Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Other interesting observations concern electrically charged nanograins in the inner coma, indicating a possible connection between dust at the surface of the nucleus and the comet’s plasma environment [53].
Interaction of the solar wind
with comets: a Rosetta perspective
Karl-Heinz Glassmeier

Reckon he'd be on the money, they are part of the current system that operates at a comet, including interacting with the cometary double layers!

Suprathermal electrons anyone?


 
There are no electric currents at and around comets, move along nothing to see here!

Gunna be good if they ever publish your paper, tusenfem. :D

There a definitely NO electric currents in the tail of a comet and most definitely nothing like this as detailed first by Don Scott.

So Whipples model still holds, sublimating ice being blown back by the wind.

my god, you really don't know anything john sol

clearly you give no answer abiut what current you mean that "changes direction", which of course is a clear indication that you have no idea what you are talking about.
so unless you express yourself clearly, this discussion is moot
also my comment "what current" did not mean tnere are no currents, but hat you just throw in words together in sentences that have no meaning
 
That's the alchemy you're trying to achieve, not us.



That's nice. All their findings still support the obvious conclusion that comets are primarily ice. I'm not sure why you struggle with this concept, it's not like electromagnetic and plasma phenomena cannot happen around ice.



Nope, doesn't follow. Not in any way, shape, or form.

Please point out where the EC has ever said ice turns to ROCK???

What EC has said is oxygen is being released from the ROCK that is a comets nucleus, via accelerated protons, via the double layer and I've added in I have reason to believe HYDRATED MINERALS are also involved.

Once in the inner comma (the "diamagnetic cavity") all sorts of electro chemistry takes place and viola

The full chemical species detected so far at 67P.

Or do you still think all the "ices" are mixed up together still...:jaw-dropp
 
my god, you really don't know anything john sol

clearly you give no answer abiut what current you mean that "changes direction", which of course is a clear indication that you have no idea what you are talking about.
so unless you express yourself clearly, this discussion is moot
also my comment "what current" did not mean there are no currents, but hat you just throw in words together in sentences that have no meaning

The current that is the complete electrical circuit in operation at a comet in including the plasma tail that ends SOMEWHERE to close the circuit!

This current will be as Don Scott has described in his paper.

This model will be shown in your tail data, guaranteed.
 
Last edited:
my god, you really don't know anything john sol

clearly you give no answer abiut what current you mean that "changes direction", which of course is a clear indication that you have no idea what you are talking about.
so unless you express yourself clearly, this discussion is moot
also my comment "what current" did not mean tnere are no currents, but hat you just throw in words together in sentences that have no meaning

Sorry not one current changing direction but many currents concentrically nested flowing in alternate directions.

As described in Scott's paper!

Hence the magnetic field also shows a nested Sunward and anti-Sunward directions, as observed.

102jbev.jpg

figure courtesy Fritz M. Neubauer from Karl-Heinz Glassmeier paper Interaction of the solar wind with comets: a Rosetta perspective

So my question to tusenfem and i'm sure you know but will not answer, is that's half a picture, how does the other half plug into this picture?

My take is they stretch down the tail and twist around themselves! forming the helical tail structures observed!
 
Last edited:
Sorry not one current changing direction but many currents concentrically nested flowing in alternate directions.

As described in Scott's paper!

Hence the magnetic field also shows a nested Sunward and anti-Sunward directions, as observed.

[qimg]http://i65.tinypic.com/102jbev.jpg[/qimg]
figure courtesy Fritz M. Neubauer from Karl-Heinz Glassmeier paper Interaction of the solar wind with comets: a Rosetta perspective

So my question to tusenfem and i'm sure you know but will not answer, is that's half a picture, how does the other half plug into this picture?

My take is they stretch down the tail and twist around themselves! forming the helical tail structures observed!

they will stretch behind the comet and the laminar structure as seen in the tail of giacobini zinner, as in the paper by slavin et at 1987(? notsure of the year)
 
The current that is the complete electrical circuit in operation at a comet in including the plasma tail that ends SOMEWHERE to close the circuit!

This current will be as Don Scott has described in his paper.

This model will be shown in your tail data, guaranteed.

still confused at what current is supposed to change direction and why
where did that idea comefrom?
 
What are you on about??

There is nothing electrical going on at all at comets, everyone know that ya duffer!

A comet is an icy small Solar System body that, when passing close to the Sun, warms and begins to release gases, a process called outgassing. This produces a visible atmosphere or coma, and sometimes also a tail. These phenomena are due to the effects of solar radiation and the solar wind acting upon the nucleus of the comet.
wiki

Silly me for even thinking this Wallace Thornhill crap!

Nothing electrical to see here...
 
What EC has said is oxygen is being released from the ROCK that is a comets nucleus, via accelerated protons, via the double layer and I've added in I have reason to believe HYDRATED MINERALS are also involved.

Which is trivially wrong, so why keep repeating it? There is no rock, there are no DLs, there is no O-, and none of this is going to create H2O. Except in the minds of clueless scientifically illiterate Velikovskians.

Once in the inner comma (the "diamagnetic cavity") all sorts of electro chemistry takes place and viola

No, it doesn't. Evidence please.

Or do you still think all the "ices" are mixed up together still...

Yes. How are you getting CO, CO2, Xe, Ar, N2, S, S2 etc, etc, etc.? Are these all being created by scientifically impossible reactions involving non-existent O-?

Sorry, but you don't have a scientifically viable hypothesis, you don't have any evidence, and you don't have a clue. Start again, preferably somewhere else, where the average IQ of the readership is akin to a brain damaged trilobite. You might have more success.
 
Last edited:
This current will be as Don Scott has described in his paper.

What paper? He only publishes in crank journals, and is clueless about astrophysics. See his mechanism for accelerating the solar wind! Lol.
 
they will stretch behind the comet and the laminar structure as seen in the tail of giacobini zinner, as in the paper by slavin et at 1987(? notsure of the year)

That would be:

Giacobini‐Zinner magnetotail: ICE magnetic field observations
Slavin, J. A. et al. (1986)
https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1029/GL013i003p00283 (paywallled)

Where they say, in the abstract;

It is concluded on the basis of these results that the ICE magnetic field observations downstream of Giacobini‐Zinner have confirmed the Alfven field line draping model of type I cometary tails.

So, just confirming stuff we'd known since 1957. Why is this all news to the EUists? Not like them to be decades out of date!
 
they will stretch behind the comet and the laminar structure as seen in the tail of giacobini zinner, as in the paper by slavin et at 1987(? notsure of the year)

Thanks for paper, good read but it has some draw backs.


And you’re saying this is the same at 67P, tusenfem?

Your data trumps 1987 data, no?

Not what I’ve seem from your paper ‘A Tail Like No Other”. :blush:
 
That would be:

Giacobini‐Zinner magnetotail: ICE magnetic field observations
Slavin, J. A. et al. (1986)
https://agupubs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/full/10.1029/GL013i003p00283 (paywallled)

Where they say, in the abstract;



So, just confirming stuff we'd known since 1957. Why is this all news to the EUists? Not like them to be decades out of date!

Why bother to send a probe then? Seems like a big waste of money, if you already knew.

Rosetta’s data has falsified Whipple’s model, so...i’m glad they did send the probe :D
 
Which is trivially wrong, so why keep repeating it? There is no rock, there are no DLs, there is no O-, and none of this is going to create H2O. Except in the minds of clueless scientifically illiterate Velikovskians.



No, it doesn't. Evidence please.



Yes. How are you getting CO, CO2, Xe, Ar, N2, S, S2 etc, etc, etc.? Are these all being created by scientifically impossible reactions involving non-existent O-?

Sorry, but you don't have a scientifically viable hypothesis, you don't have any evidence, and you don't have a clue. Start again, preferably somewhere else, where the average IQ of the readership is akin to a brain damaged trilobite. You might have more success.

No, intense electric fields will though, SAFIRE has seen this in their experiments. Especially in the double layers that surround an active comet.
 
No, intense electric fields will though, SAFIRE has seen this in their experiments. Especially in the double layers that surround an active comet.

Nope. Cannot create those elements/ molecules at a comet. DLs don't exist at comets, and even if they did, they will not turn...........??? into noble gases, elements etc. Idiotic. Putting a squillion volts through a metal ball in no way resembles a comet. In case you hadn't noticed.
 
Why bother to send a probe then? Seems like a big waste of money, if you already knew.

Rosetta’s data has falsified Whipple’s model, so...i’m glad they did send the probe

No, Whipple's model is not falsified. The EC has been, of course. Whipple was right in the general description of what a comet is. Not bad for the late 40s. On the other hand with more than six decades more data than Whipple had, plus numerous missions to draw on, T & T got it horribly wrong. There is a reason for this - Whipple was intelligent, and a scientist..............
 
Why bother to send a probe then? Seems like a big waste of money, if you already knew.

Rosetta’s data has falsified Whipple’s model, so...i’m glad they did send the probe :D

And that here, ladies and gentlemen, is why scientific education is so important.
This is the type of reasoning that lets creationism and homeopathy and every other kind of quack reasoning sneak into the media.

Yes, theories need to be checked. And yes, sometimes theories even need to be amended. That is science. But that does not mean every idiotic idea is equally valid

An analogy would be that because we know a mountain is there and is white on top we assume there is only snow. Now we send an expedition and find a few high altitude flowers in some protected cracks, therefore there must be a hidden city of over 100000 people hiding there!

And the same is here. Sol88 keeps focussing on minute details (which he consistently interprets out of context or just ignores) for a pretty solid model.
And then claims that his preferred nonsense theory MUST therefore be true. Again ignoring the fact that if the EC model had any validity every prediction about how things move about in the solar system would be wrong, and thus not a single spacecraft ever would have arrived at it's destination.

Sorry Sol88, finding lost hidden cities in the mountains is a fantasy, just like the EC model. Why not focus on the actual science and marvel at all the cool new details we find?
 
Thanks for paper, good read but it has some draw backs.


And you’re saying this is the same at 67P, tusenfem?

Your data trumps 1987 data, no?

Not what I’ve seem from your paper ‘A Tail Like No Other”. :blush:

no my data does not trump slavin's data
giacobini-zinner has a much higher outgassing rate (~2 orders of magnitude)
therefore the interaction is different
also the flyby was much further down the tail than the measly 1000 km of rosetta
another reason why my results are different from jim's
don't know of any drawbacks in jim's paper though, it is pretty solid
 
Why bother to send a probe then? Seems like a big waste of money, if you already knew.

Rosetta’s data has falsified Whipple’s model, so...i’m glad they did send the probe :D

no you dn't understand science (who is surprised?)
we had alfven's model that seemed to work from ground observations
however you don't know if it is correct until you make in situ measurements
slavin showed that indeed it works as alfven proposed
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom