Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
1060 items of ignorance, idiocy, delusion and lies from 6 July 2009 to 27 June 2018

An insanely large spate of lies, insults, etc. over the last few days needs to be recorded for prosperity.

More than 1002 items of ignorance, idiocy (citing irrelevant mainstream papers), delusion and lies from 6 July 2009 to 21 June 2018
  1. 21 June 2018: Lies about electric comets to derail from his many comet delusions.
  2. 21 June 2018: A lie that an interview with Matt Taylor is calling for new models.
  3. 21 June 2018: An interview with Matt Taylor (a rational scientist) to derail from his many comet delusions.
  4. 21 June 2018: A repeated and now insane delusion that the mainstream comet model is dead.
  5. 21 June 2018: A deluded and insulting lie about Matt Taylor.
  6. 21 June 2018: Usual lying question ("defending tusenfem") to derail from his many comet delusions.
  7. 21 June 2018: A "finding fit" question to derail from his many comet delusions
  8. 21 June 2018: 2 lying "what's being violated" questions to derail from his many comet delusions.
  9. 21 June 2018: Agrees his lying questions are to derail from his many comet delusions!
  10. 21 June 2018: Drongo insult to derail from his many comet delusions.
  11. 22 June 2018: Irrelevant ("draped fields") questions again to derail from his many comet delusions.
  12. 22 June 2018: Lies about a "Birkeland current model" from Don Scott.
  13. 22 June 2018: The idiocy of "looks like rock so must be rock" pops up yet again?
  14. 22 June 2018: An insane EDM lie.
  15. 22 June 2018: Back to an idiotic fantasy of a cometary double layer.
  16. 22 June 2018: Mindless parroting of electro-chemistry crap from the Thunderbolts cult.
  17. 22 June 2018: A lie about the Rosetta ALICE instrument not detecting FUV.
  18. 22 June 2018: A lie that a H.Laakso paper detected EDM or a double layer at a comet.
  19. 22 June 2018: An insult and an insane lie about a paper being on EDM.
  20. 22 Jun 2018: Lying "Asteroid–comet continuum" citation to derail from his many comet delusions.
  21. 25 June 2018: Stupid and irrelevant fantasy about galactic magnetic fields to derail from his many comet delusions.
  22. 25 June 2018: Inanity of a Google search to derail from his many comet delusions.
  23. 22 June 2018: Usual lies about science (lunar wake) to derail from his many comet delusions.
  24. 26 June 2018: A blatant "kinetic effects" lie about the electric comet to derail from his many comet delusions.
  25. 26 June 2018: An "argument" lie when a spate of delusions and lies is not an argument.
  26. 26 June 2018: Usual deluded lie about charges separation to details from his many comet delusions.
  27. 26 June 2018: A "nine odd years of debating" lie when a spate of delusions and lies is not an argument.
  28. 26 June 2018: A deluded lie that rocks can violate "quasi-neutrality of the solar plasma stream"
  29. 26 June 2018: A lie about the electric comet which includes them being blasted from planets.
  30. 26 June 2018: An irrelevant story about cosmology to detail from his many comet delusions
  31. 26 June 2018: A lie that cosmology is stellar system formation.
  32. 26 June 2018: A lie that the Nice model or Grand tack hypothesis is to do with this many comet delusions.
  33. 26 June 2018: Still spewing the same old delusions and lies about science and mindlessly supporting his many comet delusions.
  34. 26 June 2018: A deluded lie that a mainstream comet tail paper states the comets are rocks, etc.
  35. 26 June 2018: A deluded lie that experts are stumped about supra-thermal electrons when his quote has "We discuss the possible mechanisms that most likely are responsible for this acceleration".
  36. 26 June 2018: New "kinetic effects" fantasy about the H. Lakkso paper.
  37. 26 June 2018: Adds a "kinetic plasma effect" delusion to his usual lies about the Lakkso paper (no double layer possible for the scales in his image).
  38. 26 June 2018: Probably his usual lies about a "Evolution of the ion environment" paper to derail from his many comet delusions.
  39. 26 June 2018: Repeats his "kinetic effects" insanity to derail from his many comet delusions.
  40. 22 June 2018: Lies about and insults M. Volwerk who is not and would not support EC delusions such as comets are rocks..
  41. 26 June 2018: A deluded "ELECTRIC COMET model" lie from an EC proponent!
  42. 26 June 2018: A lie and insult of every other poster about his irrelevant question.
  43. 26 June 2018: Insults the intelligence of M. Volwerk by lying about a tweet yet again.
  44. 26 June 2018: The lying "charge separation" question again to derail from his many comet delusions.
  45. 27 June 2018: Usual lies (charge separation happens in the real world of any ionized gas, e.g. plasma).
  46. 27 June 2018: Usual lies about the Lakkso paper (no "kinetic plasma structure", no double layers)
  47. 27 June 2018: Lies about double layers and the SAFIRE project.
  48. 27 June 2018: Irrelevant gibberish to derail from his many comet delusions.
  49. 27 June 2018: Another "kinetic effects" lie to derail from his many comet delusions
  50. 27 June 2018: Yet another "serious problem for the standard model" lie (about solar wind deflection by comets).
  51. 27 June 2018: A "unexpected from a sublimating dirtysnowball" lie about a Behar et.al. paper using a sublimating comet nucleus model.
  52. 27 June 2018: A "puts paid to "draping"" lie about a Behar et.al. paper supports "the differently directed magnetic field in the near tail".
  53. 27 June 2018: Idiotic post when the cited paper is that solar wind stops (a cavity formed around 67P)!
  54. 27 June 2018: A lie about his "Where are the currents?" highlighting of a jonesdave116 post.
  55. 27 June 2018: A "Kinetic plasma effects" lie about a Berčič et.al. paper on cometary ion dynamics
  56. 27 June 2018: Deluded lies about a Berčič et.al. paper on cometary ion dynamics (no DLs or kinetic effects at all!)
  57. 27 June 2018: Irrelevant to a solar wind cavity and deluded gibberish to derail from his many comet delusions
  58. 27 June 2018: Asymmetric outgassing stupidity to derail from his many comet delusions
 
Last edited:
Sorry, you burke? What is showing up in the data, dear? Zilch, yes? When are you cretins going to get it through your thick skulls that none of this scientifically impossible woo actually happened? How dumb do you need to be? Sol88; are you teaching your children this complete and utter sh1te? Are they going to grow up as thick as you? Heaven help them, eh?

Nah ya wrong ya mug! :eusa_snooty:


The cometary atmosphere provides a constant and distributed source of ions and electrons. The electrons are picked up and swept downstream (E B drift), whereas the new-born ions are moving along the local electric field
direction. Charge separation occurs because of the scale size of the interaction region being much smaller than the gyro radius of a new born water ions. Whatever electric fields arise from this, must in the end have the net effect of reducing this separation.
Mass loading at 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko: a case study. E. Behar1, H. Nilsson1, G. Stenberg Wieser1, Z. Nemeth2, T.W. Broiles3, I.Richter

So all that arguing with tusenfem and I WAS RIGHT!!

whod i thunkit ay jd116 :D

28mhz5.jpg


Plasma Double Layers!
 
Last edited:
A lie that tusenfem and he were arguing about charge separation

So all that arguing with tusenfem and I WAS RIGHT!!
27 June 2018: A lie that tusenfem and he were arguing about charge separation.

His posts are ignorant fantasies on charge separation doing magic.
tusenfem wrote I did not say charge separation and ignored the very ignorant and irrelevant "Any separation of charges around 67p, tusenfem?" question (all ionized gases are separated charges :eye-poppi!)
 
Last edited:
A "Plasma Double Layers" lie about a "Mass loading" paper that has no DLs

Mass loading at 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko: a case study. E. Behar1, H. Nilsson1, G. Stenberg Wieser1, Z. Nemeth2, T.W. Broiles3, I.Richter
...
Plasma Double Layers!
27 June 2018: A "Plasma Double Layers" lie about a "Mass loading" paper that has no DLs.

Mass loading at 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko: a case study. E. Behar1, H. Nilsson1, G. Stenberg Wieser1, Z. Nemeth2, T.W. Broiles3, I.Richter
We study the dynamics of the interaction between the solar wind ions and a partially ionized atmosphere around a comet, at a distance of 2.88 AU from the sun during a period of low nucleus activity. Comparing particle data and mag- netic field data for a case study, we highlight the prime role of the solar wind electric field in the cometary ion dynamics. Cometary ion and solar wind proton flow directions evolve in a correlated manner, as expected from the theory of mass loading. We find that the main component of the acceler- ated cometary ion flow direction is along the anti-sunward direction, and not along the convective electric field direc- tion. This is interpreted as the effect of an anti-sunward polarisation electric field adding up to the solar wind con- vective electric field.
 
Last edited:
Sorry spell checked, the currents are driven by the potential differences.

My bad (iPads bad):blush:

yeah, right

Reckon we’d tally up the total ions moving anti sunward to the total amount of electrons and you’d have a net current.

This also makes up the potential difference, the double layer or a ambipolar electric field.

These fields can obviously get quite large in both extent and potential difference.

Maybe you should do the calculations for us, instead of making wild claims.
 
Nah ya wrong ya mug! :eusa_snooty:


Mass loading at 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko: a case study. E. Behar1, H. Nilsson1, G. Stenberg Wieser1, Z. Nemeth2, T.W. Broiles3, I.Richter

So all that arguing with tusenfem and I WAS RIGHT!!

whod i thunkit ay jd116 :D

[qimg]https://i.imgflip.com/28mhz5.jpg[/qimg]

Plasma Double Layers!

Judas Priest. WHAT DOUBLE LAYERS? None have been seen. No electric woo has been detected. Your nonsense was an utter failure. Where is your EDM (lol)? Where are your wandering arc discharges (lol)? Spell it out. None of this garbage happened. Why? Because it is scientifically impossible. Where is the water coming from? Your lunatic model failed, as is easily shown.
 
g[/qimg]

Plasma Double Layers!

If a polarization electric field would be a double layer my Swedish colleages would be clever enough to write that.

But on another note, Sol is desperate to find electric fields around a comet, because he wants his EDM on the surface of the comet. Of course discharges in a plasma are rather difficult, because of the free motion of the charge carriers.

Also the fact that, e.g. the strange large potential drops discussed by Harri Laakso (which might actually be non physical, Laakso: "It is not clear whether such a large value is true or not.") is limited to regions which are tens to hundreds of thousands km away from the cometary nucleus is basically ignored by Sol, however any electric field is for Sol "proof" that the EC is true.

That is basically the reason why I keep arguing against all the electric field claims by Sol, because non of them (convectional, ambipolar or polarization) can actually create the effects that are necessary for the EC to function. In the Behar et al. 2016 GRL paper the estimated electric field (Table 1) is 4 - 4.6 V/km (yes that is volts per kilometer!) and H2O+ is accelerated up to 330 eV and protons to 1200 eV, not the kind of death rays one expects to to the EDM on the surface of the comet.

The outgassing rate of the comet (e.g. Hansen et al., 2016, multi-instrument measurements!) is on the order of 1.E27 to 1.E28 during its most active phase. And the ionization rate and pick-up of the water (or CO or CO2) is quite enough to slow down and deflect the solar wind. Indeed, the slow down for a low-outgassing rate comet may not be as strong as at Halley, but the deflection, therefore, is very efficient, as already noted in the data by Broiles et al. 2015, and modeled by Koenders et al. 2016. This way a solar wind cavity is created around the comet, and only during a CME event during the dayside excursion did ICA measure solar wind ions.

So there is no free access of the solar wind to the cometary nucleus for a long time around perihelion, so the solar wind plasma impacting the surface of the comet creating either water or OH or whatever the EC model wants, does not occur at the time that the comet is at its most active.

So, basically, I think that the EC peeps should go back to the drawing board and start to correct their model, taking into account all the things that cannot happen. There is an abundance of data from lots of missions, all freely available for archives (Vega 1, 2, Giotto, ICE, AMTPE, Rosetta). Unless the EC community comes with some actual models and results, including data, there is little to discuss here.
 
So, basically, I think that the EC peeps should go back to the drawing board and start to correct their model, taking into account all the things that cannot happen. There is an abundance of data from lots of missions, all freely available for archives (Vega 1, 2, Giotto, ICE, AMTPE, Rosetta). Unless the EC community comes with some actual models and results, including data, there is little to discuss here.

Amen.
 
Picking just one of your recent posts, more or less at random ...
Nah ya wrong ya mug! :eusa_snooty:


Mass loading at 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko: a case study. E. Behar1, H. Nilsson1, G. Stenberg Wieser1, Z. Nemeth2, T.W. Broiles3, I.Richter

So all that arguing with tusenfem and I WAS RIGHT!!

whod i thunkit ay jd116 :D

[qimg]https://i.imgflip.com/28mhz5.jpg[/qimg]

Plasma Double Layers!
Sol88, you may not realize this, but those who try to follow what you post surely do (see the most recent of tusenfem's posts for example): what you quote from, or summarize, or editorialize on, the many papers you reference is frequently wrong, often missing some key context, and misleading.

Some of this comes, surely, from your ignorance (you do not really understand what you're reading), and a lot just as surely from the fact that you seem to be uncomfortable with numbers (and equations and mathematics in general).

Let's take this part of the ELECTRIC COMET model (or Theory) as an example:

4) comets are discharging in the solar wind as they approach the inner Solar System
[...]
5) dust is electrostatically machined from the comets' surfaces during this discharge


If you think that there's evidence, in one or more of the various papers you've been reading, that "discharges" have been observed, for it to be consistent with this part of the ELECTRIC COMET model (or Theory), you need to demonstrate that they can actually "electrostatically machine" the solid rock surface to produce dust. This shouldn't be too hard to do ... EDM is well enough understood that some fairly robust bounds on what "discharges" could produce (dust from solid rock composed of ...) should be easy to establish. But this, of course, requires you to do some calculations, and perform basic "sanity checks"; if you can't, why not take some time off from posting here to learn what you need?
 
No, ions go out, electrons go out, but electrons (thousends times lighter than ions) go faster, and get decelearated by the ambipolar electric field that is created because of the difference in outward velocity of the ions and electrons.

You really don't read the papers, in which these explanations are give, do you?

Laura Berčič specifically writes in the sentence after the one you bolded

Ah..my friend what about the dust I hear you say? :blush:

The negatively charged dust emanating from the non icy surface, that dust?
 
@ jean tate


From COSIMA measurements, we conclude that 67P particles are made of nearly 50 per cent organic matter in mass, mixed with mineral phases that are mostly anhydrous. The whole composition, rich in carbon and non-hydrated minerals, points to a primitive matter that likely preserved its initial characteristics since the comet accretion in the outer regions of the protoplanetary disc.
Carbon-rich dust in comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko measured by COSIMA/Rosetta

I’d postulate that the observation doesn’t point to some make believe nebulae creation myth story but indeed the intense surface electric fields totally disrupting the rock including any HYDRATED minerals.

As in the post above to tusenfem, the dust is negatively charged this constitutes a current from the nucleus and the mass loading paper confirms anti sunward streaming ion.

None of this needs the solar wind any wher the nucleus, as observed and commented on, but...

Not saying it was double layers but even ambipolar electric fields can and do the deflecting of the solar wind plasma flow.

Results. The solar wind deflection is increasing with decreasing heliocentric distances, and exhibits very little deceleration. This is seen both in observations and in modeled solar wind protons. According to our model, energy and momentum are transferred from the solar wind to the coma in a single region, centered on the nucleus, with a size in the order of 1000 km. This interaction affects, over larger scales, the downstream modeled solar wind flow. The energy gained by the cometary ions is a small fraction of the energy available in the solar wind.
Mass-loading of the solar wind at 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko

Plasma 101

Results. On average, two populations were observed, separated in phase space. The motion of the rst is governed by its interaction with the solar wind farther upstream, while the second one is accelerated in the inner coma and displays characteristics compatible with an ambipolar electric eld. Both populations display a consistent anti-sunward velocity component.

An asymmetry is found in the average cometary ion density in a solar wind electric field reference frame, with higher density in the negative (south) electric field hemisphere. There is no corresponding signature in the average magnetic field strength.

Cometary ion dynamics observed in the close vicinity of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko during the intermediate activity period good read.

No mention of the other half of the current...

These aggregates are charged,fragmented, and decelerated by the spacecraft negative potential and enter GIADA in showers offragments at speeds m s.
DENSITY AND CHARGE OF PRISTINE FLUFFY PARTICLES FROM COMET67P/CHURYUMOV–GERASIMENKO

We present the effects of the diamagnetic cavity on the thermal and suprathermal electron and suprathermal ion content of the plasma, and also the probable mechanisms responsible for these charged particle signatures.

Charged particle signatures of the diamagnetic cavity of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko

Not saying it was double layers or applied electric fields or any of that electric comet guff.

The inuence of solar radiation pressure on micron and submicron particles was studied. The integrated dust massux collected from the Sun direction, that is, particles reected by solar radiation pressure, was three times higher than the flux coming directly from the comet nucleus. The awakening 67P comet shows a strong dust flux anisotropy, conrming what was suggested by on-ground dust coma observations performed in 2008.
GIADA: shining a light on the monitoring of the comet dust production from the nucleus of 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko

Not so sure from the above papers that solar radiation pressure is the culprit.
 
So bar being slapped in the side of the head with it, you can now start to see from the mainstream papers there’s something going on that’s not included in the dirtysnowball model.

So if you were, thru misinterpretation and confabulation of the electric comet premise are actually expecting giant lightning bolts from space to zap the rock...

Your perspective is out!
 
Ah..my friend what about the dust I hear you say? :blush:

The negatively charged dust emanating from the non icy surface, that dust?

Edited by zooterkin: 
<SNIP>
Edited for rule 0 and rule 12.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
So bar being slapped in the side of the head with it, you can now start to see from the mainstream papers there’s something going on that’s not included in the dirtysnowball model.

So if you were, thru misinterpretation and confabulation of the electric comet premise are actually expecting giant lightning bolts from space to zap the rock...

Your perspective is out!
Edited by zooterkin: 
<SNIP>
Edited for rule 0 and rule 12.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Edited by zooterkin: 
<SNIP>
Edited for rule 0 and rule 12.

The icy surface of 67P, not the rocky surface?

If we have a little friendly competition and come up with JUST pictures, you with the icy surface and myself with the rocky surface. Total number of pics wins as determined by Realiy Check.

Can be either OSIRIS or NAVCAM.

We can decide mano a mano wether the surface of 67P is icy or rocky.



You up?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
A "negatively charged dust emanating from the non icy surface" lie

The negatively charged dust emanating from the non icy surface, that dust?
28 June 2018: A "negatively charged dust emanating from the non icy surface" lie.

The negatively charged dust grains that have been detected are far from the surface. They start as neutral dust grains very probably dragged off the surface by gases from sublimating ices. Some dust grains then grab electrons from the solar wind and comet coma.

There are ices on the surface of comets. We have detected ice on the surface of comets. The dust on the surface of comets is grains of refractory material mixed with ices. Sublimation of the ices removes the majority of the ices from the topmost part of the surface but should not reduce it to zero.

The global surface composition of 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko nucleus by Rosetta/VIRTIS. II) Diurnal and seasonal variability
CSI maps derived from data acquired at different heliocentric distances (from 3.62 to 1.72 au) along the inbound leg of the comet's orbit are used to infer surface water ice abundance. We measure a global scale enrichment of water ice from 2014 August to 2015 May across the body of the comet, along with variability at small spatial scale, possibly related with the local insolation conditions. Analysis of water ice diurnal variability is performed on 2014 August observations. Water ice appears at the border of receding shadows in the neck of the comet (Hapi), sublimating in less than 1 h, after exposure to sunlight. As similar variability is not observed in other regions of the comet, we interpreted this as the expression of a diurnal cycle of sublimation and re-condensation of water ice, triggered by sudden shadowing produced on the neck by the body and the head of the nucleus.
 
Delusions and lies about mainstream comet papers to derail from his comet delusions

Carbon-rich dust in comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko measured by COSIMA/Rosetta
...
Mass-loading of the solar wind at 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko
...
DENSITY AND CHARGE OF PRISTINE FLUFFY PARTICLES FROM COMET67P/CHURYUMOV–GERASIMENKO
...
GIADA: shining a light on the monitoring of the comet dust production from the nucleus of 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko
...
Charged particle signatures of the diamagnetic cavity of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko
...
Cometary ion dynamics observed in the close vicinity of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko during the intermediate activity period
27 June 2018: Delusions and lies about mainstream comet papers to derail from his many comet delusions
 
Complete "make believe nebulae creation myth story" delusion

I’d postulate that the observation doesn’t point to some make believe nebulae creation myth story ...
28 June 2018: Complete "make believe nebulae creation myth story" delusion.

The nebular hypothesis is widely accepted science backed up by evidence, e.g. we have images of the stages in that hypothesis.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom