Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Now your getting somewhere. we can't see into the cooler interior of the Sun (except in Sun spots) but we can see the nucleus of a comet!

The interior of the sun cannot be cooler. That's a thermodynamic impossibility.

And yes, I know you're going to ask about how the corona is hotter than the photosphere. But that's quite easy: the corona is mostly transparent, which is relevant for two reasons. First, that means heat can escape from inside. And second, very little heat is transferred from the corona to the photosphere.

But the photosphere is completely opaque. So it's not possible for what is inside the photosphere to be at lower temperature than the photosphere. You don't need to know anything about stellar dynamics to understand this. Violating it is literally the equivalent of believing in perpetual motion machines. I don't mean that as an analogy, I mean that the physics required would lead directly to that. Do you believe in perpetual motion machines, Sol?
 
Quite fiver on it?

Have a thousand on it, for all I care. There is nothing that a metal sphere, plugged into the mains, can tell us about anything going on at comets. Is the metal sphere composed of ice and dust? Does it develop a diamagnetic cavity, as seen by Giotto, at the same time as the Vega fly-bys? Does it reproduce the quasi-neutral solar wind? Or the IMF? No, of course it doesn't. Therefore it is of no relevance. The AMPTE experiments were of far more relevance.
 
But the photosphere is completely opaque. So it's not possible for what is inside the photosphere to be at lower temperature than the photosphere. You don't need to know anything about stellar dynamics
zggurat


^^^^^^^

Is that mathamajics translated into a form of English?
 
Since Sol88 will never answer, I'll make the purpose of this question more explicit.

A metal has a work function. The existence of a work function is fundamental to the behavior of any current flowing through the surface of that metal. Plasmas do not have work functions. Therefore the behavior of current through a plasma is fundamentally different from the behavior of current through a metal surface.

So, what's the sun made of? A plasma.

For people so obsessed with the electrical properties of a plasma, it's quite remarkable (but not surprising) that these EU folks can't recognize that a plasma isn't a metal.

The corona/photosphere most definitely. :thumbsup:

Whole other thread that but it is fundamental to the EC model.

When u mob come up with a coherent model on the coronas temp, call me.
 
zggurat


^^^^^^^

Is that mathamajics translated into a form of English?

You can express it mathematically, but it's actually very basic common sense. If a hot object and a cold object are in thermal contact, which way does heat flow?

You're claiming that heat flows from the cold object to the hot object. And that's, well, stupid.
 
The corona/photosphere most definitely. :thumbsup:

Whole other thread that but it is fundamental to the EC model.

When u mob come up with a coherent model on the coronas temp, call me.

The most notable feature of the sun isn't the corona's temperature. The most notable feature of the sun is its total power output. You can't even get the most basic and essential stuff close to right. Why would I care about how you fiddle around at the edges?
 
What is the Debye length, and why does it matter?

Ummmm....I don’t know, let’s ask an EXPERT, ay jd116? Somewhere where we have actually got some data on.

In Tusenfems paper Current sheets in comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko's coma

Or Decca’s paper Electron and Ion Dynamics of the Solar Wind Interaction with a Weakly Outgassing Comet

How does the Debye length and force free currents come into play in answer to jd116’s question.

We can then move back to my favourite plasma phenomena, current carrying “DOUBLE LAYERS” :jaw-dropp
 
Last edited:
You can express it mathematically, but it's actually very basic common sense. If a hot object and a cold object are in thermal contact, which way does heat flow?

You're claiming that heat flows from the cold object to the hot object. And that's, well, stupid.


NO, the ELECTRIC SUN claims the exact statement above as being contradicted by the observed temperature of the corona compared with the photosphere!

The only other place on the sun we’ve measured the temperature :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
Ummmm....I don’t know, let’s ask an EXPERT, ay jd116? Somewhere where we have actually got some data on.

In Tusenfems paper Current sheets in comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko's coma

Or Decca’s paper Electron and Ion Dynamics of the Solar Wind Interaction with a Weakly Outgassing Comet

How does the Debye length and force free currents come into play in answer to jd116’s question.

We can then move back to my favourite plasma phenomena, current carrying “DOUBLE LAYERS” :jaw-dropp

Who cares about DLs? None were seen. None are needed to explain anything. There was also no EDM (lol), and no rock. So the EC is dead. Why don't you leave the experts to get on with the plasma physics? To the best of my knowledge, EU doesn't possess any.
 
The most notable feature of the sun isn't the corona's temperature. The most notable feature of the sun is its total power output. You can't even get the most basic and essential stuff close to right. Why would I care about how you fiddle around at the edges?

ONE of THE most notable features of the Sol is the Coronal temperature! :D

And the SAFIRE project looks like it has already discovered something very similar wrt input/output!

Your problem is the steadfast belief in there being “no power socket” for the Sun to be able to be “plugged into the mains”.

But getting off topic sorta because as I said, ELECTRIC COMET = ELECTRIC SUN = ELECTRIC UNIVERSE....
 
Last edited:
ONE of THE most notable features of the Sol is the Coronal temperature! :D

And the SAFIRE project looks like it has already discovered something very similar wrt input/output!

Your problem is the steadfast belief in there being “no power socket” for the Sun to be able to be “plugged into the mains”.

I'll repeat - the Sun is not a metal sphere, and it does not have a current running from anywhere to power it. Therefore, whatever they have found is relevant only to people who are interested in what happens when you put a squillion volts through metal balls. Otherwise, irrelevant.
 
Who cares about DLs? None were seen. None are needed to explain anything. There was also no EDM (lol), and no rock. So the EC is dead. Why don't you leave the experts to get on with the plasma physics? To the best of my knowledge, EU doesn't possess any.

Sorry. :cool:

What, ummm, do you know about current carrying double layers, jd116?
 
I know what Tusenfem told you; there aren't any detected at 67P. They are not needed at 67P to explain anything.

Meh....:whistling :

Stop being a :dqueen

Have a chill pill and Come over here for a big :grouphug5

The papers coming out by the mainstream are slowly coming around to the idea, comets are NOT dirtysnowballs.

:monkeyr:

I personally eagerly await M.Volwerks new paper on 67P tail excursions with Rosetta RPC suite of goodies.

Not long now ay, tusenfem?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom