Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
My god! you have no idea what MHD is!
Just saying "MHD does not apply" does not mean that you actually know what MDH is.

Here is the original Alfvén paper in which he introduced the concept of MHD waves.

Okay, I am going to hate myself for doing this, but I cannot stand the idiocy of sol making claims without actually showing he understands what the concept of MHD is.

So, what every first-year student learns in "introduction to plasma physics" course is the MDH approximation of the plasma physics equations. This means that you do not look at the motion of individual particles, but like the name says, you assume that the plasma is a fluid. This means that the regular equations are averaged over the motion of the particles.

This means that MHD is only applicable if you look at spatial scales that are larger than the largest ion gyro radius and if you look at time scales that are longer than the longest ion gyro period.

So, basically, you have a multi fluid situation, with an electron fluid and a (multi-)ion fluid.

Now, Alfvén made an extra assumption in his paper, namely that the plasma conductivity σ = ∞ (infinitely conducting). If you do that, then you find that this results into E + v x B = 0, which leads to the interesting situation that the plasma and the magnetic field are frozen in.

Of course, space plasmas are very highly conducting, but not infinitely, so this leads to so-called "resistive MHD" in contrast to "ideal MHD" that Aflven wrote up in his 1942 paper. That certainly changes a few things, adding resistivity into the system. For example, then there are restrictions on the frozen in condition. One can only speak of the field being frozen in the plasma as long as you look at time scales which are below the magnetic diffusion time scale. This is basically the inverse of the conductivity.

In ideal MHD, there cannot be parallel electric fields, because of the infinite conductivity. However, does that exclude parallel electric currents? Currents, we know from Maxwell's equations, are either generated by a time varying electric field or by a changing magnetic field:

curl(B) = mu ( J + epsilon dE/dt )

so if something happens to the magnetic field, for example the foot points of a loop can shear, and thereby generate currents.

For the rest I would just point to the excellent chapter by Eric Priest in the Saas-Fee Advanced Course Lecture Notes (which can be found on the internet as pdf)

So actually it is very very simple what MDH means, and how it should be applied, and which limitations there are (and indeed very few of my colleagues seem to forget now and then these limitations, unfortunately)

Excellent post, this should clear up all the misconception people have on MHD. I appreciate the time you have taken out of your busy schedule to compile a concise succinct post.

So basically, if you "step back" far enough and do not take into account a few complicating factors plasma's can be considered ideal and MHD applies, greatly simplifying the maths?

Much the same way is if we "step back" far enough plasma (Space Plasma) can be considered Quasi-neutral?

More or less.

Would this be the correct understanding of the above 2 interpretations, tusenfem?

If my understanding is correct, we can then move forward without having to be accused of not understanding "basic" plasma physics.
 
Last edited:
As the only ISF member who (apparently) knows anything about the Electric Comet idea, I have a serious question (two actually) for you, Sol88:

What happens to a comet when it encounters a field aligned current?

During the time Rosetta was observing it - up close and from afar - did 67/P encounter any Birkeland currents? If so, when?

tusenfem has a paper on just such a question.

CME impact on comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko

Is this the answer you are looking for?
 
Last edited:
Excellent post, this should clear up all the misconception people have on MHD. I appreciate the time you have taken out of your busy schedule to compile a concise succinct post.

Ha! If you understanding had been so good as you claim below, you would have written this, convincing us that you actually understand.

So basically, if you "step back" far enough and do not take into account a few complicating factors plasma's can be considered ideal and MHD applies, greatly simplifying the maths?

What "step back"? What "complicated factors"?

Much the same way is if we "step back" far enough plasma (Space Plasma) can be considered Quasi-neutral?
More or less.

More less than more

Would this be the correct understanding of the above 2 interpretations, tusenfem?

If my understanding is correct, we can then move forward without having to be accused of not understanding "basic" plasma physics.

No, there is nothing "simple" about MHD, get a book on MDH. You seem to have a weird idea of what plasma physics is.

But I guess I will stop, before the moderators throw this all away.
 
Ha! If you understanding had been so good as you claim below, you would have written this, convincing us that you actually understand.



What "step back"? What "complicated factors"?



More less than more



No, there is nothing "simple" about MHD, get a book on MDH. You seem to have a weird idea of what plasma physics is.
You
But I guess I will stop, before the moderators throw this all away.

Field aligned currents, Birkeland currents, flux ropes, double layers, electrostatic shocks... etc MHD does not apply.

Correct or incorrect, tusenfem?
 
Field aligned currents, Birkeland currents, flux ropes, double layers, electrostatic shocks... etc MHD does not apply.

Correct or incorrect, tusenfem?

incorrect
color me surprised that Eric Priest, MHD expert, has in his lecture notes on magnetohydrodynamics the following picture of a flux rope ...



You know nothing, John Sol, discussion closed
 
incorrect
color me surprised that Eric Priest, MHD expert, has in his lecture notes on magnetohydrodynamics the following picture of a flux rope ...

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/imagehosting/254845ab4e3eeaad5a.jpg[/qimg]

You know nothing, John Sol, discussion closed

Oh...so a “flux rope” has no force free field aligned component?



Ok then. :boggled:

Electric potential jumps in the Io-Jupiter flux tube S. Hessa,b,, P. Zarkab, F. Motteza, V.B. Ryabovc

We also found evidence of acceleration structures, at all time (or longitude). These structures accelerate the electrons towards Jupiter in a direction parallel to the magnetic field (the electron magnetic moment is unchanged). They correspond to electric potential drops of a few hundreds of volts.

So who should we believe tusenfem?

Is MHD applicable here, tusenfem?

Is MHD applicable in the paper on CME impacts on 67P, wrt “flux tubes”?
 
Last edited:
Basically MHD does not apply at the ELECTRIC COMET.

So why bang on about it?
 
To date, the focus of modeling studies to predict and explain the complex cometary plasma observations has been on magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) or multifluid [14–19] and hybrid (using a kinetic description for the ions but describing the electrons as a massless fluid) [20–26] simulations, leading to comprehensive models for the ion dynamics. A satisfactory explanation for the observed electron dynamics, however, is not yet available. 0031-9007=17=118(20)=205101(6) For instance, the Ion and Electron Sensor (IES) instrument onboard the Rosetta orbiter shows the presence of nonthermal electron distributions inside the inhomogeneous expanding cometary ionosphere, including both a warm (∼5 eV) and suprathermal (10–20 eV) component [27–29]. The origin and physical mechanism behind the various components of the observed electron distributions is unclear, but must be understood to disentangle the cometary plasma dynamics.

Identifying the origin of the suprathermal electron populationdeliverscluestothephysicalmechanismbehindtheir acceleration or heating in the collisionless coma. Two mechanisms have been discussed in literature thus far: (i) heating of electrons through wave particle interactions, such as the singing comet waves (understood as an ion Weibel instability [43,52]) or lower hybrid waves [45], and (ii) the acceleration of electrons along the ambipolar electric field [29]. In the second scenario, solar wind electrons traveling toward the comet fall into the potential well that is generated by the gradient in electron number density [53,54]. Electrons born inside, i.e., the cometary electrons, are trapped unless they carry enough energy to escape. The potential scales as the electron thermal energy [29]; hence, only suprathermal electrons will be able to escape the nearcomet environment. Note that this interpretation is valid on subion time scales only, as quasineutrality will act such that electrons must eventually leave the potential well. Without ruling out the influence of wave particle interactions, our simulation favors the ambipolar electric field model, though this may not betIdentifying the origin of the suprathermal electron populationdeliverscluestothephysicalmechanismbehindtheir acceleration or heating in the collisionless coma. Two mechanisms have been discussed in literature thus far: (i) heating of electrons through wave particle interactions, such as the singing comet waves (understood as an ion Weibel instability [43,52]) or lower hybrid waves [45], and (ii) the acceleration of electrons along the ambipolar electric field [29]. In the second scenario, solar wind electrons traveling toward the comet fall into the potential well that is generated by the gradient in electron number density [53,54]. Electrons born inside, i.e., the cometary electrons, are trapped unless they carry enough energy to escape. The potential scales as the electron thermal energy [29]; hence, only suprathermal electrons will be able to escape the nearcomet environment. Note that this interpretation is valid on subion time scales only, as quasineutrality will act such that electrons must eventually leave the potential well. Without ruling out the influence of wave particle interactions, our simulation favors the ambipolar electric field model, though this may not9 be the case at other activity phases of the comet.hecase a to the r activity phases ofthecomet.

Electron and Ion Dynamics of the Solar Wind Interaction with a Weakly Outgassing Comet Decca

Uh oh....

Step back far enough and viola quasi neutrality, an ideal plasma!
 
Last edited:
Eric Priest‘S paper, would you happen to have a link, tusenfem?

Can’t quite make out the picture and would love to read the experts paper.
 
Last edited:
22 March 2018: Repeats his lie of DLs found around comets in a Laako paper.

22 March 2018: A lie about the definition of a [URL="https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Double_layer_(plasma_physics)double layer[/URL] being a potential drop.
The definition is "A double layer is a structure in a plasma consisting of two parallel layers of opposite electrical charge." and "typically ten Debye lengths". The potential drop is a consequence of the charge separation and falls on one side of the DL, rises on the other side. Laako only reports a potential drop.

You’re welcome rc :)
 
Basically MHD does not apply at the ELECTRIC COMET.
So why bang on about it?

Because there is no such thing as an electric comet. As proven. With or without MHD, your nonsense is still an evidence-free zone. No rock, no EDM (lol).
 
Eric Priest‘S paper, would you happen to have a link, tusenfem?

Can’t quite make out the picture and would love to read the experts paper.

It is in a book that I quoted before, if you put some effort in you might even find a pdf on the internet through sci-hub
doi = 10.1007/3-540-31627-2
 
Last edited:
Electron and Ion Dynamics of the Solar Wind Interaction with a Weakly Outgassing Comet Decca

Uh oh....

Step back far enough and viola quasi neutrality, an ideal plasma!

"Quasi-neutrality" and "ideal plasma" are obviously not the same!
 
Personally, I think Tusenfem has wasted many years of his career. Instead of all that university stuff, and working at the Alfven Laboratory, and studying reams of data, he could have just come on here to get a lesson in plasma physics from a member of a cult that believe Earth used to orbit Saturn, that the Sun is electric, and that comets are electrified lumps of rock blasted off of Earth by giant thunderbolts. I mean - why wouldn't you?
 
"Quasi-neutrality" and "ideal plasma" are obviously not the same!


Oh, sorry my misunderstanding. :blush:

I thought the solar wind (plasma) was quasi-neutrality with the magnetic field “frozen in”.

It took another six years for a complete model of the interaction of the solar wind with an outgassing comet and the creation of cometary tails. Using the relatively new theory of magnetohydrodynamics [MHD, Alfv´en, 1942], it was shown by Alfv´en [1957] how the solar wind with frozen in magnetic eld would drape itself around the active nucleus, see Fig. 3AA.

Volwerk et al. [2016b] studied May, June and July 2015 in order to nd nested-draping and associated current sheets. Fig. 8CC shows the June yby, where the axes are not equally scaled to enhance the clarity of the eld line draping. the main pattern is that for CSEQ the eld vectors are mainly red, indicating sunward directed eld, whereas on the other side the eld vectors are mainly blue, pointing away from the Sun. However, there is a mixing of the colours, which means that there is a certain amount of nested draping. An example of such a magnetic eld rotation is shown in Fig. 9AA [see also, Volwerk et al., 2016b]. In the gray box there is a strong rotation of the cone-angle of the magnetic eld, accompanied by a minimum in (low-pass ltered) total magnetic eld, lBm, and a peak in the electron density e measured by the mutual impedance probe [MIP, Trotignon et al., 2006]. These are the signatures one expects for crossing a current sheet. Assuming that the magnetic field moves together with the plasma (i.e. frozen in) at a velocity given by the ion and electron spectrometer [IES, Burch et al., 2006], km/s, a thickness of the rotation region can be obtained and thereby the current density of the embedded current sheet using Eq. (15). This results in cs nA/m2 for the rotation in Fig. 9AA, but stronger current sheets up to nA/m2 have also been found [Volwerk et al., 2016b].
Currents in Cometary Comae Martin Volwerk 1

Leads to a few problems this assumption, as Alvfen warned!
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom