Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Not what is said by Mendis!


I draw you attention to fig1 in COMETS AND COMETARY MISSIONS* D. A. Mendis

Notice the helical structures the knots and the rays?

So yeah you’ve know for quite some time but in your paper, “A Tail Like No Other” you seem a little surprised about the helical structure moving down the tail!


And the absolute bell ringer, why no magnetic reconnection with all these oppositely directed magnetic fields?

Not expect in the ELECTRIC COMET has Birkeland currents are force free and if there is any “release” of energy it is from the double layers that make up the different plasma boundaries.

These double layers are far better than “outgassing” diverting SW ions!
 
no my data does not trump slavin's data
giacobini-zinner has a much higher outgassing rate (~2 orders of magnitude)
therefore the interaction is different
also the flyby was much further down the tail than the measly 1000 km of rosetta
another reason why my results are different from jim's
don't know of any drawbacks in jim's paper though, it is pretty solid

Solid? Yup, certainly is...if you’ve used MHD!
 
No, Whipple's model is not falsified. The EC has been, of course. Whipple was right in the general description of what a comet is. Not bad for the late 40s. On the other hand with more than six decades more data than Whipple had, plus numerous missions to draw on, T & T got it horribly wrong. There is a reason for this - Whipple was intelligent, and a scientist..............

And wrong. Not he’s fault though. He had no data except from the sour face of the Earth.

Time to move toward that new model, ay jd116!
 
And that here, ladies and gentlemen, is why scientific education is so important.
This is the type of reasoning that lets creationism and homeopathy and every other kind of quack reasoning sneak into the media.

Yes, theories need to be checked. And yes, sometimes theories even need to be amended. That is science. But that does not mean every idiotic idea is equally valid

An analogy would be that because we know a mountain is there and is white on top we assume there is only snow. Now we send an expeditionary on and find a few high altitude flowers in some protected cracks, therefore there must be a hidden city of over 100000 people hiding there!

And the same is here. Sol88 keeps focussing on minute details (which he consistently interprets out of context or just ignores) for a pretty solid model.
And then claims that his preferred nonsense theory MUST therefore be true. Again ignoring the fact that if the EC model had any validity every prediction about how things move about in the solar system would be wrong, and thus not a single spacecraft ever would have arrived at it's destination.

Sorry Sol88, finding lost hidden cities in the mountains is a fantasy, just like the EC model. Why not focus on the actual science and marvel at all the cool new details we find?

:D


Did Whipples model include negatively charged nano dust being accelerted of the surface in “jets”?

6. Charging of nano-dust particles The nano-dust particles detected by RPC-IES carried a negative charge, contrary to our expectation of positively charged particles in interplanetary space where charging is dominated by UVinduced photoelectron production; this typically results in a surface potential φ +5V, independent of the size.
Mmmmm

Finally, electric fields are also generated near the boundaries of lit-dark regions where differential charging can result in surprisingly intense, but very small-scale surface electric elds pointing from the lit towards the unlit regions (Wang et al. 2007). The evaluation of these “terminator” elds remains difcult without understanding the large-and small-scale topography of the nucleus.
Negatively charged nano-grains at 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko T. I. Gombosi1,J.L.Burch2,andM.Horányi3

What say Ye, lurakk sisser

P.S

No viable model for “jets” has yet been put forward by the mainstream less the cat gets out of the bag.
 
Last edited:
:D


Did Whipples model include negatively charged nano dust being accelerted of the surface in “jets”?

Mmmmm

Negatively charged nano-grains at 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko T. I. Gombosi1,J.L.Burch2,andM.Horányi3

What say Ye, lurakk sisser

P.S

No viable model for “jets” has yet been put forward by the mainstream less the cat gets out of the bag.

First of all, as others have mentioned, there are viable models, and they are far more qualified than me, you just ignore their data and results.

And even IF you were right about that, that still does not conjure your shanri-la in the mountains. The EC fantasy is that, fantasy. Nothing it predicts happens in reality. You can rant and rail and ignore as long as you want, the EC model will never be accepted anywhere as it is just plain wrong.
Apart from amusing myself and a few others on fora like this it will never spread, never predict and never enrich humanity.
Unlike actual space science, which has.
 
First of all, as others have mentioned, there are viable models, and they are far more qualified than me, you just ignore their data and results.

And even IF you were right about that, that still does not conjure your shanri-la in the mountains. The EC fantasy is that, fantasy. Nothing it predicts happens in reality. You can rant and rail and ignore as long as you want, the EC model will never be accepted anywhere as it is just plain wrong.
Apart from amusing myself and a few others on fora like this it will never spread, never predict and never enrich humanity.
Unlike actual space science, which has.

Why is the dust negatively charged? When you were expecting positively charged dust.

Now go away and “just modify” your dirtyiceball model and get back to me on the actual mechanism charging the dust negatively?

How about those “intense” electric terminator fields, lurakkmsisser?

EC never said any thing about strong electric fields now ay?

But there they are, just like them mountain flowers! Good thing we looked.
 
Last edited:
And that here, ladies and gentlemen, is why scientific education is so important.
This is the type of reasoning that lets creationism and homeopathy and every other kind of quack reasoning sneak into the media.

Yes, theories need to be checked. And yes, sometimes theories even need to be amended. That is science. But that does not mean every idiotic idea is equally valid

An analogy would be that because we know a mountain is there and is white on top we assume there is only snow. Now we send an expedition and find a few high altitude flowers in some protected cracks, therefore there must be a hidden city of over 100000 people hiding there!

And the same is here. Sol88 keeps focussing on minute details (which he consistently interprets out of context or just ignores) for a pretty solid model.
And then claims that his preferred nonsense theory MUST therefore be true. Again ignoring the fact that if the EC model had any validity every prediction about how things move about in the solar system would be wrong, and thus not a single spacecraft ever would have arrived at it's destination.

Sorry Sol88, finding lost hidden cities in the mountains is a fantasy, just like the EC model. Why not focus on the actual science and marvel at all the cool new details we find?


Indeed. Note how Sol is careful not to attempt presenting any details of the (non-existent) EC model, instead limiting himself to speaking in vague generalities and sprinkling in EC buzzwords like "Birkeland" and "double layers". On the EC argumentation map, the regions involving scientific rigor or (shudder) math are labeled "Danger! Here be Dragons!!". Instead of addressing the faults we identify in the EC argument he tries as soon as possible to shift the discussion back to his false dilemma, as he just did in response to your post.
 
Last edited:
Not what is said by Mendis!


I draw you attention to fig1 in COMETS AND COMETARY MISSIONS* D. A. Mendis

Notice the helical structures the knots and the rays?

So yeah you’ve know for quite some time but in your paper, “A Tail Like No Other” you seem a little surprised about the helical structure moving down the tail!


And the absolute bell ringer, why no magnetic reconnection with all these oppositely directed magnetic fields?

Not expect in the ELECTRIC COMET has Birkeland currents are force free and if there is any “release” of energy it is from the double layers that make up the different plasma boundaries.

These double layers are far better than “outgassing” diverting SW ions!

maybe you should also look at the spatial scale and distance from the comet
i actually comment on the large twisting structures observed of old in the tails of comets
they have no relation to my helical wave

why no mrx? because of the high densities and heavy plasma which reduces the alfven speed sugnificantly and thereby suppresses reconnection, see my current sheet paper which you claim to have read

a double layer will not deflect the solar wind in the way it is measured, i am sure you can figure out why
 
Solid? Yup, certainly is...if you’ve used MHD!

no we just use observations which have nothing to do with mhd

these ibservations showed that alfven's model worked

are you really going to argue against alfven, the inventor of double layers? one of the gods of the electric universe?
 
are you really going to argue against alfven, the inventor of double layers? one of the gods of the electric universe?

Of course he is. He has to.

Alfven believed the sun was powered by fusion in the core. So Sol88, and every other EU believer, has to cherry pick from the stuff Alfven said, taking some of it (usually out of context) as gospel and memory holing what's inconvenient for them.
 
Why is the dust negatively charged? When you were expecting positively charged dust.

why would dust not be negatively charged, who is expecting only positive dust?
dust gets charged in two ways, electrons sticking to the surface (so negative) or by uv radiation kicking off electrons (so positive)
in the end it all depends on the balance of the (dare i say it) currents to the particles which result comes out.
 
And wrong. Not he’s fault though. He had no data except from the sour face of the Earth.

Time to move toward that new model, ay jd116!

No, he wasn't. T & T were though, with much more data. EDM? Lol. Glow discharges? Lol. Solar wind ions combining at 400 km/s with non-existent O- to somehow form OH? Lol. No H2O? Lol. Rock? Lol. Blasted off of planets by electric thunderbolts? Double lol.
In short, it is a pathetic, scientifically illiterate bunch of Velikovskian garbage, dreamed up by loons who wouldn't know science if it hit them in the face. They are not interested in science. They only care about their scientifically impossible beliefs in the idiocy proposed by an equally scientifically illiterate woo merchant back in the 50s. Oh, and convincing rubes like you to buy into their crap, and hopefully keep the cash registers ringing by buying their laughable books and DVDs.
Go away, and find out (maybe Tusenfem can help?) what is Swedish for 'unscientific nonsense.' Because that is what your hero Alfven would have called this woo. It has no place whatsoever in a serious scientific discussion, any more than astrology, homeopathy or phrenology do. It is unqualified garbage. Just like the rest of EU. Which is why nobody in their right minds takes it seriously.
 
why would dust not be negatively charged, who is expecting only positive dust?
dust gets charged in two ways, electrons sticking to the surface (so negative) or by uv radiation kicking off electrons (so positive)
in the end it all depends on the balance of the (dare i say it) currents to the particles which result comes out.

The nano-dust particles detected by RPC-IES carried a negative charge, contrary to our expectation of positively charged particles in interplanetary space

contrary, i know it’s a big word but go look it up.



And the electric fields on the surface of the comet!

And that negatively charged dust constitutes a current. As if in ELECTRIC COMET :D
 
Last edited:
And that negatively charged dust constitutes a current. As if in ELECTRIC COMET

No, it doesn't. And where is the signature of this current? Within the DC? 0 nT, remember? Nothing going on in there. So, where was the EDM (lol), Sol? Come on, we were promised this. It is central to your unscientific woo. WHERE WAS IT?
 
The nano-dust particles detected by RPC-IES carried a negative charge, contrary to our expectation of positively charged particles in interplanetary space

..........is going to be completely ignored until we have a link to where this quote comes from.
 
So where are the electron coming from to charge the dust negatively inside th DC?

There is a excess of electrons, some with high energies.
 
Scroll back up a few posts. Do you read at all?

Yes, but I only skip read your rubbish, as we've debunked it all before. It becomes tiresome. However, I was capable of reading this:

We suggest that this is likely an instrumental effect, as particles that directly deliver surplus electrons to the instrument’s micro-channel plate could more efficiently start an electron avalanche that is able to be detected.

and...........

Near the nucleus, the photo-ionized neutral gas can sufficiently increase the electron density to generate negatively charged dust particles.

So much easier to read actual science, rather than cherry-picked excerpts meant to support an impossible delusion.
 
And the electric fields on the surface of the comet!

Which I shall read more of anon, by Szego. However, Gombosi et al say:

Ignoring cometary outgassing, the effects of surface electric fields can be quickly estimated to show that their contribution to the energization of negatively charged nano-dust grains is expected to remain negligible.
 
So where are the electron coming from to charge the dust negatively inside th DC?

There is a excess of electrons, some with high energies.

Wherever they are getting their energy from, it isn't the surface:

Hence, for positively charged nano-dust particles the energy gain is <10 eV from the dayside sheath electric field.

The nightside of the nucleus could charge to surface potentials φs that are several hundreds of volts negative (Mendis et al. 1981). However, the electric field points toward the surface, hence negatively charged nano-dust particles will be accelerated in the antisolar direction, and cannot reach Rosetta.

From Gombosi et al, again.

You should have taken the time to read the paper, instead of spending a much longer time deciding which parts to cherry-pick.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom