Merged The Electric Comet Theory Part III/SAFIRE

Status
Not open for further replies.
Thanks.

So, 1980 (!), and in "COSPAR Colloquia Series" ("Space Research Proceedings of the Open Meetings of the Working Groups on Physical Sciences of the Twenty-Second Plenary Meeting of COSPAR Bangalore, India 29 May – 9 June 1979").

I note that the Scott "paper" you referenced does not cite Mendis (1980).


There may, indeed, be "birkeland current/s in the plasma tail of comets"; however, this seems to be irrelevant to the question I asked. Perhaps you'd like to explain?


Good paper, ay!

Put your philosophical hat on for on moment and read the above post of mine.

The relevance is slapping you round the scone! Shirley
 
ENCOUNTER OF THE ULYSSES SPACECRAFT WITH THE ION TAIL OF COMET McNAUGHT
Neugebauer, M. et al.
https://trs.jpl.nasa.gov/bitstream/handle/2014/40997/07-1024.pdf?sequence=1&isAllowed=y

2007, ApJ. :)

Just having a read now to see what Sol has misinterpreted this time.

EDIT:
OK, had a read. Nothing in there for electric comet fantasists. Not sure what relevance Sol thinks it has to the aforementioned woo.

How far back would you guess the tail is not a tail no more, jd116? :)
 
At the “head” all sorts of funky variable energy, electrodynamic, plasma, complicated math stuff going on including the production of all species detected. The H2O produced from the dissociation of hydrated minerals and non hydrated minerals, recombining to spontaneously form pure water ice of 1um. Of course along with ALL the other guff they’ve detected.

Errr, no. Not in the real world. Maybe in the leccy looniverse, but nowhere else. How are you getting H2O out of hydrated minerals? How is it 'spontaneously' forming ice? Scientifically impossible woo. Besides, the loon Thornhill said nothing about hydrated minerals. He wants solar wind H+ hurtling into non-existent O-, which (doesn't) form OH. Which dumb scientists then confuse with H2O, even though it is impossible to do so, as they show up at different wavelengths in IR and sub-mm. You need to make your minds up. Take a punt; where is this hydrated stuff coming from originally? Mars? Earth? Go for it.
 
So i’d say Thornhill has got a portion correct, Dr Annariba same boat and I’d hazard a guess that if Talbotts right and comets and asteroids were machined off of Mar’s surface and within “human” recorded history, then HYDRATED MINERALS could safely be thrown into the mix.

Nope. None of those people have got a clue, and have never got anything right about comets. Or much else, really. Except Anariba, who may or may not be decent in his subject area. Which doesn't include comets, otherwise he wouldn't have made such an arse of himself with his silly nonsense on thunderdolts.
However, my previous question is now moot, as we have a location for the origin of the hydrated minerals. Mars!
Do you know what D/H ratios are, Sol? And why they might be relevant?
 
I reckon anyway’s from what i’ve been reading.

I'd be interested in which work of fiction you've been reading. This nonsense gets more bizarre (if that's possible) as time goes on. First it was impossible solar wind reactions producing water, now it's some woo to do with hydrated minerals! You people need to pick a story and stick to it. Try to make it believable, which you have so far failed spectacularly to do.
 
Okay, I'll put Sol out of his misery; the D/H ratio of the H2O at 67P matches neither that of Earth, Mars or the solar wind. So, where are we off to now? Titan? Proxima Centauri b?
 
^^^^^^

Charge carrying Double Layers of various strengths, thickness and frequencies and distance from the nucleus, Birkeland currents of various lengths, strengths, widths and coherent-ness (force free and collisionless ) is the ELECTRIC COMET.

At the “head” all sorts of funky variable energy, electrodynamic, plasma, complicated math stuff going on including the production of all species detected. The H2O produced from the dissociation of hydrated minerals and non hydrated minerals, recombining to spontaneously form pure water ice of 1um. Of course along with ALL the other guff they’ve detected.

So i’d say Thornhill has got a portion correct, Dr Annariba same boat and I’d hazard a guess that if Talbotts right and comets and asteroids were machined off of Mar’s surface and within “human” recorded history, then HYDRATED MINERALS could safely be thrown into the mix.

Mars did have an ocean once yeah? Water at least pretty ubiquitous in the solar system.

And because this would be released from the surface of a comet in various amounts in response to the top paragraph on electrical/plasma interaction onto/into said ROCK, as mainly excited Water ions...

And I’d guess snaffle an election from some where, drop in energy and increase in density and not sublimate but crystallise spontaneously, into pure 1um water ice!!

To then either “frost’ up onto the nucleus in places or be lost to space.

I reckon anyway’s from what i’ve been reading.


Once again with same old blah blah and woof woof you’ve been posting for years. Folks take the time to find and present you with all manner of scientific evidence but you ignore every bit of it. Reminds me of what the schoolteacher said of her uneducable student. “I buys him books and buys him books, and all he does is eats the covers”.
 
@Fred Burfle

Once again with same old blah blah and woof woof you’ve been posting for years. Folks take the time to find and present you with all manner of scientific evidence but you ignore every bit of it. Reminds me of what the schoolteacher said of her uneducable student. “I buys him books and buys him books, and all he does is eats the covers”.

Any Double Layers detected around 1P?

Electric fields and cold electrons in the vicinity of comet Halley
Electron and Ion Dynamics of the Solar Wind Interaction with a Weakly Outgassing Comet


Any Birkeland currents (FAC's) around 67P?

Current sheets in comet 67P/Churyumov‐Gerasimenko's coma
and
CME impact on comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko



Are the lines that separate comets and asteroids becoming blurred?

Asteroid–comet continuum objects in the solar system Henry H. Hsieh Hydrated Minerals on Asteroids: The Astronomical Record



Is a new model being called for after the "dirtysnowball" has been found to not to be as expected/predicted e.g Dustier than expected?

Unexpected and significant findings in comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko: an interdisciplinary view
The Rosetta mission orbiter science overview: the comet phase


Now, just with those basics and the PREMISE that comet are an electrical phenomena... We have the bones of a new model, a change of paradigm:D in fact!
 
Last edited:
Now, just with those basics and the PREMISE that comet are an electrical phenomena... We have the bones of a new model, a change of paradigm in fact!

No you haven't. EDM (lol), remember? Where was it? Wandering glow discharges (lol)? Nowhere to be seen. Rock? Zilch. Still zero evidence for this nonsensical woo, and that isn't going to change, given that what is proposed is scientifically impossible.
 
Hydrated Minerals on Asteroids: The Astronomical Record

Uh huh. So why aren't these asteroids outgassing like a bar steward, particularly the ones on elliptical orbits?
You really need to think these things through before you post.
 
Uh huh. So why aren't these asteroids outgassing like a bar steward, particularly the ones on elliptical orbits?
You really need to think these things through before you post.

Like Ceres?

Enceladus?

The main belt comet/asteroids?
 
Like Ceres?

Enceladus?

The main belt comet/asteroids?

Ceres is huge, compared to a regular asteroid, and will have undergone some differentiation. Its mantle appears to be icy.
Enceladus is a moon, and is well beyond the ice line.
The main belt comets (centaurs) are just that - comets. Such as 29P Schwassmann-Wachmann. And they are just further proof against the EC nonsense. We are told by some loon that the only difference between asteroids and comets is that comets have elliptical orbits. Centaurs don't; https://minorplanetcenter.net/iau/Ephemerides/Comets/. However, we do have asteroids, such a 4179 Toutatis which do have orbits with similar parameters to Jupiter Family Comets, and are not outgassing.
So, it doesn't matter how you look at it it - the EC woo just doesn't cut it at any level, and is trivially shown to be Velikovskian bobbins.
 
Last edited:
Uh huh. So why aren't these asteroids outgassing like a bar steward, particularly the ones on elliptical orbits?
You really need to think these things through before you post.


For just the same answer why the majority of the comets we’ve seen are bi-lobate in appearance. The other, asteroidial!
 
For just the same answer why the majority of the comets we’ve seen are bi-lobate in appearance. The other, asteroidial!

Huh? You may need to translate that into English. What has the shape got to do with anything, if that's what you're saying? Tempel 1 wasn't bilobate. Neither was Wild 2. They were most certainly outgassing. On the other hand, 4179 Toutatis is bilobate. And in an eccentric orbit. And isn't outgassing.
Like I said; which ever way you cut it.........

Comet 19/P Borrelly:
_1910633_com300.jpg


Asteroid 4179 Toutatis:
Toutatis_from_Chang%27e_2.jpg


Comet 81/P Wild 2:
wild-2.jpg
 
Last edited:
How far back would you guess the tail is not a tail no more, jd116? :)
I hope this enigmatic post means that you agree that "ENCOUNTER OF THE ULYSSES SPACECRAFT WITH THE ION TAIL OF COMET McNAUGHT" (Neugebauer, M. et al.) was published in 2007, in ApJ. Please speak up, immediately, if this is not so.

I note that:
a) Neugebauer+ (2007) does not cite Mendis (1980)
b) Scott (2015) does not cite Neugebauer+ (2007)
 
@Fred Burfle



Any Double Layers detected around 1P?

Electric fields and cold electrons in the vicinity of comet Halley
Electron and Ion Dynamics of the Solar Wind Interaction with a Weakly Outgassing Comet


Any Birkeland currents (FAC's) around 67P?

Current sheets in comet 67P/Churyumov‐Gerasimenko's coma
and
CME impact on comet 67P/Churyumov-Gerasimenko



Are the lines that separate comets and asteroids becoming blurred?

Asteroid–comet continuum objects in the solar system Henry H. Hsieh Hydrated Minerals on Asteroids: The Astronomical Record



Is a new model being called for after the "dirtysnowball" has been found to not to be as expected/predicted e.g Dustier than expected?

Unexpected and significant findings in comet 67P/Churyumov–Gerasimenko: an interdisciplinary view
The Rosetta mission orbiter science overview: the comet phase


Now, just with those basics and the PREMISE that comet are an electrical phenomena... We have the bones of a new model, a change of paradigm:D in fact!
Would it be fair to say, despite you citing Henry H. Hsieh, that you are unaware of the Zooniverse project, Comet Hunters?
 
^^^^^^

Charge carrying Double Layers of various strengths, thickness and frequencies and distance from the nucleus, Birkeland currents of various lengths, strengths, widths and coherent-ness (force free and collisionless ) is the ELECTRIC COMET.

At the “head” all sorts of funky variable energy, electrodynamic, plasma, complicated math stuff going on including the production of all species detected. The H2O produced from the dissociation of hydrated minerals and non hydrated minerals, recombining to spontaneously form pure water ice of 1um. Of course along with ALL the other guff they’ve detected.

So i’d say Thornhill has got a portion correct, Dr Annariba same boat and I’d hazard a guess that if Talbotts right and comets and asteroids were machined off of Mar’s surface and within “human” recorded history, then HYDRATED MINERALS could safely be thrown into the mix.

Mars did have an ocean once yeah? Water at least pretty ubiquitous in the solar system.

And because this would be released from the surface of a comet in various amounts in response to the top paragraph on electrical/plasma interaction onto/into said ROCK, as mainly excited Water ions...

And I’d guess snaffle an election from some where, drop in energy and increase in density and not sublimate but crystallise spontaneously, into pure 1um water ice!!

To then either “frost’ up onto the nucleus in places or be lost to space.

I reckon anyway’s from what i’ve been reading.
That's it?

This is your best (or near best) effort/summary of the evidence which supports "the ELECTRIC COMET"?
 
Repeats a lie of DL's, etc. in cometary papers

^^^^^^

Charge carrying Double Layers ....
28 March 2018: Repeats a lie of DL's, etc. in cometary papers.

28 March 2018: Cites Wal Thornhill who has been lying abut comets for 13 years :eye-poppi!

28 March 2018: Cites insane "comets from Mars" delusions from Wal Thornhill.

10th April 2015: The ignorance, delusions and lies in the Thunderbolts web site, videos, etc.

The electric comet delusion has at least 45 years without a scientific electric comet model or observations to support it :eek: !

Getting lose to 3 years of the fear of doing basic physics: 25 June 2015 Sol88: Use a impact calculator to calculate the size of the crater on a comet made of rock by the Deep Impact impactor.

His comet delusions include comets are rocks; these rocks were blasted from the Earth including recently; blasting was by electrical discharges between Earth and Venus; an imaginary solar electric field charges up comets; the charge causes never detected electrical discharges; comet jets are electrical discharges; images show that comets are rocks; Birkeland currents in comets and their tails with no appropriate magnetic field; papers using bedrock to describe layers of ices support his comet are rock delusion, imaginary double layers do magic; many years of lying that ices have not been detected on comets, a "hard shell of refractory material on the outside" lie, insanity of consolidated ices and dust in papers being rock.

803 items of ignorance, idiocy (citing irrelevant mainstream papers), delusion and lies dating from 29 August 2016 to 22 March 2018 (maybe hundreds more in the last 8 years!)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom