Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
So lurakk sisser, you can get dragged kicking and screaming into the new paradigm or die out with the rest of the Big Bang, dark matter, dark energy, magnetic reconnection, pulsars, black holes, neutron stars, etc etc...era.

Or go read the book!

This is the first time in all the years of been following the EU that mainstream has come out with the admission

PLASMA the fundamental state of matter.

Solid, liquids and gasses are special states of matter.
So much nonsense, so little time.

Sol88, you write as if “the EU” and “mainstream” are both science. Yet you surely know, by now, that the former is avowedly anti-science, don’t you?

Plasma astrophysics is alive and well, as science. As it has been for your whole life. The EU’s “electric theorists” have made precisely zero contributions to that science. Something they clearly have no interest in changing. Ever.
 
Electric currents in space?? NEVER it’s quasi-neutral and the magnetic field is “frozen” in!!!


So there can be NO electric currents!

The whole EU shebang has been based on that exact premise, plasma DOMINATES over puny gravity!

And now the mainstream HAVE to except it is of greater importance than GR,SR.

Einstein wrong??? Never :p
 
Paradigm shift

Kuhn used the duck-rabbit optical illusion, made famous by Wittgenstein, to demonstrate the way in which a paradigm shift could cause one to see the same information in an entirely different way.[3]
 
OT, but only slightly: visited EU central lately? It seems most of the pretense has gone ... EU is just a whisker away from declaring that it's openly anti-science (not just “alternative” science).

Maybe time to consider moving this thread to a more suitable forum?

Please feel free to post your source.
 
This was the quote I was looking for

Kuhn said, using a quote from Max Planck: "a new scientific truth does not triumph by convincing its opponents and making them see the light, but rather because its opponents eventually die, and a new generation grows up that is familiar with it."[4]

And a little side story.

For quite a number of years i’d take the plasma ball and fluorescent tube and do show and tell with the my kids in their primary school class. First i’d Show them gravity, simply drop whatever I had at hand and viola gravity. Meh, we all know that no great excitement.

Next i’d tell them how a plasma ball works and then demonstrate the lighting of the fluorescent tube at distance and then by one student holding the globe and seeing how many we could “daisy chain” and still get the tube to light up (btw this was a ‘dead” tube)

Look on their faces, MAGIC and WONDER.

Few years later and in a higher class they were asked about the states of matter, my daughter shot her up her hand after the teacher had said solids, liquids and gasses and miss what about PLASMA the fundamental state of matter?

Later talking to that teacher she said it’s not in our curriculum to tell them anything about plasma as it is a special state of matter that only happens when you heat things up to be really really hot!

My kids at least have grown up with it.

Seems Max Planck was on the money!
 
Last edited:
Classic point at hand

Coronal loops form the basic structure of the lower corona and transition region of the Sun. These highly structured loops are a direct consequence of the twisted solar magnetic flux within the solar body.
wiki

And from the NEW book...

Coronal loops, carrying electric currents, above the surface of the Sun
link

Along with being told the Suns plasma is way to dense for ANY charge separation to take place. Debye length anyone?

Are you going to up date the wiki page JeanTate?

:rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
Oh yes, I personally don't buy any of the electric universe stuff either, as it requires reality to be different than observed, but the EU crowd could at the same time prove everyone wrong AND solve the worlds energy crisis is they can tap the massive electrical fields they claim exist.

So, Sol88, does the Safire project require man-made electricity or not? Because if it does, it's just a glorified glow bulb.

Any electric currents in space, champ?

:eusa_whistle:
 
Last edited:
RPC-LAPElectric Field Signatures at the Diamagnetic Cavity of Comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko Birgitte Madsen

Have you read it tusenfem?

She’s put some work into this paper.

One of the more interesting conclusions

A double layer!

Charged particle signatures of the diamagnetic cavity of comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko Zoltan Nemeth

No a polarization electric field. Like I said before every DL is an electric field but not every electric field (even when created like mentioned above) is not a DL
 
An Investigation Into Potential Causes of the Anomalistic Feature Observed by the Rosetta Alice Spectrograph Around 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko

Close to a comet the dust is negatively charged.

and? that is not what my comment was about.

The first detection of negatively charged nano grains was in a paper from 2015:
J. Burch et al., Observation of charged nanograins at comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko with data from 2014 when the comet was 3.5 AU from the sun and there was no diamagnetic cavity at that time.
 
No a polarization electric field. Like I said before every DL is an electric field but not every electric field (even when created like mentioned above) is not a DL

Ok then.

Until recently, no electric field was thought to be present inside the diamagnetic cavity itself, leaving open the question about the closure of the current.

But you still have a current and an electric field at the diamagnetic cavity boundary layer.

:rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
and? that is not what my comment was about.

The first detection of negatively charged nano grains was in a paper from 2015:
J. Burch et al., Observation of charged nanograins at comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko with data from 2014 when the comet was 3.5 AU from the sun and there was no diamagnetic cavity at that time.


Sorry.

I thought it was common knowledge. My bad.

What about the negatively charged nano-grains inside the DC? Does it make any difference when they were detected or just that they were detected?
 
Last edited:
Sorry.

I thought it was common knowledge. My bad.

What was common knowledge, that the dust is negatively charged? That all depends on the plasma environment that the dust is embedded in.

What about the negatively charged nano-grains inside the DC? Does it make any difference when they were detected or just that they were detected?

Of course it makes a difference, because YOU were making claims about the charging and the diamagnetic cavity. I just pointed out that they were observed also without the presence of a DC
 
Here’s a little bit of history, of the plasma astrophysics kind.

In the 1950s, in a country Sol88 knows well, a band of intrepid scientists discovered “double lobes”, associated with giant elliptical galaxies. How did these giant lobes form (they are generally much bigger than the biggest galaxies)? A good, scientifically sound answer quickly appeared ... in the pages of relevant, peer-reviewed, journals: they are vast clouds of plasma, part of the intergalactic medium that is heated by highly relativistic jets slamming into it.

Exciting stuff! And the research has continued to this day; one of my faves is the fact that some such double lobes can be seen even when the host galaxies are too faint to be seen, even by WISE.

Do the anti-science guys (they’re all guys, strangely) who are involved with SAFIRE know this history? Apparently not. Do you, Sol88?

Feel free to check this out, Sol88; what are the estimated currents in these radio jets? How do they compare with those observed in the Sun’s corona (etc)? What current is required to power the Sun?

Let’s have more science and less nonsense, shall we?
 
Before any real science can start, do you acknowledge there are electric currents in space?

And that these electric currents can span vast distances? Like light years long?

Do said relativistic “jets” constitute an electric current, in your book jean tate?
 
Last edited:
So lurakk sisser, you can get dragged kicking and screaming into the new paradigm or die out with the rest of the Big Bang, dark matter, dark energy, magnetic reconnection, pulsars, black holes, neutron stars, etc etc...era.

Or go read the book!

This is the first time in all the years of been following the EU that mainstream has come out with the admission

PLASMA the fundamental state of matter.

Solid, liquids and gasses are special states of matter.

You do understand that these are all review papers, which means they are based on a big set of old(er) papers, thereby completely crashing you statement that I bolded above.
 
Electric currents in space?? NEVER it’s quasi-neutral and the magnetic field is “frozen” in!!!

So there can be NO electric currents!

What kind of ridiculous claims are this?
Another demonstration that Sol88 has learned nothing about what I and others have tried to teach him about plasma physics.
It's hopeless.
 
This was the quote I was looking for



And a little side story.

For quite a number of years i’d take the plasma ball and fluorescent tube and do show and tell with the my kids in their primary school class. First i’d Show them gravity, simply drop whatever I had at hand and viola gravity. Meh, we all know that no great excitement.

Next i’d tell them how a plasma ball works and then demonstrate the lighting of the fluorescent tube at distance and then by one student holding the globe and seeing how many we could “daisy chain” and still get the tube to light up (btw this was a ‘dead” tube)

Look on their faces, MAGIC and WONDER.

Few years later and in a higher class they were asked about the states of matter, my daughter shot her up her hand after the teacher had said solids, liquids and gasses and miss what about PLASMA the fundamental state of matter?

Later talking to that teacher she said it’s not in our curriculum to tell them anything about plasma as it is a special state of matter that only happens when you heat things up to be really really hot!

My kids at least have grown up with it.

Seems Max Planck was on the money!

now please explain how a "plasma ball" works.
 
Along with being told the Suns plasma is way to dense for ANY charge separation to take place. Debye length anyone?

Are you going to up date the wiki page JeanTate?

:rolleyes:

coronal loops do not carry current because of charge separation so "rolleyes" indeed.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom