Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
23 August 2018: Stupidity that mainstream comet papers are about his electric comet insanity

This is standard astrophysics. The solar wind can charge bodies. If the body has dust it will be charged. Electrostatic forces then lift the dust. This can only happen at comets during periods of low activity when the solar wind reaches the nucleus.

[/URL]

1 INTRODUCTION
Comets are unmagnetized (Auster et al. 2015) Solar system bodies
that build up an induced magnetosphere through the interaction of
their expanding ionosphere with the incoming solar wind (Cravens
& Gombosi 2004). Therefore, besides any locally generated field
by currents, the interplanetary magnetic field, frozen into the solar
wind plasma (Alfv`en 1957), is the only source of magnetic field
at the comet. Close to the cometary nucleus, the plasma becomes
collisionally coupled to the radially expanding neutral atmosphere.
This prevents the magnetized solar wind from penetrating into the
inner cometary regions, which results in the formation of a region
void of any significant magnetic field: a diamagnetic cavity
(Cravens
1987; Ip & Axford 1987).
Diamagnetic region(s): structure of the unmagnetized plasma around
Comet 67P/CG
P. Henri,1ܠ X. Valli`eres,1 R. Hajra,1 C. Goetz

6. Conclusions
We have found that the important parameters (plasma density,
ion velocity, and magnetic field strength) at comet 67P are in the
right range for a significant polarisation electric field to build up.
Such a field has some important consequences observed in data.
(1) Once activity rises enough, the electric field of the comet
ionosphere to a large extent cancels the solar wind electric field
inside the comet ionosphere. There the ambipolar electric field
likely dominates.
(2) The cancellation is not perfect, which results in a significant
anti-sunward directed electric field with a strength of the
order of 10% of the magnitude of the solar wind electric field.
Size of a plasma cloud matters
The polarisation electric field of a small-scale comet ionosphere
H. Nilsson1; 2, H. Gunell3; 4, T. Karlsson5, N. Brenning5, P. Henri6, C. Goetz7, A. I. Eriksson8, E. Behar1; 2, G. Stenberg
Wieser1, and X. Vallières6


Our simulation results show that an increase of the electron pressure,
introduced by a parametrized local electron heating process,
leads to an ambipolar electric field that is strong enough to push
out the cometary ions and create a magnetic field-free region
A possible mechanism for the formation of magnetic field dropouts
in the coma of 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko
Z. Huang,1‹ G. T´oth,1 T. I. Gombosi,1 A. Bieler,1 M. R. Combi,1 K. C. Hansen,1
X. Jia,1 N. Fougere,1 Y. Shou,1 T. E. Cravens,2 V. Tenishev,1 K. Altwegg3
and M. Rubin3




Wonder what C.Goetz thinks?

See all the big names on the above paper, ay tusenfem. Not long now, not long.

:p rc!

No, everybody who knows anything about plasma physics and comets, calls it a diamagnetic cavity.

Correct jd116, geez you are good.

Now tell me how are they formed and sustained again? :rolleyes:

:rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
Sheer idiocy. The diamagnetic cavity hadn't even formed when the gravity was first measured, and didn't change once it did, and neither did it change when it disappeared again. Try to engage brain before hitting keyboard.

we'll see,ay!

You've been wrong before, sport. ;)

So far all I see is electric fields, plasma "boundaries" and charge separation!

So far that's :thumbsup: for the Electric comet or at least my interpretation.

Seems your inability to ACCEPT the electric force as dominate is :blush:
 
we'll see,ay!

You've been wrong before, sport. ;)

So far all I see is electric fields, plasma "boundaries" and charge separation!

So far that's :thumbsup: for the Electric comet or at least my interpretation.

Seems your inability to ACCEPT the electric force as dominate is :blush:

Errrr, nope. Talking garbage, as usual. Eh? Read the papers, woo boy. The comet was outgassing a huge 300 ml/s when they first measured the gravity. Burke. Science really isn't your thing, is it dear? Comprehension seems to be a bit of a struggle as well, yes?
Can I suggest Adult Learning classes? They might do them in Australia. Unlikely in my experience, though.
 
Now tell me how are they formed and sustained again?

Idiot. Read some papers, yes? Is this stuff beyond you? Seriously? What the hell are you doing here, if you cant figure stuff like that out? Really?
 
Repeats stupidity that mainstream comet papers are about his electric comet insanity

Diamagnetic region(s): structure of the unmagnetized plasma around
Comet 67P/CG
P. Henri,1ܠ X. Valli`eres,1 R. Hajra,1 C. Goetz

Size of a plasma cloud matters
The polarisation electric field of a small-scale comet ionosphere
H. Nilsson1; 2, H. Gunell3; 4, T. Karlsson5, N. Brenning5, P. Henri6, C. Goetz7, A. I. Eriksson8, E. Behar1; 2, G. Stenberg
Wieser1, and X. Vallières6


A possible mechanism for the formation of magnetic field dropouts
in the coma of 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko
Z. Huang,1‹ G. T´oth,1 T. I. Gombosi,1 A. Bieler,1 M. R. Combi,1 K. C. Hansen,1
X. Jia,1 N. Fougere,1 Y. Shou,1 T. E. Cravens,2 V. Tenishev,1 K. Altwegg3
and M. Rubin3
23 August 2018: Repeats stupidity that mainstream comet papers are about his electric comet insanity


Nothing to do with:
Sol88's comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory +material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock, an insane spate of lies about ices and dust papers.
Totally inane delusions about charge separation doing magic. Stupidly thinks that a ambipolar electric field is a double layer.
 
You've been wrong before, sport

Really? That wouldn't be all that surprising, I guess. However, please point out where this happened. And then I'll go through your electric comet crap, and show how many times you have been wrong.
Want to start?
 
Oi!

are they formed via

Close to the cometary nucleus, the plasma becomes
collisionally coupled to the radially expanding neutral atmosphere.
This prevents the magnetized solar wind from penetrating into the
inner cometary regions, which results in the formation of a region
void of any significant magnetic field: a diamagnetic cavity

or

Our simulation results show that an increase of the electron pressure,
introduced by a parametrized local electron heating process,
leads to an ambipolar electric field that is strong enough to push
out the cometary ions and create a magnetic field-free region

which is followed up by the most RECENT paper

We have found that the important parameters (plasma density,
ion velocity, and magnetic field strength) at comet 67P are in the
right range for a significant polarisation electric field to build up.
Such a field has some important consequences observed in data.
(1) Once activity rises enough, the electric field of the comet
ionosphere to a large extent cancels the solar wind electric field
inside the comet ionosphere. There the ambipolar electric field
likely dominates.

So which one jd11? please explain to this idiot which one he should believe.
 
So which one jd11? please explain to this idiot which one he should believe.

Pointless. You are too stupid to understand. Tusenfem might clear it up for the hard of thinking, but I suspect he's sick to death of the hard of thinking.
Go away, and find a mythology forum. This place is not for the scientifically illiterate.
 
"this idiot" quotes from mainstream comet papers unrelated to electric comet insanity

So which one jd11? please explain to this idiot which one he should believe.
23 August 2018: "this idiot" quotes from mainstream comet papers unrelated to his electric comet insanity.

Of course with even more idiocy: All three descriptions of the formation of a diamagnetic cavity may be correct or even the same :eek:!
The first paper has the solar wind being prevented from penetrating the coma. Then a paper with a simulation containing a "parametrized local electron heating process" pushing out cometary ions. Then a paper stating the electric field of the comet ionosphere pushes out the solar wind.
 
Last edited:
23 August 2018: "this idiot" quotes from mainstream comet papers unrelated to his electric comet insanity.

Of course with even more idiocy: All three descriptions of the formation of a diamagnetic cavity may be correct or even the same :eek:!
The first paper has the solar wind being prevented from penetrating the coma. Then a paper with a simulation containing a "parametrized local electron heating process" pushing out cometary ions. Then a paper stating the electric field of the comet ionosphere pushes out the solar wind.

As stated many posts back when Sol88 said the diamagnetic cavity is a double layer and NOT 'outgassing" blocking the solar wind.

Ambipolar electric field, double layer same thing!
 
Figured out what the charge on the comet needs to be for your electric gravity woo yet? Crack on, woo boy, we don't have all year.

Well I’m getting

22.10uC for Rosetta
10km = distance
.3 Newton’s of force

Gives me 15.1 coulombs for 67P

from

Estimated Mass 67P, m1= 9.98e12 kg
Estimated Mass Rosetta m2=1250 kg
Flyby distance d=10000m
Gravitational force = 0.0083240685 N

From Sol's estimation

Taking the mean density for 433 Eros = 2.67±0.03 g/cm³
and volume 67P = 1.87e+10 m3 * 2600kg/m3 = 49929000000000 kg


so Sol thinks the mass of 67p should be closer to m1= 4.9929E+13 kg
m2= 1250 kg
d=10000m
Gravitational force = 0.041644530675 N

So Rosetta felt .00832 N should have felt 0.041 N

The 0.03268 N of force required to "modify" Gravity at d=10000m can be achieved by

q1=?
q2=22.5uC Space craft charge GEO
d=10000m
electrostatic force of .03268 N

gives me q1= 16.1 C
 
Last edited:
Asteroid electrostatic instrumentation and modellingK L Aplin1,2, N E Bowles1, E Urbak1, D Keane2,3 and E C Sawyer2

Electrostatic forces on grains near asteroids and comets Christine Hartzell1,and Dylan Carter1

This is at a NON ELECTRICAL asteroid, no?

I have no idea what an electrical asteroid is, so ...
However, things are much more complicated than Sol thinks, of course, who only reads and copies the little parts that he can cherry pick. A bit further in the paper by Aplin et al., 2011, you get the link to the paper by Pascal Lee, 1996 in which you can read the details:

Lee said:
As charge differentials build up between adjacent sunlight–shadow boundaries, intense multipolar fields arise over short distances.

Which will be fields that link day and night side.

And....

MY favourite,

Surface charging and electrostatic dust acceleration at the nucleus of comet 67P during periods of low activity T.A. Nordheima,b,n, G.H. Jonesa,b, J.S. Halekasc, E. Roussosd, A.J. Coatesa

Clever words them...

Indeed clever words by Tom in his paper, where in the summary it is said that:

Nordheim said:
As shown,illuminated areas of the nucleus can be expected to reach a slightly positive potential at most SZAs, with a predicted potential of ~+6V at the subsolar point. We have also presented the results of a self-similar model of the cometary plasma wake,showing that significantly enhanced electron temperatures may be expected at the night side nucleus, leading to strongly negative surface potentials on the order of -300 to -400V in certain regions.

What about an electrically active comet one HAS to wonder :D

Yes, we always have to wonder, don't we, because something real is never presented by you or your electric cronies.
 
Also, I believe the charge causing the slight repulsion due to Coulomb AND Lorentz forces is not necessarily just from the nucleus but by Rosetta continuously “skirting” the closest plasma double layer to the nucleus, MAINSTREAMERS call it the DIAMAGNETIC cavity.

Postitive on the inside negative on the out side and Rosetta skimmed this layer during it’s “bound” orbits.

seems it’s now the electric field of the comet canceling the solar wind electric field! Not “outgassing” blocking the solar wind as stated by jd116,

Also this is very telling and maybe the super duper space plasma guy here could fill in the details; The polarisation electric eld of a small-scale comet ionosphere

electrons and charge accumulation???” Tusenfem?

Wow, this post makes no sense whatsoever, so I will recline to answer or to discuss this nonsense, apart from the point that JD already made, that the diamagnetic cavity was not present for a large part of the Rosetta mission.
 
Diamagnetic region(s): structure of the unmagnetized plasma around
Comet 67P/CG
P. Henri,1ܠ X. Valli`eres,1 R. Hajra,1 C. Goetz

Size of a plasma cloud matters
The polarisation electric field of a small-scale comet ionosphere
H. Nilsson1; 2, H. Gunell3; 4, T. Karlsson5, N. Brenning5, P. Henri6, C. Goetz7, A. I. Eriksson8, E. Behar1; 2, G. Stenberg
Wieser1, and X. Vallières6


A possible mechanism for the formation of magnetic field dropouts
in the coma of 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko
Z. Huang,1‹ G. T´oth,1 T. I. Gombosi,1 A. Bieler,1 M. R. Combi,1 K. C. Hansen,1
X. Jia,1 N. Fougere,1 Y. Shou,1 T. E. Cravens,2 V. Tenishev,1 K. Altwegg3
and M. Rubin3


Wonder what C.Goetz thinks?

I think she is thinking about finishing her PhD thesis, as far as I know.

But I also know that she thinks nothing good about the last paper you mentioned here. Huang just posits magical hot electrons that he does not know where they should come from, only that he puts them into his simulation.

See all the big names on the above paper, ay tusenfem. Not long now, not long.

Huh? what is that supposed to mean?
 
Well I’m getting

22.10uC for Rosetta
10km = distance
.3 Newton’s of force

Gives me 15.1 coulombs for 67P

from

Estimated Mass 67P, m1= 9.98e12 kg
Estimated Mass Rosetta m2=1250 kg
Flyby distance d=10000m
Gravitational force = 0.0083240685 N

From Sol's estimation

Taking the mean density for 433 Eros = 2.67±0.03 g/cm³
and volume 67P = 1.87e+10 m3 * 2600kg/m3 = 49929000000000 kg


so Sol thinks the mass of 67p should be closer to m1= 4.9929E+13 kg
m2= 1250 kg
d=10000m
Gravitational force = 0.041644530675 N

So Rosetta felt .00832 N should have felt 0.041 N

The 0.03268 N of force required to "modify" Gravity at d=10000m can be achieved by

q1=?
q2=22.5uC Space craft charge GEO
d=10000m
electrostatic force of .03268 N

gives me q1= 16.1 C

mmm seems to be several orders of magnitude wrong.
 
Well I’m getting

22.10uC for Rosetta
10km = distance
.3 Newton’s of force

Gives me 15.1 coulombs for 67P

from

Estimated Mass 67P, m1= 9.98e12 kg
Estimated Mass Rosetta m2=1250 kg
Flyby distance d=10000m
Gravitational force = 0.0083240685 N

From Sol's estimation

Taking the mean density for 433 Eros = 2.67±0.03 g/cm³
and volume 67P = 1.87e+10 m3 * 2600kg/m3 = 49929000000000 kg


so Sol thinks the mass of 67p should be closer to m1= 4.9929E+13 kg
m2= 1250 kg
d=10000m
Gravitational force = 0.041644530675 N

So Rosetta felt .00832 N should have felt 0.041 N

The 0.03268 N of force required to "modify" Gravity at d=10000m can be achieved by

q1=?
q2=22.5uC Space craft charge GEO
d=10000m
electrostatic force of .03268 N

gives me q1= 16.1 C

Wrong. I've asked you before - where are you getting the charge on Rosetta from?
 
Last edited:
Well I’m getting

22.10uC for Rosetta
10km = distance
.3 Newton’s of force

Gives me 15.1 coulombs for 67P

No. Q (charge) = C (capacitance)x V (voltage).

Harvey generously estimated the capacitance of Rosetta as ~ 1 nF (10-9 F).

Therefore Q = 10-9 F x -10 V = -10-8 Coulombs. So, how have you worked it out?
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom