Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
But the crux is, it’s still a game changer for the coma model of comets that WILL have a bearing on the nucleus and the dust from layered bedrock!

First we get some form of general agreement there ARE concentricly nested field aligned electric currents with alternating signs as you move along the Z axis.
 
There is a whole thread on MRx, why don't you read it? If not, then read the papers referenced by Falthammar in his paper. As far as reconnection goes, Falthammar IS mainstream. And yet he was Alfven's student. And co-author. And friend.


I’d ask your understanding on the electric fields and currents but good dodge sport, good dodge! :rolleyes:
 
I’d ask your understanding on the electric fields and currents but good dodge sport, good dodge! :rolleyes:

It is off-topic. Reconnection is well described in the literature, and there is a humongous thread on it here. Go read. It has little to do with comets, other than possibly in tail disconnection events. Which I don't believe was seen at 67P.
 
But the crux is, it’s still a game changer for the coma model of comets that WILL have a bearing on the nucleus and the dust from layered bedrock!

First we get some form of general agreement there ARE concentricly nested field aligned electric currents with alternating signs as you move along the Z axis.

Why would we need a 'general agreement', when the data is in? Tusenfem has seen it. Has he said there are 'concentrically nested field aligned electric currents with alternating signs as you move along the Z axis'?
I very much doubt it. Assuming he understood what you were talking about. And for the millionth time, THERE IS NO ROCK!!!!! And whatever you are prattling on about, it has zero relevance to dust production from the nucleus! How the hell would it?
 
Samuel P. D. Birch,1‹ Y. Tang,2 A. G. Hayes,1,2 R. L. Kirk,3 D. Bodewits,4 H. Campins,5 Y. Fernandez,5 R. de Freitas Bart,2 N. W. Kutsop,2 H. Sierks,6 J. M. Soderblom,7 S. W. Squyres1,2 and J-B. Vincent6,8 Geomorphology of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko

I’m going to follow there lead here and call the nucleus that is made of layered bedrock units, with a minimal amount dust of previously layered well consolidated material, ‘rock’, as a general term to describe the comet nucleus.

So if you have an issue with this terminology for the geomorphology of comet 67P then take it up with the above. Or should I refer to the well consolidated material by its correct description of layered bedrock.

Did you read the whole paper?

Simultaneously, an upper layer free of volatiles and composed of crystalline ice will develop as a dehydrated crust (Capaccioni et al. 2015), whose thickness depends on the time that 67P/C-G has been in its current orbit (Mousis et al. 2016). This upper crust will then be relatively inactive, initially, as compared to deeper reservoirs. Regions with a smaller inventory of initial volatiles in their subsurface will be covered in dust from other regions
 
Did you read the whole paper?

You must be kidding! No, he'll just cherry pick terms here and there, and then ignore anything that shows that those terms do not mean what he thinks they mean. As illustrated here, from the paper:

Explosive jet erosion from exposed cliff faces also acts to break off parts of the weakened bedrock material, which then accumulate as talus deposits at the cliff bases (Groussin et al. 2015; Pajola et al. 2016b). The large boulders within these deposits may also contribute to the jets, as volatiles in exposed faces of the boulders, previously hidden from the Sun, can sublimate away (e.g. fig. 4 in Vincent et al. 2016b).

So, the bedrock turns out to contain ice! As was also seen after a large cliff collapse that exposed quite a large amount of it.
 
Sorry my bad. Gets to get a little frustrating on a iPad trying to cut n paste links!

Most of the time it’s not a problem but at others...

The quotes were from tusenfem.


Thanks. I’m on an iPad; I’m not an expert but PM me if I can answer any questions.
 
The hilarious 1=0.5 claim by MM is only the top of the iceberg ...
I agree with what you posted in that post there, HotBlack! (Welcome to ISF, too!)

... And the 'iceberg' is truly very deep and not only centred on logic and math inabilities .. it also extends to basic electrical physics. I have also had wranglings with MM (for eg) where it became clear that he also thinks current flow is an electromotive force! (This was on the topic of current flows in a circuit containing a capacitor, focusing on 'displacement currents'). So, even the much extolled 'EU Circuit Theory' has fundamental misconceptions behind it, resulting in disconnects with what Electrical Engineers mean when they refer to real Circuit Theory.

The present diversionary and largely irrelevant topic here of Magnetic Reconnection, (in reference to comets .. for some obscure reason), also sets off the fire alarms at cult HQ ... Its funny how these folk have a desperate need to lay claim to well laid out terms, concepts and definitions as their own, and then try to use their own distortions of these as a way to distinguishing themselves from 'mainstream science'. To say that they have no concept of the fundamentals of Circuit theory ... I'm sure, would be a hangin' offence over at the 'House of Holy Electric Horrors'! :)

Cheers
 
Why would we need a 'general agreement', when the data is in? Tusenfem has seen it. Has he said there are 'concentrically nested field aligned electric currents with alternating signs as you move along the Z axis'?
I very much doubt it.
For what its worth, I'm with you in doubting that too ..

jonesdave116 said:
Assuming he understood what you were talking about.
Am I wrong in assuming that Sol88 seems to enjoy implying that there might actually be a set of EU dots which he wants others to connect for him?
Cheers
 
If those currents are unstable and the double layer separating those currents ‘shorts’ out or explosively release the inductively flowing energy....

Magnetic reconnection dosent captture the whole show!

Really, double layers separating currents?
Prithee, tell me where to get this knowledge.
 
The basic premise of Falthammar’s paper is in certain cases, in this case at a comet, MHD does NOT apply!

The field lines are not frozen in and the currents are field aligned the coma has charge seperation, particle acceleration, particle de-acceleration and deflection.

Are you going to explain to us why MHD is not applicable to a comet?

And are you going to show some evidence that the currents are field aligned in the coma?
 
First we get some form of general agreement there ARE concentricly nested field aligned electric currents with alternating signs as you move along the Z axis.

you are going to be so disappointed by the results of my paper
 
Am I wrong in assuming that Sol88 seems to enjoy implying that there might actually be a set of EU dots which he wants others to connect for him?
Cheers

Probably. Quite where those dots are, and what they will end up describing, is known only to Sol.
I honestly can't believe we're still discussing this nonsense. The core beliefs of the EC gang, as proposed by T & T, is that there is a variable radial electric field from the Sun. This has never been observed. Due to traveling through this non-existent field, the comet builds up excess charge. How much charge? None, probably, but T & T aren't saying.
The comet is rock, just like an asteroid. Investigated by multiple instruments, and an impact, and found not to be rock.
Then EDM (lol) starts to happen. Why? How? Never been observed. And would be. This burns the surface black. These discharges are the jets that we see. Which are cold, neutral, not at all electrical, and caused by sublimating ice forming vapour, and entraining dust.
This EDM (lol) causes O- ions to be removed from the non-existent rock. Why O- ions, and not O+? Who knows? So, the non-existent O- then combines with H+ to form OH. Problems here, too, unsurprisingly. There is nowhere near enough H+, there is no O-, the H+ is far too energetic to be combining with anything at ~400 km/s, and the solar wind is not reaching the nucleus for a long period. And then this OH has to somehow become H2O.
I think that pretty much covers the core beliefs of this particular woo. And, due to various missions, has been shown beyond any doubt to be wrong. Horribly wrong. It is a waste of pixels.
 
Last edited:
you are going to be so disappointed by the results of my paper
I have my doubts.

Somewhere in the incredible MR thread RC provided a link to, there’s a comment to the effect that few EU fans have the mathematical skills to be able to understand even Maxwell’s equations, let alone what you’d find in a paper on the plasma environment of a comet, or even one of Alfvén’s papers.

And without understanding all those equations, how could one possibly understand what the papers are about?

Now Sol88 has said he doesn’t understand the mathamagical stuff; three stars for the honesty. But, given the inability to understand, why post here?

I think it’s telling that, AFAIK, only Talbot tried to comment, rationally, on the EC idea, and he was quite open about having no intention of including anything to do with Maxwell’s equations, let alone plasma physics, in his analyses. So why did Scott, perhaps the only EU leader who has shown he understands Maxwell’s equations, sit the EC discussions out?

Over at “cult HQ” you have to search long and hard to find anyone who seems to actually understand anything much of physics, let alone mathematics, so it’s perhaps not surprising that Sol can’t even copy/paste from there (not counting those who occasionally stray in to critique the EU, in the short time before they’re banned). A good, recent example: not understanding why solar magnetograms have to do with the Zeeman effect and not the Stark effect ... :rolleyes:
 
?I think it’s telling that, AFAIK, only Talbot tried to comment, rationally, on the EC idea, and he was quite open about having no intention of including anything to do with Maxwell’s equations, let alone plasma physics, in his analyses. So why did Scott, perhaps the only EU leader who has shown he understands Maxwell’s equations, sit the EC discussions out?
Mozina has also distanced himself from the EC idea, saying that he didn't see it as providing any more explanatory information than the mainstream theory. :eye-poppi

JeanTate said:
... A good, recent example: not understanding why solar magnetograms have to do with the Zeeman effect and not the Stark effect ... :rolleyes:
I can't get beyond the back-to-front-edness of one of those posts/comments! Incredible .. at one point, the logic appears to be that a magnetogram is the observation (and not a graph)! Ie: the magnetogram comes first, and then the explanation of its miraculous appearance (including its x-and y-axis units) comes next. Never mind that x-axis has been selected as having units of 'Tesla' whereas an energy level spectral diagram has been selected as having units of 'volts/cm' ...(?)
(Or maybe its just the way I'm reading the post?)
 
Probably. Quite where those dots are, and what they will end up describing, is known only to Sol.
I honestly can't believe we're still discussing this nonsense. The core beliefs of the EC gang, as proposed by T & T, is that there is a variable radial electric field from the Sun. This has never been observed. Due to traveling through this non-existent field, the comet builds up excess charge. How much charge? None, probably, but T & T aren't saying.
The comet is rock, just like an asteroid. Investigated by multiple instruments, and an impact, and found not to be rock.
Then EDM (lol) starts to happen. Why? How? Never been observed. And would be. This burns the surface black. These discharges are the jets that we see. Which are cold, neutral, not at all electrical, and caused by sublimating ice forming vapour, and entraining dust.
This EDM (lol) causes O- ions to be removed from the non-existent rock. Why O- ions, and not O+? Who knows? So, the non-existent O- then combines with H+ to form OH. Problems here, too, unsurprisingly. There is nowhere near enough H+, there is no O-, the H+ is far too energetic to be combining with anything at ~400 km/s, and the solar wind is not reaching the nucleus for a long period. And then this OH has to somehow become H2O.
I think that pretty much covers the core beliefs of this particular woo. And, due to various missions, has been shown beyond any doubt to be wrong. Horribly wrong. It is a waste of pixels.
.. and pixels are useful commodities! I propose a pixels commodities tax to reduce wasteful usage! :)

Thanks for the run-down. It seems Sol88 might be the only person who bought into this sci-fi story, (which I think was originally written to gain publicity for the EU cult .. along with other classic tales like the supposed 'electrical sculpting' of Vallis Marineris on Mars :boggled: ).
 
Over at “cult HQ” you have to search long and hard to find anyone who seems to actually understand anything much of physics, let alone mathematics, so it’s perhaps not surprising that Sol can’t even copy/paste from there (not counting those who occasionally stray in to critique the EU, in the short time before they’re banned). A good, recent example: not understanding why solar magnetograms have to do with the Zeeman effect and not the Stark effect ... :rolleyes:

Because 'Common Sense' trumps mathematics.
 
You can do the maths since you're The Man?
Would you consider helping me in finding out the charge on a comet?

I think we need to include the Poisson's equation, Boltzmann's constant, electron
temperature (in Kelvin), electron charge and ambient plasma density.

Like I said mathamagics, not my forte. Show me the data you need to complete the equations and we are underway!

Once again for EC notions the data needed is the quantitative values expected by those notions.

Remember you mentioned “When entering a region of different charge” making your “region of different charge" perhaps more than your ‘comet excess electron’ charge. So just the EC or EU “region” could dominate whatever they consider the charge on the comet (by virtue of its claimed excess electrons) to be, it is still just the data of excepted values for EC/EU that is lacking.

For the mainstream the sun, the solar wind and the comet are fundamentally considered neutral. The math for that is simple as SUM of charges on each of those objects= 0. Any local variations are driven by the, well, local dynamics.

EC however doesn’t assert simple local variations but instead a direct potential difference between the comet and the sun. Without that (the electric part) the Electric Comet is just, well, a comet. So it remains to the proponents of such an eclectic comet to quantify that electric part. Again the math is simple as SUM of charges on each of those objects = anything but 0
 
From T & T's poster. Whoops.

Particularly, if as claimed the comet has an excess of electrons and thus a negative charge. Dust already stripped of one or more elections and local plasma positive ions in general will be attracted to it.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom