Indagator, another great post.
Are you able to elaborate on the following statement?
... I've got "gaslight era" physics and everything that came before and after that on my side! What have you got, Sol88? Ducks and Bunnies?
Based simply on observation, Sol88, ...
I come here to TEACH! You come here to PREACH!
I come here to educate! You come here to misinterpret, misunderstand, confound, confuse, obfuscate, deceive, and troll (when you're not attempting to demean, belittle, and insult mainstream science and scientists)! Sol88? How do you expect mainstream science will help when all you do is crap all over those that offer their assistance? In the last several years a number of people have shown you, and your 'electric comet' to be WRONG. These individuals know what they are talking about. You do not! Why then, would you think that mainstream science will suddenly provide the evidence you seek?
Mainstream physics does not work on an 'electric comet!' The world is still waiting for a description of what an 'electric comet' is! No model! No science! No evidence!
Mainstream physics does not work on an 'electric comet!'
As a mainstream scientist, I know that an 'electric comet' is physically IMPOSSIBLE! As an educator, I just need to find a way to open your eyes to the truth! .., Sol88, neither you (a layman), or I (a mainstream scientist) can build a useful model of an 'electric comet!' Why?
An 'electric comet' MUST violate basic laws of physics to exist! Ergo! It can't exist!
An 'electric comet' MUST violate basic laws of physics to exist! Ergo! It can't exist!
Now what do we do? You and I?
How about we keep discussing things you REFUSE to discuss when presented with overwhelming evidence that contradicts your 'electric rock' religion!
To date, I have gently scratched the surface of two papers that you claim contains some content that supports your 'electric comet' nonsense!
Whilst you feign a noble desire to discuss, when presented with contradictory evidence, you immediately tuck tail and run! In case it was not obvious to you, Sol88, discussion requires some back and forth! This is how it works - I ask you a few simple questions (the hard ones come later), and you, as the resident 'ec' expert MUST answer them! Remember, Sol88, this is your 'electric comet' thread! Stop cowering in the dark, Sol88, and enlighten us!
Stop preaching and start teaching! Otherwise, I will start making a case to have all references to the 'eu/es/ec' dumped in the
Religion section of the
ISF where it belongs!
So, we have two options regarding Lisse et al (2006) and Deca et al (2017), 1) you can openly admit on the internet that you misunderstood the results presented and forever drop these papers from your 'ec' toolbox, or 2) we can dig deeper and deeper and deeper into the subtleties of these papers until you realize just how wrong you are about ... everything science!
ASSIGNMENT #000 of ....
<SNIPPY>
ELECTRIC COMET MODEL = A Rock on an eliptical orbit, discharging in the solar plasma flow.
<SNIPPY>
Remember, the internet never forgets!
YOUR ASSIGNMENT
Part I: (50 points) Your PROOF re. eccentricity will require physics and mathematics to complete!
Presented for your consideration, Sol88, is the penultimate table of eccentricities! The next step is to dump the entire contents of the ever expanding JPL Small Body Database! In my humble opinion, I don't think that's necessary or helpful, as [highlight]you seem incapable of addressing the
STAGGERING FAILURE of your 'electric comet' model to account for the 35 celestial objects listed here![/highlight] Regardless, let's continue our lopsided discussion of eccentricity and why it is
IRRELEVANT to your 'electric comet' religion!
[highlight]Please explain, in 'electric comet' terms, Sol88, why comet and asteroid eccentricities are so intimately mixed!
What fundamental physics is missing from your model? The mainstream has no problem accounting for the variability! Do you, 'ec' expert, need to apply
'electric epicycles' to account for the discrepancies? You keep claiming (without science or evidence) that your 'electric comets' charge and discharge because of their eccentricity! Where's the evidence? Where's the lab work? When are you going to
PROVE IT? When is anyone in your camp going to do some real science?[/highlight]
What makes it physically IMPOSSIBLE? At this stage forget about orbits and the composition of the nucleus.
I think we need to start here before we delve into the really really fun stuff.
I feel so stupid for not realizing how scientifically/physically impossible the ELECTRIC COMET is and really need help on knowing why this is.
Are you able to set me straight,?
Reality Check likes to keep reminding me how much of an idiot I am.
Please try and keep it simple for me, I seem to struggle, so it seems.
PS
I also of the opinion that comets are a small part, the visible focus, of a larger electric circuit.
May help with your understanding of my understanding.
Sol88! What was that word again ...
feign?
And here I thought you were being sincere about wanting to have an adult conversation! You know, a discussion!
- Lisse et al (2006) presents evidence that comets accreted in a PSN! What do you think? LIES? Conspiracy?
- A'Hearn et al (date TBD) discusses the implications of cometary composition and the fact that comets are NOT rock! What do you think, Sol88? More LIES? Where's that link?
- Deca et al (2017) provides evidence that comets are "icy dirt balls!" What do you think? Conspiracy and even more LIES?
Silly me!
Once a troll, always a troll, Sol88? Let's find out!
Sol88!
This is YOUR 'electric comet' thread! Either start discussing your 'electric comet,' or we dump this 'eu/es/ec' crap in the ISF's RELIGION section where it belongs!
First off, you'll note that I recovered some material from my original post (i.e., your ASSIGNMENT #000)! In this expanded version, I've taken the liberty to refresh your memory on a couple important points that
YOU DO NOT SEEM TO GRASP or COMPREHEND!
Being that we are here to discuss your 'electric comet' model (not the mainstream model), what everyone really wants to know is,
What makes your little 'electric space rock' POSSIBLE? We both know that comets are not made of "ROCK!" A'Hearn et al (date TBD - your ASSIGNMENT #002) was quite clear about that! When are you going to stop cowering in some dark hole and find that paper! I just checked and the paper in question is still available on the interwebz! It has not gone into hiding! It's right there for everyone to read! Get on it! Stop wasting time! What are you afraid of discovering?
Now, I wonder who said this ...?
Will you out smart me and find the link to the peer reviewed paper?
The internet is watching and waiting, Sol88! Time to look through the telescope! Time to open your eyes to the fact that you've been deceived! Time to start "thinking" for yourself instead of parroting the lies of some unethical scam artists! Time to stop swallowing someone else's fantasy! Time to join the real world!
Regarding your question, Sol88, as a mainstream scientist, I understand statics, dynamics, mechanics of materials, fluid mechanics, ballistics, thermodynamics, optics, instrumentation, electronics, electrostatics, electrodynamics, orbital mechanics, geology, geomorphology, geophysics, cryophysics, plasma physics, chemistry, numerical modeling and simulation, calculus, and statistics!
And yet, with all my acquired knowledge, I cannot find a way to 'build' a quantitative, functional model of an 'electric space rock!' No one can!
THAT realization, alone, is why your 'electric comet' is physically IMPOSSIBLE! Furthermore, EVERY mainstream scientist who might try to build an 'electric comet' model would face the same dilemma! You know, it should be profoundly disappointing that in the last 20+ years, no one on planet Earth has been able to produce a working model of an 'electric comet' or an 'electric star!' Thus, we may conclude, there is NO 'electric comet!' There is NO 'electric star!' And there is NO 'electric universe!' Mainstream science can't build a functional model! Thornhill can't build a functional model! Scott can't build a functional model! I can't build a functional model! And Sol88 can't build a functional model, or even provide a reasonable description of what an 'electric comet' is supposed to be!
No model! No science! No evidence! Thirteen years you've been at this! Unless someone rewrites ALL the laws of physics, there will never be an 'electric comet' model! But, that FACT will not deter someone like you from believing your religion! That's the way of all religions!
FAITH is more important than evidence! FAITH is more important than data! FAITH is more important than observation!
Do you recall this statement, Sol88?
Now, as a mainstream scientist, I have no agenda! I am only interested in moving science forward! That means that,
- I like to learn new things that I (personally) did not know before!
- I like to learn new things that no living human ever knew before! And,
- I really like to solve problems!
Restated! I cannot, and will not, stand in the way of real scientific progress!
So, ... how do you build an "electric comet" model that uses real mainstream science? You can't!
It is physically IMPOSSIBLE! FACT! Your vague, ethereal description of an "electric comet" violates fundamental laws of physics! FACT! Thornhill's vague, ethereal description of an "electric comet" (which you apparently have abandoned) violates fundamental laws of physics!
If your model was based on science, mainstream scientists, like myself, would be willing and able to help! Why would anyone in the mainstream science community want to stand in the way of real progress! When are you, Sol88, or any of your 'eu' buddies going to
submit a quantitative model for peer-review?
As far as I can tell, Sol88, your whole 'ec' model is based on nothing more than ...
"Hey! That looks like a bunny!"
Statement of fact! I like to learn new things that I (personally) did not know before!
Statement of fact! I really like to solve problems! I make a living doing just that!
When I first heard of the 'electric universe' in the fall of 2014, I had to go look it up! Give it a fair hearing! You know, learn something new that I (personally) did not know before! A mere 15 minutes was all I needed to realize that the 'electric universe,' the 'electric star,' and your 'electric comet' were all part of a scam religion!
No science! No models! No math! No substance! Just a bunch of pretty pictures of ducks and bunnies!
Fifteen minutes, Sol88!
SO! What do you think the problem is, Sol88? Mainstream physics? Mainstream science? Or your 'electric comet' delusion?
Did you say this, Sol88?
<SNIPPY>
ELECTRIC COMET MODEL = A Rock on an eliptical orbit, discharging in the solar plasma flow.
<SNIPPY>
Ya! You know you did!
Indagator, another great post.
Ya! I know!

Problem is you didn't read it. Did you?
What makes it physically IMPOSSIBLE?
Well, your 'electric comet' (and it's underlying assumptions) violate the physics described by ...
- Electrostatics,
- Electrodynamics,
- Orbital mechanics,
- Thermodynamics,
- Conservation of Energy,
- Instrumentation (science), and ...
- Basic Electricity
Please note, this is by no means the complete list of all the physics
FAILURES associated with your 'electric comet' nonsense! But don't you worry! If you're patient, we'll get around to discussing
ALL the FAILURES of your model!
At this stage forget about orbits and the composition of the nucleus.
Don't be silly, Sol88! Orbits (i.e., orbital mechanics) and the composition of the nucleus are fundamental to your
FAILED model! You say as much right here!
<SNIPPY>
ELECTRIC COMET MODEL = A Rock on an eliptical orbit, discharging in the solar plasma flow.
<SNIPPY>
Obviously composition is important to you! You say an 'electric comet' is a "ROCK!" A'Hearn et al (TBD) state that comets are not made of "ROCK!" Sounds like we have a real problem here! Between you and Dr. A'Hearn, who do you think has more credibility? What's your PhD in again? STRIKE ONE!
You also need the equivalent of
'electric epicycles' for eccentricity to play a role in your 'electric comet' model!
Observational evidence (i.e., the tabulated data) indicates that eccentricity is NOT applicable to your 'electric comet' model! No mechanism! No science! No evidence! STRIKE TWO!
You know, it's OK to be wrong! Tis tough on the ego to admit when you're wrong, but it's not the end of the world.
I think we need to start here before we delve into the really really fun stuff.
Sol88! I'm a mainstream scientist! Let me tell you, EVERYTHING about science is "really really fun stuff." To bad there's no science in your 'electric comet!' Are you having fun yet? I'm having a blast!
By the way, plasma physics is "
pretty advanced fun stuff!" You still haven't a clue about the "basic fun stuff" like electricity, electrostatics, thermodynamics, orbital mechanics, and calculus! You know, the "fun stuff" your 'electric comet' has to violate to exist!
I feel so stupid for not realizing how scientifically/physically impossible the ELECTRIC COMET is and really need help on knowing why this is.
Sol88! Forgive me, but you DO NOT sound at all sincere! Thirteen years of ignorant, arrogant, misinformed, confrontational posts, and you're just now realizing "how scientifically/physically impossible the ELECTRIC COMET is?" NO! I call BS!
If, however, I am wrong about your sincerity, I would ask you to PROVE IT! Apologize to each individual poster on the ISF that you have offended! And there are many! Now, are you being honest and sincere, or is this just another trolling tactic? We shall soon see!!!
Still having fun, Sol88? Am I reading you right? Are you sincere, or NOT?
Are you able to set me straight,?
NO! Your religion blinds you! You will not open your eyes until you are ready! In the mean time, I will present evidence (e.g, A'Hearn et al (200X)), data (from real telescopes and instrumentation), and offer literally thousands of peer-reviewed papers and questions, that MAY (or may not ever) lead you out of the darkness!
Please try and keep it simple for me, I seem to struggle, so it seems.
True statement! You do seem to struggle! As for keeping it simple, perhaps you could give me an indication of just how far you got in your education! Of course, you are not obligated to answer that! However, if you really are sincere about understanding why your 'electric comet' is physically IMPOSSIBLE, you'll let me know. I remind you again, science is hard! Plasma physics is incredibly difficult without a solid foundation in electrostatics, electrodynamics, thermodynamics, calculus, etc.!
I also of the opinion that comets are a small part, the visible focus, of a larger electric circuit.
Good for you! PROVE IT! Draw a circuit diagram! Identify the source! Identify all the components in the circuit! Use standard RLC convention! Now, you've claimed that the 'electric comet' is the load in this circuit!
PROVE IT! HERE ARE THE QUESTIONS YOU MUST ANSWER FOR YOUR 'electric comet' TO EVOLVE TOWARDS MODEL STATUS!
- What is the source of your electromotive force?
- What is the voltage produced by your source? I need real numbers here!
- What is the current supplied by your source? I need real numbers here, too!
- What is the return path for your circuit? You MUST have a return path for this model to be REAL!
- What is the nature of this load? I need values for resistance, capacitance, inductance!
- Are these RLC values fixed, or do they vary according to some unknown 'electric comet' laws?
- Do you need other "engineered" components to complete your circuit (e.g., lamps, diodes, IC's)?

- How much energy is dissipated in the resistive element of your load? Conservation of energy implies HEAT!
- Of what practical purpose is the capacitive element in your circuit (e.g., response time)?
- Of what practical purpose is the inductive element in your circuit?
- If your 'electric comet' is a ROCK, why is there a coma in your circuit? Purpose?
- If your 'electric comet' is a ROCK, why is there a dust tail shaped by solar radiation pressure?
- If your 'electric comet' is a ROCK, why is there an ion tail driven anti-sunward by the solar wind?
- How does the objects elliptical orbit alter RLC behaviour?
- How does the objects inbound "discharging" leg alter RLC behaviour?
- How does the objects outbound "charging" leg alter RLC behaviour?
- How does your 'electric comet' circuit explain "discharging" observed at 14 AU on the outbound leg?
- What is SWEAP? Define the acronym.
- Why is SWEAP mainstream science?
- Will SAFIRE, as it is configured, be able to replicate SWEAP data?
Remember, Sol88, from a scientific perspective, a model without numbers is just poorly written fiction!!!
Do you really want to dig deeper into why your 'electric space rock' is IMPOSSIBLE? Is so,
Please answer a few more simple questions! From
ASSIGNMENT #000 ...!
- How does 'electric rock' explain the wild variability in the eccentricities tabled above?
- How does 'electric rock' explain observed density discrepancies (noted previously and ignored)?
- How might different rock types explain these mounting 'ec' discrepancies?
- Is your 'electric rock' of IGNEOUS origin? What is your evidence?
- Is your 'electric rock' of METAMORPHIC origin? You know the routine!
- Is your 'electric rock' of SEDIMENTARY origin? How do you know? Fossils?
- Is your 'electric rock' better modeled like THIS?
- How much of your 'electric comet' is consolidated rock? Specific numbers, please!
- How much of your 'electric comet' is machined dust? More numbers, please!
- How much of your 'electric comet' is primordial dust (i.e., unprocessed from the ISM)?
- What is the size distribution of 'electric rock' particles? Power law? Numbers, please!
- What is the technical difference between "rock" and "stone?"
- Why have you moved the goal posts again regarding 'electric comet' composition?
- At what temperature does EDM remove material from a planet? NUMBERS based on thermodynamics, please!
- At what temperature does EDM remove material from a comet? NUMBERS based on thermodynamics, please!
- At what temperature does a "Coulomb explosion" operate? NUMBERS based on thermodynamics, please!
- How is a "Coulomb explosion" even remotely similar to the Wang et al (2016) "patched charge model?"
- What is the EM frequency of the "pulsed solar laser" emitted by your 'electric star?'
- What is the duty cycle for the "pulsed solar laser" emitted by your 'electric star?'
- What is the power output and areal coverage of this "pulsed solar laser?"
- How does an 'electric star' produce and direct a "pulsed solar laser?"
- Why don't we observe the effects of this "pulsed solar laser" on the moon?
- How does eccentricity influence "pulsed solar laser" machining behaviour?
- How did the micro-machining concept of a "Coulomb explosion" become an 'ec' machining mechanism?
- What was the maximum temperature measured at 67P?
- Where are the thermodynamic signatures of EDM or "Coulomb explosions" at 67P?
- What temperatures did Lisse et al (2006) use to determine the IR-based composition of DI impact ejecta?
- How much cold water was observed in the DI impact ejecta?
- How does your 'electric comet' model account for amorphous dust in the DI impact ejecta?
- How much amorphous dust comes from the interstellar medium?
- According to 'eu/ec'
science religious myth, how old is comet 9P?
- According to 'eu/ec'
science religious myth, how old is comet 67P?
- According to 'eu/ec'
science religious myth, how old is KBO 2014 MU69?
- According to your 'eu/ec' religion, what "physics" forced KBO 2014 MU69 from its "point of origin" to its current orbit (a = 44.63 AU, e = 0.0505, i = 2.50, q = 42.38 AU, Q = 46.88)? Magic?
- According to your 'eu/ec' religion, what "physics" forced the orbit of KBO 2014 MU69 to be almost circular (e = 0.0505) in a span of how many years? More magic?
- According to your 'eu/ec' religion, where did comet C/2004 U1 come from (a = 3613 AU, e = 0.9993, i = 130.63, q = 2.66 AU, Q = 7224 AU)? An inclination of 130 degrees?
I'm really curious to find out how old 2014 MU69 is according to the 'electric comet' genesis myth! Any numbers there, Sol88? A real "model" needs numbers! No numbers! No model! Bad fiction!
Now, if you wish to get the most out of this post, I would recommend reading it at least three times before commenting on it!
I would also like you, our resident 'ec' expert to start answering some of the posted questions! The exercise will help you figure out WHY your 'electric comet' is physically IMPOSSIBLE! Just trying to put realistic constraints on things (e.g, Questions 8), 9), 10), 11), 14), 15), and 16)) should make your head "explode!"
Post Script - Did you have any questions about the last column in the
Eccentricity Table? Let me tell you, Sol88, that's some "really really fun stuff" right there!
I've also hidden a couple more clues within this post that should lead you to the A'Hearn et al (TBD) paper, wherein the authors talk about comets NOT being made of "ROCK!" Good luck!
Soon, we will discuss your answers from ASSIGNMENT #001! Are you excited?
