Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Before any real science can start, do you acknowledge there are electric currents in space?

And that these electric currents can span vast distances? Like light years long?

Do said relativistic “jets” constitute an electric current, in your book jean tate?
Sol88: the existence of "electric currents in space" has been known for ~a century, and was first confirmed via in situ measurements around the dawn of the Space Age (i.e. 1950s). As every ISF member who has been following your posts here for some time knows you know (see, for example, tusenfem's recent post). May we use the word "lie" then?

If you are truly interested in aspects of plasma astrophysics other than to do with the Sun and its immediate environs, please post in an appropriate ISF thread, and do not derail the discussion of SAFIRE.

So, back to SAFIRE: where, in space, is the equivalent of the cable(s) which fed power to the ball in SAFIRE (i.e. which constitute "the electric current which powers the Sun")?

Where does the SAFIRE team publish details of the density, composition, and temperature gradients of the medium surrounding the ball? Comparisons with what's known about those around the Sun?
 
Sorry, about 6 on the Mohs scale at -70c

OK, that's a start.

Now you tell me, ‘ol mate, why would the penetrator RECOIL off of the “ice” they found at 67P and not in the experiments they did to calibrate MUPUS-PEN before sending it on its PRIMARY mission?

Well, how hard did they expect the ice to be? And what's the limit of what they would be able to drill, given the weakness of gravity on the comet?

Oh, but wait: gravity isn't real. It's actually caused by electricity. That's what Thornhill believes. But never mind, that's off topic.
 
Oh yes, I personally don't buy any of the electric universe stuff either, as it requires reality to be different than observed, but the EU crowd could at the same time prove everyone wrong AND solve the worlds energy crisis is they can tap the massive electrical fields they claim exist.

So, Sol88, does the Safire project require man-made electricity or not? Because if it does, it's just a glorified glow bulb.
Over the past ~decade or so, quite a few people have written extensively about the "Electric Sun" (and the EU in general). Some of them have posted here, in ISF.

One person who has not is Brian Koberlein, whose blog can be found here.

Back in 2014, he wrote about the Electric Sun, Testing the Electric Universe (despite the title, the blog post is mostly about the Electric Sun). The 501 comments on it are well worth you spending a few hours reading, when you have some idle time. Likewise those in the follow-up blog post from earlier this year, Just-So Story (as far as I know, Sol88 has not posted any comments to either, and may not even be aware of the blog).

The bottom line: those who like "the EU" (and SAFIRE, etc) are, almost without exception, anti-science. The source of this stance is also obvious: the "electric theorists" behind this (Thornhill, Talbott, and Scott) make little effort to demonstrate that they even understand what science is, let alone attempt to follow the scientific method. Further, the fact that they do nothing to attempt to "set the record straight" leads almost inevitably to the conclusion that they too are anti-science.
 
Kuhn said, using a quote from Max Planck: "a new scientific truth does not triumph by convincing its opponents and making them see the light, but rather because its opponents eventually die, and a new generation grows up that is familiar with it."


We see this quote often from purveyors of nonsense. Let's take a look at the highlighted word. Woo-mongers hope you'll assume, as they do, that what they're selling is true when in fact it is codswallop. It's a variation on the Galileo gambit "They laughed at Galileo", to which the proper retort is "But Galileo was right".
 
OK, that's a start.



Well, how hard did they expect the ice to be? And what's the limit of what they would be able to drill, given the weakness of gravity on the comet?

Oh, but wait: gravity isn't real. It's actually caused by electricity. That's what Thornhill believes. But never mind, that's off topic.

Did MUPUS-PEN drill or hammer?

Discussing anything with you mob is like bloody hearding cats! :rolleyes:

And you never returned the courtesy I afforded you. Will you answer my question Ziggurat?
 
Last edited:
Did MUPUS-PEN drill or hammer?

Hammer, sorry. Not that this changes what I'm saying. Now, what hardness were they expecting? What are the constraints on the force that they could apply?

And you never returned the courtesy I afforded you. Will you answer my question Ziggurat?

Well, I just answered one. Your previous question about why the penetrator would recoil is quite simple: they were wrong about the expected hardness. That's not a mystery, and they state so explicitly. But to understand the significance of that, we need to know what hardness they expected, and why.

It should be obvious, but encountering a hardness of cold solid ice cannot prove that it wasn't ice. So if they expected something less hard than cold solid ice, then encountering something harder than they expected doesn't prove it's rock.
 
So lurakk sisser, you can get dragged kicking and screaming into the new paradigm or die out with the rest of the Big Bang, dark matter, dark energy, magnetic reconnection, pulsars, black holes, neutron stars, etc etc...era.
Typical electric universe stupidity of ignoring the real universe and lying.
The book 'Electric Currents in Geospace and Beyond' is standard plasma physics - the current paradigm.
The book 'Electric Currents in Geospace and Beyond' is not cosmology (Big Bang, dark matter, etc.).
The book 'Electric Currents in Geospace and Beyond' is not astrophysics (pulsars etc.).
 
Last edited:
Electric currents in space?? NEVER it’s quasi-neutral and the magnetic field is “frozen” in!! ...
Usual lies from Sol88, see 826 items of ignorance, idiocy (citing irrelevant mainstream papers), delusion and lies dating from 29 August 2016 to 13 April 2018 (maybe hundreds more in the last 8 years!)

Plasma is always quasi-neutral.
The frozen-in magnetic field approximation is sometimes still used in MHD but we went past ideal MHD (which requires it) over 30 years ago :eye-poppi!
We have always studied electric current in space and plasma.
Plasma can never always dominate over gravity (quasi-neutrality).
A delusion that plasma physics is GR or SR.
 
Classic point at hand...
Classic lies about wiki and what the book states. wiki is what coronal loops are. The book quote is that hey also have electric currents in them (ell duh - plasma in a magnetic field!)

The lie is that these are about charge separation.

The truth still is (as explained to him many times that plasma acts as neutral at scales over the Debye length.
 
A "smattering of dust" lie about the working model of comets

Rosetta has thrown a spanner in that simpleton model!
17 April 2018: A "smattering of dust" lie about the working model of comets.

17 April 2018: A lie that Rosetta has shown anything about his lie of a model.
We have known that some comets have more dust than ices since 2005 (Deep Impact and Tempel 1).

On the other hand we have Sol88 who blindly believes in an obvious liar, electric comet insanity, deluded papers and everything else the Thunderbolts cult vomits out. See this stupidity in the SAFIRE thread where denial of the existence of neutron stars, etc. are some of his cult's delusions.

A few of Thornhill's lies, fantasies and delusions.
18 November 2010: The lies, failures and successes of Thunderbolts Deep Impact predictions by Wal Thornhill
2 December 2014: Sol88 does not notice that Wal Thornhill narrates an ignorant and deluded video about 67P!
18 December 2014: The bad science and delusions in Newton’s Electric Clockwork Solar System by Wal Thornhill.
5 January 2015: Wal Thornhill makes up fantasies about comets

10th April 2015: The ignorance, delusions and lies in the Thunderbolts web site, videos, etc.
13 April 2018: A couple of the delusions in Scott's Birkeland current paper.

The electric comet delusion has at least 45 years without a scientific electric comet model or observations to support it :eek: !

Getting lose to 3 years of the fear of doing basic physics: 25 June 2015 Sol88: Use a impact calculator to calculate the size of the crater on a comet made of rock by the Deep Impact impactor.

Sol88's comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock.

826 items of ignorance, idiocy (citing irrelevant mainstream papers), delusion and lies dating from 29 August 2016 to 13 April 2018 (maybe hundreds more in the last 8 years!)
 
Last edited:
A "know before hand to as hard as rock" double lie

Why not build the probe to penetrate the “ice” know before hand to as hard as rock?
17 April 2018: A "know before hand to as hard as rock" double lie.
MUPUS PEN was the first attempt to measure the hardness of ices on a comet.
MUPUS PEN gave us a lower limit for the hardness of a layer of ice on one location on 67P which was not as hard as rock .The results were consistent with a layer of sintered ices which he knows :eye-poppi.
 
Last edited:
So lurakk sisser, you can get dragged kicking and screaming into the new paradigm or die out with the rest of the Big Bang, dark matter, dark energy, magnetic reconnection, pulsars, black holes, neutron stars, etc etc...era.

Or go read the book!

This is the first time in all the years of been following the EU that mainstream has come out with the admission

PLASMA the fundamental state of matter.

Solid, liquids and gasses are special states of matter.

You know: you, Bjarne, Markie, Pixy of Key, Maartten100, and Jeffreyw ALL claim that soon 'a new paradigm' will 'sweep away' all known physics.
In all cases that is because you lot claim that all that observed, tested, repeated, theoretically predicted, functional stuff is somehow a lie and your personal idea (which in all cases lacks both an actual theory, experimental data and usually goes against actual observations), will soon be accepted.

Yet all your ideas are mutually exclusive. If you are right, all of them are wrong. But that goes both ways.

And I've never seen any evidence that any of you have even tried to reconcile your ideas or even tried to convince each other.

If your arguments are so weak you cannot even convince other fringe
'scientists' to give it at least a passing mention, I'm not holding my breath that it will soon replace actual physics any time soon.

As for your Gallileo gambit. You are right, some ideas slowly replace others. But you keep forgetting that many many ideas just turned out to be wrong.

Electricity and currents of course can exist in space (take the Io/Jupiter lightning), but the currents are small, localized and do not have any effect on planetary orbits, the working of the sun or anything else your pet theory claims.
 
coronal loops do not carry current because of charge separation so "rolleyes" indeed.

but for current to flow in the loops there must be a potential difference and in a plasma this would be because of seperation of charges.
 
You know: you, Bjarne, Markie, Pixy of Key, Maartten100, and Jeffreyw ALL claim that soon 'a new paradigm' will 'sweep away' all known physics.
In all cases that is because you lot claim that all that observed, tested, repeated, theoretically predicted, functional stuff is somehow a lie and your personal idea (which in all cases lacks both an actual theory, experimental data and usually goes against actual observations), will soon be accepted.

Yet all your ideas are mutually exclusive. If you are right, all of them are wrong. But that goes both ways.

And I've never seen any evidence that any of you have even tried to reconcile your ideas or even tried to convince each other.

If your arguments are so weak you cannot even convince other fringe
'scientists' to give it at least a passing mention, I'm not holding my breath that it will soon replace actual physics any time soon.

As for your Gallileo gambit. You are right, some ideas slowly replace others. But you keep forgetting that many many ideas just turned out to be wrong.

Electricity and currents of course can exist in space (take the Io/Jupiter lightning), but the currents are small, localized and do not have any effect on planetary orbits, the working of the sun or anything else your pet theory claims.

And that’s the difference between the EU and big bangers!

We believe it does without making fairytales up.
 
Hammer, sorry. Not that this changes what I'm saying. Now, what hardness were they expecting? What are the constraints on the force that they could apply?



Well, I just answered one. Your previous question about why the penetrator would recoil is quite simple: they were wrong about the expected hardness. That's not a mystery, and they state so explicitly. But to understand the significance of that, we need to know what hardness they expected, and why.

It should be obvious, but encountering a hardness of cold solid ice cannot prove that it wasn't ice. So if they expected something less hard than cold solid ice, then encountering something harder than they expected doesn't prove it's rock.

But it ain’t fluffy dust or porous “ice” either!

Rock is harder than ice in the example I gave to you, no Ziggurat?

PS you are aware of the analogs they were testing to simulate the surface of a comet?
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom