Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Sol88: Lies and gibberish about jonesdave116's post

Ummm....yes it is!
27 November 2017 Sol88: Lies and gibberish about jonesdave116's post.
This is a Master of Science thesis starting with a review of standard comet physics. A paragraph on the estimate of outgassing rate Q is nothing to do with ionization.
 
Sol88: A lying and idiotic waste of time derailing from his comet delusions

At the moment just a hastily written "list" of points that need clarifying.]
27 November 2017 Sol88: A lying and idiotic post derailing from his comet delusions.

Starts with his persistent lie about MUPUS. Insane delusions abut bedrock. etc. etc.
 
Already addressed. Not rock, for the millionth time.



Constraints for the subsurface structure at the Abydos site on 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko resulting from CASSE listening to the MUPUS insertion phase
Knapmeyer, M. et al.
http://adsabs.harvard.edu/abs/2016AGUFM.P42A..04K



sniped.



A homogeneous nucleus for comet 67P/Churyumov– Gerasimenko from its gravity field
If the dust-to-ice mass ratio of 4 is correct, then the nucleus of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko appears to be a very porous, very dusty body with a dust content by volume about two times larger than the ice content by volume.

We therefore conclude that large voids within the nucleus (macroporosity) can be excluded and that the interior of the nucleus is homogeneous on a global scale, which is in agreement with the CONSERT4 and OSIRIS observations20. The Rosetta CONSERT experiment, which studies the propagation of radio waves in the VHF-band (~100 MHz) between the Rosetta orbiter and the Philae lander through the nucleus, has concluded that at least the interior of the ‘head’ of the duckshaped nucleus is homogeneous down to scales of 3 m and that the porosity is 75% to 85% (ref. 19). As stated above, we consider the lower-porosity value to be more likely because porosities larger than 75% unrealistically constrain the nucleus material to mostly dust with very little ice. The porosity of about 70% to 75% inferred from the mass and the bulk density must therefore be considered an inherent property of the nucleus material.


So we'll take the lower value just to keep it realistic , the nucleus is 75% porous. but

Geomorphology of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko
For reasonable dust material densities one can relate the porosity of the nucleus to the dust-to-ice ratio. The cometary dust particles may be extremely porous and fluffy objects, but the silicate material densities are likely to be around 3,000 kg m-3, as determined by the Stardust mission. Organic carbonaceous particles may have material densities of 2,200 kg m-3. Assuming a ratio of 1:1 for both aggregates would account for an average global material density of 2,600 kg m-3, in accordance with earlier estimates16.
6 SUMMARY Our geomorphologic mapping reveals a complex terrain of consolidated bedrock[\b] material overlain by sedimentary deposits


which of course would be inline with

Thermal and mechanical properties of the near-surface layers of comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko

The lack of progress into the subsurface can be interpreted as being caused by a near-surface layer of a strength the PEN was not capable of penetrating. Alternative interpretations invoke malfunctioning of MUPUS-PEN but are not independently confirmed. These are discussed in the supplementary materials. It is very probable that the mechanism worked nominally at least for three of the four levels. For level 4, housekeeping data suggest that hammering occurred only once per four-stroke sequence, thus at a rate of only a quarter of what was designed. This indicates a lack of full synchronization between charging of the capacitor and release of the hammer, and it is possible that the hammer mechanism could not use the full energy of level 4. A very conservative estimate would then assume that the PEN hammer worked only at level 3. From a comparison with calibration data collected in Table 1, we conclude that the material must have provided a resistance to penetration by the PEN of more than 4MPa, which is equivalent to a uniaxial compressive strength of the material of about 2MPa. An independent estimate of the strength can be made by using the efficiency c of the hammer mechanism of 10% and taking the downward movements of the hammer tip d of ~3 mm recorded by the DS as deformation of the surface (the stronger upward movements interpreted as recoil).

So we have light, fluffy, extremely porous, consolidated bedrock????? So what exactly do we have?

This???

miyb6.jpg
 
Last edited:
Quote:
16. Diocotron instability incorrectly called Kelvin-Helmholtz instability
Wrong. This is a quasi-neutral plasma. Therefore it isn't a dicotron instability. As Tusenfem has already explained to you.

quasi-neutrality is violated in this case.

As shown here

Electron and Ion Dynamics of the Solar Wind Interaction
with a Weakly Outgassing Comet


Hybrid modelling of cometary plasma environments

and then we'd have to hop in the time machine and revisit

Double Layers in Astrophysics Sorry no quotes as this in old photocopied pdf.

As Alfven predicted, seems the frozen in field assumptions is causing mischief!
 
quasi-neutrality is violated in this case.

As shown here

Electron and Ion Dynamics of the Solar Wind Interaction
with a Weakly Outgassing Comet


Hybrid modelling of cometary plasma environments

nope not what Jan is saying

Deca et al. 2017 said:
Coupled to the need for quasineutrality at those scales, the solar wind electrons become decoupled from the solar wind protons upstream of the comet. At the same time, the convective electric field has an opposite sign in the solar wind and cometary ion reference frame and transfers momentum between the two species. While the solar wind protons are deflected, the interplanetary magnetic field continues to be carried close to the comet through the solar wind (and cometary) electrons as they are still frozen-in into the magnetic field. This behavior is quite similar to the ion diffusion region in magnetic reconnection [44].
 
Ahhh the ‘ol frozen in magnetic field chestnut!

I understand the plasma is quasi neutral over all but not in these cases.

How’s that concept helping you with your draped magnetic fields?

anybody using the ‘frozen’ in concept of magnetic field lines is going look like a drongo.

14. Plasma tail will show a nested Birkeland current structures,(concentric cylindrical current sheet surfaces) This will be evident in the the pitch angle of the helical total magnetic field B vector encircling a field aligned current changing continuously with increasing radial distance r from the central axis of the current. As Don Scotts described in the model D E Scott has presented http://www.ptep-online.com/2015/PP-41-13.PDF this was also found in the ULYSSESS ION TAIL OF COMET McNAUGHT data.

But I ‘spose as long as it makes your maths easier, then it’s doing it’s job, ay?

Same as using the radial outgassing, an assumption to make the maths easier... unfortunately this does not reflect observation and indeed reality.
 
Last edited:
Ahhh the ‘ol frozen in magnetic field chestnut!

I understand the plasma is quasi neutral over all but not in these cases.

How’s that concept helping you with your draped magnetic fields?

anybody using the ‘frozen’ in concept of magnetic field lines is going look like a drongo.



But I ‘spose as long as it makes your maths easier, then it’s doing it’s job, ay?

Same as using the radial outgassing, an assumption to make the maths easier... unfortunately this does not reflect observation and indeed reality.

When will we see your maths?
 
Very basically, what the quotation suggests is that incoming neutrals displace the heavier and slower ions which, eventually, draws the electrons with them (maintaining quasi-neutrality) against the impedance of the magnetic field resulting in "critical ionization velocity (CIV) events" from those electrons ionizing the neutrals and thus increasing plasma density.

What exactly does the electric comet theory suggest is "going on here"?

In reference to your assertion of excess electrons before, generally how many excess electrons does the electric comet theory propose such a comet has?

not really sure how many electrons, just that the nucleus should have some "spare" and would like to try and "give" them to the solar wind

An cometary "outburst" or more correctly a discharge would be a good place to look.

Let's have a little looksee ay? :eye-poppi

The nucleus is more or less at a lower potential than the local solar wind. When entering a region of different charge it will form a Langmiour Sheath around it to "protect" itself from the local solar wind. This in turn sets up a series of double layer/s some distance from the nucleus. These are current carrying double layer doing "work".

In this area quasi neutrality is violated and magnetic fields are NOT frozen in, along with photo ionisation playing a minor role.

When there is a breakdown in the electric field between the nucleus and the closest double layer you will get a "burst' of electrons as the nucleus try's to charge equalise.

This should show up in the instruments as different timing between constituents of the discharge.

Bit like lightning really!

Anywho,

This is what I would expect to see. I'll group them to make my electrical explanation a little clearer.

  1. OSIRIS WAC, OSIRIS NAC, Alice
  2. MIRO RPC LAP Spacecraft potential, RPC MIP Electron density, ROSINA COPS Gas density
  3. STR-A Brightness, GIADA Dust count rate
List from table 1 Measurement parameters at 9:00 and at maximum. The 2016 Feb 19 outburst of comet 67P/CG: an ESA Rosetta multi-instrument study

Simply

We see a "flash", then we see an increase in the electrons, then the dust is brought along with the electrons after being machined of the rocky nucleus via the focused the discharge , with a lag of course because of the mass difference. The dust of course is also charged and removing that also helps try and balance the charge within the nucleus with that of it's surroundings.

These discharges would be cyclic when the potential difference would be the highest, around perihelion, unless there was a change in the solar wind e.g CME, solar flare etc

The long version..

This geometry allowed Alice, beginning in 2015 mid-April, to observe a number of outbursts above the sunward limb. These outbursts are characterized by sudden increases in the atomic emissions, particularly the semi-forbidden O I ë1356 multiplet, over a period of 10–30 minutes, without a corresponding enhancement in long-wavelength solar reflected light characteristic of dust production. The corresponding increase in the brightness ratio O I ë1356/O I ë1304 suggests that O2, detected for the first time in a comet by Bieler et al. (2015), is the primary source of the additional gas. This is the same spectroscopic diagnostic used to determine that O2 is the dominant species in the exospheres of Europa and Ganymede (Hall et al. 1995, 1998). As the comet rotates, the Alice slit samples different regions above the comet’s limb, but the magnitude of the increase on the short timescale as well as the spatial distribution along the slit makes it very unlikely that it is due to a spatial gradient or a collimated “jet.” Although C I ë1657 is also seen to increase, the variation in the brightness ratio O I ë1356/C I ë1657 indicates that it cannot be CO2 alone, nor can the effects be due to an increase in photoelectron flux. These outbursts do not correlate with any of the visible images of outbursts taken with either OSIRIS (Lin et al. 2016; Vincent et al. 2016) or the navigation camera. We also find that CO does not appear to be driving any of the observed outbursts.
THE NATURE AND FREQUENCY OF THE GAS OUTBURSTS IN COMET 67P/CHURYUMOV–
GERASIMENKO OBSERVED BY THE ALICE FAR-ULTRAVIOLET SPECTROGRAPH ON ROSETTA


and

Interaction of the solar wind with comets: a Rosetta perspective


Just to start the ball rolling! :thumbsup:
 
Last edited:
When will we see your maths?

cant do mathamagics :(
Sorry

Your maths has massive holes in it any way, full of highly dubious :deadhorse ASSUMPTIONS.

You know to make the maths easier, as stated by jd116!

Spherical symmetry is assumed in many models to make them easier to compute.

:rub:


Does the nucleus "outgass" symmetricaly, captain swoop?
Does the surface ice sublimate?
2.2 Generation of cometary boundaries
When illuminated by the Sun, energy from the solar radiation causes sublimation of ice from the comet
surface.
RPC-LAP Electric Field Signatures at the Diamagnetic Cavity
of Comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko
pretty big call that i'd say but to be fair, it is the ASSUMPTION of the "Dirtysnowball" model of comets.
 
Last edited:
not really sure how many electrons, just that the nucleus should have some "spare" and would like to try and "give" them to the solar wind

Which is getting nowhere near the nucleus for long periods.

An cometary "outburst" or more correctly a discharge would be a good place to look.

No discharges happening. They would be seen. On the other hand, gas and dust from the outbursts are seen.

The nucleus is more or less at a lower potential than the local solar wind. When entering a region of different charge it will form a Langmiour Sheath around it to "protect" itself from the local solar wind. This in turn sets up a series of double layer/s some distance from the nucleus. These are current carrying double layer doing "work".

Really? How much lower a potential? Where has this been measured? What Langmuir sheath? Where has this been observed and measured? What double layers? Where have these been observed and measured? Complete waste of pixels invoking a bunch of nonsense that has never been observed at a comet, to explain things that have never been seen at a comet! Can't get more pseudoscientific than that!

Followed by the idiocy of mentioning the Feb 19 outburst paper, where the gas causing the outburst is observed by ROSINA! As I have already pointed out:

The 2016 Feb 19 outburst of comet 67P/CG: an ESA Rosetta multi-instrument study
Grun, E, et al.
https://academic.oup.com/mnras/article/462/Suppl_1/S220/2633359

Section 2.6
However, at ∼10:00 the gas density rapidly increased to almost 1.5 × 108 cm−3 which is more than 50 per cent higher than the normal fluctuations at a similar nucleus phase.

Way to kill your own argument!

And does so again by quoting the ALICE observations of O2!

It seems to me that everything invoked by Sol just happens to be invisible to all the instruments that would detect such things. Funny that, eh? It's almost as if he's gone full creationist on us. Whereby all the evidence against his beliefs is ignored, and a whole bunch of fairy tales are conjured up to help him in his desire to carry on believing in impossible, unscientific woo.
 
Last edited:
Get a life champ, go read the papers!

Why the the increase in brightness FIRST then GAS then DUST!

Ya still got no viable mechanism for your "explosive" "jets" yet as far as I know?

Maybe Tusenfems got the inside goss after chatting with J Agarwal and Yu. V. Skorov?

Got yourself some serious dramas there I'd say sport! like where all your o2 coming from? and for that matter ALL the "stuff' coming from the nucleus via your hidden "ices" :rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
I should clarify this somewhat. The main suggestion for DLs came from Ip and Mendis. Such as in the paper:

The generation of magnetic fields and electric currents in cometary plasma tails
Ip, W-H. & Mendis, D. A. (1976)
http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/001910357690110X

Alfven merely mentions their proposal in his double layers paper. And Ip and Mendis were only ever talking about their possible formation in the tail. They most certainly were not suggesting that the diamagnetic cavity was a DL! Both of those authors continued to publish papers on comets for some years, and Ip, from memory, was an author on at least one of the 67P papers. They both knew the difference between a DL and a diamagnetic cavity.

Any double layers seen during the tail excursion, Tusenfem?

or is quasi neutrality violated with in the tail region, Tusenfem?

Are there any force free filed aligned currents, Tusenfem?

Could Ip and Mendis be correct in relation to comet 67p's tail, Tusenfem?

or do I have to go to another forum to be able to ask question from a plasma physicist working on the RPC team at the ESA on the comet 67P??
 
Last edited:
Why the the increase in brightness FIRST then GAS then DUST!

Because light is faster than gas, which is faster than dust! Duh.

Ya still got no viable mechanism for your "explosive" "jets" yet as far as I know?

Yes, there are. And they've been mentioned on here and in various papers.

where all your o2 coming from? and for that matter ALL the "stuff' coming from the nucleus via your hidden "ices"

The O2 is most likely contained within the H2O. And the ices have been seen on numerous occasions, as has been repeatedly pointed out to you. It is pointless to keep linking to papers that you refuse to read, because they don't happen to fit in with your quasi-religous beliefs. You are the one that needs to read the papers. Start with the Tempel 1 papers, where ice grains were ejected from the nucleus after a projectile smashed into it.
 
Because light is faster than gas, which is faster than dust! Duh.

And the electrons, champ?

Read table 1, again. The 2016 Feb 19 outburst of comet 67P/CG: an ESA Rosetta
multi-instrument study
 
Last edited:
Could Ip and Mendis be correct in relation to comet 67p's tail, Tusenfem?

And what did Ip & Mendis suggest that this putative DL might do? Did it involve EDM? Electric discharges? No would be the answer to that.
 
Because light is faster than gas, which is faster than dust! Duh.



Yes, there are. And they've been mentioned on here and in various papers.



The O2 is most likely contained within the H2O. And the ices have been seen on numerous occasions, as has been repeatedly pointed out to you. It is pointless to keep linking to papers that you refuse to read, because they don't happen to fit in with your quasi-religous beliefs. You are the one that needs to read the papers. Start with the Tempel 1 papers, where ice grains were ejected from the nucleus after a projectile smashed into it.

Along with all the other "stuff" we've observed?

Oh ok then :blush: :boggled:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom