The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Last edited:
Okay, so we have nothing, other than the poster written by T & T again....
There are also blatant and deluded lies from the authors as in the first quote.

You pointed out the obvious stupidity of an imaginary electric field accelerating the neutral gas and dust in a comet jet. That author is also lying about the electric comet insist which has a solar-centric (not comet nucleus-centric) electric field but jets accelerate away from the Sun :eek:!

He evokes an electromagnetic “pinch effect” that match jet densities but the EU idiots have not done any cometary calculations in the last 45 years or maybe ever :jaw-dropp!

A deluded lie of a mainstream "simple radial sublimation" mechanism for jets that cannot match jet densities by "many orders of magnitude". The mainstream has models for jets that match observed jets.

A probable deluded lie of "instabilities and fluctuations suddenly relocate jets in exceedingly short periods of time". We have only traced jets to specific sources on 67P in the last 3 years. I am not aware of papers tracking jets moving from one location to another.

ETA: For lurkers, this is the poster which starts with the ignorant fantasies and lies in the first paragraph.
Comets are debris produced during violent electrical interactions of planets and moons in an earlier phase of solar system history. Comets are similar to
asteroids, and their composition varies. Most comets should be homogeneous—their interiors will have the same composition as their surfaces. They are simply “asteroids on eccentric orbits.”
The "evidence" for the electric comet include our myths and we did not exist in that "earlier phase of solar system history".
The electric comet insanity has imaginary violent electrical interactions between planets such as Venus whizzing by Earth and exchanging lightning bolts.
Comets are 6 rimes less dense than asteroids. Comets have more ices than asteroids.
The evidence is that the surface of comets is different from their interior.
Actual insanity of "asteroids on eccentric orbits" when some asteroids have orbits as eccentric as comets.

Followed by making Sol88 a liar about the electric comet's electric field: "a weak electrical field centered on the Sun". T&T lie with "weak" when their delusions cannot know the strength of that imaginary electric field.

Total insanity of jets being "electric arc discharges to the nucleus". Jets are imaged from reflected sunlight, e.g. they vanish on the night side of comets :eek:! Discharges have unique signals which have never been detected.

Total insanity of EDM.

Insanity about about surface features which are not "scarring patterns of electric discharges".

etc. etc.
 
Last edited:
The usual lies, delusions, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years

The usual lies, delusions, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years.

Usual insane, irrelevant lies about mainstream cometary science. Especially after jonesdave116 cited just 3 minutes ago:
Suprathermal electrons near the nucleus of comet67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko at 3 AU: Model comparisons with Rosetta data
Madanian, H. et al. (2016)

And back in January 2019 :jaw-dropp!
Suprathermal electrons near the nucleus of comet 67P/Churyumov Gerasimenko at 3 AU: Model comparisons with Rosetta data
Madanian, H. et al.
https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdf/10.1002/2016JA022610
 
I see nothing from electric universe idiots. Please specify what was written and who wrote it.

EDIT:

Okay, so we have nothing, other than the poster written by T & T again. So, let's do another word search on 'field', and ignore the non-observed, impossible radial electric field of the Sun, which is failing to affect asteroids on highly elliptical orbits!

1) 

Really? Which matter in the jets is it accelerating? Neutrals, as observed? How is that happening? Large dust particles? How? Electrons and ions in the same direction? Where did these people go to school? The only putative field so far discussed is an ambipolar field, somewhere above the electron exobase. And that is proposed purely to explain the velocity of the ions, which are not coupled to the neutrals, as they were at Halley. This retards electrons, so cannot accelerate them, or anything else negatively charged. Next;

So how do you reconcile the observations, jd116?

The suprathermal electrons and ions all leaving the nucleus.
 
The usual lies, delusions, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years

The usual lies, delusions, etc. already addressed over the last 10 years.

An insane "suprathermal electrons and ions leave the nucleus" lie when jonesdave116 (and Sol88's demented thunderbolts colleague!) was writing about jets. There are only suprathermal electrons and they are far from the nucleus in the comet coma.
Cited months or maybe 3 years ago ago: Suprathermal electrons near the nucleus of comet67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko at 3 AU: Model comparisons with Rosetta data by Madanian, H. et al. (2016)
 
Last edited:
So how do you reconcile the observations, jd116?

The suprathermal electrons and ions all leaving the nucleus.

Can you not read? An ambipolar field is set up to RETARD electrons and ACCELERATE ions, to maintain quasi-neutrality.

The suprathermal electron distribution can have solar wind origin or can be produced by photoionization, or it can be accelerated inward through various processes such as ambipolar electric field.
 
So, let's do a word search in the Electric Comet woo poster by Thornhill & Talbott. 'Plasma' is what we'll look for, but only where they apply it to comets;

1)

Whoops, that would be the dust that is 'glowing'! Not a good start.

2) 
Whoops again! You can't see the plasma. Once again, for the hard of thinking, that is sunlight reflecting from dust and sometimes ice.

3) 

That's dust, dummies! How many times?

4) 
WTH is 'plasma voltage'? Where has it been measured? Why isn't it affecting asteroids on highly elliptical orbits? Another bunch of unscientific nonsense.

5) 

Been there, done that. No cathode jets. Lol. No visible plasma sheath. Repeat after me; it is sunlight reflecting off of dust. Write it out 1000 times until it penetrates what counts for the collective EU brain.

6)

Oh dear! No double layer. And what 'voltage difference'? There isn't one. And why is this not happening at asteroids? And what 'electrical stress'? What the hell does that even mean? This garbage was obviously written by non-scientists. And the sheath does not 'glow'. That is sunlight........................................... you get the picture!

7) 

No voltage difference of any note. You might get a healthy one at asteroids, but.......well, you know! And nothing is being accelerated to x-ray energies. We have known for some years that those x-rays are from charge exchange between solar wind heavy ions and cometary neutrals.

8) 

Lol. These people obviously don't know the sublimation temperature of CO2 and CO! And 67P copped at least one solar flare. Nothing much happened, flaring up wise.

9) 

Haha. How is this 'plasma potential' arising in the quasi-neutral solar wind?


Well, that is most of the crap. Not gone well, has it?

Dude, you’ve completely lost the plot.

the study are the following: (i) The ion-neutral decoupling distance,rin, when defined according to equation (6), is strongly dependent on the electric potential profile.

Such a scenario is unrealistic (if not dissociative recombination is very efficient) as it would cause a build-up of cold electrons incapable of escaping the potential barrier associated with the ambipolar field. This leads us to speculate on a periodically varying potential structure.
On the ion-neutral coupling in cometary comae

Electric potential....what electric potential (says jonesdave116).

I mean this
Haha. How is this 'plasma potential' arising in the quasi-neutral solar wind?

What a complete and utter numpty, jonesdave116.

That’s the end of your little game champ, good on ya.





Comets are electric phenomena. Thank you jonesdave116.
 
Last edited:
Dude, you’ve completely lost the plot.



On the ion-neutral coupling in cometary comae

Electric potential....what electric potential (says jonesdave116).

I mean this

What a complete and utter numpty, jonesdave116.

That’s the end of your little game champ, good on ya.





Comets are electric phenomena. Thank you jonesdave116.

Complete crap. And you know that is not what the idiot Thornhill was talking about. Comets are not electric. Your woo is dead. The ambipolar field is doing the exact opposite of what you want it to do, and you are so ignorant of the subject that you cannot understand why. Go learn some science. Take the idiot Thornhill with you.
 
As we will discuss later, the electric field near the nucleus is not just the motional electric field but should include the polarization (or ambipolar) electric field, which tends to confine electrons and expel ions in order to maintain quasi-neutrality.

The ion density structure (Figure 9) is associated with an ambipolar electric field that confines the photo-electrons created within the ion density structure. This tends to boost the overall electron density so that it equals the ion density so as to maintain quasi-neutrality.

However, as discussed earlier in the paper, we know that an ambipolar field that enforces quasi-neutrality must operate to increase the electron density to the larger values associated with the ions in the slower ion motion. The coexistence of slow ions with fast electrons creates an electrical potential that draws electrons into the ion-rich coma so that the charge quasi-neutrality can be attained.

From Madanian's paper linked upthread.

Oh, and;

The Debye length in the solar wind and/or near the nucleus is only a few meters.
 
Last edited:
From Madanian's paper linked upthread.

Oh, and;

Yawn, again.

Jan Deca’s paper.

Charge separation and the violation of quasi neutrality.


The electric comet.

We’ve been here dude and you were shown to be wrong, why would you bring it up again?

Stupidity? Ignorance?
 
PATHETIC DISPLAY, Sol88 ...

Yawn, again.

Jan Deca’s paper.

Charge separation and the violation of quasi neutrality.

The electric comet.

We’ve been here dude and you were shown to be wrong, why would you bring it up again?

Stupidity? Ignorance?


Sol88! Do you really think Deca et al (2017) supports your RELIGION? REALLY? That brilliant bit of mainstream science? YOUR ASSIGNMENT #003? WTF! How dense can one person be?

Deca et al (2017) said:
Cometary nuclei are small, irregularly shaped "icy dirt balls" left over from the dawn of our Solar System 4.6 billion years ago and are composed of a mixture of ices, refractory materials, and large organic molecules. When a comet is sufficiently close to the Sun, the sublimation of ice leads to an outgassing atmosphere and the formation of a coma, and a dust and plasma tail.


A few simple questions, Sol88!
  1. According to Deca et al (2017), how much water was required to produce the simulated charge separation?
  2. According to Deca et al (2017), how much dust was required to produce the simulated charge separation?
  3. According to Deca et al (2017), what was the water temperature required to produce the simulated charge separation?
  4. According to Deca et al (2017), is the "frozen-in" magnetic field orthogonal to, or parallel to the solar wind flow?
  5. According to Deca et al (2017), why is the orientation of the "frozen-in" magnetic field important?
  6. According to Deca et al (2017), why is it important to know the ion and electron Larmor radii?
  7. According to Biver et al (2015), how much water did MIRO "observe" being emitted by 67P at 3.4 AU?
  8. According to Biver et al (2015), what was the "observed" physical distribution of the water being emitted?
  9. Is the amount of water used by Deca et al (2017) consistent with that "measured" by MIRO (Biver et al (2015))?
  10. Regarding Q, please provide a detailed description of the Haser model and why it is still applicable when used correctly!


For the life of me, Sol88, I can't figure out how you manage to breath! For some reason you seem incapable of learning! For some reason you seem oblivious to reality! Astounding! Truly astounding!

Thirteen years you've been at this! And still NO science! NO math! NO model! NO evidence! Will you ever learn, Sol88?
 
PATHETIC SHOW, 'ec' expert!

Sol88! This is a public forum! You can't hide from me! You can't hide from my questions! And you can't hide from your model's complete failure and collapse! Of course, you can try! But ...

The internet is watching to see what you will do, Sol88!
The internet knows that you CAN'T answer my questions!
The internet knows that you REFUSE to answer my questions!

And why can't you deal with my questions? Simple really ... NO science! NO math! NO model! NO evidence!

What are YOU AFRAID of, Sol88?

STOP running and hiding! It's time to face facts! Your 'electric comet' violates basic laws of physics! Your 'electric star' violates basic laws of physics! Your 'electric universe' violates basic laws of physics!

For the lurkers and the curious, here are a few highlights of what Sol88 is running and hiding from ...

TABLE: Sol88's Outstanding FAILED(?) 'electric comet' ASSIGNMENTS!!!
Number | Posted | Grade | Scope
000 | #2690 | 0/100 | Explain, in 'electric comet' terms, why comet and asteroid eccentricities are so intimately mixed!
001 | # 860 | 0/100 | A Test of Observation Skills and the Five Simple Questions Posed and Answered in A'Hearn (2017)
002 | #2580 | 0/100 | A Detailed Discussion of A'Hearn et al (2008), wherein they present evidence that COMETS ARE NOT MADE OF ROCK!
003 | #2681 | 0/100 | A Detailed Discussion of Deca et al (2017), wherein comets are shown to be made of Volatile Ices and Dust!
004 | NEXT | ------ | Plasma Physics 555 - Fundamental Plasma Physics - I
005 | ------ | ------ | Forces Acting on Rosetta during the RSI Experiment - Calculations based on cited DATA
006 | ------ | ------ |
007 | ------ | ------ |
008 | ------ | ------ |
009 | ------ | ------ |
010 | ------ | ------ |

Now, while it's not a formal ASSIGNMENT, I will also include Lisse et al (2006) as unfinished business! What do you know about the science conducted by the Spitzer Space Telescope, Sol88? Let's spend a couple weeks discussing instrumentation principles across the whole of the EM spectrum and how all potential 'electric comet' signatures are missing from the data!

More highlights ...? Why not! Here are some additional issues and questions being IGNORED by our resident 'ec' expert!

COMET DENSITY: Part 1/3 Here, I asked you, Sol88, to review the 21/Lutetia data gathered by the RSI team to confirm the physics and methods used for determining mass are sound! Do you have anything to contribute? No? Your silence = FAILURE!

COMET DENSITY: Part 2/3 In this post, I asked you, Sol88, our resident 'ec' expert, to show how the RSI data has been "fooled" to produce a mass that is 5x smaller than that required by your model! Do you have any evidence of errors to contribute? No? Your silence = FAILURE! On top of FAILURES!

COMET DENSITY: Part 3/3 Guess what! Laboratory data! REAL laboratory data! Here, I asked you, Sol88, to review the KOSI density results and explain how the experimental evidence could be wrong! Measured density values range from 400 to 600 kg/m3 which is consistent with that measured at the handful of comets visited to date!

Tell me, Sol88! Are you happy with comets being made of volatile ices and dust? Just like Deca et al require in order to establish charge separation?

1. The RSI findings = (9.982±0.003)×10^12 kg
2. The Shape Model = 18.7 km3
3. The dust density = ~3g/cm3

Indagator, are you happy with the above?

Stay with me here champ, this has a direct bearing on all those really good questions you have.

Comets are rocky objects.


NOPE! NOT at all happy with those values! Would you like to discuss Patzold et al (2018)? We'll apply the same RIGOUR as was used on Lisse et al (2006) and Deca et al (2017)! You up for it ... champ? Why are you afraid to answer MY questions, Sol88? Are they too hard for you? Is real science too hard for you? Is mathematics too hard for you? What's your next play? More deflection? More inconsequential whinging?

UNAMBIGUOUSLY DEFINE 'electric comet' ROCK! Would you like to take a chance and compound your problems further, Sol88? There is absolutely NO evidence that comets are made of rock! A'Hearn et al (200X)? ASSIGNMENT #002? What are you afraid of? Science? TRUTH?

Twenty Simple Questions - Revisited once again! These ARE the simple questions, Sol88! It only gets harder from here! And these questions require no explanation! No science! Just your personal perspective! Nothing more! And yet you resist! WHY? What are you afraid of, Sol88?

Evidence that Sol88's 'electric comet' REQUIRES LARGE QUANTITIES OF WATER TO PRODUCE CHARGE SEPARATION! How do you respond to this observation, Sol88? Can we dump this thread, and all mentions of 'eu/es/ec' in the religion section of the ISF? Or are you going to scientifically address this profoundly devastating issue? Because the internet never, ever forgets, I will constantly remind you of this FAILURE along with all the other FAILURES! And I want ALL your friends here at the ISF to forever keep this in your face! FACT is, comets are made of volatile ices and dust ... the mainstream model! And YOU need large quantities of water to get your vaunted charge separation ... the mainstream model! YES! Thoughts? Any counter-arguments? Evidence? Science? A model? SILENCE? FEAR? COWERING? HIDING? Why do you IGNORE the obvious?

The 'electric comet' violates fundamental laws of physics! Of course, without an education you will never, ever figure that out! A real pity!

As long as you keep posting, Sol88, I'll keep hanging about to show the world just how stupid the 'eu/es/ec' really is! I'll BET you can't wait!

REMEMBER, Sol88, THE INTERNET NEVER, EVER FORGETS!

Post Scripts Sol88! You'll note that I've added two new ASSIGNMENTS to the table! What was going to be ASSIGNMENT #004 has been bumped to ASSIGNMENT #005, while ASSIGNMENT #012 has been advanced due to some things you've said recently! I can't wait to watch you run and hide from what's to come! Why deal with the failures of your 'model' when you can avoid and deflect! Right?

Remember, Sol88, the internet is waiting for your answers!

What are you afraid of, Sol88! Your 'model' has been torn to shreds! FIX IT! OR THROW IT OUT!
EXPLAIN THE FACT THAT ECCENTRICITY PLAYS ABSOLUTELY NO ROLL IN YOUR CHARGING AND DISCHARGING MECHANISM!
EXPLAIN THE LACK OF ELECTROMAGNETIC "DISCHARGE" SIGNATURES IN THE RPC DATA!
EXPLAIN THE LACK OF THERMODYNAMIC SIGNATURES DUE TO DISCHARGE MACHINING!
EXPLAIN THE OBSERVED SUBSTANTIAL WATER OUTPUT!
EXPLAIN THE OBSERVED DUST PRODUCTION!


You are too shy to answer any REAL questions as the resident <'ec' expert> ...?

Why?

Do you feel threatened?

Do you feel threatened?

Do you feel threatened?


Do YOU feel threatened, Sol88? Is that why you REFUSE to answer my questions? Address your 'ec' FAILURES! NO science! NO math! NO model! NO evidence!

FIX THIS PATHETIC 'ec' MESS! IF YOU CAN!

Sadly, you can't fix stupid ... and the 'eu/es/ec' is some special kind of stupid!

Have a nice day! :D
 
Everything ok Indy?

Please discuss with me just one paper.

This one. Electron and Ion Dynamics of the Solar Wind Interaction with a Weakly Outgassing Comet DOI: 10.1103/PhysRevLett.118.205101

You up to narrow the scope to just this one paper?

What we are going to talk about is charge seperation and quasi neutrality.
 
Last edited:
ASSIGNMENT #004

Sol88! Do you remember uttering any of these delightful remarks ...?

Academics :rolleyes: always about them.

... DOUBLE LAYERS here we come! ...

Do you understand how the diamagnetic cavity is formed?

You do know what plasma is, don’t you?

You do know what plasma is?


Sol88! I want YOU to prove to EVERYONE that YOU know what PLASMA is! OK?

ASSIGNMENT #004!

Welcome to Plasma Physics 555 - Fundamental Plasma Physics - I

Let's play a little game, shall we? Here's how it goes --- For some inexplicable reason, you have managed to worm your way into a graduate-level introductory course in Plasma Physics! NO prerequisites! NO demonstrated skills in "gaslight era" physics or vector calculus! NO demonstrated skills in reading comprehension! NO demonstrated skills in research? NO demonstrated skills in English! YOUR only qualifications are an over-blown ego and righteous arrogance! Oh! And a dogmatic adherence to your 'eu/es/ec' RELIGION! ARE YOU READY?

Welcome to class, Sol88! This is a twelve week "introductory" course in Plasma Physics! We will meet for three one-hour lectures per week! ASSIGNMENTS will be posted at the beginning of the week and are due before the next ASSIGNMENT is posted! The first ASSIGNMENT is attached below! This ASSIGNMENT (referred to here as ASSIGNMENT #004) will require that you read the introductory chapter of almost any Plasma Physics textbook. Turns out, they all cover pretty much the same material, so any text will do for this exercise!

QUESTIONS:

1) Earth's ionosphere is divided into three regions! Why are the "E" and "F" regions considered plasma, while the "D" region is not! This is a question designed to test your intelligence, your reading comprehension skills, your research skills, and your ability to reason! For full marks your answer must be at least FOUR PAGES, double-spaced! It must also include numerical data specific to your answer!

2) Reference Deca et al (2017)! Using boundary conditions provided by Deca et al,
a) Compute the plasma beta, Debye length, and Alfven velocity for the solar wind!
b) Compute the "number of particles" within the solar wind Debye sphere!
c) Is the Deca et al solar wind super-Alfvenic? Please explain!
d) Explain the connection between Deca et al (2017) and MAGNETIC RECONNECTION!

3) Reference Poppe et al (2015)! Using boundary conditions provided by Poppe et al,
a) Compute the plasma beta, Debye length, and Alfven velocity for the solar wind!
b) Compute the "number of particles" within the solar wind Debye sphere!
c) What is the radius of the "inert" body used in the simulation? What is the length of an individual surface segment?
d) Of the three scenarios considered, which one is applicable to comets? Please explain!

4) Place a metal sphere, with radius r = a and charge Q, in a neutral plasma with number density N0 and temperature T!
a) Determine the effective capacitance of the system!
b) Compare this "value" to that of the same sphere placed in free space!

Deca et al (2017) Electron and Ion Dynamics of the Solar Wind Interaction with a Weakly Outgassing Comet!

Poppe et al (2015) The Electrostatic Plasma Environment of a Small Airless Body Under Non-Aligned Plasma Flow and UV Conditions!

You do know what plasma is, don’t you?

You do know what plasma is?


I'll wager real money that Sol88 knows ABSOLUTELY NOTHING about plasmas and plasma physics, regardless of his ... claims! And he's going to prove he knows nothing by COWERING in a corner and REFUSING to answer my questions! Par for the course with 'eu/es/ec' zealots!

Anyone want to take my bet?

Sol88?

You up for it? Show us what you've got resident 'ec' AND 'plasma' expert! At least take a shot at Question 2)!

And FYI! These are the kinds of questions given to "real" students taking introductory courses in plasma physics! WILL YOU ANSWER MY QUESTIONS, Sol88? OR WILL YOU RUN AND HIDE? Can you prove you know enough about plasmas to actually carry on a conversation! Or are you nothing but a poser and a troll?

Did you think any of this was easy, Sol88? Would you actually like to learn some science? Would you like to grow? Or are you going to stick with your RELIGION? I think EVERYONE on the internet knows the answer to that! How do like me now, Sol88? Should I ramp things up? Make things harder? I've got thousands of questions and hundreds of real-world examples of how and why your RELIGION FAILS! What's your next move?

The internet is watching you, Sol88! The internet knows that you and your 'electric comet' FAIL when you make no effort to answer my questions! Your 'electric comet' is nothing more than a fragment of an inconsequential FAILED SCAM RELIGION! Prove me wrong, Sol88! Prove me wrong by answering some questions!
 
Yawn, again.

Jan Deca’s paper.

Charge separation and the violation of quasi neutrality.


The electric comet.

We’ve been here dude and you were shown to be wrong, why would you bring it up again?

Stupidity? Ignorance?

No, I was not shown to be wrong. You were. You know nothing about the subject. As a real plasma physicist kept telling you. Learn the subject before prattling on endlessly about it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom