The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
The presence of a non-negligible ambipolar electric field and limited importance of ion-neutral collisional coupling are further supported by observations in the diamagnetic cavity of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko by plasma instruments onboard Rosetta that reveal ion speeds several times higher than the neutral expansion velocity.

Yup, whatever you say jonesdave116 whatever you say.

:rolleyes:
 
So you do know about the suprathermal electrons, don’t you?

:D

Seen at 3 AU, when no DC is formed. And;

Not surprisingly, electrons, from either the coma gas or surface, must be partially confined to the vicinity of the nucleus by an ambipolar electric field as described by the generalized Ohm’s law.

The suprathermal electron distribution can have solar wind origin or can be produced by photoionization, or it can be accelerated inward through various processes such as ambipolar electric field.

but should include the polarization (or ambipolar) electric field, which tends to confine electrons and expel ions in order to maintain quasi-neutrality. This could help to explain the differences between our simple model and the Rubin et al. [2014] study.

The ambipolar field is indicated in the schematic, and this should partially confine lower energy photoelectrons to the ion density structure. Solar wind electrons will be accelerated toward the density enhancement region by this electric field.

Three processes must be operating near the nucleus: (1) collisional cooling of suprathermal electrons through electron-neutral collisions, (2) confinement of the electrons near the nucleus by an ambipolar electric field, and (3) enhancement of the fluxes due to compression of the electron gas near the nucleus. We also showed that at 3 AU within 100 km from the nucleus, cooling of suprathermal electrons through electron-neutral collisions becomes significant and a population of cold thermal electrons begins to build up, which is also confined by the ambipolar electric field.

Suprathermal electrons near the nucleus of comet 67P/Churyumov Gerasimenko at 3 AU: Model comparisons with Rosetta data
Madanian, H. et al.
https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/pdf/10.1002/2016JA022610

So, are we starting to figure out that this field is pointing the wrong way, yet?
 
Yup, whatever you say jonesdave116 whatever you say.

:rolleyes:

Irrelevant. The DC is not formed due to electric fields. And nobody is saying that it is. As I have quoted and linked. Ion and electron-neutral collisions. As stated by actual scientists.
 
Yup, whatever you say jonesdave116 whatever you say.

:rolleyes:

Vigren and Eriksson [2017] used a 1D model to simulate the radial acceleration of water group ions interrupted by collisions (primarily charge transfer processes) with neutral water molecules, taking into account the energy-dependence of the cross-sections. They found that for an out-gassing rate ∼2·1028 s−1, typical of 67P near perihelion, even a weak electric field of 0.03 mV/m, typical of what would be expected for an ambipolar field, is sufficient to partially decouple the ions from the neutrals, giving a bulk ion velocity of about 4 km/s at distances ∼200 km from the nucleus, typical of the Rosetta spacecraft around perihelion. For an outgassing rate ∼2·1029 s−1, closer to that of Halley during the Giotto encounter (6.9·1029 s−1 [Krankowsky et al., 1986]), collisional coupling was found to prevail.

So, no field at Halley.
 
Good, I’m happy with the knowledge you know the DC is caused via ion/electron-neutral collisions and there may only possibly be an ambipolar electric field at at 67P but none at Halley.

Could I hazard a guess and say this would be true, no ambipolar electric field at Tempel 1, Wild 2, Borelly, Hartley 2 and Giacobini–Zinner?
 
Last edited:
Usual lies about mainstream comet science to derail from electric comet insanity

Your outdated way or the new way?...
More from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

Usual lies about mainstream comet science to derail from Sol8's electric comet insanity
The modern comet model is up to date.
There is no "new way" because insane delusions from the Thunderbolts cult made more insane by Sol88 is not science.
An insane lie that mass loading is the solar wind not being deflected when it is the solar wind picking up mass from the coma when it is deflected.
"And the solar wind ion go in a different direction than cometary ions" insanity.
 
Idiocy of asking irrelevant, ignorant, already answered questions again and again

Do you believe there is an ambipolar electric field at comet 67p, Jean tate?
More from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

Idiocy of asking irrelevant, ignorant, already answered questions again and again (ambipolar electric field) to derail from Sol88's electric comet insanity.
 
Insane lying questions to derail from Sol88's electric comet insanity

How do you measure the total power of the Birkeland currents flowing up and down the tail of comets? (You call the field aligned currents)
More from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

Insane lying questions to derail from Sol88's electric comet insanity.
This is Birkeland currents which have only been detected around the Earth and shuld be present around other planets.

Sol88 lies that there are Birkeland currents in comet tails.
Sol88 lies that field aligned currents have to be Birkeland currents. Field aligned currents are a class of current which in specific environments can be Birkeland currents.
Sol88 and his cult's insanity of assigning Birkeland currents to places that they are impossible such as comet tails :eye-poppi!
An insane question because the total power of any currents in the tails is irrelevant and not part of Sol88's electric comet insanity.
 
Emphasizes the electric comet insanity yet again, insane lies, usual insane questions

No , I(and Thornhill’s model) has not deviated from the basic premise that comets are ROCK discharging in the solar plasma. ...
More from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

Emphasizes the electric comet insanity yet again, insane lies, usual insane questions to derail from Sol88's electric comet insanity.
Sol88 writes his usual lie that there is a model and adds more insanity by citing the documented liar Thornhill.
Sol88 writes an insane lie about the electric comet insanity. Comets are not rock. Nothing discharges in a plasma because plasma conducts :jaw-dropp!.
Sol88 writes an insane lie that a set of insane fantasies backed up by lies and with no numeric prediction is more accurate than actual working, predictive science :jaw-dropp!
 
Emphasizes the electric comet insanity yet again with an insane lie

All pretty basic stuff were sublimation is not required or observed, it’s only inferred because when you only have a hammer...:rolleyes:
More from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

Emphasizes the electric comet insanity yet again with an obviously insane lie.
We observe that comets are made of ices and dust. No sublimation is impossible under the conditions that comets experience when they approach the Sun. The ices will sublimate. Additional evidence is inference of the existence of sublimating ices from detecting the gasses they produce and the daughter products of the outgassing.

The lie is obviously insane because Sol88 knows about Deep Impact in 2005, the many detections of ices at comets, etc.
 
Abysmal ignorance and a "all papers have to mention everything" delusion

This, as far as I know, is absolutely brand spanking new for the mainstream sublimation model. The paper however does not mentioned n the negatively charged dust.
More from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

Abysmal ignorance and a "all papers have to mention everything" delusion to derail from Sol88's electric comet insanity.
Astronomers have been modeling comet coma for many decades :eye-poppi!
Scientific papers are supposed to present "absolutely brand spanking new" science :eek:!
The paper does not need to mention the negatively charged dust.
 
Insanity of citing new results in mainstream ices and dust comet papers

.... Onthe ion-neutral coupling in cometary comae by Erik Vigren‹ and Anders I. Eriksson?
...
Cometary Dust Anny-Chantal Levasseur-Regourd1·Jessica Agarwal2·Hervé Cottin3· Cécile Engrand4 ·George Flynn5·Marco Fulle6·Tamas Gombosi7· Yves Langevin8·Jérémie Lasue9·Thurid Mannel10,11·Sihane Merouane2· Olivier Poch12 · Nicolas Thomas13·Andrew Westphal
More from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

Insanity of citing new results in mainstream ices and dust comet papers to derail from Sol88's electric comet insanity.
 
Sol88 repeats Birkeland current insanity to emphasize Sol88's electric comet insanity

If you’d like some more information on Birkeland currents in relation to comets, you maybe able to ask tusenfem. Though you may have to call them force free field aligned currents.
More from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

Sol88 repeats Birkeland current insanity to emphasize Sol88's electric comet insanity.
Birkeland currents have only been detected around Earth.
 
Usual lies to derail from Sol88's electric comet insanity

It rethorical any who but I seem to be running into a lot of resistance from ALL the other posters here on this very basic question.
More from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

Usual lies to derail from Sol88's electric comet insanity.
Sol88's insane and irrelevant ambipolar electric field question has been answered many times.
Ambipolar electric fields are irrelevant (not part of Sol88's electric comet insanity).
The insanity is partially the endless repeating of an already answered question. Also the fact that Sol88 knows that they happen inside the comet coma plasma. Mainly the insanity of lying about Sol88's electric comet insanity which has the delusion of a massively strong, solar electric field.
 
Usual lies to derail from Sol88's electric comet insanity

And I’m not sure if we can discuss the fum part of cometary jets without you first acknowledging that electric fields are a part of the electric comets model.
More from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

Usual lies to derail from Sol88's electric comet insanity.
Posters have acknowledged that Sol88's electric comet insanity has an insane delusion of a solar electric field that needs to be strong enough to support more of that insanity (electric discharges, electric discharge machining, etc.).
 
An insane "been confirmed by the Rosetta mission" lie

...

They are required by the electric comet they are not required by the sublimation model.

They have however been confirmed by the Rosetta mission..
More from Sol88's insane electric comet playbook.

An insane "been confirmed by the Rosetta mission" lie emphasizes Sol88's electric comet insanity.
Comet coma are plasma and will have electric fields. No confirmation is needed. Electric comets still do not exist!(from back when I did not know that Sol88 was spewing out actual insanity from his cult about comets): We measured electric fields around a comet decades ago.
The insanity is Sol88 recently citing "Electric Fields and Cold Electrons in the Vicinity of Comet Halley" by Harri Laakso on May 1, 1991.
The insanity is Sol88 lying about his electric comet insanity which is has an insane delusion of a specific solar electric field.

A minor insanity is Sol88's delusion that the mainstream comet model ("sublimation model") only includes sublimation. Sublimation of ices is a part of the mainstream comet model which describes everything about a comet - the interior of the nucleus, its surface, the coma, tails, interaction with the solar wind, electrostatic dust activity during low activity, etc.

The massive insanity is Sol88's lie that electric fields in coma plasma is not required by the mainstream comet model.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom