Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
And I'll repeat, for the terminally stupid - what the hell has ionisation got to do with lifting dust from the surface??????? And what has the quote from Deca et al got to do with anything? They are talking about the situation in the coma at a weakly outgassing comet. All of this is nothing whatsoever to do with why the coma is dustiest at peak outgassing. As already explained umpteen times, it CANNOT be electrostatic levitation. You need solar wind electrons for that. Hence why Nordheim only posits it at large heliocentric distances. If it were a serious player, then all near Earth asteroids would be sporting a coma just like comets. Why don't they? Because they haven't got ice. And the vapour from the sublimating ice is seen by a number of instruments in the coma, close to the surface. This argument is long dead. As dead as the electric comet woo.
 
Last edited:
Diamagnetric cavity = double layer! Lol. Tell us Sol, who were quite keen on invoking DLs before the Halley mission? Mendis and Alfven, right? Check the literature. Were they around for the Halley results? Yes they were. Did they think the predicted diamagnetic cavity was a DL? No, they didn't. Only one person on the planet thinks that, and they are wrong. As usual.
 
As Tusenfem says, photo-ionization is the main player, even when the coma is optical thick to incoming EUV!

Yes. And? You have some electrons and ions created. Not many compared to the neutrals. And they are cold. And therefore not very energetic. And they really aren't going to do much at all in the absence of a magnetic field, are they? They'll just head on up, away from the comet, towards the pile-up region. Where some of the electrons will recombine with ions to form neutrals. They aren't going to reverse direction and go looking for dark places on the nucleus! This is all getting too silly for words, and goes to show the psychology of woo believers, in how they try to hold on to their quasi-religious beliefs, even in the face of a mountain of evidence against them, and zero evidence in favour of them.
 
and further, seems the DIAMAGNETIC cavity seems to coincide (@170 km First detection of a diamagnetic cavity
at comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko
) if not inside the double layer where the distance from the nucleus were charge separation is occurring in this simulation at around 500km from the nucleus? Electron and Ion Dynamics of the Solar Wind Interaction with a Weakly Outgassing Comet

and where is the problem, exactly?
(apart from the fact that is is not a double layer, but we will let that go)

I guess you are talking about this
Deca et al. [2017 said:
]
We observe a spatial separation of the cometary electrons with respect to the cometary ions, and of the solar wind electrons with respect to the solar wind protons. Cometary electrons eventually end up neutralizing the solar wind protons, and solar wind electrons eventually neutralize the cometary ions.

Which basically says that the electrons and ions (either C or SW) move into different directions, which they should, from basic electrodynamics. And then later:

Deca et al. [2017 said:
]
Solar wind electrons accelerate towards the comet [Fig. 4(a)] under the influence of an ambipolar electric field that is generated by the large electron pressure gradient in the inhomogeneous cometary plasma [50],which further enhances the separation of the solar wind electron and ion flows.

Basically, the electron pressure gradient, in Jan's model is over 500 km, from looking at the figures and he links back to Erik Vigren

Vigren et al. [2015 said:
]
As the neutral number density drops as r−2, the electron number density drops as 1/r. Neglecting the solar windʼs convective electric field (and ion-neutral momentum exchange) and assuming further that the electron temperature is constant (at a high value of Te ∼ 10^5 K roughly corresponding to 10 eV), this gradient in electron number density sets up an outwardpointing ambipolar electric field, Er, that (by neglecting the motional electric field) is inversely proportional to r. The relation is given in Appendix B (Equation (14)).

There is no reason why the diamagnetic cavity and the ambipolar field cannot exist together as the two have nothing to do with each other.
 
Houston we have a problem...

. The spacecraft is not moving significantly in relation to the nucleus of the comet. It is therefore reasonable to assume that all the diamagnetic cav- ity observations presented here happened due to extrusions mov- ing over an effectively stationary spacecraft. We propose that all our observations took place in bulges, and that currents are run- ning through these protuberant parts, generating current-driven ion acoustic waves. The nature of the wave environment deeper inside the diamagnetic cavity will have to be determined by future space missions.
Plasma waves confined to the diamagnetic cavity of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko

Mmmmm.....
 
and where is the problem, exactly?
(apart from the fact that is is not a double layer, but we will let that go)

I guess you are talking about this


Which basically says that the electrons and ions (either C or SW) move into different directions, which they should, from basic electrodynamics. And then later:



Basically, the electron pressure gradient, in Jan's model is over 500 km, from looking at the figures and he links back to Erik Vigren



There is no reason why the diamagnetic cavity and the ambipolar field cannot exist together as the two have nothing to do with each other.

But the diamagnetic cavity is after the double layer, sonwhats stopping the solar wind? Diamagnetic cavity or electric double layer?
 
Diamagnetric cavity = double layer! Lol. Tell us Sol, who were quite keen on invoking DLs before the Halley mission? Mendis and Alfven, right? Check the literature. Were they around for the Halley results? Yes they were. Did they think the predicted diamagnetic cavity was a DL? No, they didn't. Only one person on the planet thinks that, and they are wrong. As usual.

I should clarify this somewhat. The main suggestion for DLs came from Ip and Mendis. Such as in the paper:

The generation of magnetic fields and electric currents in cometary plasma tails
Ip, W-H. & Mendis, D. A. (1976)
http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/001910357690110X

Alfven merely mentions their proposal in his double layers paper. And Ip and Mendis were only ever talking about their possible formation in the tail. They most certainly were not suggesting that the diamagnetic cavity was a DL! Both of those authors continued to publish papers on comets for some years, and Ip, from memory, was an author on at least one of the 67P papers. They both knew the difference between a DL and a diamagnetic cavity.
 
But the diamagnetic cavity is after the double layer, sonwhats stopping the solar wind? Diamagnetic cavity or electric double layer?

Wrong. There is no double layer. It would have been seen.

ETA:
The diamagnetic cavity isn't stopping the solar wind. It is piling up the IMF. The solar wind is nowhere to be seen. In October, two months after perihelion, the spacecraft had a sunward excursion out to 1500 km. The solar wind was missing all the way out.

EETA:
The birth and growth of a solar wind cavity around a comet – Rosetta observations
Behar, E. et al
https://research.aalto.fi/files/15736627/Behar_et_al_stx1871.pdf
 
Last edited:
But the diamagnetic cavity is after the double layer, sonwhats stopping the solar wind? Diamagnetic cavity or electric double layer?

So frakking what?
Why would the ambipolar electric field have anything to do with the diamagnetic cavity. They are created by completely different processes.
And I am not going to edumacate you.
 
I should clarify this somewhat. The main suggestion for DLs came from Ip and Mendis. Such as in the paper:

The generation of magnetic fields and electric currents in cometary plasma tails
Ip, W-H. & Mendis, D. A. (1976)
http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/001910357690110X

Alfven merely mentions their proposal in his double layers paper. And Ip and Mendis were only ever talking about their possible formation in the tail. They most certainly were not suggesting that the diamagnetic cavity was a DL! Both of those authors continued to publish papers on comets for some years, and Ip, from memory, was an author on at least one of the 67P papers. They both knew the difference between a DL and a diamagnetic cavity.


Interesting, ay! So they COULD be there. :D
 
So frakking what?
Why would the ambipolar electric field have anything to do with the diamagnetic cavity. They are created by completely different processes.
And I am not going to edumacate you.

RPC-LAP Electric Field Signatures at the Diamagnetic Cavity of Comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko

2.4.3 Diamagnetic cavity (DC)

The diamagnetic cavity is thought to be the innermost region of the cometary coma and is characterized by an exclusion of the solar wind magnetic field. It is separated from the cometosheath by the contact surface at the point where the magnetic field magnitude reaches zero. The gradual decrease in the magnetic field magnitude happens within the DCBL just outside the contact surface. Prior to the Rosetta mission, the cavity has been observed only once, i.e. during the Giotto flyby of comet 1P/H (Neubauer et al., 1986). The relatively small cometocentric distances of orbits close to perihelion has made the Rosetta spacecraft cross the contact surface of comet 67P more than 600 times, giving the possibility of further studies on the dynamical features related to this region (Goetz et al., 2016b).

Further

When ions moving with a finite speed radially from the comet penetrate into the boundary layer, the movement of the ions will be disturbed by the presence of the solar wind magnetic field BSW . This leads to an ion gyration of gyroradius rL perpendicular to the magnetic field lines. After half a gyration, the ions have returned to the magnetic field free cavity, continuing their motion radially towards to comet. This gives rise to a current JDCBL within the boundary, but no current in the cavity itself, as illustrated in Figure 2.7 (Israelevich and Ershkovich, 1994). Similarly, the free electrons produced by the ionization of cometary neutrals in the cavity will be affected by the presence of the magnetic field at the boundary layer. The gyration of the electrons is in the opposite direction of the ion gyration, due to the difference in the sign of their charges. Hence, both species add up to the same effective current in the cavity boundary. Since the gyroradius is proportional to the mass of the gyrating particle (see Eq. (2.18)), the electron and ion gyroradii will differ from each other. Ions will therefore penetrate deeper into the boundary than the electrons, leading to a charge separation within the boundary layer. This results in a polarization electric field, in addition to the DCBL current.


Hell we’ll even get into a bit of critical ionisation velocity (CIV) again, watya reckon Tusenfem?

We’ve been here before if you care to remember.
 
The above paper introduces some new problems for the mainstream!

Seems your assumptions for radial ‘outgassing’ is a fair way out.

2.2 Generation of cometary boundaries When illuminated by the Sun, energy from the solar radiation causes sublimation of ice from the comet surface. The amount of sublimated ice per time unit is described by the cometary outgassing rate Q, on which the activity level of a comet and the extent of the comet -solar wind interaction region depend on. It is, therefore, highly relevant to estimate Q when doing in-situ observations of the cometary environment. By assuming spherical symmetry and negligible gravitational pull on the cometary neutrals, the observed neutral number density nn at a distance r from the comet nucleus is related to the outgassing rate Q by
 
Last edited:
You may be able to fill the lurkers in here a bit Tusenfem.

Oblique Langmuir waves are thought to be related to energy transfer from ions to electrons (Galeev, 1989). The wave detections and sudden increase in ion density makes Savin et al. (1986) conclude that the observed region is subject to so-called critical ionization velocity (CIV) events. The reason for this conclusion is explained in the following. ACIVeventis the ionization of neutrals moving with a speed greater than a critical speed (u > uc) relative to a magnetized plasma (see Figure 2.9). It was originally proposed by Alfv´en (1954) as an explanation to the formation of planets in the solar system, but now additionally serves as an explanation for events in the cometary environment. The process converts mechanical energy of the moving neutral gas into electrostatic energy through interaction with the plasma and its electromagnetic eld. By that the density of the plasma increases. For this to happen, the required kinetic energy of the intruding neutral gas has to equal the ionization energy Eionize. Hence, for neutrals of mass m, the CIV is uc = 2Eionize m (2.38) However, keep in mind that this is only true if the energy transfer processes are optimal. If not, an ef ciency term with a value between 0 and 1 can be introduced on the right hand side of the equation. This would yield a greater critical velocity of the neutrals (Galeev et al., 1986). The CIV mechanism is poorly understood, and several models have been proposed to explain the phenomenon. Some of the models are reviewed by Brenning (1992), who concludes that none of the proposed models fully explains the observed features in experiments and, hence, that several processes must play a role in the complex mechanism of CIV events. However, it is widely accepted that the main source of ionization of the neutrals in CIV events is impact with energetic electrons (Lai, 2001). To explain the origin of the electron energization, Alfv´en (1960) suggested that the intrusion of a moving neutral gas in a plasma displaced ions causing inhomogeneities in the plasma. The magnetic eld does not allow the electrons to follow the ions, and hence a voltage difference will occur. Eventually, the electrons are accelerated by this voltage difference making them energetic enough to ionize the neutral gas. The LH instability is often mentioned as an important factor in the CIV mechanism (Formisano et al., 1982), and a peak in the spectrum corresponding to the LHF has often appeared in experiments (Brenning, 1992). In the comet -solar wind interaction region, the solar wind stagnates upstream of the contact surface. This does not inuence the speed of the cometary neutrals signicantly causing the neutrals to travel with a nite speed relative to the plasma, suggesting that CIV events could be accountable for some of the ionization of outgassing neutrals in the inner coma of the interaction region. Hence, an excitation of the LHF along with an ion density increase and anisotropic distributions of suprathermal electrons, as observed by Savin et al. (1986) and Galeev et al. (1986) during the Vega 2 ybys of comet 1P/H, are good indicators of the CIV process.
paper as above

What’s going on here?
 
Sol88. Have you considered joining the Cosmoquest Forum and starting a thread over there in the Q&A section?
It is for asking questions on astronomy and cosmology. You will get a number of very well informed answers.
Be aware though it is for asking questions and receiving mainstream answers, not advocating your own theories but it will get you answers to your mainstream questions and help you understand the papers you quote.

https://forum.cosmoquest.org/forumdisplay.php?8-Space-Astronomy-Questions-and-Answers
 
Last edited:
The above paper introduces some new problems for the mainstream!

Seems your assumptions for radial ‘outgassing’ is a fair way out.

2.2 Generation of cometary boundaries When illuminated by the Sun, energy from the solar radiation causes sublimation of ice from the comet surface. The amount of sublimated ice per time unit is described by the cometary outgassing rate Q, on which the activity level of a comet and the extent of the comet -solar wind interaction region depend on. It is, therefore, highly relevant to estimate Q when doing in-situ observations of the cometary environment. By assuming spherical symmetry and negligible gravitational pull on the cometary neutrals, the observed neutral number density nn at a distance r from the comet nucleus is related to the outgassing rate Q by

Nothing in that quote is the least bit relevant to what I said. The neutrals will head out. A small number will be ionised before they reach the pile up boundary. The lifetime against photoionisation for H2O is of the order of 106 seconds. The molecules are travelling at ~ 600 m/s. To reach the boundary at, say, 200 km would take ~ 300 s. Any ions and electrons formed within the cavity are not subject to a magnetic field. There is no reason for them to go wandering off to dark parts of the nucleus. Spherical symmetry is assumed in many models to make them easier to compute. It just means in those models (Haser model?) that the comet is modelled as being a sphere. The speed of the sublimating gases means that gravitational pull can be ignored. The gas will still head up and out.
 
Interesting, ay! So they COULD be there. :D

Theoretically, yes. In the tail. And nothing to do with the diamagnetic cavity boundary. All the processes we have been talking about happen in the sunward coma. Where they have not been proposed to occur. And, chances are, they won't have been seen in the tail, either. Even if they were, what do you think they are doing that affects the sunward coma?
 
You may be able to fill the lurkers in here a bit Tusenfem.

paper as above

What’s going on here?

Very basically, what the quotation suggests is that incoming neutrals displace the heavier and slower ions which, eventually, draws the electrons with them (maintaining quasi-neutrality) against the impedance of the magnetic field resulting in "critical ionization velocity (CIV) events" from those electrons ionizing the neutrals and thus increasing plasma density.

What exactly does the electric comet theory suggest is "going on here"?

In reference to your assertion of excess electrons before, generally how many excess electrons does the electric comet theory propose such a comet has?
 
Very basically, what the quotation suggests is that incoming neutrals displace the heavier and slower ions which, eventually, draws the electrons with them (maintaining quasi-neutrality) against the impedance of the magnetic field resulting in "critical ionization velocity (CIV) events" from those electrons ionizing the neutrals and thus increasing plasma density.

What exactly does the electric comet theory suggest is "going on here"?

In reference to your assertion of excess electrons before, generally how many excess electrons does the electric comet theory propose such a comet has?

I'm not sure that this has got anything to do with the 'electric comet theory' any more. Given the predictions on this site by David Talbott, and the pdf poster he co-wrote with Thornhill. it is blindingly obvious that that has failed to eventuate. No electric discharges, no EDM (lol), no rock, plenty of ice, etc.
He appears now (insofar as I can follow his twisted logic) to be claiming that electrostatic charging is responsible for dust jets! This despite the fact that said jets are associated with an increase of gas. Such as:

Comet's firework display ahead of perihelion
http://sci.esa.int/rosetta/56325-comets-firework-display-ahead-of-perihelion/

And:

The 2016 Feb 19 outburst of comet 67P/CG: an ESA Rosetta multi-instrument study
Grun, E. et al.
https://academic.oup.com/mnras/article/462/Suppl_1/S220/2633359

Then there seems to be some stuff about double layers and CIV. I have no idea where this is meant to be going. It just seems to be distraction tactics, as one would expect from a woo believer whose beliefs have been well and truly debunked by real science and observation.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom