Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Also interesting to note the effect would be the most pronounced with a terminator orbit.

Wonder where Rosetta orbited the most?

Please explain
Please put links in to the papers you think are important
 
So Solly wants to equate the "missing force" with electrostatic effects, because the comet is solid rock and not porous.
As already discussed, the distance to the comet does not matter, we just search for the missing force, which would be:

[latex]
F_{mis} = \frac{G \Delta M_{67p} M_{ros}}{R^2} = \frac{k q_{ros} q_{67p}}{R^2}
[/latex]

So we take the mass of Rosetta as 1250 kg, and the missing mass, according to Solly is about 401E12 kg.
We take the charge of Rosetta as 1.e-8 Coulomb and the charge of 67P as unknown.
Wonder, wonder, the R2 falls out at both sides of the second = sign.

So we get that

[latex]
q_{67p} = \frac{G \Delta M_{67p} M_{ros}}{k q_{ros}}
[/latex]

G = 6.67E-11 and k = 9.0E12, and then nicely all the powers of 10 disappear if you write it out (and I did not make a mistake) and you get:

q67p = 6.67 * 401 * 1250 / 9 = 371481 C

Okay, but now, we know that Rosetta can have both positive and negative voltage, which means different charge, and thus 67P will have keep track of that, by varying in a similar way, so unloading and uploading about 700000 Coulombs, just in order to keep Rosetta in its orbit.
 
So Solly wants to equate the "missing force" with electrostatic effects, because the comet is solid rock and not porous.
As already discussed, the distance to the comet does not matter, we just search for the missing force, which would be:

[latex]
F_{mis} = \frac{G \Delta M_{67p} M_{ros}}{R^2} = \frac{k q_{ros} q_{67p}}{R^2}
[/latex]

So we take the mass of Rosetta as 1250 kg, and the missing mass, according to Solly is about 401E12 kg.
We take the charge of Rosetta as 1.e-8 Coulomb and the charge of 67P as unknown.
Wonder, wonder, the R2 falls out at both sides of the second = sign.

So we get that

[latex]
q_{67p} = \frac{G \Delta M_{67p} M_{ros}}{k q_{ros}}
[/latex]

G = 6.67E-11 and k = 9.0E12, and then nicely all the powers of 10 disappear if you write it out (and I did not make a mistake) and you get:

q67p = 6.67 * 401 * 1250 / 9 = 371481 C

Okay, but now, we know that Rosetta can have both positive and negative voltage, which means different charge, and thus 67P will have keep track of that, by varying in a similar way, so unloading and uploading about 700000 Coulombs, just in order to keep Rosetta in its orbit.

I think the missing mass would be ~ 3 x 1013 kg. The mass of 67P as measured is 1 x 1013 kg, and Sol wants it to be ~ 4 times that. So, 4 x 1013 - 1 x 1013 kg.
401 X 1012 kg = 4 x 1014 kg. So, your final figure would be ~ 10 x higher than required, which gets us to ~ 3.7 x 104 C on the comet, which is pretty much what was worked out by Tom, Harvey and myself.
I think the 401 figure was a typo, and should have been 40.
 
Well I’m gettting

22.10uC for Rosetta
10km = distance
.3 Newton’s of force

Gives me 151 coulombs

How are you getting 2.2 x 10-5 C on Rosetta?

We know the voltage on Rosetta. Ever changing, but -10 V is a decent average, and easy to work with. So, given that Q = C/V, then you only need to work out a capacitance for Rosetta. Harvey's estimate looks pretty good to me. Ergo, the charge on Rosetta is ~ -10-8 C.
 
Last edited:
I think the missing mass would be ~ 3 x 1013 kg. The mass of 67P as measured is 1 x 1013 kg, and Sol wants it to be ~ 4 times that. So, 4 x 1013 - 1 x 1013 kg.
401 X 1012 kg = 4 x 1014 kg. So, your final figure would be ~ 10 x higher than required, which gets us to ~ 3.7 x 104 C on the comet, which is pretty much what was worked out by Tom, Harvey and myself.
I think the 401 figure was a typo, and should have been 40.

okay, that will teach me not to copy numbers from S
divide by 10
 
It seems to me that you are ignoring the comments on your calculations. It was pointed out that the distance did not matter, but you still actually as if it matters. Can't you show the calculation that you make where the distance is not factored out? Although I am dead certain that you are wrong, I still think is instructive for everyone if you could point out errors in the calculations that the others have shown, rather than skipping the subject to head down a new argument.


ok distance is not a factor and every thing cancels out just so!

So how powerful is gravitational force compared to the electric force?

:D

Only need 33 grams of "push" to upset your .08 grams of "pull".
 
ok distance is not a factor and every thing cancels out just so!

So how powerful is gravitational force compared to the electric force?

:D

Only need 33 grams of "push" to upset your .08 grams of "pull".

Just "clever" comments bring nothing to the table.

Maybe you should put some real effort in? Is it feasible that the charge of the comet is XYZ Coulomb, etc.

The onus is on you, did your thunderbuddies not give you the math you needed?
 
So how powerful is gravitational force compared to the electric force?

Considerably. Obviously. It allowed them to place the craft in bound orbits, whilst totally ignoring fictitious electrical forces.
 
Last edited:
Just "clever" comments bring nothing to the table.

Maybe you should put some real effort in? Is it feasible that the charge of the comet is XYZ Coulomb, etc.

The onus is on you, did your thunderbuddies not give you the math you needed?

Electrostatic dust levitation has been proposed as a method to redistribute particles [1,2], and also as a loss mechanism for smaller particles, not bound by the gravitational field of the asteroid [1]. Asteroid electric charge has never been measured, but simple estimates predict that an electric potential (~1 kV) can be attained on the dark side compared to the sunlit side, which becomes slightly positively charged by photoelectron emission. These differences are enhanced further at the terminator (the day/night boundary), when fields could reach ~100-300 kV/m [1].
Asteroid electrostatic instrumentation and modellingK L Aplin1,2, N E Bowles1, E Urbak1, D Keane2,3 and E C Sawyer2

Electrostatic forces on grains near asteroids and comets Christine Hartzell1,and Dylan Carter1

This is at a NON ELECTRICAL asteroid, no?

And....

MY favourite,

Surface charging and electrostatic dust acceleration at the nucleus of comet 67P during periods of low activity T.A. Nordheima,b,n, G.H. Jonesa,b, J.S. Halekasc, E. Roussosd, A.J. Coatesa

Clever words them...



What about an electrically active comet one HAS to wonder :D
 
Last edited:
Considerably. Obviously. It allowed them to place the craft in bound orbits, whilst totally ignoring fictitious electrical forces.


Ha ha joker.

Are you saying they already new the GM of 67P BEFORE they launched Rosetta so as to place it into a bound orbit upon rendezvous with 67P??

WoW, I have underestimated the power of math :eek:

Or did they just adjust the orbits AFTER they rendezvous with 67P?

And during these orbit adjustments they found the nucleus had a vanishingly small GM and the adjustments they made to Rosetta’s orbit to suite the desired orbital distance required LESS fuel burn to achieve?

Almost like there was hardly and MASS to the comet?

But we can see it’s actually quite massive!
 
Last edited:
Also, I believe the charge causing the slight repulsion due to Coulomb AND Lorentz forces is not necessarily just from the nucleus but by Rosetta continuously “skirting” the closest plasma double layer to the nucleus, MAINSTREAMERS call it the DIAMAGNETIC cavity.

Postitive on the inside negative on the out side and Rosetta skimmed this layer during it’s “bound” orbits.

seems it’s now the electric field of the comet canceling the solar wind electric field! Not “outgassing” blocking the solar wind as stated by jd116,

Also this is very telling and maybe the super duper space plasma guy here could fill in the details;
We conclude that the simple cloud model we used can point towards the relevant physics involved in the interaction between a small comet ionosphere and the solar wind and provide some relevant quantitative estimates of the electric eld strength and direction in the vicinity of the comet. For more detailed studies a proper simulation model is still needed, and our results indicate that important physics will be missed unless electrons and charge accumulation are taken properly into account.
The polarisation electric eld of a small-scale comet ionosphere

electrons and charge accumulation???” Tusenfem?



:o
 
Last edited:
Ha ha joker.

Are you saying they already new the GM of 67P BEFORE they launched Rosetta so as to place it into a bound orbit upon rendezvous with 67P??

WoW, I have underestimated the power of math :eek:

Or did they just adjust the orbits AFTER they rendezvous with 67P?

And during these orbit adjustments they found the nucleus had a vanishingly small GM and the adjustments they made to Rosetta’s orbit to suite the desired orbital distance required LESS fuel burn to achieve?

Almost like there was hardly and MASS to the comet?

But we can see it’s actually quite massive!

Complete piffle. The spacecraft orbited the comet at a speed and an orbital distance commensurate with the already measured gravity from the RSI measurements. In other words, the RSI measurements agree with the orbital behaviour of the spacecraft. Ergo, there is no electrical contribution. If you think there is, work out what it is.
 
Also, I believe the charge causing the slight repulsion due to Coulomb AND Lorentz forces is not necessarily just from the nucleus but by Rosetta continuously “skirting” the closest plasma double layer to the nucleus, MAINSTREAMERS call it the DIAMAGNETIC cavity.

Sheer idiocy. The diamagnetic cavity hadn't even formed when the gravity was first measured, and didn't change once it did, and neither did it change when it disappeared again. Try to engage brain before hitting keyboard.
 
ok distance is not a factor and every thing cancels out just so!

So how powerful is gravitational force compared to the electric force?
23 August 2018: Finally understands high school physics and then the idiocy of just comparing EM and gravity strength :eye-poppi!

No charge on a mass = no EM force so obviously gravity dominates :eye-poppi!
All we get from him are electric comet delusions about charged bodies. When people do the calculations the Thunderbolts cult are too ignorant to do, it turns out that the charge in 67P would be impossible to miss.
Electric Comets III: Mass vs. Charge
Harvey: Which gives a voltage on 67P from Q/C of around 35 GIGAVOLTS

Also see:
Electric Comets: Failures of the Electric Comet Model
Electric Comets II. Of Water & Ice
Electric Comets: More Failures of the Electric Comet Model

There is 18 November 2010: The lies, failures and successes of Thunderbolts Deep Impact predictions by Wal Thornhill where Thornhill lies about a confirmed prediction of a flash between the Deep Impact impactor and Comet Tempel 1 before impact. Apparently no Thunderbolts person was brave enough to made a similar prediction for the landing of Philae on 67P (maybe it is in Talbott's list of fantasies somewhere in this thread).
 
Last edited:
Stupidity that mainstream comet papers are about his electric comet insanity

Asteroid electrostatic instrumentation and modellingK L Aplin1,2, N E Bowles1, E Urbak1, D Keane2,3 and E C Sawyer2

Electrostatic forces on grains near asteroids and comets Christine Hartzell1,and Dylan Carter1
...

Surface charging and electrostatic dust acceleration at the nucleus of comet 67P during periods of low activity T.A. Nordheima,b,n, G.H. Jonesa,b, J.S. Halekasc, E. Roussosd, A.J. Coatesa
23 August 2018: Stupidity that mainstream comet papers are about his electric comet insanity

This is standard astrophysics. The solar wind can charge bodies. If the body has dust it will be charged. Electrostatic forces then lift the dust. This can only happen at comets during periods of low activity when the solar wind reaches the nucleus.

Nothing to do with:
Sol88's comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory +material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock, an insane spate of lies about ices and dust papers.
Totally inane delusions about charge separation doing magic. Stupidly thinks that a ambipolar electric field is a double layer.
 
Last edited:
An idiotic question about the value of GM for comet 67P

Are you saying they already new the GM of 67P BEFORE they launched Rosetta so as to place it into a bound orbit upon rendezvous with 67P??
23 August 2018: An idiotic question about the value of GM for comet 67P.

He has known for 9 years that the density of comets is measured. by measuring their mass M and dividing by their volume. GM was known for 67P as soon as the comet's orbit was determined, probably in 1969. M may have been refined by looking at the orbital changes produced by outgassing.
 
Persistent insanity that a DIAMAGNETIC cavity is a double layer

Also, I believe the charge causing the slight repulsion due to Coulomb AND Lorentz forces is not necessarily just from the nucleus but by Rosetta continuously “skirting” the closest plasma double layer to the nucleus, MAINSTREAMERS call it the DIAMAGNETIC cavity.
23 August 2018: Persistent insanity that anything he wants (a DIAMAGNETIC cavity now) is a double layer.

23 August 2018: A stupid delusion about Rosetta "skirting" his imaginary double layer
A double layer has positive and negative sides. These are neutralized outside of the double layer by the surrounding plasma. Sounds like this is a job for the Debye length (10 meters in the soar wind).
He has no knowledge of Rosetta 's trajectory during the measurement of the mass of 67P.
The diamagnetic cavity was not a static feature: Structure and evolution of the diamagnetic cavity at comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko. There is a chance that it did not exist during the mass measurement. Rosetta travels through the cavity during the time period in that paper.

That double layer still needs the charge that generated a voltage of 35 gigavolts on the comet nucleus. Not sure what that charge would produce in plasma.

23 August 2018: Usual citation of a mainstream comet paper irrelevant to his electric comet insanity.

23 August 2018: Stupid "god of the gaps" argument when a mainstream comet paper says a better model is needed.

Sol88's comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory +material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock, an insane spate of lies about ices and dust papers.
Totally inane delusions about charge separation doing magic. Stupidly thinks that a ambipolar electric field is a double layer.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom