The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Hayabusa2 has touched down on Ryugu!

And electric comet insanity did not make it explode :p!


Why would it explode champ?

When the samples are returned and found to be comet like...:blush:

In case you’ve not heard Asteroid–comet continuum objects in the solar system.

Bennu will be interesting as well, though I note there not real big on the plasma side of instrumentation as is the Hayabusa 2 probe.

So who knows what the electric field strength is a these asteroids? :confused:
 
As I’ve said all along...


Yup, the “instruments” overestimated the gas production rates leading the gullible to believe comets are mostly “ice”...:o

Hydrated minerals and hydrogen implantation are more than enough to account for Q.

Intergrating the data from earth based observations was a good start but now shown to be incorrect.

Liar. The production rates are worked out in various ways, and all agree within a factor of a few. And I am getting sick of telling you that you cannot extract anything from hydrated minerals at those temperatures. And you are 7 orders of magnitude short for proton implantation to account for anything, your D/H ratio is wrong, and the solar wind is getting nowhere near the comet for ~ 8 months. So quit with the lying. You failed. Get over it.
 
The aim of argument, or of discussion, should not be victory, but progress.
Joseph Joubert

Everybody else seems to be progressing, Reality check, Jonesdave116.
 
Joseph Joubert

Everybody else seems to be progressing, Reality check, Jonesdave116.

Rubbish. Do the maths. Explain the water production from solar wind protons. Explain how you are getting anything out of hydrated minerals. Do it, or shut up about it.
 
For very high Fnucleus values, the nucleus is highly porous and dusty with very little ice (e.g. for Fnucleus = 7, the ice content is about 7% for porosities between 68% and 80%, respectively). A variation in porosity by 1% beyond the 70% implies a steep increase in Fnucleus, leaving only a tiny fractional ice content. As a reminder, the upper bound on the porosity is 73% to 85% for a highly porous stony body without ice for the selected dust material density range.

4. Discussion An evaluation of low dust material densities (Fulle et al., 2016; 2017) versus relatively high dust material densities (RSI; CONSERT) favors dust material densities of 2000 - 3500 kg/m3 and high dust contents by volume in order to account for the observed nucleus mass and bulk density. All together, this implies high porosities and high dust-to-ice mass ratios Fnucleus. The nucleus body presents itself therefore as a highly porous dusty body with little ice.

From the discussion above it seems to be clear that the lost gas mass was strongly overestimated by the gas instruments and these teams work all on more realistic estimates.

The total mass loss may be related to the product (Fcoma+1)Q0 (22; Table 4), where Q0 is the gas production rate at perihelion and Fcoma is the dust-to-gas mass ratio in the coma. The observed mass loss (9) implies that either the dust-to-gas mass ratio in the coma is smaller than 1 or that the Q0 is smaller up to a factor of 10 (Table 5) than estimated by ROSINA (Hansen et al., 2016) or MIRO (Marshall et al., 2017).

The Nucleus of Comet 67P/ChuryumovGerasimenko - Part I: The Global View – nucleus mass, mass loss, porosity and implications



Your problem sport! :)
not so unrealistically, the nucleus would be a highly porous stony agglomerate, essentially devoid of volitiles.
ROCK!
 
Still waiting. A five minute calculation. Do it, or quit lying.

Using which data if
From the discussion above it seems to be clear that the lost gas mass was strongly overestimated by the gas instruments and these teams work all on more realistic estimates.

The teams are working on more realistic estimates :thumbsup:

Stay tuned jonesdave116!

Keep your napkin handy though.
 
Using which data if

The teams are working on more realistic estimates :thumbsup:

I very much doubt that. And there is still way too much gas for the proton nonsense.

Solar wind avg. velocity = ~ 400 km/s.
Density at 3 AU = ~ 1 proton cm3.
Surface impacted by SW = ~ 12 km2Outgassing rate at 3 AU = 1 l/s.

Do the maths. You will find that you are at least 7 orders of magnitude short. That is, 10 millionths of a litre. Which is 1/10 000th of a millilitre. A millilitre of H2O = 1 cm3. A cubic millimetre would be 1/1 000th of a millilitre. So you get 1/10th of a cubic millimetre from this impossible nonsense. The solar wind is not reaching the comet when it is most active. The D/H of the cometary water is nowhere near the SW value. It is a non-starter.
 
Last edited:
So, let's see what the latest estimates look like from another method. This is from the He+/He2+ flux;

2. Remote sensing of the cometary neutral atmosphere from local ion measurements is possible. Outgassing rates derived from the local He+/He2+ flux ratio were well within a factor 2 of the neutral pressure sensor estimates: 14-day averages between January 2015 and June 2016 were within 10% of each other and the MIRO estimates. Our fitted production rates agree well with those of Hansen et al. (2016).

Whoops. Whichever way they look at it, the production rate kills the EC lunacy. Not that it wasn't dead already.

Solar wind charge exchange in cometary atmospheres III.
Results from the Rosetta mission to comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko

Simon-Wedlund, S. et al (2019)
https://arxiv.org/pdf/1902.04417.pdf
 
Last edited:
Mmmm....1050’s Haser model, mmmmmm

Irrelevant. Whichever way they measure it, it produces far more vapour than the EC model can account for. Therefore you failed. The Haser model did not cause thousands of tonnes of ice to come flying out of Tempel 1. Or to be ejected at Hartley 2. Or to be detected around other comets. You lost. Please go away.
 
Yup, thought so.
In the simple assumption of a spherically expanding cometary atmosphere (following Haser 1957), the equivalent local outgassing rate inferred from ROSINA-COPS can be calcu

ROSINA-COPS. Local differences between the two estimates may arise, for example, (i) from the ion dynamics and the increasing deflection and energy spread of solar wind ions, and (ii) from the assumption of a spherically symmetric outgassing used in this work.

On the other hand, improvements on the physics of the model are clearly possible, but would come at the expense of the simplicity and portability of our initial approach: they include the addition of a realistic solar wind ion dynamics (gyromotion and deflection), or that of a more realistic neutral atmosphere (asymmetric outgassing), for example.

Solar wind charge exchange in cometary atmospheres III. Results from the Rosetta mission to comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko
Cyril Simon Wedlund and me old mate Martin Volwerk
 
Irrelevant. Whichever way they measure it, it produces far more vapour than the EC model can account for. Therefore you failed. The Haser model did not cause thousands of tonnes of ice to come flying out of Tempel 1. Or to be ejected at Hartley 2. Or to be detected around other comets. You lost. Please go away.

Seems you’ve been led up the garden path, jd116. ;)

Unlike the paper you’ve linked this one is pretty sparse on the assumption side of things.

The Nucleus of Comet 67P/ChuryumovGerasimenko - Part I: The Global View – nucleus mass, mass loss, porosity and implications

Can’t wait for part II! :D

Please pick it apart, jd116. :D
 
Yup, thought so.





Solar wind charge exchange in cometary atmospheres III. Results from the Rosetta mission to comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko
Cyril Simon Wedlund and me old mate Martin Volwerk

Irrelevant. Your model has failed. Why are you still here?
 
In the simple assumption of a spherically expanding cometary atmosphere (following Haser 1957), the equivalent local outgassing rate inferred from ROSINA-COPS can be calcu

Assumption assumption assumption. Best you can do champ?
 
Last edited:
Does 67P have a spherically expanding atmosphere, jonesdave116?

Irrelevant. There is a shed load of gas, and it is measured in numerous ways. Therefore your model fails. Tempel 1 happened. You lost. 13 years ago. Go away.
 
Assumption assumption assumption. Best you can do champ?

Isn't your entire 'model' based upon the assumption of some magical extra/intra solar electrical field that can both cause massive localized discharges on comets (but not similar astroids on similar paths), that at the same time isn't even capable of making lose electrons and protons react to it?
And is undetectable by even our most senstive measuring equipement?

Or did you work out the maths that makes that possible?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom