Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
So, let us summarise the eejitical (is that a word? If not, I claim it as my own invention) reaction of the EU woo merchants so far:
Evidence in favour of their woo - zero.
Evidence argued for it (EU whining) - well the crater at Tempel 1 was big' cos there was some electrical woo.
Answer: No there wasn't. As shown by Chandra and SWIFT.
EU woo: Oooh, the comet is hard, as per Philae.
Answer: Nowhere near hard enough to be rock. As shown by MUPUS.
EU woo: the water is created by......s*** we don't actually know, but it's probably something to do with the solar wind, or hydrated thingies......
Answer: go back to school.
EU woo: there will be loads of electrical woo happening at the comet.
Answer: Errr, no. Didn't happen dears. Go away, and invest a shed load in homeopathy. Far more chance of that being right than this asinine nonsense. Eh?
Anything else, woo boys? Thought not, goodnight.
 
You're welcome. Mind you, it is the equivalent of shooting fish in a barrel.

yes, I have read through and participated in many versions of the Electrical Universe and EC threads. I got worn out after a while. Sol88 seems to have a mind numbing quality to their posts

BeAChooser, Zeuzzz and many posters gone by...
 
Ummm...no.

But I do think ^^^^^^ that happens.

Along with



And a do you realise the RSI also used two bands.

Rock and jazz I think.

so basically you think that determining changes in velocity through the carrier signal's doppler shift is the same as gps localisation .... mmmm interesting
 
so basically you think that determining changes in velocity through the carrier signal's doppler shift is the same as gps localisation .... mmmm interesting

The variables involved lead the result to be “best fit” with our assumptions on the the bulk density...

In practice, the spacecraft orbital elements after the last ma- noeuvre before closest approach will be computed from the radio tracking directly after this manoeuvre. The post-manoeuvre tra- jectory will be extrapolated by solving the equation of motion for Rosetta to many hours after closest approach, assuming that the asteroid and its perturbing forces are not present. This extrap- olated unperturbed trajectory, the gravity attraction of all planets acting on Rosetta, the knowledge of the precise location of the ground station on the surface, the Earth rotation, plate tectonics, solid Earth tides, the position of the antenna phase centres on ground, and relativistic propagation effects, all provide the ba- sis for the computation of the relative velocity vector along the line-of-sight (LOS). This leads to a predicted Doppler shift and, together with the transmitted carrier frequency, to a predicted received frequency for all times during and after the flyby.
Pre-flyby estimates of the precision of the mass determination of asteroid (21) Lutetia from Rosetta radio tracking

And the electric field or charge on the target object!
 
The variables involved lead the result to be “best fit” with our assumptions on the the bulk density...

Pre-flyby estimates of the precision of the mass determination of asteroid (21) Lutetia from Rosetta radio tracking

And the electric field or charge on the target object!

What charge on the object? It has already been shown that this would need to be ginormous. You were shown the calculation. You were asked to show where it was wrong. You couldn't.
You also seem to forget that the charge on the spacecraft was variable. Therefore bound orbits would be a nightmare; every time Rosetta's charge changed, so would its orbit. You also seem to forget that both Philae and Rosetta landed on this comet. All of this without having to include any calculations for impossible, non-existent charge repulsion idiocy.
It is nonsense. Pure woo.
 
Last edited:
Well hasn’t the SAFIRE project got some stark truths the mainstream are going to spit the dummy over!

SAFIRE project update.

Some brilliant stuff in there on double layers and the funkyness of plasma!

Now to dig those papers out on electron density, suprathermal electrons, negatively charged nano-dust, cold and warm electron populations and especially electric fields and cold electrons at 1P.
 
Ahhhh I see the problem here. :blush:

So, what is the problem? The comet has a measured density of ~535 kg m-3. You want it to be > 2 000 kg m-3. The charge on the spacecraft varies from a few Volts positive, to about 20 Volts negative. Work out the charge needed on the comet to make 2 000 kg m-3 appear to be 535 kg m-3. Surely somebody has done this already? Well, as it happens, they have. And the answer is many, many gigavolts. Funny how we didn't notice that.
So, when are the EU geniuses going to do the calculation? Why haven't they done it already? I think we all know the answer to that.
 
Well hasn’t the SAFIRE project got some stark truths the mainstream are going to spit the dummy over!

SAFIRE project update.

Some brilliant stuff in there on double layers and the funkyness of plasma!

Now to dig those papers out on electron density, suprathermal electrons, negatively charged nano-dust, cold and warm electron populations and especially electric fields and cold electrons at 1P.

Lol. First question will be - you have a metallic sphere; is that what the Sun is made of? Second; you plugged it into the mains. Where is the solar system equivalent? Thirdly; we already know how the Sun works, and there is mountains of evidence for it. Why would we need to look at this nonsense? Next.
 
Well hasn’t the SAFIRE project got some stark truths the mainstream are going to spit the dummy over!

SAFIRE project update.

Some brilliant stuff in there on double layers and the funkyness of plasma!

Now to dig those papers out on electron density, suprathermal electrons, negatively charged nano-dust, cold and warm electron populations and especially electric fields and cold electrons at 1P.


Let’s see, SAFIRE, SAFIRE...oh yeah! Is that the so-called project where some Thunderbolts clowns dick around with a terrella in a vacuum chamber until they produce a plasma on it, and then take pictures of it so scientifically ignorant folks will believe because a round thingy can be made to glow the Sun must be powered by electricity? You mean that SAFIRE project? That had ****-all to do with comets?
 
Let’s see, SAFIRE, SAFIRE...oh yeah! Is that the so-called project where some Thunderbolts clowns dick around with a terrella in a vacuum chamber until they produce a plasma on it, and then take pictures of it so scientifically ignorant folks will believe because a round thingy can be made to glow the Sun must be powered by electricity? You mean that SAFIRE project? That had ****-all to do with comets?

Silly buggers, they are! Why waste all that money when u can ask Fred burfle how double layers are formed and sustained.

So how is mainstreams attempt at magnetic confinement going nowadays anyway?

The above NEW SAFIRE data can now put “Electric Fields and Cold Electrons in the Vicinity of Comet Halley” into a whole new light!
 
Lol. First question will be - you have a metallic sphere; is that what the Sun is made of? Second; you plugged it into the mains. Where is the solar system equivalent? Thirdly; we already know how the Sun works, and there is mountains of evidence for it. Why would we need to look at this nonsense? Next.

Why bother you still can’t grasp the absolute basics of the EU, there is change separation in space.

So go play with the other kids over in the black hole, neutron star, dark matter/energy sand box!

A lot less threatening and you won’t feel all put out.
 
Lol. First question will be - you have a metallic sphere; is that what the Sun is made of?

Since Sol88 will never answer, I'll make the purpose of this question more explicit.

A metal has a work function. The existence of a work function is fundamental to the behavior of any current flowing through the surface of that metal. Plasmas do not have work functions. Therefore the behavior of current through a plasma is fundamentally different from the behavior of current through a metal surface.

So, what's the sun made of? A plasma.

For people so obsessed with the electrical properties of a plasma, it's quite remarkable (but not surprising) that these EU folks can't recognize that a plasma isn't a metal.
 
The above NEW SAFIRE data can now put “Electric Fields and Cold Electrons in the Vicinity of Comet Halley” into a whole new light!

Nope. It'll be a total irrelevance, and will never even be published. Except maybe in some crank or irrelevant journal. Nothing whatsoever to do with Halley. Or any other comet.
 
What’s generating the electric fields at a comet, jd116?

Why don't you read the papers or, even easier, listen to what an actual plasma physicist has been telling you for years?
 
Since Sol88 will never answer, I'll make the purpose of this question more explicit.

A metal has a work function. The existence of a work function is fundamental to the behavior of any current flowing through the surface of that metal. Plasmas do not have work functions. Therefore the behavior of current through a plasma is fundamentally different from the behavior of current through a metal surface.

So, what's the sun made of? A plasma.

For people so obsessed with the electrical properties of a plasma, it's quite remarkable (but not surprising) that these EU folks can't recognize that a plasma isn't a metal.

Now your getting somewhere. we can't see into the cooler interior of the Sun (except in Sun spots) but we can see the nucleus of a comet!
 
Last edited:
Why don't you read the papers or, even easier, listen to what an actual plasma physicist has been telling you for years?

I have...

It has a positively charged outer surface
and a negatively charged inner surface with a potential drop of
50-100 kV. A current layer, with a thickness of 22,000 km and
the electric current flowing from dusk to dawn located on Vega
1 outside the cometo pause to distance of 8,000 kin
:D

Now what have SAFIRE discovered....
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom