Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Dynamic molecular oxygen production in cometary comae

Which would be of interest to jd116, in relation to he’s above assertions and my assertions on why double layers are of some importance in the cometary context.

I think there is a refutal paper being written about this paper, by several Rosetta scientists.
 
Mmmm....what could be doing the ‘accelerating’ I wonder?

.......and we are back to double layers, field aligned electric currents, ‘magtagic’ Reconnection and all that wonderful plasma stuff.

If you would read Hans Nilsson's papers you would know what is accelerating the water ions.

Nilsson et al. 2015 said:
the newborn ion is accelerated by the solar wind electric field

But then again, it is much easier to just assume something, instead of looking up what is actually measured.

Any chances of being able to read your new paper tusenfem?

It has been sent back to the journal last week, I guess I will get the acceptance email this week. When it will be published, I have no say in that.

Here is the abstract in the rather quaint Astronomy & Astrophysics format.

me et al. said:
Abstract
Context. The Rosetta Plasma Consortium (RPC) magnetometer (MAG) data during the tail excursion in March - April 2016 are used to investigate the magnetic structure of and activity in the tail region of the weakly outgassing comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko (67P/CG).
Aims. The goal of this study is to compare the large scale (near) tail structure with that of earlier missions to strong outgassing comets, and the small scale turbulent energy cascade (un)related to the singing comet phenomenon.
Methods. The usual methods of space plasma physics are used to analyze the magnetometer data, such as minimum variance analysis, spectral analysis and power law fitting. Also the cone- and clock-angle of the magnetic field are calculated to interpret the data.
Results. It is found that comet 67P/CG does not have a classical draped magnetic field and no bilobal tail structure at this late stage of the mission, with the comet already at 2.7 AU distance from the Sun. The main magnetic field direction seems to be more across the tail direction, which may implicate an asymmetric pick-up cloud. During periods of singing comet activity the propagation direction of the waves is at large angles with respect to the magnetic field and to the radial direction towards the comet. Turbulent cascade of magnetic energy from large to small scales is different in the presence of singing as without it.
 
@ Reality Check

[qimg]https://freeclipartimage.com//storage/upload/pinocchio-clip-art/pinocchio-clip-art-7.gif[/qimg]

Yea, he's a known confabulator here. Since most people here do only haphazard due diligence, it works for him because it confirms the preconceptions (albeit misguided) of the audience rather quickly.
 
If the water is being made electrically, much to jd116’s utter horror, then it solves a whole lot more problems than the mainstreams model presents.

It isn't. There is no 'electrical' mechanism that can explain either the ice or the vapour. Please show this non-existent mechanism, and relate it mathematically to the observed outgassing rate.
 
Dynamic molecular oxygen production in cometary comae



Which would be of interest to jd116, in relation to he’s above assertions and my assertions on why double layers are of some importance in the cometary context.

As Tusenfem mentioned, that paper is way off base. It has been discussed before. Their numbers, not to mention the mechanism, would appear to be in disagreement with observation. And how many negative O ions have been detected in the inner coma? Numbers please, as a comparison to the H2O outgassing rate.
 
So dramas ahead for the dirtysnowball!

Err, no. As you quoted yourself, this is expected. And, in case it has escaped your attention, ice and vapour are not exactly lacking in detection at comets. However, all the electric woo promised by T & T is most definitely conspicuous by its absence. So, as the EC crowd are still batting zero, where is the drama? Certainly not in the camp of real science.
 
Sol88: Resorts to a pathetic insult rather than addressing his lies

@ Reality Check
@Sol88:
5 December 2017 Sol88: Resorts to a pathetic insult rather than addressing his overt lies

It is very simple to understand.
A delusion requiring that comets be blasted off a wet planet such as Earth means that its minerals are wet. It is a lie to cite an observation that 67P minerals are dry to support his comet delusions.
Lie 1: Yu. V. Skorov did not cast doubt on all of gas dragging.
Lie 2: "dirtysnowball model"
Lie 3: " Sounds a bit like rock" when quoting the analysis of dust from a comet made of ices and dust.
Lie 4: "dramas ahead for the dirtysnowball!" when what he highlights is a problem for his comet delusions :eek:!
Planets such as the Earth have lots of water. Their minerals are hydrated. That not hydrated "very pristine material" is material that does not exist on planets.
Any citation of mainstream papers is a lie that comets are rock because they are about comets made ices and dust.
Any mention of double layers is a lie because no double layers have been detected around comets as he knows (40 odd abstracts for 'comet double layer' out of 13.4 million).
The insanity of denying the physics he has been told about in this thread in over 8 years leads to more lies, e.g. it is a lie that detecting energetic negative ions is imaginary double layers.

His comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; etc. etc.

441 items of ignorance, idiocy (citing irrelevant mainstream papers), delusion and lies dating from 29 August 2016 to 24 November 2017 (maybe hundreds more in the last 8 years!)
 
Last edited:
Yea, ....
Oh dear Sol88: Support from someone with the delusion that planets are old stars. You may want to distance yourself from him. On the other hand you are content being associated with the Thunderbolts cult so I do not have any high hopes of you being sensible.

And yea - jeffreyw is ignorant/deluded enough to be an electric universe (as in Thunderbolts) acolyte.

For others: jeffreywhas stated 220 items of ignorance and delusion since 15th January 2015 in The General Theory of Stellar Metamorphosis thread. The idiocy starts with stars such as the Sun insanely (he denies stellar fusion!) changing into rock and magically losing 99.9999% of their mass to become gas and then rocky planets. There is the stupidity of stars capturing planets at random to form the fairly ordered systems we see, e.g. the Solar System. There is the insanity of assigning planets ages that are older than the universe. The usual crank delusion that working science is dogma. Plenty of lies about science.
 
Err, no. As you quoted yourself, this is expected. And, in case it has escaped your attention, ice and vapour are not exactly lacking in detection at comets. However, all the electric woo promised by T & T is most definitely conspicuous by its absence. So, as the EC crowd are still batting zero, where is the drama? Certainly not in the camp of real science.

When we say dirty, we don’t just mean the dust but also the organics.

That’s a dirtyicedustball or some such? How’s Whipples model get those to accrete way out whoop whoop.

Organics, not a problem, just give me an electric field of the right magnitude.
 
Sol88: Usual irrelevant inanity to derail from his comet delusions

When we say dirty...
5 December 2017 Sol88: Usual irrelevant inanity to derail from his comet delusions.
He exposes his continued ignorance of the basic facts of comets making his comet delusions even more unfounded. With the ignorance that imagining any problem in the working model of comets as ices and dist supports his physically impossible comet delusions.
His comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; etc. etc.

441 items of ignorance, idiocy (citing irrelevant mainstream papers), delusion and lies dating from 29 August 2016 to 24 November 2017 (maybe hundreds more in the last 8 years!)

What jonesdave116 actually wrote was that you lied about what you quoted, ice and vapour have been detected at comets and that your electric woo has never been detected at comets.

Researchers present list of comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko ingredients
"Of course, Rosetta's comet contains water like any other comet, too," says Hilchenbach. "But because comets have spent most of their time at the icy rim of the solar system, it has almost always been frozen and could not react with the minerals." The researchers therefore regard the lack of hydrated minerals in the comet's dust as an indication that 67P contains very pristine material.

This conclusion is supported by the ratio of certain elements such as carbon to silicon. With more than 5, this value is very close to the Sun's value, which is thought to reflect the ratio found in the early solar system.
.
The lack of hydrated minerals is what is expected for real comets forming in the early solar system. The ratio of carbon to silicon is was expected for real comets forming in the early solar system.
The lack of hydrated minerals debunks your comet delusions. The ratio of carbon to silicon debunks your comet delusions.

The paper is Anaïs Bardyn et al. Carbon-rich dust in comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko measured by COSIMA/Rosetta, Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society (2017). DOI: 10.1093/mnras/stx2640
Abstract
Cometary ices are rich in CO2, CO and organic volatile compounds, but the carbon content of cometary dust was only measured for the Oort Cloud comet 1P/Halley, during its flyby in 1986. The COmetary Secondary Ion Mass Analyzer (COSIMA)/Rosetta mass spectrometer analysed dust particles with sizes ranging from 50 to 1000 μm, collected over 2 yr, from 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko (67P), a Jupiter family comet. Here, we report 67P dust composition focusing on the elements C and O. It has a high carbon content (atomic $${\rm{C}}/{\rm{Si}} = 5.5{\rm{\ }}_{ - 1.2}^{ + 1.4}\ \ {\rm{on\ average}}$ $) close to the solar value and comparable to the 1P/Halley data. From COSIMA measurements, we conclude that 67P particles are made of nearly 50 per cent organic matter in mass, mixed with mineral phases that are mostly anhydrous. The whole composition, rich in carbon and non-hydrated minerals, points to a primitive matter that likely preserved its initial characteristics since the comet accretion in the outer regions of the protoplanetary disc.

For others:
Abundance of chemical elements on Earth
Symbol Mass fraction (ppm) Atomic fraction (ppb)
C 730 1,600,000
Si 161000 150,000,000
That is ratios of 220 and 93.75 which is nowhere near the observed ratio of 5 in comets.
 
Last edited:
441 items of ignorance, idiocy (citing irrelevant mainstream papers), delusion and lies dating from 29 August 2016 to 28November 2017 (maybe hundreds more in the last 8 years!)

  1. 28 November 2017 Sol88: Insult and the repeated stupidity of referring to papers about comets made of ices and dust.
  2. 28 November 2017 Sol88: Multiple lies about "no viable mechanism for your "explosive" "jets"".
  3. 28 November 2017 Sol88: Lies about a problem with the source of O2.
  4. 28 November 2017 Sol88: A stupid lie about a problem with "stuff" coming off the nucleus (e.g. jets exist!).
  5. 28 November 2017 Sol88: A lie about ices being hidden - we have many observations of ices and he knows this.
  6. 28 November 2017 Sol88: The usual "ices in quotes" lie.
  7. 28 November 2017 Sol88: Stupidity of posting images of receding actual ice cliffs on Tempel 1.
  8. 28 November 2017 Sol88: A delusion about electrons in table 1 of E. Grün et. al (2016)
  9. A note on the bedrock idiocy.
  10. 29 November 2017 Sol88: No math skills (still does not know that 0.6 g/cc is not 3.0 g/cc after over 8 years) but can lie again about double layers, etc.
  11. 29 November 2017 Sol88: Added the stupidity of Birkeland currents in comet tails to his comet delusions.
  12. 29 November 2017 Sol88: A couple of delusions - that there is "a electric circuit between the 67p and the sun (solar wind)" and that people who know about his over 8 years of persisting with ignorance, delusions and lies will waste time answering this delusion.
  13. 29 November 2017 Sol88: Lies about comets being rocks and a post being about how dust is removed from the comet nucleus.
  14. 30 November 2017 Sol88: Ignorant electrostatic, etc. delusions from a person ignorant of math, physics and English.
  15. 30 November 2017 Sol88: An irrelevant lie that magnetic reconnection is dead.
  16. 30 November 2017 Sol88: A lie that Hannes Alfven stated that the frozen in magnetic field approximation was wrong.
  17. 30 November 2017 Sol88: Ignorant statement and question to derail from his comet delusions.
  18. 30 November 2017 Sol88: A lie and ignorant delusion that comets are spacecraft!
  19. 30 November 2017 Sol88: Confirms how idiotic his comet delusions are by asking a question he must already have an answer to.
  20. 30 November 2017 Sol88: Repeats his lie of hidden ice when he knows that ice has been observed many times.
  21. 30 November 2017 Sol88: More whining and lying about irrelevant physics (double layers, etc.).
  22. 1 December 2017 Sol88: A lie about Fälthammar's paper on Earth's magnetosphere being about his comet delusions.
  23. 1 December 2017 Sol88: A lie about magnetic reconnection holding a critical role in his comet delusions.
  24. 1 December 2017 Sol88: A lie of tusenfem's "interpretation" having anything to do with Birkeland currents or the deluded Don Scott.
  25. 1 December 2017 Sol88: A lie that we cannot use MHD.
 
Last edited:
This paper may lead to finding out answers to your questions?

Nope, can't recall ever asking about O2 production. I do however recall asking about what charge on the comet EC expects or requires.


Makes Researchers present list of comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko ingredients interesting in basically finding the dust bone dry, also lends weight to the ELECTRIC COMET paradigm. :D

Nope, from the article...

The dust belongs to the most pristine and carbon-rich material known in our solar system and has hardly changed since its birth.

and

This conclusion is supported by the ratio of certain elements such as carbon to silicon. With more than 5, this value is very close to the Sun's value, which is thought to reflect the ratio found in the early solar system.

...so no support there.

If the water is being made electrically, much to jd116’s utter horror, then it solves a whole lot more problems than the mainstreams model presents.

Nope, still evidently hasn't solved the problem of what charge on the comet EC expects or requires.
When I say electrical or it’s more along the lines of Dynamic molecular oxygen production in cometary comae

Mmmm....what could be doing the ‘accelerating’ I wonder?

.......and we are back to double layers, field aligned electric currents, ‘magtagic’ Reconnection and all that wonderful plasma stuff.

Funny that, maybe there is a link.

Nope, not back just still at the lack of quantitative values that EC doodad expects or requires.

When we say dirty, we don’t just mean the dust but also the organics.

That’s a dirtyicedustball or some such? How’s Whipples model get those to accrete way out whoop whoop.

Organics, not a problem, just give me an electric field of the right magnitude.

Again what value does EC expect or require “an electric field of the right magnitude” to be?

Well at least your own citation...

https://phys.org/news/2017-12-comet-67pchuryumov-gerasimenko-ingredients.html

answers your own "whoop whoop" question.
 
When we say dirty, we don’t just mean the dust but also the organics.

That’s a dirtyicedustball or some such? How’s Whipples model get those to accrete way out whoop whoop.

Organics, not a problem, just give me an electric field of the right magnitude.

Christ. Would somebody like to put that into a sensible sentence for me? How is the non-existent 'electric model' doing anything? Please explain. Along with evidence. Lol.
 
Christ. Would somebody like to put that into a sensible sentence for me?
Ok :D.
The first sentence seems a lie since there is no "we". The Thunderbolts cult has electrical discharges burning the surface of rocks implying no organics.
The real world has H2O, CO and CH4 ices + sunlight = chemical reactions and formation of organics.

The middle 2 sentences are a repeat of the lie (comets of ices and dust do form organics as above) and a stupid question to derail from the cult comet delusions.

The last sentence is his personal delusion that electrical fields can do anything he imagines. That includes taking rock and somehow forming organic components from it.
 
Originally Posted by me(Tusenfem) et al.
Abstract
Context. The Rosetta Plasma Consortium (RPC) magnetometer (MAG) data during the tail excursion in March - April 2016 are used to investigate the magnetic structure of and activity in the tail region of the weakly outgassing comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko (67P/CG).
Aims. The goal of this study is to compare the large scale (near) tail structure with that of earlier missions to strong outgassing comets, and the small scale turbulent energy cascade (un)related to the singing comet phenomenon.
Methods. The usual methods of space plasma physics are used to analyze the magnetometer data, such as minimum variance analysis, spectral analysis and power law fitting. Also the cone- and clock-angle of the magnetic field are calculated to interpret the data.
Results. It is found that comet 67P/CG does not have a classical draped magnetic field and no bilobal tail structure at this late stage of the mission, with the comet already at 2.7 AU distance from the Sun. The main magnetic field direction seems to be more across the tail direction, which may implicate an asymmetric pick-up cloud. During periods of singing comet activity the propagation direction of the waves is at large angles with respect to the magnetic field and to the radial direction towards the comet. Turbulent cascade of magnetic energy from large to small scales is different in the presence of singing as without it.

Does not have a classical draped magnetic field?? :confused:

So Alfven's draped magnetic field model is not true in this case?

So the usual methods of space plasma physics are used which include DOUBLE LAYERS, FIELD ALIGNED ELECTRIC CURRENTS and ELECTRIC FIELD SHORT CIRCUITS (reconnection)?

Does your paper not prove Alfven correct in this instance? Ideal MHD can not be used.
 
Sol88: Cannot understand English in a post

Does not have a classical draped magnetic field??
5 December 2017 Sol88: Cannot understand the English of "does not have a classical draped magnetic field"!
The tail of come 67P is found not to have a magnetic field draped around it, rather the magnetic field seems to point across the tail.

A fantasy of "Alfven's draped magnetic field model" since I see no such model in this thread. 42 abstracts out of 13.4 million for 'Alfven draped magnetic field model'.

5 December 2017 Sol88: Irrational and irrelevant double layer, reconnection, etc. rant.
 
Last edited:
466 items of ignorance, idiocy (citing irrelevant mainstream papers), delusion and lies dating from 29 August 2016 to 28 November 2017 (maybe hundreds more in the last 8 years!)
  1. 1 December 2017 Sol88: A lie that Fälthammar's paper on the Earth has a connection to comet nuclei.
  2. 1 December 2017 Sol88: An ignorant statement about the Rosetta probe which was crashed into 67P!
  3. 1 December 2017 Sol88: A delusion that any probe into a comet tail will support his comet delusions, e.g. impossible Birkeland currents.
  4. 4 December 2017 Sol88: A lie that magnetic reconnection does not exist when that is what he quotes states.
  5. 4 December 2017 Sol88: His double layers at comets delusion.
  6. 4 December 2017 Sol88: Ignorance of basic electrodynamics
  7. 4 December 2017 Sol88: Lies about Falthammar’s paper which is not about comets.
  8. 4 December 2017 Sol88: Gibberish and his persistent bedrock delusion included in his other comet delusions.
  9. 4 December 2017 Sol88: Repeated lies about a Birch et. al. paper describing the surface of a comet made of ices and dust
  10. 4 December 2017 Sol88: Delusion and an stupid question to derail from his comet delusions
  11. 4 December 2017 Sol88: A lie about a new paper being related to a "debate on MRx".
  12. 4 December 2017 Sol88: A lie abut a new paper supporting his comets delusions.
  13. 4 December 2017 Sol88: An idiotic demand that we agree with his "concentricly nested field aligned electric currents" delusion when he provided no credible source for them.
  14. 4 December 2017 Sol88: An inane post to hide the derail from his comet delusions.
  15. 4 December 2017 Sol88: ...is deluded about yet another mainstream paper and lies about Yu. V. Skorov!
  16. 4 December 2017 Sol88: Idiocy again of just a title of a paper presumably about comets made of ices and dust.
  17. 4 December 2017 Sol88: Repeat his delusions that bedrock on comets = rock.
The electric comet delusion has at least 45 years without a scientific electric comet model or observations to support it :eek: !

ETA: If we look back to 1972 and the beginnings of the electric comet delusions with Ralph Juergens then we see what we see today - a lot of ignorant prose with no physics or math from people with little knowledge of astronomy (a retired civil engineer in this case!). His electric comet fantasy is about their tails and combined with delusions about an electric sun, e.g. idiotic statements such as "In short, conventional celestial mechanics, which had proved time and again its ability to describe and predict planetary motions in today's solar system..." as if he had never heard of NASA!
 
Last edited:
Does not have a classical draped magnetic field?? :confused:

I bet you are.

So Alfven's draped magnetic field model is not true in this case?

As the Austrians like to say: jein

So the usual methods of space plasma physics are used which include DOUBLE LAYERS, FIELD ALIGNED ELECTRIC CURRENTS and ELECTRIC FIELD SHORT CIRCUITS (reconnection)?

NO

Does your paper not prove Alfven correct in this instance? Ideal MHD can not be used.

NO
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom