Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Thank you, Sol88.

Unfortunately, it seems this paper is not relevant to my questions. For example, I could find no mention of Birkeland currents. And there seems to be nothing on the Electric Comet.

Can you help me please; what am I missing?

Vision, independent thinking??? Not sure.

Would you be prepared to read Don Scott’s paper on Birkeland currents (field aligned currents, flux ropes, stringy things...)

There were, however, many short reversals of the field from nearly radially inward to nearly radially outward and then back again.
ENCOUNTER OF THE ULYSSES SPACECRAFT WITH THE ION TAIL OF COMET McNAUGHT

Or you may be able to glean some information from tusenfem and the comets tail! We all eagerly await the publishing of “A tail like no other”.
 
Last edited:
Personally, I think Tusenfem has wasted many years of his career. Instead of all that university stuff, and working at the Alfven Laboratory, and studying reams of data, he could have just come on here to get a lesson in plasma physics from a member of a cult that believe Earth used to orbit Saturn, that the Sun is electric, and that comets are electrified lumps of rock blasted off of Earth by giant thunderbolts. I mean - why wouldn't you?

Not my problem tusenfem as to :boxedin:

Publish or die!
 
Would you be prepared to read Don Scott’s paper on Birkeland currents (field aligned currents, flux ropes, stringy things...)

Which was a complete bunch of nothing, mixed in with utter nonsense. Butterfly nebula = z-pinch! Dear me. Where did you find that bloke?
 
Who cares about DLs? None were seen. None are needed to explain anything. There was also no EDM (lol), and no rock. So the EC is dead. Why don't you leave the experts to get on with the plasma physics? To the best of my knowledge, EU doesn't possess any.

:thumbsup:

You shouldn’t care about double layers. :rolleyes:

Too scary.

Though they DL’s are accelerating electrons off the nucleus and ions to the nucleus?

Phenomena which cannot be understood without explicitly accounting for the current are:
1.Formation of double layers.
2.Energy transfer from one region to another.

And tusenfem will not tell the good people lurking here where he’s currents come from and go to, the circuit! Dodged the question and hand waving it away.

But that’s not important, move along nothing to see here.

Meanwhile over on the dirtysnowball side... How’s those models for “jet” formation coming along?

We still collapsing cliffs? How’s that subsurface energy coming along?

There are quite a few papers out now that are undeniably ELECTRIC COMET centred.

Mainstream just have a different, limited (by the assumption comets are dirty Snowballs) interpretation of the data.



Plasma boundaries caused by outgassing...
 
Last edited:
Which was a complete bunch of nothing, mixed in with utter nonsense. Butterfly nebula = z-pinch! Dear me. Where did you find that bloke?

Don Scott’s paper showed exactly what the RPC team found in the tail of 67P!

As tusenfems paper will show, if it ever gets puplished.
 
Don Scott’s paper showed exactly what the RPC team found in the tail of 67P!

Don Scott couldn't find his own backside with an extra pair of hands! He wants you dead, Sol! He has got fusion occurring in a DL in the chromosphere. Yikes! Or, maybe, given that we aren't all dead, and have managed to evolve over the past 4 Ga, then he is just wrong, and utterly clueless about astrophysical processes. As for his z-pinch nebula......well that's as daft as Thornhill's z-pinch supernova.
What is it with you guys and DLs, z-pinches and Birkeland currents, anyway?
 
Oh, sorry my misunderstanding. :blush:

I thought the solar wind (plasma) was quasi-neutrality with the magnetic field “frozen in”.

yes it is (if you take my comments into account)
again showing that you are only showing off telling you "understand MHD"

Currents in Cometary Comae Martin Volwerk 1

Leads to a few problems this assumption, as Alvfen warned!

No, there is no problem, if you had actually read my explanation about MDH and frozen in. Try figure out why there is no problem.
 
Last edited:
Nope, you just made that up.

5. Summary We presented the first assessment of electron observations from Rosetta IES. We found that electrons are being accelerated upward to several hundreds of eV, which is most likely due to an admixture of photoelectrons and waves produced by the pick-up ion instability. Cross-shock potentials and adiabatic compression acting as a dominant acceleration mechanism appear to be unlikely, but data from future excursions from the comet need to be considered. These results paint a dynamic picture of the plasma environment around comet 67P, which was previously thought to be tranquil for a weakly outgassing comet at large heliocentric distances. The nascent formation of the plasma environment produced by massloading of the solar wind with heavy cometary ions at distances >2 AU plays an important role in the dynamics of the electron environment. Lastly, these observations of the suprathermal electrons are important for the future modeling of cometary photoelectrons, coma chemistry, and charging of small dust grains.

Suprathermal electron environment of comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko: Observations from the Rosetta Ion and Electron Sensor


Another surprise for the mainstream.
 
And tusenfem will not tell the good people lurking here where he’s currents come from and go to, the circuit! Dodged the question and hand waving it away.

But of course I do, they are created by curl B, in a Harris-type current sheet.
Keep on the good work on showing how little you know and how bad your reading skills are.
 
yes it is (if you take my comments into account)
again showing that you are only showing off telling you "understand MHD"



No, there is no problem, if you had actually read my explanation about MDH and frozen in. Try figure out why there is no problem.


Right, so I get the ASSUMPTIONS mainstream make wrt quasi-neutrality and ‘frozen in’ magnetic fields.

So let’s move on...
 
yes it is (if you take my comments into account)
again showing that you are only showing off telling you "understand MHD"


No, there is no problem, if you had actually read my explanation about MDH and frozen in. Try figure out why there is no problem.

Maybe you could fill this ignorumus, and for the lurkers of course, on non classical draping wrt “frozen in” magnetic field lines and quasi-neutrality?

And you could explain for the lurkers just what HARRI LAAKSO paper was banging on about, with the below carry on? http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=12227437#post12227437
 
Last edited:
Vision, independent thinking??? Not sure.

Would you be prepared to read Don Scott’s paper on Birkeland currents (field aligned currents, flux ropes, stringy things...)

ENCOUNTER OF THE ULYSSES SPACECRAFT WITH THE ION TAIL OF COMET McNAUGHT

Or you may be able to glean some information from tusenfem and the comets tail! We all eagerly await the publishing of “A tail like no other”.
What is this DS paper, Sol88? Where was it published, and when?

Perhaps most important, for this thread, what’s in it, re (electric) comets?
 
What is this DS paper, Sol88? Where was it published, and when?

Perhaps most important, for this thread, what’s in it, re (electric) comets?

Birkeland Currents: A Force-Free Field-Aligned Model Donald E. Scott

Fig. 5: The pitch angle of the helical total magnetic field,B
vector,that encircles a field-aligned current changes continuously with in-
creasing radial distance from the central axis of the current. There
are no abrupt quantum jumps or breaks in this angle’s change or
in the field’s magnitude
. One cycle (0◦–360◦) of the pitch angle
is shown. The cycle is sketched at eleven incrementally increasing
sample values of radius. The shaded arrows show the total magnetic
field direction at each value of radius,r, and the white arrows show
the field direction at an increment just below each of those values of
radius.

Fig. 6: Two different sized scale models of a FAC. These are both
Lundquist-Alfv ́en-type images showing the helical structure of the
collinear j and B vectors for small values of radius, r .
This demonstrates why some investigators say that alpha controls the “tightness of twist”. It only appears to do that as a secondary effect because it’s primary effect is as a scale factor on the overall dimensional size (r,z) of the model’s structure.

and

just for tusenfem and his "helical structure" moving down the tail...

24xzxv4.jpg


COMETS AND COMETARY MISSIONS*
D. A. Mendis

This is shown in Fig. 5. It is difficult to
avoid the conclusion, following Alfven [14] , that these rays constitute magnetic
flux tubes
and that their umbrella folding motion is simply their drift in crossed
electric and magnetic fields. While the extreme straightness and stability of
these rays could conceivably be merely a consequence of hypersonic flow[l5] ,
a purely hydrodynamic model does not address itself to the evolution of the rays,
particularly their umbrella folding morphology.

Again "ideal plasma" is not applicable here.

Notice the date on the paper!
 
Last edited:
Nope, you just made that up.


We identified distinct cavity signatures in both the thermal and
suprathermal electron populations as well as in the ion spectrum.
The drop-outs in the suprathermal electron population is interpreted
as the result of this population being bound to the field lines
. These
electrons are accelerated in the magnetic pile-up region, most likely
by a betatron-like mechanism, gyrate along the field lines, and thus
are expelled from the cavity together with the field lines. The thermal
plasma density peaks at the edge of the cavity because as the
plasma flowing from the direction of the nucleus enters the magnetized
region the field immediately traps its electron component.
These density peaks probably lead to enhancements of the electron
current charging the spacecraft, and the resulting strongly negative
spacecraft potential can accelerate ions into the detector, which is
the most probable cause of the detection of 20–40 eV ion bursts
near the edge of the cavity


Electric Fields and Double layers!

any news on the "jets" jd116?

Surely after all those orbits and pictures/movies we know one of the fundamental properties of comets. "outgassing" in "jets" from hidden "ice", :blush:.
 
Originally Posted by Jean Tate: Perhaps most important, for this thread, what’s in it, re (electric) comets?

Birkeland currents or FAC's in the tail of the comet!

Have read of Scott's paper then go back and read ENCOUNTER OF THE ULYSSES SPACECRAFT WITH THE ION TAIL OF COMET McNAUGHT

Important, I think so!
 
Do you think they'll get your paper out soon, tusenfem?

Feel like a kid before Christmas :)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom