Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Errrrm.. Alfven, bless 'im is long since dead. Yes? The guy is irrelevant to modern plasma physics, isn''t he? Go away and learn some plasma physics, dear. Just like Falthammar did.
How come you guys are so crap at this?

Aww gee, shucks. Thanks sweetie.

MHD should have died with Alfven but here we are! Mainstream REQUIRE MHD so that the maths can be done! Simple.

So the plasma physics that is applicable here doe NOT require the plasma to be ideal! (quasi-Neutral and magnetic field "frozen" in)

this is what I have learned in the 9 odd years since this thread started. We used to argue the can be no charge separation in space plasmas well that's PROVEN to be wrong, as Alfven stated it would be.

Would you care to talk about Tusenfem's "non classical nest draping" around 67P and how that applies to the above statement wrt MHD?
 
A lie that Alfven said MHD is wrong from another lying, deluded Thunderbolts video

...Alfven said MHD is wrong
11 April 2018: A lie that Alfven said MHD is wrong from another lying, deluded Thunderbolts video.

We have yet another lying, deluded Thunderbolts video which is mainly a rant about the Slashdot community.
  1. The lie that space scientists assume that electric charge and current do not exist in space. Plasma always has charges. Add a magnetic field and we get electric currents.
  2. Stupidity about a Quara.com answer to a "is there lightning in space" questions. The answer is correct (there is none) but for the wrong reason. There is no dielectric medium such as air to breakdown so no lightning. Plasma conducts so no lightning.
  3. A lie that electric current in a galactic jet reported in 20111 is "space lightning": Universe’s highest electric current found. Or the idiocy that "equivalent to a trillion bolts of lightning" = actual lightning.
  4. A delusion that the standard astrophysics of galactic jets containing electric currents and being electromagnetic structures needs announcement by reporters.
  5. A lie that there is a "shift in theory" that needs reporting.
  6. Chris Reeve has the delusion that comments on How we discovered the strange physics of jets from supermassive black holes are scientific literature. A commenter wrote a delusion that jets are electric currents and others stated that was wrong (jets are electromagnetic though).
  7. Insane obsession with Hannes Alfvén (and a few others) statements from up to 40 years ago (That 1970 speech) )as if he was the only plasma scientist who ever lived!
  8. Total insanity of a widespread "no interstellar matter" concept citing a 1937 Alfvén paper proposing a galactic magnetic field, a 1963 Popular Science article, etc.
  9. Delusions of recent "admissions" that electricity can flow through space.
  10. Delusion that dark matter can be explained by plasma.
  11. The delusion that galactic jets are Birkeland currents because a Thunderbolts "prophet" says so.

The big lie is "Alfvén realized towards the end of his career that the widespread application of MHD in astrophysics was a huge mistake" and cites his 1970 Nobel lecture (PDF).
Next is the frozen in magnetic field approximation lie we have seen from Thunderbolts idiots before and a lie of a "plea to ignore his earlier work" in his acceptance speech which is mostly about the origin of the solar system (Plasma physics, space research and the origin of the solar system).

The real insanity is the Thunderbolts cult ignoring maybe 40 years of plasma physics during which the frozen in magnetic field approximation has been largely removed with advances n MHD.
 
An inane "MHD should have died with Alfven" delusion

MHD should have died with Alfven but here we are!
11 April 2018: An inane "MHD should have died with Alfven" delusion.

Ideal MHD worked as Alfven acknowledged for the appropriate plasma. It was the failure to match other plasma that has lead to progress of non-idea MHD.
 
11 April 2018:Snip

The real insanity is the Thunderbolts cult ignoring maybe 40 years of plasma physics during which the frozen in magnetic field approximation has been largely removed with advances n MHD.

Would you like the complete list of where MHD was used wrt cometary plasma?

Should we start with Tusenfem papers?

Magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) models (electrons and ions are treated as fluids) have shortcomings in modeling the structure of the plasma around the comet (Hansen et al. 2007).
PLASMA ENVIRONMENT AROUND COMET 67P/CHURYUMOV–GERASIMENKO AT PERIHELION: MODEL COMPARISON WITH ROSETTA DATA
 
Last edited:

Newtonian mechanics is wrong. That's not a reason not to use it. You use it when it's accurate, which isn't the same thing as not being wrong. And real scientists (which you are manifestly not) understand that difference. More over, real plasma physicists understand when MHD is accurate and when it's not.

Oh, and your thunderdolts link is stupid and irrelevant. Your links never actually support your claims.
 
Newtonian mechanics is wrong. That's not a reason not to use it. You use it when it's accurate, which isn't the same thing as not being wrong. And real scientists (which you are manifestly not) understand that difference. More over, real plasma physicists understand when MHD is accurate and when it's not.

Oh, and your thunderdolts link is stupid and irrelevant. Your links never actually support your claims.


Would you like to discuss non classical nested draping at comets?

I'm sorry you did not understand the video. :o

MHD has less and less to do with actual REAL plasmas and more to do with the maths involved.

The comet is surrounded by double layers and Birkeland currents (FAC's, flux ropes, flux tubes, stringy things.....)

As Tusenfem states it's a ROCK in the SOLAR WIND.

35b5xn4.jpg
M.Volwerk
 
Idiocy and a lie not related to his insane video

Would you like the complete list of where MHD was used wrt cometary plasma?
11 April 2018: Idiocy and a lie not related to his insane video.

11 April 2018: A lie that Alfven said MHD is wrong from another lying, deluded Thunderbolts video.

PLASMA ENVIRONMENT AROUND COMET 67P/CHURYUMOV–GERASIMENKO AT PERIHELION: MODEL COMPARISON WITH ROSETTA DATA is real physics not the delusions of an ignorant cult.
Magnetohydrodynamic (MHD) models (electrons and ions are treated as fluids) have shortcomings in modeling the structure of the plasma around the comet (Hansen et al. 2007). However, the improved multifluid MHD model of Rubin et al. (2014) showed that draping of the magnetic field lines and gyration of the ions near the comet are in agreement with hybrid model results. These models predicted that the cause of instabilities in the magnetic field, such as those seen in MAG data (Goetz et al. 2016), can be due to asymmetric outgassing from the nucleus or a sudden drop in the solar wind dynamic pressure (Rubin et al. 2012; Koenders et al. 2015; Richter et al. 2015).

11 April 2018: Lies by quote mining H. Madanian et.al.
 
Lies about tunsenfem's joke in a tweet

As Tusenfem states it's a ROCK in the SOLAR WIND.
11 April 2018: Lies about tunsenfem's joke in a tweet.

13 March 2018: A lie that a tweet title supports his many comet delusions.
14 March 2018: A "M.Volwerk, M.Taylor, Jean-Pierre Bibring and others call it rock" lie.
That is an Rosetta RPC insiders' joke, which you will not understand.

ETA: and that was not a link to my poster (whatever that might be), but to a tweet about my talk in Umeå
 
Lies of "double layers and Birkeland currents (FAC's, flux ropes, flux tubes, ...

The comet is surrounded by double layers and Birkeland currents (FAC's, flux ropes, flux tubes, stringy things.....)
11 April 2018: Lies of "double layers and Birkeland currents (FAC's, flux ropes, flux tubes, stringy things.....)" around comets.

He knows that there is no evidence of double layers or Birkeland currents around comets.
 
Last edited:
Sol. who gives a tuppenny **** about DLs? You have just had a spacecraft, and its lander, at and around a comet for 2+ years, down to zero metres. If there are any DLs, and the experts say there aren't, then what do you think they are doing? EDM (lol)? Glow discharges (lol)? Please spell out how this has any relevance whatsoever to the garbage proposed by the idiot Thornhill, and what the evidence for it is.
 
Sol. who gives a tuppenny **** about DLs? You have just had a spacecraft, and its lander, at and around a comet for 2+ years, down to zero metres. If there are any DLs, and the experts say there aren't, then what do you think they are doing? EDM (lol)? Glow discharges (lol)? Please spell out how this has any relevance whatsoever to the garbage proposed by the idiot Thornhill, and what the evidence for it is.

Hello RC!

Oh it's wait jd116 not RC answering. funny that.

I'll ask you then jd116, what id this if not a double layer;

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=12227647#post12227647
 
MHD should have died with Alfven.................

Wrong. As Alfven would tell you. And Falthammar. And others. The only loons who believe this are the EU lot, and they haven't got a plasma physicist amongst them.
 
okay to put a few things right

electricity is an engineering word not a physics word

no mainstream ever said that currents are not important, that is an electric uninerse fable. one uses the technique that fits best, sometimes currents, sometimes magnetic fields.

and this is something that is a recurring theme, use the suitable method for your problem.
you will not use general relatvity to calculate when the apple will hit newton's head
smilarly you will not use kinetic plasma theory for a fluid scale process

mhd is not dead, and a few pages ago i gave the conditions for mhd to be applicable, if you look at large scales in time and space you cam (most of the time) use mhd, why make it more difficult for yourself?
and if the plasma is near ideal, you can even use frozen in fields over not too long time scales

harris current sheets, that i discussed are not the only ones that may be present, but they are the ones that are related to the rotations of the magnetic field that i observed, and the density peaks at the centre of the rotation fits with that modl. but if i would look at the current on the boundary of the diamagnetic cavity it would pribablynot be a harris type.

then double layers, which are tens of debye lengths in size (so 10000 km would probable a wee bit much) may or may not occur, we have not seen them yet. laakso sees strong electric fiels in the cometopause (but says in the text sol shows that he questions tbe validity of such large values).
as i am on my tablet and on a meeting i cannot check the paper, so i cannot check the direction of the field, but most likely across the magnetic field, from the outside to the inside of the cp. then it is the question if a dl can actually be generated.

every dl is an electric field but not every electric field is a dl. also in a dl the electric field is basicalky constant, and at halley it changes a lot.

well that is all i will type on my tablet
 
Would you like to discuss non classical nested draping at comets?

Why would I? It's not relevant to anything I said, nor does it support your central claim about the nature of comets.

MHD has less and less to do with actual REAL plasmas and more to do with the maths involved.

tusenfem gave a description of when and why MHD doesn't work. You have consistently failed to describe how comets meet those conditions. Furthermore, the inapplicability of MHD to some plasmas cannot turn ice into rock.

As Tusenfem states it's a ROCK in the SOLAR WIND.

Yeah, no. That's really not what tusenfem is saying. It's most definitely not an actual rock.
 
A deluded DL question was ignored but since he insists ...

I pointed out that he lied about a Laako paper finding double layers when it did not mention DLs:
22 March 2018: Repeats his lie of DLs found around comets in a Laako paper.

22 March 2018: A lie about the definition of a double layer being a potential drop.
The definition is "A double layer is a structure in a plasma consisting of two parallel layers of opposite electrical charge." and "typically ten Debye lengths". The potential drop is a consequence of the charge separation and falls on one side of the DL, rises on the other side. Laako only reports a potential drop [as quoted].

22 March 2018: A "discharge from the nucleus" lie about a Laako paper.

His ignorant fantasies about the paper do not count given his many insanely ignorant delusions about comets and track record of lies here.
803 items of ignorance, idiocy (citing irrelevant mainstream papers), delusion and lies dating from 29 August 2016 to 22 March 2018 (maybe hundreds more in the last 8 years!)

12 April 2018: A deluded DL question was ignored but since he insists on his delusions being recorded forever we have a size of DL delusion.

Debye lengths), compared to the sizes of the plasmas that contain them.[/QUOTE]
Click in that that Debye length link to see that length of "typically ten Debye lengths" is ~100 meters for the solar wind. Laako states as in that image "The thickness of the CP is thus about 10,000 km"
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom