Ziggurat
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Jun 19, 2003
- Messages
- 64,419
Now your getting somewhere. we can't see into the cooler interior of the Sun (except in Sun spots) but we can see the nucleus of a comet!
The interior of the sun cannot be cooler. That's a thermodynamic impossibility.
And yes, I know you're going to ask about how the corona is hotter than the photosphere. But that's quite easy: the corona is mostly transparent, which is relevant for two reasons. First, that means heat can escape from inside. And second, very little heat is transferred from the corona to the photosphere.
But the photosphere is completely opaque. So it's not possible for what is inside the photosphere to be at lower temperature than the photosphere. You don't need to know anything about stellar dynamics to understand this. Violating it is literally the equivalent of believing in perpetual motion machines. I don't mean that as an analogy, I mean that the physics required would lead directly to that. Do you believe in perpetual motion machines, Sol?

:

