The Electric Comet Theory Part IV/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Now you understand a little mainstream plasma physics at comets, do you think the ambipolar electric field is the cause of the diamagnetic cavity?

:D

How the hell would that happen?????? Only an idiot would propose such nonsense. Where was this field at Halley? Where is it at asteroids? Stop making stuff up.
 
Please, fill us in on the details of the Haser model?


I think you’ll find a massively overestimated volatile production from an overly simplistic model.

Aaaaannndddd, another lie. Already linked to the sophisticated shape model used to estimate the volatile production. Stop lying, it is getting tiresome, not to mention pathetic.
 
And you reckon there enough to account for the whole coma and tail?

The nucleus has to be mostly ice and this ice needs to be exposed and on the surface. Problem for you is it’s not.

And more lying. By volume the comet is ~ 1/3rd ice (not including the porosity). And it does not need to be at the surface. Just quit with the lying, yes? 8-18 000 tonnes ejected at Tempel 1. Shed loads of it floating around Hartley 2, and detected around other comets, and almost certainly at 67P.
 
How’s this delusional, reality check?

The non negligible ambipolar electric field is doing “something” is not rc?

Or are you of the same opinion as jd116?

Yes it is there but it doesn’t do anything?

Sounds very familiar.

Think I’ve heard a quote from Thornhill along these lines before, there is electric currents in space but it doesn’t do anything. :rolleyes:

Complete idiocy. What the hell are you claiming that it is doing? You haven't told us. And there are far stronger fields at asteroids. Address it. And such a field was not seen at Halley. Address it. Ambipolar fields are a total irrelevance. The fact that you can't tell us what you think they are doing just proves that.
 
Complete idiocy. What the hell are you claiming that it is doing? You haven't told us. And there are far stronger fields at asteroids. Address it. And such a field was not seen at Halley. Address it. Ambipolar fields are a total irrelevance. The fact that you can't tell us what you think they are doing just proves that.

Do you believe there are ambipolar electric fields at comet 67P, jonesdave116?
 
Just a little reminder for Sol of what his model says;


• The observed jets of comets are electric arc discharges to the nucleus, producing “electrical discharge machining” (EDM) of the surface. The excavated material is accelerated into space along the jets’ observed filamentary arcs.

Lol. Nope. They are gas and dust and (sometimes) ice grains, all heading away from the nucleus. No signatures of EDM (lol). No signatures of discharges to the nucleus. Or anywhere else. Fail.

• Intermittent and wandering arcs erode the surface and burn it black, leaving the distinctive scarring patterns of electric discharges.

More lols! No wandering arcs seen eroding the surface. The surface is black due to the observed organics. Fail.

• The primary distinction between comet and asteroid surfaces is that electrical arcing and “electrostatic cleaning” of the comet nucleus will leave little or no dust or debris on the surface during the active phase, even if a shallow layer of dust may be attracted back to the nucleus electrostatically as the comet becomes dormant in its retreat to more remote regions.

Nope. The comet is producing more dust in the active phase. As would be expected for insolation driven ejection. And the majority of the dust ejected appears to be falling back to the nucleus. So, this supposedly negatively charged dust is being ejected from a supposedly negatively charged comet, and then being attracted back toward the comet? I think not. Fail.


• It is the electric force that holds the spherical cometary coma in place as the
comet races around the Sun. The diameter of the visible coma will often reach millions of miles. And the visible coma is surrounded by an even larger and more “improbable” spherical envelope of fluorescing hydrogen visible in ultraviolet light.

Lai proposed………..This view might seem to be contraindicated by the fact that roughly matching amounts of oxygen are deduced from observed OH emission. Most workers would take this as a support for the concept of water molecules as the source for both dissociated hydrogen and hydroxyl radicals.”

Asteroid and Comet Exploration
Arrhenius, G., Alfven, H., Fitzgerald, R.
https://ntrs.nasa.gov/archive/nasa/c...9730018994.pdf

So, who do we believe? A couple of scientifically illiterate woo merchants who say that it is improbable? Or this Alfven bloke and his co-authors? Fail.


• Comets follow their elongated paths within a weak electrical field centered on the Sun. In approaching the Sun, a charge imbalance develops between the nucleus and the higher voltage and charge density near the Sun. Growing electrical stresses initiate discharges and the formation of a glowing plasma sheath, appearing as the coma and tail.

Whoops! So, why aren't asteroids on elliptical orbits doing this? Why do main belt comets exist, that have low eccentricities? Fail.

• Comets are debris produced during violent electrical interactions of planets and moons in an earlier phase of solar system history. Comets are similar to asteroids, and their composition varies. Most comets should be homogeneous—their interiors will have the same composition as their surfaces. They are simply “asteroids on eccentric orbits.”

See the previous re eccentricity. And cometary material is nothing like any planet or moon known to man. Density is wrong. Ice would not survive impossible electrical woo blasting it off a planet.

So, to summarise - a complete and utter failure. Which could have been avoided had the authors bothered to avail themselves of the data from the Halley missions 20 years previous to that pile of fail being written.

Maybe Sol has forgotten this? Certainly done nothing to challenge it. Proving that he knows, as well as we do, that his quasi-religion has failed.
 
Do you believe there are ambipolar electric fields at comet 67P, jonesdave116?

I have already answered this. Will you stop repeating this nonsense? Quite possibly at 67P. Not seen at Halley. Definitely at asteroids, and weakly active comets. And much stronger than at highly active comets. And is pointing the wrong way at 67P to be doing anything to the dust, most of which is too massive to be affected by such a trifling field anyway. It is a total irrelevance.
 
Do you believe there are ambipolar electric fields at comet 67P, jonesdave116?

Electric fields, charged dust and charged particles, you don’t have to be really smart to work that out.

I bring the latest papers in and you revert back to some archaic papers.

I mean just this one statement from a paper released in March 2018, states

In summary, the simplistic model of dust production resulting from gas drag overcoming gravity is no longer tenable. However, the dominant mechanism is still unclear

We hen have,

However, even in the case of the electrostatic mechanism, some circumstantial evidence can be found. For example, 67P/C-G shows ponded deposits (Thomas et al. 2015b) that are also seen on asteroids and have been attributed to the effect of electrostatic forces (Hartzell et al. 2013).

Dust charging is a delicate interplay between several currents, including electron and ion collection currents from the surrounding plasma, ultraviolet induced photoelectron currents, secondary electron emission (due to energetic ion and/or electron bombardment), thermo-ionic emission, field emission (due to large surface fields), etc. Asaruleofthumb,adustparticle collects about 700 extra electrons per unit particle volume equivalent radius (measured in µm) and unit electric potential difference between the particle surface and the surrounding plasma (measured in V). This means that in the solar wind a particle of 1 µm size can have about 104 extra electrons. Based on our experience with mesospheric dust charging at Earth it can be assumed that most of the extra electrons are deep inside the dust particle and they can electrostatically disrupt fluffy, highly friable dust particles (Hill and Mendis 1981). An updated version (Mendis and Horányi 2013)predicts that a 10−19 kg particle can be electrostatically disrupted if its tensile strength is less than about 0.5 MPa.
https://doi.org/10.1007/s11214-018-0496-3


It was coupled to a combination of large-scale gradients in the probe potentials indicative of large density gradients, and very fast f luctuations in the probe potentials. This was correlated with very regular and intense gradients in the electric field signal.
Statistical analysis of the electric field measurements from the Rosetta spacecraft in the plasma environment of comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko

You’d have to be a complete duffer to not work out what’s going on. :cool:






So that pretty well put the above post into sharp focus.
 
Electric fields, charged dust and charged particles, you don’t have to be really smart to work that out.

I bring the latest papers in and you revert back to some archaic papers.

And the ambipolar field, from the latest papers, IS POINTING THE WRONG WAY. Try to understand that. If it is trapping negatively charged electrons, what is it doing to negatively charged dust? You simply don't understand the paper.

You’d have to be a complete duffer to not work out what’s going on.

No, you'd have to be scientifically illiterate to think that it was doing anything relevant.
 
Last edited:
I have already answered this. Will you stop repeating this nonsense? Quite possibly at 67P. Not seen at Halley. Definitely at asteroids, and weakly active comets. And much stronger than at highly active comets. And is pointing the wrong way at 67P to be doing anything to the dust, most of which is too massive to be affected by such a trifling field anyway. It is a total irrelevance.

What say Ye, jonesdave116?

The dc electric field exhibits a large gradient (the total potential drop over the layer is -135 kV)
Electric Fields and Cold Electrons in the Vicinity of Comet Halley

The cometopause is observed inbound at 160,000 km with a thickness of 10,000 kin. It has a positively charged outer surface and a negatively charged inner surface with a potential drop of 50-100 kV.

And it’s not just one but many.

So, what are you on about again.

Please do try and understand. :blush:

Ignorance only gets you so far. :rolleyes:

Do you believe there are electric fields at comet 67P?

Not possibly but yes or no?

wiggle wiggle wiggle your running out of wiggle sport.

:D
 
And the ambipolar field, from the latest papers, IS POINTING THE WRONG WAY. Try to understand that. If it is trapping negatively charged electrons, what is it doing to negatively charged dust? You simply don't understand the paper.



No, you'd have to be scientifically illiterate to think that it was doing anything relevant.

Are you able to tell me a little more about Suprathermal electron environment of comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko: Observations from the Rosetta Ion and Electron Sensor

And the wrong way round electric field. :rolleyes:

Need a giggle mate, let rip.
 
What say Ye, jonesdave116?

Electric Fields and Cold Electrons in the Vicinity of Comet Halley



And it’s not just one but many.

So, what are you on about again.

Please do try and understand. :blush:

Ignorance only gets you so far. :rolleyes:

Do you believe there are electric fields at comet 67P?

Not possibly but yes or no?

wiggle wiggle wiggle your running out of wiggle sport.

:D

Complete and utter crap. If those measurements were real, and as Tusenfem pointed out, the author tends to doubt them, then they ARE NOWHERE NEAR THE NUCLEUS. The ions inside the DC at Halley were travelling at the same velocity as the neutrals, and all the electrons were cold. Fail.
 
PS

The dust is negatively charged and it is being emitted from the nucleus in colimated jets, how?
 
And the wrong way round electric field.

Read the bloody paper. It is obvious to all but the dimmest, that a field that is accelerating ions, and trapping electrons is the wrong way round to be accelerating dust that is mostly too massive to be affected by such a tiny field. And that the much larger fields at asteroids would have much more effect. And what do we see at asteroids? Zilch.
 
Last edited:
Complete and utter crap. If those measurements were real, and as Tusenfem pointed out, the author tends to doubt them, then they ARE NOWHERE NEAR THE NUCLEUS. The ions inside the DC at Halley were travelling at the same velocity as the neutrals, and all the electrons were cold. Fail.

This paper throws a spanner in your beloved ion-neutral coupling,

These analytical results are in line with previous numerical calculations, adapting similar but not identical field profiles. The presence of a non-negligible ambipolar electric field and limited importance of ion-neutral collisional coupling are further supported by observations in the diamagnetic cavity of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko by plasma instruments onboard Rosetta that reveal ion speeds several times higher than the neutral expansion velocity.
Onthe ion-neutral coupling in cometary comae

So, how does it feel to live in the past, ‘ol mate?

:cool:
 
The dust is negatively charged and it is being emitted from the nucleus in colimated jets, how?

Sublimation. Otherwise, explain why this isn't seen at asteroids. A direct question. Where is your model? Stop trolling, and explain it.
 
This paper throws a spanner in your beloved ion-neutral coupling,

Onthe ion-neutral coupling in cometary comae

So, how does it feel to live in the past, ‘ol mate?

:cool:

Already explained. Not doing it again. You failed. A DC is seen, as at Halley, and you have no mechanism to explain it. Fail.
 
Read the bloody paper. It is obvious to all but the dimmest, that a field that is accelerating ions, and trapping electrons is the wrong way round to be accelerating dust that is mostly too massive to be affected by such a tiny field. And that the much larger fields ar asteroids would have much more effect. And what do we see at asteroids? Zilch.

Do we see jets coming from the nucleus?

Is this dust negatively charged?

Is there a non-negligible ambipolar electric field?

:rolleyes:

We see it a Ceres!
 
Already explained. Not doing it again. You failed. A DC is seen, as at Halley, and you have no mechanism to explain it. Fail.

They are explaining the DC with the ambipolar electric field.

As already touched upon, the picture gets further complicated outside the diamagnetic cavity, where the plasma distribution will be shaped also by the magnetic field and the solar wind motional electric field. We should also emphasize that our model is based on a stationary situation with an electric field profile that remains constant in time. Speculatively, the field profile may rather vary periodically. A decaying potential profile will tend to trap electrons with insufficient energy to overcome the potential barrier. Such electrons will subsequently cool further via collisions closer to the nucleus. Unless effectively removed via dissociative recombination (a process which is more efficient the slower the electrons are), the cold electron population grows and continues to do so up to a point where the resulting reduced electron temperature leads to a diminishing (or even reversal) of the ambipolar electric field that then can allow the cold electrons to escape outwards. This in turn leads back to an outward-pointing ambipolar electric field. Such a scenario would be qualitatively consistent with the time-varying cavity boundary observed on Rosetta (Goetz et al. 2016).

Goose. :blush:

Not your outgassing mass loading model.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom