The economy, technology and the future of work

Um, what wages? Robots don't work for pay, basically they work for oil and maintenance expenses. What's that? Oh, if your job is replaced by a robot, you should still get paid? Exactly how many robots do you think the bosses will purchase under those terms? My guess is 0, because then there is no return on the investment. If your goal is to keep everyone employed it might work, but if your goal is a life of ease, this scheme isn't going to do the trick.

The wages are paid to the owners of the robots who then may get rich. Plus taxes. These taxes can then pay for the UBI. That is if the system works. Otherwise, the owners get very rich and the majority of the people are poor.
 
I was discussing the economy with The Atheist and asked how how it was actually measured...

First, we need to differentiate the IS vs the SHOULD. Economics and econometrics deal with descriptive models, the IS. Public policy (can) take these models into consideration for setting specific prescriptive outcomes one wishes from a economy so modeled, the SHOULD.

I found a very quick, very intuitive slideshow you might look at, the IS. I crafted my search to find one like this because I value descriptions that differentiate between stocks (accumulations, in this case) and flows (payments). Stocks allow for the flows, assuming they are not depleted. The real action is in the flows, which represent the activities resulting from decisions made by all actors. (Stock and flow models are critical to all sorts of systems, and relate to systematic approaches to policy.)

Income equity is a question of policy, the SHOULD. Say, if incomes are driven by merit (skill, experience), equity concerns equal pay for equal merit, but does not imply equal pay for all. Lot more could be said on this, but good enough for now.

For now, hope that clarifies that GDP is indeed one of many valid measures of IS, and that SHOULD is a question of public and private policy choices. Aside: The lack of separation between these two very different notions creates a lot of problems, including blaming corporate bathwater on capitalist babies, if that makes sense. (One very good reason I "truck" with neither the Right or the Left, as neither is very systematic at all, and both cross the IS|SHOULD divide like madmen.)
 
Last edited:
The wages are paid to the owners of the robots who then may get rich. Plus taxes. These taxes can then pay for the UBI. That is if the system works. Otherwise, the owners get very rich and the majority of the people are poor.

If you are talking about actual workers buying robots to replace themselves on the assembly lines, then I could see employers paying the robot who passes it on to its owner, the former worker. However, it strikes me as a very inefficient system. If (as I suspect) most people are assuming that the employers will pay for the robot and continue to pay salary to the no-longer-needed employee, then you are removing any incentive for the employer to buy the robot in the first place.
 
This seems to be a longer term outlook being discussed but I have been wondering about a shorter time window. Cities, population centers with high cost of living which have higher on average paying jobs, have become way more inclined to allow work from home for most or all days. I think the longer this goes on, the more of an impact this will have, and not in a good way for the people that live in those high cost areas.

Besides an outflow of workers to lower cost areas, how long until businesses that will first downsize office space, start to consider hiring remote workers from lower cost areas that can be paid lower wages. They can keep gaining the data now of what metrics wfh people can do. Once the data's in, not sure how well it will work out for everyone.
 
Can we discuss this now?
Where does fit into the larger scheme of economics?
United States Of America's national debt as of the year 2017

https://demonocracy.info/infographics/usa/us_debt/us_debt.html


Every debt must be repaid and until the debt is repaid the debtor pays compounded interest to the issuer of the debt.
Has anyone ever compiled the sum of interest payed annually ?


A hundred years of repining will not pay one farthing of debt
_Italian proverb


This link delineates the graphically the 2020 ten trillion Dollar bailout (10,000,000,000 dollar stimulus ) that also be repaid
by the same taxpayers, and their progeny, on the hook for the nation debt.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YPHEM4gEqvg&feature=emb_rel_end
 
Last edited:
Fonebone, debt needs to be looked at in comparison to a country's (or person's) wealth.

Let's not get sidetracked now. End of derail.
 
First, we need to differentiate the IS vs the SHOULD. Economics and econometrics deal with descriptive models, the IS. Public policy (can) take these models into consideration for setting specific prescriptive outcomes one wishes from a economy so modeled, the SHOULD.

I found a very quick, very intuitive slideshow you might look at, the IS. I crafted my search to find one like this because I value descriptions that differentiate between stocks (accumulations, in this case) and flows (payments). Stocks allow for the flows, assuming they are not depleted. The real action is in the flows, which represent the activities resulting from decisions made by all actors. (Stock and flow models are critical to all sorts of systems, and relate to systematic approaches to policy.)

Income equity is a question of policy, the SHOULD. Say, if incomes are driven by merit (skill, experience), equity concerns equal pay for equal merit, but does not imply equal pay for all. Lot more could be said on this, but good enough for now.

For now, hope that clarifies that GDP is indeed one of many valid measures of IS, and that SHOULD is a question of public and private policy choices. Aside: The lack of separation between these two very different notions creates a lot of problems, including blaming corporate bathwater on capitalist babies, if that makes sense. (One very good reason I "truck" with neither the Right or the Left, as neither is very systematic at all, and both cross the IS|SHOULD divide like madmen.)

I like this distinction very much. Thank you for your kind help.
 
It's pretty easy to find out what the Federal government pays in interest. It's about 540 billion now. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/A091RC1Q027SBEA

When Reagan was President, federal interest payments were about 4.8 percent of GDP. Today, they're about 2.6 percent of GDP.

And this seems a bit strange for this forum to post a link to a site named "demonocracy." :)
 

Attachments

  • interest.jpg
    interest.jpg
    19.8 KB · Views: 1
It's pretty easy to find out what the Federal government pays in interest. It's about 540 billion now. https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/A091RC1Q027SBEA

When Reagan was President, federal interest payments were about 4.8 percent of GDP. Today, they're about 2.6 percent of GDP.

And this seems a bit strange for this forum to post a link to a site named "demonocracy." :)
It doesn't sound like good news to me that interest rates are scraping the zero level. It suggests a loss of a method to keep the economy on track and if it becomes necessary to raise interest rates to keep the economy from overheating in the future, borrowers (including the government) will be the big losers.

In any case, I suspect that it is the level of national debt (rather than interest payments) in relation to the GDP that is the relevant measure. Conventional wisdom seems to suggest that the national debt should not exceed the GDP.
 
Conventional wisdom seems to suggest that the national debt should not exceed the GDP.

This isn't the conventional wisdom. There is no magic number that's an abrupt threshold. It is quite true that there was work by Carmen Reinhart and Ken Rogoff (both excellent economists) that suggested the national debt should not exceed annual GDP, but it hasn't really held up.

Japan's debt is something over twice GDP I believe, and they're not in any sort of crisis. (https://spendmenot.com/blog/national-debt-by-country/)
 
Japan's debt is something over twice GDP I believe, and they're not in any sort of crisis. (https://spendmenot.com/blog/national-debt-by-country/)
None of these countries on that list could be described as "economic power houses". Some are in the depths of despair with forced austerity measures taking their toll.

Japan might appear to be an exemption but it has fallen a long way from the economic highs of the past. In any case, most of the money the Japanese government owes is to its own citizens.
 
Thank you Orphia for changing the subject. It's well past time for me to ignore everything Trump.

I agree with your premise in the OP. I have not read all the posts in the thread so forgive me for not following the discussion yet.

Measuring GDP and unemployment misses a critical measurement we really need: standard of living. Are wages adequate to support a family or even an individual? Are wages keeping up with the success of the people profiting off those wages?
 
Thank you Orphia for changing the subject. It's well past time for me to ignore everything Trump.

I agree with your premise in the OP. I have not read all the posts in the thread so forgive me for not following the discussion yet.

Measuring GDP and unemployment misses a critical measurement we really need: standard of living. Are wages adequate to support a family or even an individual? Are wages keeping up with the success of the people profiting off those wages?

Cheers, SG. I'll quote you a few replies that address that question.

The measurement has always been subjective, and politically biased. One side will point to GDP while another points to standard of living.

To me, the measure we should be using is inequality. If it's increasing, we're losing.

I believe automation isn't even an issue.

We were led to believe in the 1970s, then '80s, then '90s, then all the 21st century so far, that automation would decimate workforces, yet we still have a glut of jobs and very low unemployment worldwide - pre Covid, and it will return to those levels.

Automated tasks are the repetitive ones that people don't want to do, and new jobs open as others close.

Who the hell would have thought e-gamer or Insta influencer would be viable career options in the year 2000?

A single occupation that needs a massive influx of workers is age care. You can have robots to do some tasks and that might just enable us to find sufficient people to do the jobs the residents will want people to do.

And in the end, any savings made by automation go into the hands of shareholders, and when we're welded to the ******* Friedman Doctrine, I don't imagine they're about to share the wealth.

Economists still tend to have a "technology creates more and better jobs for horses" mentality.

I see good things being done by those with wealth. The internet's instant dissemination of bad news about a company makes them a bit more honest, IMHO.

But they have to keep their wealth to be philanthropic.

So long as improvements in laws that mean better living standards keep happening, we will all be more Scandinavia-like in our quality of life.

Hmmm, anyone know anything about their taxing of the rich and automation of menial jobs?
 
None of these countries on that list could be described as "economic power houses". Some are in the depths of despair with forced austerity measures taking their toll.

Japan might appear to be an exemption but it has fallen a long way from the economic highs of the past. In any case, most of the money the Japanese government owes is to its own citizens.

The point about who holds the debt is a good one. The U.S. is, and has been for a long-time, a special case. This is in part because the dollar is the world reserve currency and in part because the U.S. is considered the safe place to park money. It is, of course, possible for those things to change.

Many economists think that this is exactly the right time to be running up more debt. If the government has highly productive investment opportunities and interest rates are low, it should borrow and invest. The two current targets might be keeping people going until we recover from covid and rebuilding our collapsing infrastructure.

As a somewhat on-topic example, should the government be taking advantage of low interest rates to build out the infrastructure to support driverless vehicles?
 
It doesn't sound like good news to me that interest rates are scraping the zero level. It suggests a loss of a method to keep the economy on track and if it becomes necessary to raise interest rates to keep the economy from overheating in the future, borrowers (including the government) will be the big losers.

I said at the start of the current recession that central banks only had more free money as an option, and so it has proved to be.

It's keeping economies afloat by tipping trillions into the hands of existing asset holders.

We're creating an underclass that will last for generations, and the social costs of that will be horrible.

I see good things being done by those with wealth.

Let's take a decent look at that statement, because I think it's confirmation bias fallacy. It's easy to see Bill Gates and Warren Buffet acting altruistically while ignoring the hundreds of other billionaires who don't.

First off, charitable giving by individuals outweighs corporate giving by many times, and while the numbers are a little dated, UK is showing a decline over the past three years, USA is flat, with declining individual giving., while Aussie has the number of people down, but money up, although the picture isn't complete.

I'm only looking at pre-Covid, because Covid has unquestionably been disastrous for charities.

So long as improvements in laws that mean better living standards keep happening, we will all be more Scandinavia-like in our quality of life.

I do admire your optimism, but I think that statement just flies in the face of reality.

We still can't feed a significant and growing proportion of people alive. I think Eritrea being the new Norway is a little way off.

As a somewhat on-topic example, should the government be taking advantage of low interest rates to build out the infrastructure to support driverless vehicles?

Driverless vehicles are a red herring, but governments should absolutely be spending on infrastructure like crazy. It's an international problem - we've been so consumed with growth that we've forgotten to maintain existing systems.

Auckland was crippled for over a week recently by a single vehicle crash. Our infrastructure is appalling and the awful state of our roads alone costs a couple of hundred lives a year, plus thousands of injuries.

The same kind of think is repeated around the world.

Far too obvious.
 
We're creating an underclass that will last for generations, and the social costs of that will be horrible.

To answer your questions, I'll reply with a question for you.

How would business be structured if the rich didn't get richer?
 
To answer your questions, I'll reply with a question for you.

How would business be structured if the rich didn't get richer?

Paying living wages. Ensuring a percentage of profits go to altruistic uses - there are plenty of ways to do it. It wouldn't be too hard to ditch the Friedman Doctrine.

When billionaires have increased their wealth by 25% during the Covid pandemic, there's clearly enough that they wouldn't miss a cut.

https://www.theguardian.com/busines...is-boosts-the-fortunes-of-worlds-billionaires
 
Paying living wages. Ensuring a percentage of profits go to altruistic uses - there are plenty of ways to do it. It wouldn't be too hard to ditch the Friedman Doctrine.

When billionaires have increased their wealth by 25% during the Covid pandemic, there's clearly enough that they wouldn't miss a cut.

https://www.theguardian.com/busines...is-boosts-the-fortunes-of-worlds-billionaires


I agree. While the article showed altruism by billionaires, UK billionaires in particular were less charitable. Good old colonialism at its foundation.
 
World vs Virus podcast (by the World Economic Forum): Did COVID Kill our cities?

The second interviewee, Robert Mugger talks about the following ways our cities will be reshaped.

COVID-19 means that poorer areas' healthcare needs to be improved.

As above, affordable housing needs to be provided in cities to stop the spread of the virus (which happens when large groups share living conditions).

"15 minute cities" are becoming more widely used in town infrastructure plans. Suburbs where you can walk to the supermarket and get exercise, so you are not at risk of health problems.

Parks, micromobility (cycling paths, etc), liveable neighbourhoods are becoming seen as essential



My added comments:

Health affects the national debt and the economy, since health contributes to unemployment etc - an understatement in 2020.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom