The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Isn't your entire 'model' based upon the assumption of some magical extra/intra solar electrical field that can both cause massive localized discharges on comets (but not similar astroids on similar paths), that at the same time isn't even capable of making lose electrons and protons react to it?
And is undetectable by even our most senstive measuring equipement?

Or did you work out the maths that makes that possible?

I think Sol88 is on record as saying that he cannot do the necessary calculations, and is unwilling to learn how to. Also, some time ago, he called for help on this, over at TD, and got no (public) response.

It’s hand waving and False Dichotomy all the way down. :p
 
Also, some time ago, he called for help on this, over at TD, and got no (public) response.

This would be the equivalent of going to a kosher restaurant and ordering a bacon sandwich!
 
Seems you’ve been led up the garden path, jd116. ;)

Unlike the paper you’ve linked this one is pretty sparse on the assumption side of things.

The Nucleus of Comet 67P/ChuryumovGerasimenko - Part I: The Global View – nucleus mass, mass loss, porosity and implications

Can’t wait for part II! :D

Please pick it apart, jd116. :D

No takers then?
 
Isn't your entire 'model' based upon the assumption of some magical extra/intra solar electrical field that can both cause massive localized discharges on comets (but not similar astroids on similar paths), that at the same time isn't even capable of making lose electrons and protons react to it?
And is undetectable by even our most senstive measuring equipement?

Or did you work out the maths that makes that possible?

These are observed. :D

Ice is not! :D

Is there an ambipolar electric field at comet 67P, Lukraak?

Is the dust we observe in “jets” charged and “dense” (~3g/cm3)?

Is the nucleus 85% porous?

Is the volume some 18.7km3?

Is the mass accurately determined to be (9.982±0.003)×10^12 kg?

Which of these is incorrect?
 
Last edited:
These are observed. :D

Ice is not! :D

Is there an ambipolar electric field at comet 67P, Lukraak?

Is the dust we observe in “jets” charged and “dense” (~3g/cm3)?

Is the nucleus 85% porous?

Is the volume some 18.7km3?

Is the mass accurately determined to be (9.982±0.003)×10^12 kg?

Which of these is incorrect?

Pointless details. We have detected electrons and protons leaving the sun in the same direction, with speeds that are fully explainable by actual functional physics.
If the EC electric field would exist one of those particles would be sucked back to the sun, whereas the other would be sped up away from the sun.

This is not observed.
So until you explain how there can be an electric field as strong as your fantasy theory needs while at the same time not affecting basic charged particles all the rest of the questions are pointless.

I understand you wanting to focus on pointless details though, as that keeps you in the illusion that the EC theory is in some way relevant.

Unless of course you have the maths ready to show that this is possible (which would also open up untold possibilities in engineering and make you rich beyond your wildest dreams).
 
These are observed. :D

Ice is not! :D

Is there an ambipolar electric field at comet 67P, Lukraak?

Is the dust we observe in “jets” charged and “dense” (~3g/cm3)?

Is the nucleus 85% porous?

Is the volume some 18.7km3?

Is the mass accurately determined to be (9.982±0.003)×10^12 kg?

Which of these is incorrect?

Liar. Go away. Ice is observed. Tempel 1, Hartley 2, 67P, Hale-Bopp, Catalina, 17P Holmes,.......................... Quit lying. It is a bad habit. Typical of EUists, but bad, all the same.
 
Pointless details. We have detected electrons and protons leaving the sun in the same direction, with speeds that are fully explainable by actual functional physics.
If the EC electric field would exist one of those particles would be sucked back to the sun, whereas the other would be sped up away from the sun.

This is not observed.
So until you explain how there can be an electric field as strong as your fantasy theory needs while at the same time not affecting basic charged particles all the rest of the questions are pointless.

I understand you wanting to focus on pointless details though, as that keeps you in the illusion that the EC theory is in some way relevant.

Unless of course you have the maths ready to show that this is possible (which would also open up untold possibilities in engineering and make you rich beyond your wildest dreams).

Simpleton electrostatics.

Plasma is a little more complicated and the math becomes unwieldy for your average joe.

Parker Solar Probe will give you a little more insight.

Oh and those pointless details say
The nucleus is thus a highly porous very dusty body with very little ice.

For very high Fnucleus values, the nucleus is highly porous and dusty with very little ice (e.g. for Fnucleus = 7, the ice content is about 7% for porosities between 68% and 80%, respectively). A variation in porosity by 1% beyond the 70% implies a steep increase in Fnucleus, leaving only a tiny fractional ice content. As a reminder, the upper bound on the porosity is 73% to 85% for a highly porous stony body without ice for the selected dust material density range.
The Nucleus of Comet 67P/ChuryumovGerasimenko - Part I: The Global View – nucleus mass, mass loss, porosity and implications :D

As A’Hearn said as well. :thumbsup:

Stony/rocky same thing. ;)

I like that, pointless details bit like the Haser model...
 
Liar. Go away. Ice is observed. Tempel 1, Hartley 2, 67P, Hale-Bopp, Catalina, 17P Holmes,.......................... Quit lying. It is a bad habit. Typical of EUists, but bad, all the same.

Oh dear...:boggled:


Ice ice everywhere.

Common as but comets are not MOSTLY ICE, if they have any subsurface ice at all. It’s all inferred.
 
Liar. Go away. Ice is observed. Tempel 1, Hartley 2, 67P, Hale-Bopp, Catalina, 17P Holmes,.......................... Quit lying. It is a bad habit. Typical of EUists, but bad, all the same.

Not me sport but a real fair dinkum scientist using the scientific method and data returned from in situ observations at 67P came to the same conclusion as A’Hearn
4. Discussion An evaluation of low dust material densities (Fulle et al., 2016; 2017) versus relatively high dust material densities (RSI; CONSERT) favors dust material densities of 2000 - 3500 kg/m3 and high dust contents by volume in order to account for the observed nucleus mass and bulk density. All together, this implies high porosities and high dust-to-ice mass ratios Fnucleus. The nucleus body presents itself therefore as a highly porous dusty body with little ice.
The Nucleus of Comet 67P/ChuryumovGerasimenko - Part I: The Global View – nucleus mass, mass loss, porosity and implications

:D


Poor jonesdave116 :(
 
Pointless details. We have detected electrons and protons leaving the sun in the same direction, with speeds that are fully explainable by actual functional physics.
If the EC electric field would exist one of those particles would be sucked back to the sun, whereas the other would be sped up away from the sun.

This is not observed.
So until you explain how there can be an electric field as strong as your fantasy theory needs while at the same time not affecting basic charged particles all the rest of the questions are pointless.

I understand you wanting to focus on pointless details though, as that keeps you in the illusion that the EC theory is in some way relevant.

Unless of course you have the maths ready to show that this is possible (which would also open up untold possibilities in engineering and make you rich beyond your wildest dreams).

What is a Plasma?

Given its nature, the plasma state is characterized by a complexity that vastly exceeds that exhibited in the solid, liquid, and gaseous states. Correspondingly, the study of the physical and especially the electrodynamical properties of plasma forms one of the most far ranging and difficult research areas in physics today. From spiral galaxies to controlled fusion, this little-known state of matter, the fundamental state, is proving to be of ever greater significance in explaining the dynamics of the universe and in harnessing the material world for the greatest technological result.

Plasma is not electrostatics me ‘ol mate!

You seem to fail, among others here, to grasp this fact. :boggled:
 
Last edited:
Oh dear...:boggled:


Ice ice everywhere.

Common as but comets are not MOSTLY ICE, if they have any subsurface ice at all. It’s all inferred.

Tempel 1. Stop lying, you loon. Hartley 2. Etc. How many times are you going to lie about this?
 
Yawn, Been done to death... Spontaneous formation of nonspherical water ice grains in a plasma environment GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH LETTERS, VOL. 40, 1–6, doi:10.1002/2013GL058268, 2013

Water vapour from Ingredients for water could be made on surface of moon, a chemical factory

And as stated many many times and confirmed by Martin Pätzold you’ve duffed up to “outgassing” rate ;
From the discussion above it seems to be clear that the lost gas mass was strongly overestimated by the gas instruments and these teams work all on more realistic estimates

Leading you to believe comets are MOSTLY ICE when even the grand poobah stated, again for context,
although our understanding has been evolving more toward mostly rock
Michael F. A’Hearn

Oh dear...
 
Last edited:
Kosher restaurant. Bacon sandwich :)

Ahhh, good ‘ol maths.

So powerful if you divide by zero you get a black holes totally proven by mathamajigics!

:jaw-dropp

Maths has also proven we don’t know what some some 85% of the universe is. lol :eye-poppi

All maths has done lately is secure funding for advancing farietales like Higgs boson, gravitational waves dark energy....list goes on and on.

SISO ‘ol saying.
 
Yawn, Been done to death... Spontaneous formation of nonspherical water ice grains in a plasma environment GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH LETTERS, VOL. 40, 1–6, doi:10.1002/2013GL058268, 2013

Water vapour from Ingredients for water could be made on surface of moon, a chemical factory

And as stated many many times and confirmed by Martin Pätzold you’ve duffed up to “outgassing” rate ;

Leading you to believe comets are MOSTLY ICE when even the grand poobah stated, again for context, Michael F. A’Hearn

Oh dear...

Stop lying. Do the maths, or shut up.
 
All maths has done lately is secure funding for advancing farietales like Higgs boson, gravitational waves dark energy....list goes on and on
.

Just because you never went to school and can't do maths, does not mean the whole of physics is wrong. Quit lying. Higgs boson found. Gravitational waves proven. Go away. Getting sick of your scientifically illiterate lying.
 
Last edited:
All right, all right I’m pretty sure Martin Pätzold used real fair dinkum maths and bonafide in situ data to come up with
4. Discussion An evaluation of low dust material densities (Fulle et al., 2016; 2017) versus relatively high dust material densities (RSI; CONSERT) favors dust material densities of 2000 - 3500 kg/m3 and high dust contents by volume in order to account for the observed nucleus mass and bulk density. All together, this implies high porosities and high dust-to-ice mass ratios Fnucleus. The nucleus body presents itself therefore as a highly porous dusty body with little ice.

Would this be a fair observation?

Why would my math beat Martin’s math and “prove” to you comets have little ice? I’d assume this would mean ALL ices, not just water.
 
All right, all right I’m pretty sure Martin Pätzold used real fair dinkum maths and bonafide in situ data to come up with

Would this be a fair observation?

Why would my math beat Martin’s math and “prove” to you comets have little ice? I’d assume this would mean ALL ices, not just water.


So where is all the vapour coming from? Where did the thousands of tonnes of ice at Tempel 1 come from, 13 years ago? You have failed. Long since. Why are you still here?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom