The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Reading the last pages of chit-chat, I can only concur with JeanTate - what Sol88 defends has nothing to do with science; it is purely a faith-based postulate.

I'd add that it isn't even a positive postulate, but a negative one, in that it is only defined by the denial of other theories. Notice how he never once precisely describes mechanisms of the EC, never says how to formalize or quantify effects related to EC, or how they solve issues left unexplained by other models.

Instead, all his answers actually consist in taking a random part of another model, and either ask about it, or say how wrong it is.

Where did you ever talk about EC, and only EC? Can you provide a single answer about it without relying on the denial of competing models?

Is EC so empty of any meaning that it cannot be defined by its own internals, but only as the antithesis of everything else?

When will you finally explain EC without referring to 'mainstream'?
 
Reading the last pages of chit-chat, I can only concur with JeanTate - what Sol88 defends has nothing to do with science; it is purely a faith-based postulate.

I'd add that it isn't even a positive postulate, but a negative one, in that it is only defined by the denial of other theories. Notice how he never once precisely describes mechanisms of the EC, never says how to formalize or quantify effects related to EC, or how they solve issues left unexplained by other models.

Instead, all his answers actually consist in taking a random part of another model, and either ask about it, or say how wrong it is.

Where did you ever talk about EC, and only EC? Can you provide a single answer about it without relying on the denial of competing models?

Is EC so empty of any meaning that it cannot be defined by its own internals, but only as the antithesis of everything else?

When will you finally explain EC without referring to 'mainstream'?

To easy champ and welcome.


Lets start from the very start shall we?

Do you believe there is charge separation and electric fields at comet 67P?

If not you believe in "ices" melting in the Sun's heat.

Though you do mention
competing models
besides the sublimation model what others are there?
 
Last edited:
Do you believe there is charge separation and electric fields at comet 67P?

If not you believe in "ices" melting in the Sun's heat.

Ices do not melt. That is pure ignorance. They sublime, and are observed to do so. Fail. And any minimal charge separation is of no relevance to the complete lack of evidence for any glow discharges, EDM (lol) or electric discharges. Fail. Your model is a total failure. As shown. Give it up.
 
Fail. No rock ever detected at comets. Density = ~ 530 kg/m3. Game over.

Which funny enough, leaves you with little to no ice!

Which is were the statement by A'Hearn
(c) What are comets made of? At the simplest level, a very basic question is whether comets are mostly ice or mostly rock/dirt/refractory material. Whipple’s [2] model of the dirty snowball, the first quantitative model, envisioned cometary nuclei as mostly ice, although our understanding has been evolving more toward mostly rock, particularly for 67P/C-G for which refractory/volatile ratios as high as 6 have been cited [3,4].
is bang on the money!

Mainstream science at it's very best.

Where's all your ice jonesdave116?

Your understanding seems to be NOT evolving!
 
Last edited:
Ices do not melt. That is pure ignorance. They sublime, and are observed to do so. Fail. And any minimal charge separation is of no relevance to the complete lack of evidence for any glow discharges, EDM (lol) or electric discharges. Fail. Your model is a total failure. As shown. Give it up.

Do you believe there is an ambipolar electric field at comet 67P, jd116?

Do you believe the dusty plasma is responding to this fabled electric field?

the sublimation model has been known to be lacking for some time, it's now untenable.

Wont stop you, jonesdave116, crusader of Whipple’s model of the dirty snowball, the first quantitative model from blathering on about some ice at Tempel 1 and Hartley 2.

Good work, keep it up
 
Are you saying one of these is incorrect?

  1. The RSI findings
  2. The Shape Model
  3. The dust density

or, as usual, you have only...:confused:
 
Which funny enough, leaves you with little to no ice!

Which is were the statement by A'Hearn is bang on the money!

Mainstream science at it's very best.

Where's all your ice jonesdave116?

Your understanding seems to be NOT evolving!

And more lying about A'Hearn's statement. He is referring to dust. As his references indicate. And thousands of tonnes of ice was blasted out of Tempel 1. So your model, such as it is, failed. 13 years ago. And yet you're still here. Brainwashed, or what? No science, no mechanisms, no evidence. A complete and utter failure.
 
Do you believe there is an ambipolar electric field at comet 67P, jd116?
Possibly.

Do you believe the dusty plasma is responding to this fabled electric field?

Nope. Your field, if present, should be holding the dust along with the electrons. That plainly is not happening. Therefore the field, if present, is not affecting the dust. As has already been pointed out. Further out in the coma, the very smallest grains may be affected.
 
Last edited:
Usual insanity and lies from Sol88

Brilliant, comets have little to no ice!
Sol88's insane electric comet playbook of ignorance, delusions, idiocy (god of the gaps/false dichotomy/irrelevant mainstream citations), insults (an insane one of Michael O'Hearn), lies

Sol88's insane lie here is that jonesdave116 agreed to "little to no ice" when No, they are all correct. Therefore your model fails. is about
  1. The RSI findings
  2. The Shape Model
  3. The dust density
The RSI findings are a measurement of density less than water. This debunks Sol88's electric comet insanity.
The Shape Model is probably the shape of 67P. This is irrelevant to Sol88's electric comet insanity.
The dust density starts with the measured density of dust grains returned by Stardust, i.e. as expected for dust left over from the early solar system. The Stardust dust grains debunks Sol88's electric comet insanity (no granite, no basalt, no limestone, no minerals unique to rocky planets, grains that formed in space).
The density of dust measured at 67P does not say anything about ices. This is emphasizes Sol88's electric comet insanity.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom