lauwenmark
Scholar
- Joined
- Mar 23, 2017
- Messages
- 103
Reading the last pages of chit-chat, I can only concur with JeanTate - what Sol88 defends has nothing to do with science; it is purely a faith-based postulate.
I'd add that it isn't even a positive postulate, but a negative one, in that it is only defined by the denial of other theories. Notice how he never once precisely describes mechanisms of the EC, never says how to formalize or quantify effects related to EC, or how they solve issues left unexplained by other models.
Instead, all his answers actually consist in taking a random part of another model, and either ask about it, or say how wrong it is.
Where did you ever talk about EC, and only EC? Can you provide a single answer about it without relying on the denial of competing models?
Is EC so empty of any meaning that it cannot be defined by its own internals, but only as the antithesis of everything else?
When will you finally explain EC without referring to 'mainstream'?
I'd add that it isn't even a positive postulate, but a negative one, in that it is only defined by the denial of other theories. Notice how he never once precisely describes mechanisms of the EC, never says how to formalize or quantify effects related to EC, or how they solve issues left unexplained by other models.
Instead, all his answers actually consist in taking a random part of another model, and either ask about it, or say how wrong it is.
Where did you ever talk about EC, and only EC? Can you provide a single answer about it without relying on the denial of competing models?
Is EC so empty of any meaning that it cannot be defined by its own internals, but only as the antithesis of everything else?
When will you finally explain EC without referring to 'mainstream'?
