Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
What I would like to know, is where is all this scientifically impossible electric woo that Sol88 thinks is happening? You know - where is it detected? EDM (lol)? Discharges? Who gives a tuppenny whatsit whether or not he thinks he sees DLs? There were none. The crux of the matter comes down to what is causing the outgassing. And we've known that for decades. The electric comet woo cannot explain it. Not scientifically, anyway. It is just unscientific word salad. Nothing to do with real science, and all to do with loons who believe in Velikovskian woo. It is provably wrong. As proven.
 
What I would like to know, is where is all this scientifically impossible electric woo that Sol88 thinks is happening? You know - where is it detected? EDM (lol)? Discharges? Who gives a tuppenny whatsit whether or not he thinks he sees DLs? There were none. The crux of the matter comes down to what is causing the outgassing. And we've known that for decades. The electric comet woo cannot explain it. Not scientifically, anyway. It is just unscientific word salad. Nothing to do with real science, and all to do with loons who believe in Velikovskian woo. It is provably wrong. As proven.

Tick jonesdave116 off the list!

Done

Next please!
 
Tick jonesdave116 off the list!

Done

Next please!

What are you on about, woo boy? What you need to find is not plasma effects that you don't understand. It is all this electric woo we were promised. And then you can work back and see where the impossible electric woo came from. Yes? As there was no electric woo, why are you even bothering to misunderstand plasma physics, that is apparently beyond your grasp? Just show us all where this EDM (lol) was detected. Simple. Loads of instruments that could, and didn't, detect it. Where is it? Sick of asking.
 
What are you on about, woo boy? What you need to find is not plasma effects that you don't understand. It is all this electric woo we were promised. And then you can work back and see where the impossible electric woo came from. Yes? As there was no electric woo, why are you even bothering to misunderstand plasma physics, that is apparently beyond your grasp? Just show us all where this EDM (lol) was detected. Simple. Loads of instruments that could, and didn't, detect it. Where is it? Sick of asking.

..., and thus kinetic effects on the structure of the tail should be expected and not the typical MHD-type of tail structure.


and thus... the ELECTRIC COMET!
 
and thus... the ELECTRIC COMET!

Errrr, no. There was no electric woo. And you don't understand what kinetic effects means. Point us to the observed electric woo that was causing non-existent O- ions to be electrically machined from non-existent rock, to somehow create water (lol). Simple. Two years worth of data. Where is it? Where are the DLs? Where are the currents? Where is the EDM (lol)? None of it happened. Ergo, the electric comet woo is as dead now as it was when the impactor excavated far too big a crater at Tempel 1, and threw out thousands of tonnes of ice. You are still batting zero, and are still clueless about science. Which is why you believe this garbage in the first place. Correct?
 
You still don't get it, do you?
The kinetic effects are e.g. the deflection of the solar wind in the neighbourhood of the comet, which creates the differently directed magnetic field in the near tail, which has nothing to do with any "electric comet".

Which also raises a serious problem for the standard model!

The solar wind is not slowing down, unexpected from a sublimating dirtysnowball!

Mass-loading of the solar wind at 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko Observations and modelling
E. Behar1; 2, J. Lindkvist1; 3, H. Nilsson1; 2, M. Holmström1, G. Stenberg-Wieser1, R. Ramstad1; 3, C. Götz4

and puts paid to "draping"!
 
Last edited:
The solar wind is not slowing down, unexpected from a sublimating dirtysnowball!

The solar wind is completely missing for nine months! Yet is still somehow combining with non-existent O- to create water! Go away, learn some science. Come back when you have.

The birth and growth of a solar wind cavity around a comet - Rosetta observations
Behar, E. et al.
https://arxiv.org/pdf/1805.06159.pdf
 
Last edited:
Jesus. You mean the draping that was predicted by Alfven, and has been seen? That draping, yes?


No I mean this one:


Evolution of the magnetic field at comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko Charlotte Goetz,1‹ Martin Volwerk,2 Ingo Richter1 and Karl-Heinz Glassmeier1,3

ABSTRACT The magnetic field at a comet is signicantly infuenced by the solar wind on one side and the outgassing rate on the other. There are no simple spatial models for the magnetic field direction, neither at a comet with low outgassing rates (∼1025 s−1) where ion gyroradius effects are non-negligible, nor at high outgassing rates (∼1027 s−1) where plasma boundaries form. However, the long duration of the European Space Agency Rosetta mission has made it possible to track the evolution of the magnetic field while comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko approaches the Sun. Herein we present a simple model that ts the data quite well, depending on input parameters. The study also includes the inuence of the comet’s gas production rate and the solar wind conditions, which both have complex effects on the magnetic eld, but are clearly recognizable. The evolution of the magnetic field direction related to draping is more complex than previously suggested. Classical draping only exists at the comet for high outgassing rates, for lower rates, the magnetic field roughly follows the Parker angle. It is shown that the interaction of the solar wind with the comet can be roughly divided into three main classes.
 
The solar wind is completely missing for nine months! Yet is still somehow combining with non-existent O- to create water! Go away, learn some science. Come back when you have.

The birth and growth of a solar wind cavity around a comet - Rosetta observations
Behar, E. et al.
https://arxiv.org/pdf/1805.06159.pdf

So your saying, with a straight face, the sublimation of subsurface ice “stops” the solar wind?

That one?

Hint, think Kinetic plasma effects.

:D
 
Errrr, no. There was no electric woo. And you don't understand what kinetic effects means. Point us to the observed electric woo that was causing non-existent O- ions to be electrically machined from non-existent rock, to somehow create water (lol). Simple. Two years worth of data. Where is it? Where are the DLs? Where are the currents? Where is the EDM (lol)? None of it happened. Ergo, the electric comet woo is as dead now as it was when the impactor excavated far too big a crater at Tempel 1, and threw out thousands of tonnes of ice. You are still batting zero, and are still clueless about science. Which is why you believe this garbage in the first place. Correct?

No currents you say??? :boggled:
 
Which also raises a serious problem for the standard model!

The solar wind is not slowing down, unexpected from a sublimating dirtysnowball!

Naturally, what I observed in the tail is in complete agreement with the deflection of the solar wind that is presented in the paper below by Behar et al.

Mass-loading of the solar wind at 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko Observations and modelling
E. Behar1; 2, J. Lindkvist1; 3, H. Nilsson1; 2, M. Holmström1, G. Stenberg-Wieser1, R. Ramstad1; 3, C. Götz4

But the solar wind does slow down, as shown in Fig. 5 of the above paper. However, the solar wind is also deflected strongly, because of the outgassing of the nucleus, and the solar wind ions are decoupling from the magnetic field.
To quote from etienne's paper:

Behar et al. said:
As the heliocentric distance decreases from 3.6 to 2.2 au, the observed solar wind is increasingly deflected, up to 90 deg. The modeled interaction results in the same evolution of the deflection angle, with a lower maximum value than observed.
In contrast with this strong deflection, the observed solar wind is not significantly slowed down, with an estimated deceleration of 40 km/s at heliocentric distances between 2.65 and 2.2 au. The modeled deceleration is consistent with the observations.

So our "bad" models show results that are "consistent with observations".

Further in the conclusions:

Behar et al. said:
The strong proton deflection is the most obvious signature of mass-loading at a small comet, while little deceleration is observed. This may also have important implications for other objects where the interaction region is small compared to the gyro radii of pick up ions.


and puts paid to "draping"!

I have no idea what that is supposed to mean, I did not pay for draping, I only show that it is present at 67P.
 
yes, heard etienne talk about it, did not read it completely, and ... ?

Or this paper:

Cometary ion dynamics observed in the close vicinity of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko during the intermediate activity period

L. Berčič1,2, E. Behar2,1, H. Nilsson2,1, G. Nicolaou2,4, G. Stenberg Wieser2, M. Wieser2 and C. Goetz3

Abstract
Aims. Cometary ions are constantly produced in the coma, and once produced they are accelerated and eventually escape the coma. We describe and interpret the dynamics of the cometary ion flow, of an intermediate active comet, very close to the nucleus and in the terminator plane.
Methods. We analysed in situ ion and magnetic field measurements, and characterise the velocity distribution functions (mostly using plasma moments). We propose a statistical approach over a period of one month.
Results. On average, two populations were observed, separated in phase space. The motion of the first is governed by its interaction with the solar wind farther upstream, while the second one is accelerated in the inner coma and displays characteristics compatible with an ambipolar electric field. Both populations display a consistent anti-sunward velocity component.
Conclusions. Cometary ions born in different regions of the coma are seen close to the nucleus of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko with distinct motions governed in one case by the solar wind electric field and in the other case by the position relative to the nucleus. A consistent anti-sunward component is observed for all cometary ions. An asymmetry is found in the average cometary ion density in a solar wind electric field reference frame, with higher density in the negative (south) electric field hemisphere. There is no corresponding signature in the average magnetic field strength.

Kinetic plasma effects! :thumbsup:

Seems ions go in, electrons go out? :)
 
Last edited:
Naturally, what I observed in the tail is in complete agreement with the deflection of the solar wind that is presented in the paper below by Behar et al.



But the solar wind does slow down, as shown in Fig. 5 of the above paper. However, the solar wind is also deflected strongly, because of the outgassing of the nucleus, and the solar wind ions are decoupling from the magnetic field.
To quote from etienne's paper:



So our "bad" models show results that are "consistent with observations".

Further in the conclusions:






I have no idea what that is supposed to mean, I did not pay for draping, I only show that it is present at 67P.

So what are the solar wind electrons up to? Or the cometary electrons at this time?

Charge separation you said. :jaw-dropp
 
No I mean this one:

Evolution of the magnetic field at comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko Charlotte Goetz,1‹ Martin Volwerk,2 Ingo Richter1 and Karl-Heinz Glassmeier1,3

Oh dear, Charlotte says "complex" in "The evolution of the magnetic field direction related to draping is more complex than previously suggested." and Sol immediately gets his knickers in a twist.
 
So your saying, with a straight face, the sublimation of subsurface ice “stops” the solar wind?

That one?

Hint, think Kinetic plasma effects.

Did you even read the Behar et al. papers from 2016?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom