SCAM RELIGION! Start answering my questions! Questions that MUST be answered if you want to graduate from RELIGION to science! NOT going to happen, is it? Impossible task for a RELIGIOUS zealot to see the REAL WORLD! It's all just "ducks and bunnies" with you, and your ThunderButt buddies! Yes?

Answer my questions, Sol88! You are not in the driver's seat, here! You do NOT run this show! I DO! Your JOB is to PROVE your 'electric comet' actually works within the REAL WORLD! Something you constantly and consistently FAIL to do! Answer my questions! I have torn your 'ec' to shreds! You don't realize it, because you are blinded by your RELIGIOUS convictions and total lack of appropriate education! Answer my questions!

Answer MY questions, Sol88!

Is the 'electric comet' SCIENCE or nothing more than a PATHETIC SCAM RELIGION? Answer MY questions! Mainstream science needs your answers!

NO science! NO math! NO model! NO evidence! ONLY FEAR AND SILENCE!

TYPICAL!

Balls in your court, Sol88! If you are sincere about discussing Deca et al (2017), NOW is the time to start answering my questions! Questions that employ mainstream science, not the "head-up-your-ass" fantasies the 'eu/es/ec' whinge about! Remember, Sol88, there is NO science in your 'electric comet' model! If there were, I would be willing to bring my expertise to the game! Alas!

NO science! NO math! NO model! NO evidence!

What's your next move 'ec' AND 'plasma' expert? The internet is watching and laughing ....
 
Last edited:
Sol88! How's your heart?

According to Deca et al (2017), what is the Debye length for the simulated solar wind?

According to Deca et al (2017), how much water was required to produce the simulated charge separation?

According to Biver et al (2015), how much water did MIRO "observe" being emitted by 67P at 3.4 AU?

Let's discuss your 'electric comet' response to the following paper ...

Protopapa et al (2018) Icy Grains from the Nucleus of Comet C/2013 US10 (Catalina)

I'm intrigued to hear how your 'electric comet' accounts for water ice grains in the coma with only 1% refractory contamination! Would you like to talk about implications for dust-to-ice ratios? Would you like to talk about IR spectroscopy?

Enjoy!
 
Last edited:
Let's discuss your 'electric comet' response to the following paper ...

Protopapa et al (2018) Icy Grains from the Nucleus of Comet C/2013 US10 (Catalina)

I'm intrigued to hear how your 'electric comet' accounts for water ice grains in the coma with only 1% refractory contamination! Would you like to talk about implications for dust-to-ice ratios? Would you like to talk about IR spectroscopy?

Enjoy!

Ahh, been there, done that! Here is Sol's highly intelligent response to the paper;

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=12520091&postcount=888

So, do not expect anything even remotely scientific from Sol on that paper.

Of course, that is not the only observation of icy grains around a comet;

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=12682503&postcount=3477

Not to mention those around Tempel 1 after the impact. And in a jet at 67P as detected by ALICE. Etc.

snowstorm_strip.jpg


Ice around Hartley 2, or a disaster for the interplanetary arm of the Medellin cartel?
 
Last edited:
Think Protopapa has been sampling Medellin gear.

Seems 67P is a special comet in the mainstream books.

Paper is full of holes, assumptions and ad hoc fix’s to keep the Whipple model alive.

Like I said doesn’t pass the smell check.
 
Think Protopapa has been sampling Medellin gear.

Seems 67P is a special comet in the mainstream books.

Paper is full of holes, assumptions and ad hoc fix’s to keep the Whipple model alive.

Like I said doesn’t pass the smell check.

Total nonsense. You are neither sufficiently qualified, nor knowledgable enough to understand, let alone criticise the paper. If you believe otherwise, show us where she has gone wrong. I won't hold my breath.
 
Last edited:
Complete crap. Comets are no more charged than asteroids. Why are asteroids not turning into comets? Dumb argument for which there is no mechanism and no evidence. As usual.

usually the answer has been something dumb like 'cathode tube dark mode', never mind that there are hundreds of asteroids in the asteroid belt going through exactly the same space as the five the show comas
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom